Economic Policy II + III

Overview of Economic Systems and Global Spectrum

  • Fundamental Economic Dichotomy: The fundamental tension in economic policy exists between the ideological poles of Capitalism and Socialism.

  • The Economic Spectrum: A ideological axis used to evaluate the degree of government involvement in the economy.     - More Government / Collectivism: This end of the spectrum is represented by Communism.     - Intermediate Systems: Mid-spectrum systems include Socialism and the Mixed Economy Welfare model.     - Less Government / Individualism: This end of the spectrum is represented by Capitalism.

  • Existential Questions for the United States:     - Determining which economic system the United States currently operates under.     - Debating which economic system the United States should idealistically possess.

The Role of Government and Core Economic Policies

  • The Central Question of Economic Activity: "What is the proper role of government in a free market economy?"

  • Defining Capitalism: According to page 579 of the course materials, Capitalism is defined as a system where "The government generally stays out of most economic activity, except to regulate the market when it produces too much of something that is not in the public’s interest."

  • Avenues of Economic Policymaking: The government influences the economy through two primary levers:     - Fiscal Policy: The management of government revenue and expenditures through taxing and spending.     - Monetary Policy: The management and regulation of the nation's money supply.

Fiscal Policy: Analysis of Top Marginal Tax Rates (1915-2024)

  • Definition of Top Marginal Tax Rate: The specific tax rate paid by the wealthiest Americans on any income earned above a designated financial threshold.

  • 2024 Single Taxpayer Threshold: For a single filer in 2024, the top marginal tax rate applies to income exceeding $609,351\$609,351.

  • Historical Fluctuations in Top Tax Rates:     - 1945: The top marginal tax rate reached its historic peak of 94%94\%.     - 2012: The rate declined significantly to a low of 35%35\%.     - 2013: The rate saw a slight increase to 39.6%39.6\%.     - 2018-2024: The rate fell back to and has remained at 37%37\%.

  • Political and Economic Debate: Policymakers continuously weigh the arguments for and against increasing these rates to address revenue needs versus promoting individual wealth retention.

  • Data Sources: Historical figures derived from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) "SOI Tax Stats-Historical Table 23" and IRS data updates through August 2024.

Fiscal Policy: Mandatory vs. Discretionary Spending (1974-2034)

  • Budgetary Composition: Federal spending is divided into three primary categories: Mandatory Spending, Discretionary Spending, and Net Interest.

  • Trends in Discretionary Spending: Since the 19701970s, the percentage of the budget allocated for discretionary spending has been consistently shrinking.

  • Implications for Governance: The reduction in discretionary funds creates significant challenges for members of Congress and the President when attempting to reduce federal deficits, as a larger portion of the budget is pre-committed to mandatory programs.

  • Projected Outlook: Based on the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) update from June 2024, projections through 20342034 suggest a continued dominance of mandatory spending and net interest over discretionary options.

Economic Growth Philosophies: Keynesian vs. Supply-Side

  • Keynesian Economics:     - Primary Problem: Identified as insufficient demand within the market.     - The Vicious Cycle: High unemployment leads to people having no money to spend. This lack of consumer spending results in further business losses and subsequent job cuts.     - Proposed Solution: Utilization of Fiscal Policy. The government should initiate tax cuts and increase government spending to "get money in people’s pockets."     - Desired Outcome: To break the cycle by stimulating a chain reaction: spending →\rightarrow employment →\rightarrow more spending →\rightarrow more employment.

  • Supply-Side Economics:     - Primary Problem: Identified as insufficient supply within the market.     - Economic Constraints: A tight money supply leads banks to charge high interest rates or refuse loans entirely. This environment makes it difficult for businesses to start up, expand, or hire new personnel.     - Proposed Solution: Utilization of Monetary Policy. This involves cutting taxes and reducing government spending to ensure there is more money available for private investment and to curb inflation.     - Desired Outcome: An ultimate increase in government revenue as thriving businesses and their employees pay more in taxes over the long term.

Course Schedule and Reading Assignments

  • Economic Policy Phase:     - Dates: March 23 (Mon.), March 25 (Wed.), & March 27 (Fri.).     - Reading: Chapter 15, pages 574−603574-603 and 608−611608-611.

  • Social Policy Phase:     - Dates: March 30 (Mon.) & April 1 (Wed.).     - Reading: Chapter 16, pages 618−633618-633 and 639−654639-654.

  • Observed Breaks:     - No class scheduled for April 3 (Fri.) and April 6 (Mon.) in observance of Easter Break.