Argument and Thesis Notes
Learning Objectives for Research Paper Drafting
The primary objective of Module 7 is to enable students to recognize the specific differences between three critical components of writing: the argument, the working thesis, and the final thesis statement.
Drafting the Argument
Definition of Argument: Within the context of a research paper, the argument is defined as the overall claim being made by the essay, inclusive of the specific reasons provided to support that claim.
The Transitional State of Drafting: During the drafting phase, the argument exists in a "tricky transitional state" that requires a balance between two competing approaches:
Maintaining Focus: Writers must avoid losing track of the overall argument. Failure to do so can lead to several structural issues:
Meandering into side-points.
Stalling out at "dead-end details."
Bloating the paper with irrelevant or unnecessary data.
Maintaining Flexibility: Writers should avoid clinging too tightly to their initial conception of the argument.
The argument is expected to grow and change as the drafting process progresses.
It is possible—and sometimes necessary—to end up arguing nearly the opposite of the original point after a full exploration of the evidence within the body of the paper.
The Working Thesis
Definition and Purpose: A working thesis acts as a preliminary tool used during the drafting phase. It provides the flexibility to follow the nuances of an argument without locking the paper into a specific conclusion too early.
Function:
It serves as a "first pass" at answering the research question.
It acts as a navigational guide to prevent the writer from wandering too far off course.
It must remain open-ended enough so that it does not pre-determine the eventual findings of the research.
Application Example (Cursive Instruction):
Research Question: "Should grade school students be taught cursive?"
Working Thesis: "Cursive instruction is still important, since some students benefit from learning cursive."
The Final Thesis Statement
Definition: The final thesis is the polished, definitive statement that appears in the completed research paper.
The Refinement Process: The transition from a working thesis to a final thesis occurs after several steps are completed:
The argument has been fully developed.
Research questions have been thoroughly explored.
A variety of sources have been examined.
The information has been synthesized into a well-organized paper structure.
Characteristics of a Final Thesis:
It is a clear and refined claim.
It provides a brief summary of the argument.
It explicitly demonstrates to the reader why they should agree with the paper's conclusions.
Application Example (Refined Final Thesis):
Statement: "Because the research on the advantages of cursive instruction is still inconclusive, educators need to evaluate this activity within a dynamic framework that considers both the benefits and the opportunity costs of setting time aside to teach cursive."
Content Metadata
Module Title: Module 7: Drafting a Research Paper Argument and Thesis.
Subject: English Composition II.
Lead Author: Lindsey Fliger.
Provider: Lumen Learning.
License: CC BY: Attribution.
Access/Transcript Date: June 22, 2026.