Chapter 12 Study Notes on Aggression

Chapter 12: Aggression

Why Do We Hurt Other People? Can We Prevent It?

Chapter Outline and Learning Objectives
  • Is Aggression Innate, Learned, or Optional?
      - How do evolutionary, cultural, and learning explanations of aggression differ?
  • 12.1: Influences on Aggression
      - Evolutionary View
      - Culture and Aggression
      - Gender and Aggression
      - Learning to Behave Aggressively
      - Physiological Influences
      - Social Situations and Aggression
  • 12.2: Situational and Social Causes of Aggression and Sexual Assault
      - Frustration and Aggression
      - Provocation and Reciprocation
      - Weapons as Aggressive Cues
      - Putting the Elements Together: The Case of Sexual Assault
      - Violence and the Media
  • 12.3: Observing Violence
      - Studying the Effects of Media Violence
      - Problem of Determining Cause and Effect
  • 12.4: Diminishing Aggression
      - Can Punishing Aggression Reduce It?
      - Catharsis and Aggression
      - What Are We Supposed to Do with Our Anger?
      - Disrupting the Rejection-Rage Cycle

Aggression: Definition and Distinctions

  • Definition: Intentional behavior aimed at causing physical harm or psychological pain to another person.
  • Distinction from Assertiveness: Aggression is not assertiveness; aggression involves intent to harm.
  • Types of Aggression:
      - Hostile Aggression: Stemming from anger and aimed at inflicting pain or injury.
      - Instrumental Aggression: Intention to hurt occurs as a means to an end other than causing pain.

12.1: Is Aggression Innate, Learned, or Optional?

The Evolutionary View
  • Observation: Men are statistically more aggressive than women; over 90% of mass murders are committed by men (Hillshafer, 2013).
  • Biological Factors:
      - Testosterone's Role: Higher testosterone levels correlate with higher aggression.
      - Laboratory studies show aggression levels fluctuate with testosterone manipulation.
  • Evolutionary Perspective:
      - Aggression helps males defend their group and secure mating opportunities.
      - Female aggression often involves protecting offspring.
Culture and Aggression
  • Aggression is shaped by cultural contexts; humans have the capacity for aggression but its expression is learned and influenced by social circumstances.
  • Variability in Aggression: Different cultures manifest aggression differently, with some emphasizing honor and aggression more than others.
  • Example: Historical shifts in Iroquois aggressiveness due to economic competition.
Gender and Aggression
  • Males are more likely to engage in direct aggression, while females may resort to relational aggression.
  • High rates of domestic violence exist, but data reveals women also engage in reciprocal aggression.
Learning to Behave Aggressively
  • Social-Cognitive Learning Theory: Argues that people learn aggressive behaviors from observing and imitating others, alongside cognitive processes.
  • Influential Figures: Albert Bandura's Bobo Doll study illustrates the power of observational learning in childhood aggression.
Some Physiological Influences
  • Alcohol: Increases aggression by lowering inhibitions and impairing judgment; can misinterpret social cues.
  • Pain and Heat: Increased aggressive behavior correlates with conditions of discomfort and emotional arousal (e.g., high temperatures produce more violence and riots).

12.2: Situational and Social Causes of Aggression and Sexual Assault

Frustration and Aggression
  • Frustration-Aggression Theory: Frustration can trigger aggression, especially when thwarted from clear goals.
  • Relative Deprivation: The feeling of having less than deserved or expected increases the likelihood of aggressive responses.
Provocation and Reciprocation
  • Individuals often reciprocate aggression; however, contextual mitigating factors (such as intent) can influence responses.
Weapons as Aggressive Cues
  • The mere presence of an aggressive tool (e.g., a gun) can provoke aggressive responses in individuals already feeling angry or frustrated.
Putting the Elements Together: The Case of Sexual Assault
  • Majority of rapes occur between acquaintances; it's crucial to evaluate social norms and expectations surrounding consent and aggression in these contexts.
Violence and the Media
  • Impact of Media: Research connects media violence to a rise in aggression, particularly in children, through observational conditioning and desensitization.

12.3: Observing Violence

Studying the Effects of Media Violence
  • Experiments usually show increases in aggressive behaviors following exposure to violent media.
  • Longitudinal Studies correlate heavy viewing of violence with later aggressive behaviors.
The Problem of Determining Cause and Effect
  • Correlation does not imply causation; predisposition to violence may lead to both aggression and preference for violent media.

12.4: Diminishing Aggression

Can Punishing Aggression Reduce It?
  • Harsher Punishments Lead to Increased Aggression: Aggressive forms of discipline may teach children to mimic such behavior and generate further aggression.
  • Prompt and Certain Punishment: For punishment to effectively deter crime, it must be immediate and unavoidable, which is often not the case.
Catharsis and Aggression
  • Contrary to popular belief, venting aggression does not reduce further aggressive behavior; it can actually increase it.
What Are We Supposed to Do with Our Anger?
  • Constructive Expressions: Understanding your feelings, calmly discussing them, and actively managing anger can yield more positive outcomes.
  • Vent Instead of Commit: Venting alone doesn't help; deeper self-examination through writing can be beneficial.
Disrupting the Rejection-Rage Cycle
  • Social Rejection: Significant risk factor for teenage violence; bullying prevention programs like Olweus’s have shown promise in reducing aggression statistics in schools.

Review Questions

  1. Aggression stems from feelings of hostility and is aimed at inflicting pain, whereas instrumental aggression serves as a means to some goal other than pain.
  2. What does the research on cultures of honor suggest about testosterone and aggression? Culture affects when and why men can be provoked to become aggressive.
  3. Relational aggression refers to expressing aggression indirectly by manipulating a relationship.
  4. In terms of physical aggression, men are more likely than women to engage in public displays of violence.
  5. Social-cognitive learning theory explains why, when provoked, people respond aggressively if they think aggression is justified.
  6. John is most likely to become aggressive under the condition where a stranger bumps into him in a crowded restaurant.
  7. The reasonable conclusion about the effects of media violence is that they have an effect, but primarily on children already predisposed to aggression.
  8. In the U.S., most rapes occur due to force by an acquaintance.
  9. Research finds that the catharsis theory is not supported; venting does not alleviate aggression.