Lecture: Learning from Plants (Plant Behavior, Cognition, and Plant Rights)
keeping an eye on the intended agent
*with plants more-so than any topic, it is easier for us to drift towards human-centers topics and anthropocentric framings (past lectures)
how do the plants matter to us
try to look from non/less anthropocentric frame
“agent / agency”- the ability to make your own decisions independently (choice, action) (the capacity to act)
“agent” - the main character, making choices, taking actions
not saying that all life is identically valuable, but that all life is intrinsically valuable
intrinsic value does not equate to equal treatment
we just have to recognize that they are all living beings and that means something/ could mean something
Calvo’s new frame of thinking: deeply considering plant behavior and the experience of plant life
what does it mean to be “a subject of a life”?
to recognized that you have a life that you are living and that you have agency (main character that can make choices and do actions)
“subject” can also just be anything that “is not an object” like a “self”, a “main character”, etc.
plants have the right to simply be NOT considered objects (have the right to BE the SUBJECT and not just an object)
plant
Christopher Stone: “should trees have legal standing”?
did not argue that the trees are like people and deserve identical treatment. He argues that legal systems have repeatedly expanded who counts as a legal subject over time
he asks the question: why must natural entities always appear in court only through human property owners?
the only way to take the case to court was to make an anthropocentric argument that building the resort infringed on the sierra club members ability to hike, even though they didnt own the land (comes down to property)
Manoomin et al. vs. Minesota department of natural resources
case could be made because the Manoomin is central to the indigenous people Anishinaabe Ojibwe (there is a relationship with rights and responsibilites)
humans being sustained and custodians of the Manoomin
reciprocal relationship btw humans and manoomin (rice)
case was argued that the rights of the rice itself had been violated and bc our legal systems does not recognize plants as persons (they dont have “rights) the case was dismissed
recognizing the plant time scale and not ignoring it because of our own human time-scales
Smart Plant Behaviour: Cognition, Adaptation, and Learning in Plants
Methodological Principles: Seeing Not Looking
Technological Observation vs. Direct Naturalistic Engagement:
Scientific inquiry into plant life has shifted historically from the windowsill observations of bedridden naturalists to laboratory setups utilizing high-resolution, automated time-lapse cinematography.
Comprehensive evaluation of plant intelligence requires combining modern technological instrumentation with the naked-eye observational intimacy modeled by Charles Darwin in the nineteenth century.
The naked eye grounds scientific observation in the concrete reality of a specific plant, situated in an exact location, at an exact moment in time.
Technological tools provide necessary augmentation but possess intrinsic perceptual limits that require deliberate methodological caution.
Rejection of Abstract Taxonomy in Favor of Individual Plasticity:
Traditional botanical paradigms have historically prioritized taxonomy, static classification systems, and formal botanical nomenclature.
Broad taxonomic categories and abstract groupings obscure individual behavioral variations and fail to capture the flexible, intelligent capacities of distinct organisms.
Empirical focus must shift toward connecting with the concrete, individual reality of specific plants functioning within their immediate operational environments.
Avoiding Animism, Anthropocentrism, and Anthropomorphism:
Researchers must recognize plants as fundamentally animate organisms without collapsing into spiritualized animism.
Dismantling anthropocentric hegemony requires acknowledging that cognitive capabilities are not unique to human or vertebrate architectures.
Avoiding anthropomorphic bias is essential: cognitive faculties must be assessed strictly according to the organism's unique ecological needs rather than by projecting animal forms or behaviors onto plant systems.
Extending cognitive science to non-animal life expands objective frameworks for understanding cognition in general, including human cognition.
The Biophysics and Kinematics of Circumnutation
The Root-Tip Brain Hypothesis and Early Explorations:
Collaborative investigations conducted by František Baluška (Institute of Cellular and Molecular Botany, University of Bonn), Stefano Mancuso (International Laboratory of Plant Neurobiology in Florence), and MINT Lab researchers in San José, southern Spain, centered on the hypothesis that the plant's central sensory-processing organ resides within the root apex.
This theoretical orientation originates from Charles Darwin's foundational work positing that the radicle functions analogously to the brain of lower animals.
Initial observations centered on time-lapse footage of Phaseolus vulgaris (the Supermarconi variety of pole bean), revealing dynamic, directed searches for structural climbing poles.
Cellular Mechanics of the Motor Zone:
Circumnutation—the circular or elliptical rotational movement executed by growing plant organs—is controlled by an active "motor zone" situated between the terminal tendril and the vertical stem.
