Consumer Response to Brand Image Changes

  • Overview of Study Context

  • The research examines the implications of changing brand images for consumers with strong self-brand connections.

  • Brands can evoke self-identity reflections, thus forming emotional bonds.

  • Key Concepts

  • Consumer-Brand Bonding: The relationship between consumers’ self-concepts and their preferred brands.

    • Brands serve as identity markers reflecting who individuals are or wish to be (Escalas & Bettman, 2009).
  • Self-Brand Connection: The degree to which a brand is incorporated into the consumer's self-concept.

    • High self-brand connection implies deeper emotional investment in the brand.
  • Brand Image Changes: Modifications either dampening or augmenting existing brand associations (e.g., brand acquisitions, repositioning).

    • Consumers often react differently depending on whether these changes align with their actual self or ideal self.
  • Hypotheses

  1. Hypothesis 1: Higher self-brand connection leads to negative responses to changes that dampen brand associations.
  2. Hypothesis 2: Consumers with high actual self-brand connections will respond more negatively to changes that augment brand associations compared to those connected to their ideal self.
  3. Hypotheses 3A & 3B:
    • Changes augmenting brand image enhance efficacy for ideal self connections (3A).
    • Reductions in self-verification efficacy occur for actual self connections (3B).
  • Consumer Responses to Damping Brand Associations

  • Brand Image Damping: Managers sometimes intentionally lower a brand's image to align with market trends or emerging consumer preferences.

    • Example: Dunkin’ Donuts changing its brand to Dunkin’ to move beyond donut associations.
  • Consumers with low self-brand connection are less affected by identity changes than those with high connections, who rely on brands for self-expression.

  • Consumer Responses to Augmenting Brand Associations

  • Augmentation can backfire if it leads to a mismatch with the consumer's actual self—reducing perceived brand congruity.

  • Example: Timberland branding might become too rugged for individuals perceiving themselves as moderately rugged.

    • Augmenting image can alienate consumers who identify closely with the brand’s current attributes.
  • Methodologies in Research

  1. Study 1: Experimental study examining responses to brand image changes through participant self-selection of brands.
  2. Study 2: Marketplace study observing real changes in university branding and student responses.
  3. Study 3: Focused on testing the motives behind self-brand connections to enrich understanding of consumer responses to image changes.
  • Findings from Studies

  • Consumers linked to their ideal selves view augmentations positively, while those connected to their actual selves respond negatively.

  • Study finds strong evidence for consumers with high ideal self-brand connections viewing image augmentation as enhancing personal identity signals (support for 3A); conversely, those with high actual self-brand connections perceive it as diminishing their self-verification (support for 3B).

  • Managerial Implications

  • Companies must carefully balance brand image consistency with the need for innovation and adaptation.

  • Understanding whether consumer connections originate from aspirations or perceptions of actual self can guide effective brand management strategies.

  • Recommendations encourage gradual image adjustments, monitoring consumer responses to maintain engagement without alienation.

  • Future Research Directions

  • Explore varied contexts of brand changes beyond acquisitions and their specific impacts on consumer behavior.

  • Investigate the psychological distinction of consumer responses stemming from self-identity constructs across diverse brands and consumer segments.

  • Further studies could analyze situations of diminished brand image and their long-term effects on consumer relationships with brands.