Retribution

  1. Retribution is payback.

    • E.g: inflicting punishment on an offender as a revenge for a criminal act.

  2. Offender gets their just desserts for having breached society norms.

    • ensuring fairness and justice that society wants

  3. With retribution the punishment must fit the crime - should be equal to or proportionate to the harm done.

    • murder - death penalty

  4. This idea leads to a “tariff” system or fixed scale of mandatory penalties for different offences.

  5. Retribution is about satisfying the outrage of society, not for deterrence or rehabilitation

    • it’s backwards looking


Evaluation


  1. Right realists - rational choice

    • assumes that offenders are rational actors who consciously choose to commit their crimes and are fully responsible for their actions

    • Therefore they must suffer the outrage of society for what they have chosen to do

  2. criticism - left realists

    • offenders deserve forgiveness, mercy or a chance to make amends not just punishment

    • There are fixed tariffs and penalties, punishments must be inflicted even if no good will come of it.