Chapter 12 Study Notes on Aggression
Chapter 12: Aggression
Why Do We Hurt Other People? Can We Prevent It?
Chapter Outline and Learning Objectives
- Is Aggression Innate, Learned, or Optional?
- How do evolutionary, cultural, and learning explanations of aggression differ? - 12.1: Influences on Aggression
- Evolutionary View
- Culture and Aggression
- Gender and Aggression
- Learning to Behave Aggressively
- Physiological Influences
- Social Situations and Aggression - 12.2: Situational and Social Causes of Aggression and Sexual Assault
- Frustration and Aggression
- Provocation and Reciprocation
- Weapons as Aggressive Cues
- Putting the Elements Together: The Case of Sexual Assault
- Violence and the Media - 12.3: Observing Violence
- Studying the Effects of Media Violence
- Problem of Determining Cause and Effect - 12.4: Diminishing Aggression
- Can Punishing Aggression Reduce It?
- Catharsis and Aggression
- What Are We Supposed to Do with Our Anger?
- Disrupting the Rejection-Rage Cycle
Aggression: Definition and Distinctions
- Definition: Intentional behavior aimed at causing physical harm or psychological pain to another person.
- Distinction from Assertiveness: Aggression is not assertiveness; aggression involves intent to harm.
- Types of Aggression:
- Hostile Aggression: Stemming from anger and aimed at inflicting pain or injury.
- Instrumental Aggression: Intention to hurt occurs as a means to an end other than causing pain.
12.1: Is Aggression Innate, Learned, or Optional?
The Evolutionary View
- Observation: Men are statistically more aggressive than women; over 90% of mass murders are committed by men (Hillshafer, 2013).
- Biological Factors:
- Testosterone's Role: Higher testosterone levels correlate with higher aggression.
- Laboratory studies show aggression levels fluctuate with testosterone manipulation. - Evolutionary Perspective:
- Aggression helps males defend their group and secure mating opportunities.
- Female aggression often involves protecting offspring.
Culture and Aggression
- Aggression is shaped by cultural contexts; humans have the capacity for aggression but its expression is learned and influenced by social circumstances.
- Variability in Aggression: Different cultures manifest aggression differently, with some emphasizing honor and aggression more than others.
- Example: Historical shifts in Iroquois aggressiveness due to economic competition.
Gender and Aggression
- Males are more likely to engage in direct aggression, while females may resort to relational aggression.
- High rates of domestic violence exist, but data reveals women also engage in reciprocal aggression.
Learning to Behave Aggressively
- Social-Cognitive Learning Theory: Argues that people learn aggressive behaviors from observing and imitating others, alongside cognitive processes.
- Influential Figures: Albert Bandura's Bobo Doll study illustrates the power of observational learning in childhood aggression.
Some Physiological Influences
- Alcohol: Increases aggression by lowering inhibitions and impairing judgment; can misinterpret social cues.
- Pain and Heat: Increased aggressive behavior correlates with conditions of discomfort and emotional arousal (e.g., high temperatures produce more violence and riots).
12.2: Situational and Social Causes of Aggression and Sexual Assault
Frustration and Aggression
- Frustration-Aggression Theory: Frustration can trigger aggression, especially when thwarted from clear goals.
- Relative Deprivation: The feeling of having less than deserved or expected increases the likelihood of aggressive responses.
Provocation and Reciprocation
- Individuals often reciprocate aggression; however, contextual mitigating factors (such as intent) can influence responses.
Weapons as Aggressive Cues
- The mere presence of an aggressive tool (e.g., a gun) can provoke aggressive responses in individuals already feeling angry or frustrated.
Putting the Elements Together: The Case of Sexual Assault
- Majority of rapes occur between acquaintances; it's crucial to evaluate social norms and expectations surrounding consent and aggression in these contexts.
- Impact of Media: Research connects media violence to a rise in aggression, particularly in children, through observational conditioning and desensitization.
12.3: Observing Violence
- Experiments usually show increases in aggressive behaviors following exposure to violent media.
- Longitudinal Studies correlate heavy viewing of violence with later aggressive behaviors.
The Problem of Determining Cause and Effect
- Correlation does not imply causation; predisposition to violence may lead to both aggression and preference for violent media.
12.4: Diminishing Aggression
Can Punishing Aggression Reduce It?
- Harsher Punishments Lead to Increased Aggression: Aggressive forms of discipline may teach children to mimic such behavior and generate further aggression.
- Prompt and Certain Punishment: For punishment to effectively deter crime, it must be immediate and unavoidable, which is often not the case.
Catharsis and Aggression
- Contrary to popular belief, venting aggression does not reduce further aggressive behavior; it can actually increase it.
What Are We Supposed to Do with Our Anger?
- Constructive Expressions: Understanding your feelings, calmly discussing them, and actively managing anger can yield more positive outcomes.
- Vent Instead of Commit: Venting alone doesn't help; deeper self-examination through writing can be beneficial.
Disrupting the Rejection-Rage Cycle
- Social Rejection: Significant risk factor for teenage violence; bullying prevention programs like Olweus’s have shown promise in reducing aggression statistics in schools.
Review Questions
- Aggression stems from feelings of hostility and is aimed at inflicting pain, whereas instrumental aggression serves as a means to some goal other than pain.
- What does the research on cultures of honor suggest about testosterone and aggression? Culture affects when and why men can be provoked to become aggressive.
- Relational aggression refers to expressing aggression indirectly by manipulating a relationship.
- In terms of physical aggression, men are more likely than women to engage in public displays of violence.
- Social-cognitive learning theory explains why, when provoked, people respond aggressively if they think aggression is justified.
- John is most likely to become aggressive under the condition where a stranger bumps into him in a crowded restaurant.
- The reasonable conclusion about the effects of media violence is that they have an effect, but primarily on children already predisposed to aggression.
- In the U.S., most rapes occur due to force by an acquaintance.
- Research finds that the catharsis theory is not supported; venting does not alleviate aggression.