Retribution
Retribution is payback.
E.g: inflicting punishment on an offender as a revenge for a criminal act.
Offender gets their just desserts for having breached society norms.
ensuring fairness and justice that society wants
With retribution the punishment must fit the crime - should be equal to or proportionate to the harm done.
murder - death penalty
This idea leads to a “tariff” system or fixed scale of mandatory penalties for different offences.
Retribution is about satisfying the outrage of society, not for deterrence or rehabilitation
it’s backwards looking
Evaluation
Right realists - rational choice
assumes that offenders are rational actors who consciously choose to commit their crimes and are fully responsible for their actions
Therefore they must suffer the outrage of society for what they have chosen to do
criticism - left realists
offenders deserve forgiveness, mercy or a chance to make amends not just punishment
There are fixed tariffs and penalties, punishments must be inflicted even if no good will come of it.