*Chapter 4 Professional Ethics

What Are Ethics?

  • Ethics can be defined broadly as a set of moral principles or values

  • Ethical behavior is necessary for a society to function in an orderly manner

  • The need for ethics in society is sufficiently important that many commonly held ethical values are incorporated into laws

Why People Act Unethically

  • Most people define unethical behavior as conduct that differs from what they believe is appropriate given the circumstances

  • There are two primary reasons why people act unethically:

    • The person’s ethical standards are different from
      those of society as a whole

    • The person chooses to act selfishly

Ethical Dilemmas

  • An ethical dilemma is a situation a person faces in which a decision must be made about the appropriate behavior

  • Care must be taken to avoid methods that are rationalizations of unethical behavior:

    • Everybody does it

    • If it’s legal, it’s ethical

    • Likelihood of discovery and consequences

      • No one will figure it out

Resolving Ethical Dilemmas

  • The following is a six-step approach intended to be a relatively simple approach to resolving ethical dilemmas:

    • Obtain the relevant facts

    • Identify the ethical issues from the facts

    • Determine who is affected by the outcome of the dilemma and how each person or group is affected

    • Identify the alternatives available to the person who must resolve the dilemma

    • Identify the likely consequence of each alternative

    • Decide the appropriate action

Special Need for Ethical Conduct in Professions

  • Professionals are expected to conduct themselves at a higher level than most other members of society

  • Public confiedece in the quality of professional service is enhanced by high standards of performance and conduct

  • It is essential that:

    • Client and external financial statement users have Confedent in the quality of audits and other services

    • Users regard CPA firms as competent and unbiased

*Auditors only give 1-page reports→ people need to trust their page, or we are unemployed (Anderson)
Difference Between CPA Firms and Other Professionals

  • Other professionals are typically engaged and paid by a client and have primary responsibility to be an advocate for that client

    • A client hires their own attorney, etc

  • CPA firms are usually engaged by management for private companies and the Audit committee for public companies:

    • They are paid by the Company issuing the financial statements

    • The primary Benficiaries of the audit are financial statement users

      • Client→User→Firm: Ethics become more important

Figure 4.2 Ways the Profession and Society Encourage CPA s to Conduct Themselves at a High Level
Need code of conduct (ethics) to maintain trust
Let’s Discuss (1 of 7)

  • Identify some of the most important ways that the profession and society encourage CPA s to conduct themselves at a high level.

Let’s Discuss (2 of 7)

  • Why is there a special need for professional conduct by CPA s?

    • How does this differ from the need for special conduct in other professions?

Code of Professional Conduct (1 of 2)

  • Members of the AICPA agree to follow the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct

  • The Code consists of:

    • Principles that provide the framework for the rules that govern the CPA’s performance of professional responsibilities

    • Rules of Conduct that must be followed by members

    • Interpretations of the rules to address circumstances members may face that are threats to compliance with the rules of conduct

  • Rules of conduct are Enforcable and many practitioners refer to them as the AICP A Code of Professional Conduct

  • When practitioners conduct themselves at the minimum level set up the profession, it does not imply unsatisfactory conduct

  • The profession has presumably set the standards sufficiently high to make the minimum conduct satisfactory

Table 4.2 (1 of 2)
image
Table 4.2 (2 of 2)
Principles of Professional Conduct (continued)
image
Table 4.3 (1 of 3)
Threats to Compliance with Rules Under the AICPA Code of
Professional Conduct
image
Table 4.3 (2 of 3)
Threats to Compliance with Rules Under the AICP A Code
of Professional Conduct (continued)
image
Table 4.3 (3 of 3)
Threats to Compliance with Rules Under the A I C P A Code
of Professional Conduct (continued)
image
Let’s Discuss (3 of 7)

  • What is the purpose of the Principles of Professional Conduct? Identify the six principles.

  • Explain the conceptual framework for the Rules of Conduct and how it should be applied.

