PSAT 8/9 Grammar Rules Quick Reference

What You Need to Know

PSAT 8/9 “grammar” questions (in the Writing/Language style) test whether a sentence follows Standard English Conventions and communicates ideas clearly and logically. You’re usually choosing the best revision: correct grammar and the cleanest, most precise option that keeps the original meaning.

Big idea: Prefer the choice that is grammatically correct, clear, concise, and consistent with the passage’s tone and facts.

The 4 highest-yield skill buckets
  1. Sentence boundaries: avoiding fragments and run-ons; choosing correct punctuation between clauses.
  2. Agreement & verb form: subject–verb agreement, tense consistency, correct verb forms.
  3. Pronouns & modifiers: clear pronoun reference, correct pronoun case, no dangling/misplaced modifiers.
  4. Punctuation & concision: commas/semicolons/colons/dashes, parallel structure, removing redundancy.

If two answers are both grammatical, the PSAT 8/9 usually rewards the one that is shorter and more direct (as long as it keeps the meaning).

Step-by-Step Breakdown

Use this quick process on almost any grammar question.

  1. Find what’s changing.

    • Compare the answer choices: are they changing punctuation, verb tense, pronouns, wording, or sentence structure?
  2. Check sentence boundaries first (fast elimination).

    • Ask: Do you have two complete sentences (independent clauses) stuck together?
    • Ask: Do you have a “sentence” missing a subject/verb (fragment)?
  3. Identify clauses and connectors.

    • Independent clause (IC): can stand alone.
    • Dependent clause (DC): starts with words like because, although, when, which, that and cannot stand alone.
  4. Apply the punctuation rule that matches the structure.

    • IC + IC needs: period, semicolon, or comma + FANBOYS.
    • IC + DC or DC + IC: usually needs a comma only when the DC comes first or is nonessential.
  5. Then check agreement/tense/pronouns/modifiers.

    • Make sure verbs match subjects, tenses stay consistent, pronouns match antecedents, modifiers attach to the right word.
  6. Choose the clearest, most concise correct option.

    • Cut redundancy.
    • Avoid awkward/wordy phrasing.
    • Keep meaning and logical relationships intact.
Mini worked checks (quick pattern recognition)
  • Run-on fix:

    • Wrong: The exhibit opened last week it drew huge crowds.
    • Right options:
    • The exhibit opened last week; it drew huge crowds.
    • The exhibit opened last week, and it drew huge crowds.
    • The exhibit opened last week. It drew huge crowds.
  • Dependent clause opener:

    • Right: Because the roads were icy, the game was postponed.
    • Wrong: Because the roads were icy the game was postponed. (missing comma after opener)

Key Formulas, Rules & Facts

Sentence boundaries & clause punctuation (highest yield)
Structure you haveCorrect punctuationNotes / quick test
IC + ICPeriodSafest boundary fix
IC + ICSemicolonBoth sides must be complete sentences
IC + ICComma + FANBOYSFANBOYS = for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so
IC + ICColonSecond clause explains/defines the first; first side must be IC
IC + ICDashLike a colon but more informal/emphatic; don’t mix with commas
IC + DCUsually no commaI left because it was late.
DC + ICComma after DCBecause it was late, I left.
IC + nonessential phrase/clauseCommas (or dashes/parentheses)If you can delete it and sentence still works, it’s nonessential

A comma splice is wrong: IC + comma + IC (no FANBOYS). Fix with period/semicolon/FANBOYS.