Circumnutation is an actively modulated, fine-tuned motor pattern rather than an involuntary, passive physical trajectory.
Motor-zone cells function as biological hydraulic pumps through alternating, asymmetrical cycles of cellular expansion and contraction across opposing flanks of the stem.
Charged ions move through dynamic, wave-like patterns across cell membranes, creating an osmotic gradient that drives water into and out of adjacent cells.
This shifting turgor pressure causes a rhythmic pulse—resembling a smooth Mexican wave of fluid inflation and deflation—that alters the relative length of each side of the stem, driving directional movement.
Kinematic Trajectory and Targeted Groping in Climbing Beans:
In The Movements and Habits of Climbing Plants, Darwin described the movement of Ceropegia (an ornamental twiner) as resembling a rope swung in shifting arcs until making firm physical contact with a support, ascending it, or falling across to an opposite stick.
The circumnutation of twining shoots exhibits kinematic characteristics analogous to a fly fisherman casting a line or a cowboy swinging a lasso: successive arcing revolutions sweep through space, pausing briefly at the apex of the back-cast before lunging forward with targeted trajectory refinement.
Controlled laboratory studies of Phaseolus vulgaris conducted in custom growth booths with support poles positioned at a distance of revealed that the shoot tip carves an expanding helical pathway in three-dimensional space.
Trajectory profiles shift gradually from circular to distinctly elliptical sweeps as the shoot lengthens.
In controlled tracking trials, the bean completed full revolutions, displaying a mean lap duration of , with the shortest lap measuring and the longest extending to .
Crucially, when homing in on the target, shoots can interrupt the expected regular circular sweep, cutting directly across the center of the helical orbit to grasp the support pole in an efficient, targeted maneuver.
Defining Plant Cognition: Adaptation versus Flexible Intelligence
The Evolutionary Critique of Plant Behavior:
Skeptics frequently argue that plant movements represent mere phenotypic adaptations—fixed, pre-programmed, reflex-driven responses shaped strictly by natural selection over evolutionary timescales.
Complex structural features, such as orchid flowers engineered to lure, deceive, and coat pollinating insects with pollen, demonstrate sophisticated evolutionary selection without requiring real-time cognitive processing by the plant.
Differentiating between automatic adaptation and authentic cognitive processing requires examining the degrees of real-time behavioral flexibility, integration, and anticipation exhibited by the organism.
Structural and Functional Criteria Distinguishing Adaptation from Cognition:
Adaptation (Reactive/Hardwired):
Genetically hardwired responses optimized for survival over evolutionary generations.
Operates purely reactively: an external physical or chemical stimulus must directly trigger the physiological reaction.
Exhibits minimal behavioral plasticity, typically executing an invariant, stereotyped output.
Demands negligible internal processing power, functioning akin to an automatic garage-door sensor or a human patellar (knee-jerk) closed-circuit neural reflex arc.
Cognition (Flexible/Goal-Directed):
Operates anticipatorily, enabling an organism to forecast and prepare for future environmental fluctuations.
Displays multi-layered behavioral flexibility, producing diverse phenotypic responses based on context and multiple interacting environmental inputs.
Maintains goal-directed intentionality aimed at actively altering the organism's physiological state or external surroundings.
Synthesizes and integrates complex information streams flowing between disparately located organ systems (e.g., systemic root-to-shoot communication).
Demonstrates lifetime plasticity that can be updated through ontogenetic learning and memory acquisition.
The Radicle as an Integrative Processor:
Charles Darwin and Francis Darwin demonstrated in The Power of Movement in Plants that the tip of the germinating root (the radicle) serves as the primary seat of sensorimotor integration.
The radicle constantly interrogates multiple simultaneous, often conflicting, environmental variables—including moisture gradients, nutritional pockets, gravity, light, and mechanical barriers.
The Darwins conceptualized this decision-making process as an internal "war of causes," in which competing environmental stimuli act concurrently upon the root apex, with the plant resolving conflicts hierarchically to execute adaptive directional choices based on immediate survival needs.
Structural Adaptations and Fixed Interspecific Arms Races
Structural Engineering in the Walking Palm (Socratea exorrhiza):
Native to the humid, tropical rainforests of South America, Socratea exorrhiza features a slender, waif-like trunk measuring only in average diameter while reaching heights between and .
A basal basket of stilt-like aerial roots elevates the trunk base above the forest floor.
A 1980 hypothesis suggested that the palm actively "walks" across swampy terrain by producing new roots toward open space while shedding older roots behind it.
Rigorous empirical evaluation confirms that the walking palm does not locomote across the forest floor.
