Economic Policy II + III
Overview of Economic Systems and Global Spectrum
Fundamental Economic Dichotomy: The fundamental tension in economic policy exists between the ideological poles of Capitalism and Socialism.
The Economic Spectrum: A ideological axis used to evaluate the degree of government involvement in the economy. - More Government / Collectivism: This end of the spectrum is represented by Communism. - Intermediate Systems: Mid-spectrum systems include Socialism and the Mixed Economy Welfare model. - Less Government / Individualism: This end of the spectrum is represented by Capitalism.
Existential Questions for the United States: - Determining which economic system the United States currently operates under. - Debating which economic system the United States should idealistically possess.
The Role of Government and Core Economic Policies
The Central Question of Economic Activity: "What is the proper role of government in a free market economy?"
Defining Capitalism: According to page 579 of the course materials, Capitalism is defined as a system where "The government generally stays out of most economic activity, except to regulate the market when it produces too much of something that is not in the public’s interest."
Avenues of Economic Policymaking: The government influences the economy through two primary levers: - Fiscal Policy: The management of government revenue and expenditures through taxing and spending. - Monetary Policy: The management and regulation of the nation's money supply.
Fiscal Policy: Analysis of Top Marginal Tax Rates (1915-2024)
Definition of Top Marginal Tax Rate: The specific tax rate paid by the wealthiest Americans on any income earned above a designated financial threshold.
2024 Single Taxpayer Threshold: For a single filer in 2024, the top marginal tax rate applies to income exceeding .
Historical Fluctuations in Top Tax Rates: - 1945: The top marginal tax rate reached its historic peak of . - 2012: The rate declined significantly to a low of . - 2013: The rate saw a slight increase to . - 2018-2024: The rate fell back to and has remained at .
Political and Economic Debate: Policymakers continuously weigh the arguments for and against increasing these rates to address revenue needs versus promoting individual wealth retention.
Data Sources: Historical figures derived from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) "SOI Tax Stats-Historical Table 23" and IRS data updates through August 2024.
Fiscal Policy: Mandatory vs. Discretionary Spending (1974-2034)
Budgetary Composition: Federal spending is divided into three primary categories: Mandatory Spending, Discretionary Spending, and Net Interest.
Trends in Discretionary Spending: Since the s, the percentage of the budget allocated for discretionary spending has been consistently shrinking.
Implications for Governance: The reduction in discretionary funds creates significant challenges for members of Congress and the President when attempting to reduce federal deficits, as a larger portion of the budget is pre-committed to mandatory programs.
Projected Outlook: Based on the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) update from June 2024, projections through suggest a continued dominance of mandatory spending and net interest over discretionary options.
Economic Growth Philosophies: Keynesian vs. Supply-Side
Keynesian Economics: - Primary Problem: Identified as insufficient demand within the market. - The Vicious Cycle: High unemployment leads to people having no money to spend. This lack of consumer spending results in further business losses and subsequent job cuts. - Proposed Solution: Utilization of Fiscal Policy. The government should initiate tax cuts and increase government spending to "get money in people’s pockets." - Desired Outcome: To break the cycle by stimulating a chain reaction: spending employment more spending more employment.
Supply-Side Economics: - Primary Problem: Identified as insufficient supply within the market. - Economic Constraints: A tight money supply leads banks to charge high interest rates or refuse loans entirely. This environment makes it difficult for businesses to start up, expand, or hire new personnel. - Proposed Solution: Utilization of Monetary Policy. This involves cutting taxes and reducing government spending to ensure there is more money available for private investment and to curb inflation. - Desired Outcome: An ultimate increase in government revenue as thriving businesses and their employees pay more in taxes over the long term.
Course Schedule and Reading Assignments
Economic Policy Phase: - Dates: March 23 (Mon.), March 25 (Wed.), & March 27 (Fri.). - Reading: Chapter 15, pages and .
Social Policy Phase: - Dates: March 30 (Mon.) & April 1 (Wed.). - Reading: Chapter 16, pages and .
Observed Breaks: - No class scheduled for April 3 (Fri.) and April 6 (Mon.) in observance of Easter Break.