Comma rules that show up constantly
Comma useRuleExample
After an introductory elementIf the intro is a phrase/clause, usually commaAfter the storm, the streets flooded.
Before FANBOYS joining 2 ICsComma goes before the conjunctionI wanted to go, but I had homework.
Items in a listSeparate items; don’t separate two-word “single” itemsapples, oranges, and pears
Nonessential (extra) infoSet off with commasMy sister, who lives in Denver, is visiting.
Essential infoNo commasThe student who won the prize thanked her teacher.
Between coordinate adjectivesUse comma if you can swap them or insert “and”a bright, sunny day vs two red balloons (no comma)
Semicolons, colons, and dashes
MarkUse it when…Don’t do this
Semicolon (;)Joining two ICs closely relatedDon’t use if either side isn’t an IC
Colon (:)After an IC to introduce list/explanation/exampleDon’t put a colon after a verb or preposition (includes:… is usually wrong)
Dash (—)Adds emphasis or interruption; can set off nonessential infoDon’t use both dash and comma for the same interruption
Apostrophes (possession vs contraction)
FormMeaningExample
it’sit isIt’s raining.
itspossessiveThe dog wagged its tail.
plural nouns ending in spossessive with apostrophe after sthe players’ uniforms
singular nounapostrophe + sthe player’s uniform
Subject–verb agreement (SVA)

Rule: The verb must match the true subject (ignore prepositional phrases in between).

PatternCorrectWhy
The list of itemsisSubject = list (singular)
The items on the listareSubject = items (plural)
Either/Neither/Each/Everyone/Someonesingular verbEach of the students is…
More than one (as a phrase)singular verbMore than one student is…
A number ofplural verbA number of students are…
The number ofsingular verbThe number of students is…
Verb tense & form
What they testRuleQuick check
Tense consistencyKeep tense consistent with time markers and nearby verbsLook for yesterday, now, since 2010
Perfect tensesUse has/have/had + past participlehas written, had gone
Simple past vs present perfectPast = finished time; present perfect = continues/unspecified timeIn 2019, she wrote… vs She has written many…
Pronouns (agreement, reference, case)
SkillRuleExample
AgreementPronoun matches antecedent in number and personA student should bring his or her / their notes (keep consistent)
Clear referencePronoun must clearly refer to one nounAvoid vague this/that/it/they
Subject vs objectUse I/he/she/we/they as subjects; me/him/her/us/them as objectsShe and I went; between you and me
Who vs whomwho = subject; whom = objectWho called? / Whom did you call?
Modifiers (placement matters)
IssueFixExample
Dangling modifierPut the doer right after the introWrong: Walking to school, the rain soaked me. Right: Walking to school, I got soaked by the rain.
Misplaced modifierPlace modifier next to what it describesWrong: She almost drove her kids to school every day. (means “almost drove”) Better: She drove her kids to school almost every day.
Parallelism (lists & comparisons)

Rule: Items in a list or comparison must match grammatical form.

StructureCorrectWrong
-ing listrunning, jumping, and swimmingrunning, jumped, and swimming
to + verb listto read, to write, and to drawto read, writing, and to draw
comparisonsCompare like with likeher work is better than his work (not better than him)
Concision & word choice (PSAT loves “clean”)
PreferAvoidWhy
fewer wordsextra fillerPSAT rewards clarity
specific, accurate wordsfancy but imprecise wordsDon’t change meaning
active voice (often)unnecessary passive voiceClearer agent/action
“because”“due to the fact that”Wordiness
“many”“a large number of”Wordiness
Common idioms & usage (frequent traps)
Tested pairCorrect use
between / amongbetween = 2; among = 3+
fewer / lessfewer = countable; less = uncountable
number / amountnumber = countable; amount = uncountable
compare to / compare withto = liken; with = analyze similarities/differences (either may appear, but keep meaning)
different fromstandard on tests (not different than)
not only…but alsokeep parallel structure on both sides

Examples & Applications

Example 1: Fixing a run-on

Sentence: The scientist recorded the results she published them the next day.

Key insight: Two independent clauses.

Best fixes (any would work depending on choices):

  • The scientist recorded the results; she published them the next day.
  • The scientist recorded the results, and she published them the next day.

Avoid: …results, she published… (comma splice)

Example 2: Essential vs nonessential clause

Sentence: The painting, that hangs in the museum’s east wing, is on loan.

Key insight: that typically introduces essential info (no commas). Also, if the location is just extra detail, use which + commas.

Two correct routes (meaning decides):

  • Essential: The painting that hangs in the museum’s east wing is on loan.
  • Nonessential: The painting, which hangs in the museum’s east wing, is on loan.
Example 3: Subject–verb agreement with prepositional phrase

Sentence: The bouquet of roses and lilies smell sweet.