The true functional value of the stilt architecture is purely structural: it permits the plant to rapidly reach canopy light without investing massive metabolic resources into radial trunk girth, while stabilizing the tree on unstable ground littered with decaying logs.
Obligate Mycoheterotrophy in Sciaphila yakushimensis:
Identified in 2015 by Kenji Suetsugu's research group (Hakubi Center for Advanced Research, Kyoto University) on Yakushima Island, Japan.
Sciaphila yakushimensis is a subterranean, sciaphilic ("shade-loving") parasitic plant that has entirely lost photosynthetic capability.
The plant remains underground for the majority of its life cycle, emerging only to produce small, deep-red aerial stems several inches tall bearing reproductive flower buds.
It bypasses autotrophic carbon synthesis by tapping into mycorrhizal fungal networks linked to the root systems of ancient cedar trees, pilfering sugars and essential minerals without contributing energetic compounds.
Herbivore Manipulation and Induced Cannibalism in Tomatoes:
Studies conducted by John Orrock and colleagues (Department of Integrative Biology, University of Wisconsin) show that cultivated tomato plants under herbivore attack by caterpillars mount sophisticated chemical defenses.
Damaged tomato tissues synthesize defensive phytochemicals that render their foliage unpalatable while alerting nearby healthy plants via volatile signals.
These defensive compounds shift the caterpillars' feeding behavior, inducing intra-species predation (cannibalism) among the caterpillars.
This cross-species behavioral manipulation reduces caterpillar populations while diverting feeding away from the plant's photosynthetic foliage.
Despite its complexity, this chemical mechanism constitutes an evolutionary adaptation developed through an ongoing plant-herbivore arms race, functioning via genetically pre-programmed chemical induction rather than active cognitive computation.
Anticipatory Behavior, Heliotropism, and Internal Models
Phenological and Heliotropic Forecasting:
Tropical African flora routinely produce lush foliage prior to the onset of the seasonal rains, preparing photosynthetic tissues in advance to maximize exploitation of the upcoming wet season.
Heliotropism (solar tracking) involves leaves, stems, and flower heads dynamically tracing the sun's trajectory across the celestial arc from east to west.
Young sunflowers (Helianthus annuus) maintain tracking accuracy within of the sun's actual position, keeping floral tissues warm to optimize pollinator attraction.
Related taxa exhibiting heliotropic tracking include cotton (Gossypium) and other Malvaceae, as well as legumes such as soybean (Glycine max) and alfalfa (Medicago sativa).
Mature sunflowers permanently cease dynamic tracking, fixing their open flower heads in an eastward orientation to capitalize on early morning irradiance.
Internal Predictive Clocks versus Passive Light Following:
Heliotropic plants track the sun even during overcast, cloudy days when direct solar cues are completely absent.
If a young sunflower is rotated during the night, it cannot instantly reorient to the inverted light regime; it requires several consecutive days to systematically recalibrate its directional sweeps to the new solar vector.
Sun-tracking plants execute overnight reorientation, sweeping back from west to east in darkness to face the anticipated point of sunrise before dawn occurs.
This nocturnal repositioning occurs at approximately double the speed of daytime solar tracking, maintaining its anticipatory timing in the total absence of external solar cues.
Asymmetric Starch Allocation as a Physical Clock in Cornish Mallow (Lavatera):
The predictive nocturnal reorientation of Cornish mallow (Lavatera) relies on an internal biochemical memory mechanism mediated by starch storage.
During daytime photosynthesis, synthesized sugars are converted into starch granules within the stem tissues; directional sunrise irradiation deposits high concentrations of starch granules on the eastern side of the stem, whereas overhead midday sun deposits starch symmetrically.
Throughout the night, stored starch is metabolized into energy; however, because the dawn-facing flank accumulated higher starch reserves, residual granules persist on that side at night's end.
These residual starch deposits regulate differential cellular hydration and turgor across the stem, physically bending the stem eastward in anticipation of dawn.
Lavatera maintains this anticipatory eastward bending across multiple days even when kept in prolonged, total darkness.
Ecological Advantages of Predictive Internal Models:
Internal circadian clocks synchronize internal physiological cycles with external ecological rhythms; genetic knockout of circadian genes results in profound fitness penalties.
Fast-Paced Biological Economy: Plants operate in complex, dynamic ecosystems alongside fast-moving herbivores, competitors, and environmental perturbations; foraging roots, opening shoots, and pollinator-attracting blooms must forecast resource locations, seasonal shifts, and soil chemistries weeks in advance.