Independence Rule

  • The value of auditing depends heavily on the public’s Peception of the independence of auditors

  • CPA firms are required to be independent for certain services that they provide:

    • The Independence Rule applies to audits and other types of attestations

      • Assurance

    • A CPA firm can do tax returns and provide consulting (Management services) without being independent

  • *Independence consists of two components:

    • Independence of mind

      • Reflects the auditor’s state of mind that permits the audit to be performed with an unbiased attitude

    • Independence of appearance

      • The result of others’ interpretations of the auditor’s independence

      • 3rd person thinks that independence is violated

  • Significant issues and interpretations involving independence: (Violate independence of appearance)

    • Financial issues/intersts (typically stock, etc)

    • Related financial interests (Parents own stock)

    • Consulting, bookkeeping, other non attest servises

    • Litigation between the CPA firm and the client

    • Unpaid fees

    • Network of firms (Subsidiaries or groups) (PWC: PWC US, PWC Japan, PWC UK)

Sarbanes–Oxley and Related Independence Requirements (1 of 2)

  • Auditors of Public companies must comply with the independence requirements of the Sarbanes–Oxley Act, the PCAOB, and the SEC

  • Sarbanes–Oxley and SEC rules restrict the types of nonattest services that can be provided to publicly held audit clients

  • Sarbanes–Oxley also requires the audit committee of a public company to be responsible for the appointment, Compensation, and oversight of the work of the auditor

    • Audit committee is an independent part of the public company

    • Board of directors: oversees the client, including management (CEO,CFO,etc) (Only for public company)

      • Independent directors: in charge of some policies (helps give the CEO oversight)

        • Compensate CEO

        • Appoint CEO

      • Non-independent directors

        • CEO

      • SUB group: Audit committee

        • Independent directors that oversee the audit and financial reporting

        • Responsible for paying the auditor

        • Who the auditor reports to

  • There are other independence rules related to the following:

    • Conflicts arising from employment relationships

    • Partner rotation (US: 5 yrs)

      • Lead partner must change

    • Ownership interests

    • Shopping for accounting principles (“opinion shopping”)

      • Examples:

        • Company takes crypto as payment; accounting standards are unclear on treatment. Audit company asks PWC and KPMG: Do you allow crypto as a short-term asset?

        • Lease treatment: Will you allow it as an operating or capital lease?

    • Engagement and payment of audit fees by management

Let’s Discuss (4 of 7)

  • Distinguish between independence of mind and independence in appearance. Identify an activity that may not affect independence of mind but is likely to affect independence in appearance.

  • Explain the role of the audit committee in enhancing auditor independence.

Let’s Discuss (5 of 7)

  • Why is an auditor’s independence so essential?

  • Many people believe that a CPA cannot be truly independent when payment of fees is dependent on the management of the client.

    • Explain two approaches that could reduce this appearance of lack of independence.

Other Rules of Conduct (1 of 4)

  • Integrity and Objectivity

    • Auditor shall maintain objectivity and integrity, be free of conflicts of interest, and shall not knowingly misrepresent facts or subordinate his or her judgment to others

  • Technical Standards

    • The primary purpose is to provide support for the technical standards-setting bodies

  • Confidentiality

    • Practitioners shall not disclose any confidential client information without the specific consent of the client

  • *Contingent Fees

    • Basing fees on the outcome of engagements is prohibited

  • Commissions and Referral Fees

    • CPA s are prohibited from receiving commissions for a client who is receiving attestation services from them

    • Referral fees for recommending or referring the services of another CPA are not restricted

  • Advertising and Solicitation

    • CPA s are prohibited from advertising or solicitation that is false, misleading, or deceptive

  • Form of Organization and Name

    • Restrict the permissible forms of organization and prohibit CPA s from practicing under a firm name that is misleading

  • Discreditable Acts

    • CPA s shall not commit an act discreditable to the profession

Let’s Discuss (6 of 7)

  • Identify the circumstances under which a CPA can disclose confidential information without client permission.

  • Explain the rule on contingent fees.

    • Why is this rule necessary?

Enforcement

  • Failure to follow the rules of conduct can result in expulsion, sanctions, and suspension from the following entities:

    • AICPA Professional Ethics Division

      • Suspension or expulsion

    • State Board of Accountancy

      • Loss of the CPA certificate and license

    • PCAOB

      • Sanctions, suspension, or revocation of the firm’s registration

Let’s Discuss (7 of 7)

  • Assume that an auditor makes an agreement with a client that the audit fee will be contingent upon the number of days required to complete the engagement.

    • Is this a violation of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct?

    • What is the essence of the rule of professional conduct dealing with contingent fees, and what are the reasons for the rule?