Key insight: Subject is bouquet (singular), not roses/lilies.

Correct: The bouquet of roses and lilies smells sweet.

Example 4: Parallelism with correlative conjunctions

Sentence: The program not only teaches coding but also teamwork.

Key insight: The two things after not only and but also should match form.

Correct options:

  • …teaches not only coding but also teamwork. (noun + noun)
  • …not only teaches students to code but also helps them build teamwork skills. (verb phrase + verb phrase)

Common Mistakes & Traps

  1. Comma splice (IC, IC)

    • What goes wrong: You join two complete sentences with only a comma.
    • Why wrong: A comma alone can’t join two ICs.
    • Fix: Use a period, semicolon, or comma + FANBOYS.
  2. Fragment after a dependent word

    • What goes wrong: Because/Although/When… starts a “sentence” with no IC.
    • Why wrong: Dependent clauses can’t stand alone.
    • Fix: Add an independent clause or remove the dependent starter.
  3. Using a semicolon like a comma

    • What goes wrong: I went to the store; because we needed milk.
    • Why wrong: After a semicolon, you need an IC.
    • Fix: I went to the store because we needed milk.
  4. Random commas splitting subject and verb

    • What goes wrong: The students in the band, practice daily.
    • Why wrong: Don’t separate subject from its verb with a comma.
    • Fix: The students in the band practice daily.
  5. Nonessential vs essential confusion

    • What goes wrong: Commas around information that’s necessary to identify the noun.
    • Why wrong: Essential info should not be “lift-out” with commas.
    • Fix: Use no commas for essential clauses (often with that).
  6. Pronoun ambiguity (“this/that/they” with no clear noun)

    • What goes wrong: The committee debated the proposal, and this upset residents.
    • Why wrong: “This” could mean the proposal, the debate, or the decision.
    • Fix: Replace with a noun: …and the delay upset residents.
  7. Faulty comparison

    • What goes wrong: Her salary is higher than her assistant.
    • Why wrong: You compared a salary to a person.
    • Fix: …higher than her assistant’s salary.
  8. Choosing the “fancier” wording instead of the clearest

    • What goes wrong: Picking longer synonyms that shift tone/meaning.
    • Why wrong: The test rewards precision and concision.
    • Fix: If two are correct, choose the simpler/shorter one that keeps meaning.

Memory Aids & Quick Tricks

Trick / mnemonicWhat it helps you rememberWhen to use it
IC, FANBOYS ICComma + coordinating conjunction joins two ICsIf you see and/but/so etc.
FANBOYS (for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so)The only conjunctions that can follow a comma to join ICsRun-on/comma splice fixes
“Delete test”If you can delete a phrase and sentence still works, it’s nonessential → set off with commasEssential vs nonessential decisions
“Preposition phrases don’t vote”Ignore phrases like of…, in…, with… when matching subject–verbSubject–verb agreement
“Who = he, whom = him”Subject vs object caseWho/whom questions
“Colon = drumroll”A colon introduces what comes next (list/example/explanation) after a full sentenceColon vs semicolon vs comma
“Like with like”Comparisons must compare the same kinds of thingsThan/as comparisons

Quick Review Checklist

  • Can you spot independent vs dependent clauses quickly?
  • If it’s IC + IC, did you use period / semicolon / comma + FANBOYS (not just a comma)?
  • Did you avoid fragments starting with because/although/when/which?
  • Are commas used only for intro elements, lists, nonessential info, or IC + FANBOYS?
  • Do verbs match the true subject (ignoring prepositional phrases)?
  • Are verb tenses consistent with time markers and surrounding sentences?
  • Do pronouns have a clear antecedent and correct case (I/me, who/whom)?
  • Are modifiers placed right next to what they describe (no dangling/misplaced modifiers)?
  • Are lists and paired structures parallel?
  • If multiple choices are correct, did you pick the clearest and most concise?

You’ve got this—scan for structure first, then polish for clarity and concision.