The Penalty of Slowness (Ariel Novoplansky, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev): Mobile animals can explore an environment, make navigation errors, and quickly retrace their steps with modest energetic costs. Plants grow into their environments via irreversible morphological structures; misallocating energy toward resource-poor soil or light-deprived canopies imposes devastating fitness costs. Plants must make accurate anticipatory decisions on the first attempt.
Sensory Integration, Trade-Offs, and Internal Communication
Multimodal Environmental Sensing:
Plants continuously monitor, parse, and integrate an extensive suite of environmental variables, including:
Five distinct spectral bands of light, photoperiodic day length, and seasonal day-length shifts.
Ambient humidity, thermal fluctuations, and mechanical vibrations.
Soil salinity, moisture levels, and fine-grained spatial and temporal nutrient gradients.
Soil microbiome compositions and neighboring plant root competition.
Herbivore wounding and mechanical disturbance (e.g., wind stress).
Stomatal Regulation and Physiological Triage:
Leaves must balance carbon acquisition against fatal dehydration through the aperture of stomatal pores on the abaxial (lower) leaf epidermis.
Carbon dioxide () influx is required for photosynthetic carbohydrate production, yet open stomata inevitably drive transpiration of internal water vapor.
During hot, sunny periods with dry soils, stomata must balance local photosynthetic demand with whole-plant hydraulic survival.
Stomatal guard cells integrate opposing physiological signals: leaf-level internal partial pressures and root-derived stress messages delivered via the phytohormone abscisic acid ().
Drought Memory and GABA: Plants surviving severe water stress accumulate (\gamma)-aminobutyric acid ()—a ubiquitous signalling molecule shared with animal neurobiology—within leaf tissues, providing a persistent physiological memory that downregulates stomatal opening during subsequent dry episodes.
Proprioception and Subterranean Spatial Mapping:
Plants exhibit proprioception: the capacity to sense and map the relative physical positioning of their dispersed branches, tendrils, and roots in spatial coordinates.
Root systems construct internal maps of soil heterogeneities, allowing them to actively forage toward nutrient-rich patches while steering around subterranean obstacles prior to direct mechanical contact.
Systemic Inter-Organ Signaling and Phenotypic Plasticity:
Plant behavior is defined by four core responses: irreversible structural growth alterations, rapid reversible turgor-driven movements (e.g., Dionaea muscipula trap closure or stomatal actuation), morphogenesis of specialized organs (such as flowers), and dynamic physiological remodeling via secondary metabolite synthesis.
Animals generally maintain a determined morphology regardless of external context, whereas plants exhibit pronounced phenotypic plasticity—producing completely distinct morphological, architectural, and behavioral phenotypes based on their unique environmental history.
Systemic cross-talk coordinates above-ground shoot experiences with below-ground root development; for instance, light contact between adjacent leaves initiates root-borne chemical signals that inform neighboring plants of local density.
In maze experiments, maize (Zea mays) seedlings presented with an inverted Y-maze chose to direct their primary root growth toward solutions housing untouched plants rather than solutions housing mechanically touched plants; plants confined to touched solutions dramatically upregulated shoot growth relative to root mass to escape impending shade competition.
In Brassica rapa, long-day plants (induced toward rapid flowering) communicate phenological states via root exudates to neighboring short-day plants, inducing the latter to abandon vegetative storage investments and flower prematurely in the absence of external photoperiodic cues.
Plant Communication and Social Intelligence
The Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) Lexicon:
Airborne chemical communication occurs ubiquitously across species through emissions from leaves, stems, roots, flowers, fruit, and woody bark.
The structural vocabulary of plants comprises over recognized volatile chemical blends, primarily organized around terpenoids (notably isoprene oligomers) and benzenoids, which combine combinatorially into distinct semiochemical messages.
Green leaf volatiles emitted during mechanical damage (such as the scent of freshly mown grass) serve as airborne distress signals that induce systemic defense priming in undamaged neighbors.
Interspecific Warning Networks: Sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata) damaged by herbivores releases airborne VOC cocktails that are detected by neighboring wild tobacco (Nicotiana attenuata); recipient tobacco plants quickly upregulate chemical deterrents, suffering significantly lower herbivore losses.
Indirect Defenses and Predatory Recruitment:
Plants under active herbivore attack recruit third-trophic-level mutualists as biological bodyguards.
Lima bean plants (Phaseolus lunatus L.) attacked by two-spotted spider mites (Tetranychus urticae) synthesize and release specialized terpenoid volatiles that specifically attract predatory mites (Phytoseiulus persimilis), which prey upon the herbivores.
Numerous plant taxa produce extrafloral nectaries that secrete carbohydrate-rich solutions to maintain resident ant colonies that defend the host plant against insect herbivores.
Kin Recognition and Social Allocation Strategies:
Plants use root exudates and reflected light spectra to discriminate biological relatives from unrelated conspecific strangers.
Root Competition in American Sea-Rocket (Cakile edentula): When potted alongside unrelated strangers, plants allocate large quantities of metabolic energy into expanding root biomass to monopolize soil resources; when cultivated alongside siblings, they suppress competitive root proliferation.
Spectral Kin Recognition in Arabidopsis thaliana: Arabidopsis detects light reflectance signatures specific to neighboring kin leaves, adjusting canopy architecture to avoid shading relatives, which results in elevated group-level seed production.
Risk-Sensitive Decision-Making in Foraging Roots:
Pea plants (Pisum sativum) grown in split-root configurations evaluate resource variance to make economically optimal foraging choices:
When roots are split between a constant nutrient container and a variable nutrient container with an equal mean, pea roots display risk-averse ("bearish") foraging if the constant supply exceeds baseline metabolic demand, concentrating growth in the predictable source.
When the constant nutrient level drops below minimal metabolic requirements, the plants transition to risk-prone ("bullish") behavior, preferentially allocating root growth into the variable container where high-yield nutrient patches remain possible.
Learning, Memory, and Associative Conditioning
Non-Associative Learning: Habituation in Mimosa pudica:
In the eighteenth century, René Louiche Desfontaines subjected Mimosa pudica to carriage vibrations, observing that leaves folded immediately upon initial movement but reopened as the shaking continued, re-closing only after the cart stopped and resumed motion.
In 1873, Wilhelm Pfeffer formally documented tactile habituation in Mimosa, demonstrating that repeated, non-injurious mechanical stimulation led to a progressive reduction and eventual cessation of the leaf-folding reflex.
Kinship to Psychological Definitions: The Penguin Dictionary of Psychology defines habituation as "the gradual elimination of superfluous activity in learning" and "a form of non-associative learning whereby each repetition of a stimulus results in a progressively diminished response."
Modern Experimental Advances (Monica Gagliano et al., 2014):
Light-Dependent Habituation Dynamics: Mimosa maintained in low-light environments habituated to repeated physical drops significantly faster than plants in high-light environments, prioritizing photosynthetic carbon capture over defensive folding when light resources were scarce.
Long-Term Memory Retention: Habituation memories persisted for up to , with plants continuing to ignore mechanical drop stimuli long after training ended.
Classical Pavlovian Conditioning in Seedlings:
Associative Learning Framework: Classical conditioning pairs an unconditioned stimulus (, evoking an innate physiological response) with a neutral conditional stimulus (, evoking no baseline reaction) until the alone triggers a conditioned response ().
Pea Seedling Conditioning (Gagliano et al.):
Seedlings of Pisum sativum grown in Y-mazes normally exhibit positive phototropism toward blue light ().
During training, directional air currents generated by a small electric fan () were paired with the blue light source.
Following training, when blue light was removed, the seedlings grew preferentially toward the arm containing the fan alone, using the air current to predict the appearance of light.
Historical Observations: Charles Darwin noted that the cotyledons and leaves of germinating seedlings modulated their phototropic sensitivity based on prior light exposure histories.
Nutrient-Light Conditioning in Strawberries (Fragaria vesca): Latzel and colleagues trained wild strawberries to associate distinct ambient light intensities with localized soil fertility; when placed in uniform soil, the trained plants concentrated their root biomass in lighting conditions that had previously signaled nutrient abundance.
Scientific Controversies, Replication Challenges, and Epigenetics:
Mainstream plant physiologists (e.g., Lincoln Taiz) have pushed back against the concept of plant learning, arguing that phenomena like Mimosa leaf habituation are better described as physiological desensitization or motor fatigue rather than true learning.
Replication Status: Attempts by laboratories, including the MINT Lab, to independently replicate Pavlovian associative conditioning in Pisum sativum have yielded mixed results; heat-stress conditioning in Arabidopsis thaliana similarly awaits robust external validation.
Ecological Validity: The artificial, sterile conditions of typical growth chambers may suppress the behavioral expressions observed in ecologically complex natural habitats.
Transgenerational Memory: Plants primed by prior pathogen attack or chemical stress pass heightened defensive readiness down through epigenetic mechanisms to offspring across subsequent generations.