Architectural History: The 18th Century, Neoclassicism, and L'Architecture Parlante
Eighteenth Century as the Starting Point of Modern Architecture
Historical Context of the Eighteenth Century:
Marked by rapid industrialization in full development.
Rise of secular power that rivaled the divine authority of God.
Awakening of class consciousness, with the bourgeois class in its formative stages.
Acceleration of global trade networks as Western empires opened port cities and colonies in non-Western societies.
Surge in literacy driven by the popularization of print culture.
Triumph of science as a new, literal religion.
Etienne Louis Bouley's Cenotaph for Newton:
Designed as a tomb/graveyard for Sir Isaac Newton, reflecting the supreme privilege and elevated status of science in the century, as well as human hubris.
Architectural Section Drawings: A section drawing imagines a three-dimensional building cut in half (like using a wedding cake knife) to view the internal spatial structure.
Night vs. Day Views:
Left section: Night view.
Right section: Day view.
Expression of Hubris: Bouley used architecture to invert nature—creating a sun inside the thicket of night and creating night during broad daylight. This constructed a man-made microcosm against the laws of physics to demonstrate that science triumphs over nature.
Relation to Classical Architecture:
Bouley retained classical architectural language despite defying traditional religion.
Comparison with Mausoleum of Augustus: Bouley's cenotaph was imagined times larger than the Mausoleum of Augustus, yet shared design affinities including strict symmetry to convey authority and stability.
Diocletian Window: Originally an architectural device invented by Palladio; Bouley reinvented it by utilizing it as an entrance rather than a window.
Cypress Trees: Implemented in the design due to their traditional association with death.
Drama of Light, Shadow, and Scale:
Features extreme lighting contrast across a massive sphere interacting with a vast, ambiguous background landscape.
Human figures are drawn infinitesimally small to emphasize scale.
Entourage: In architectural terminology, entourage refers to everything in a drawing not intrinsic to the building itself (e.g., trees, human figures) used to communicate scale to the viewer.
The Theory of the Sublime and Romanticism:
Antrim Burke (Edmund Burke) and the Sublime:
Burke posited that human beings derive pleasure and emotional thrill from imminent danger (e.g., the terror experienced on a roller coaster).
When observing natural calamities, humans experience terror regarding impending danger, yet are simultaneously moved by the awe-inspiring spectacle.
Sublime Aesthetics in Romanticism:
Casper David Friedrich: Sought divinity within a godless landscape. Solitary figures in snow-clad landscapes force observers into awareness of their own solitude, weakness, and triviality. This humility makes the vastness of nature moving and beautiful.
Transference of Energy: Friedrich drew visual parallels between natural forms (conic fir trees) and architectural forms (conic pseudo-Gothic cathedral spires), transferring divine energy from nature directly into built form.
Turner's Walk at the Cathedral: Architecture assumes full agency in communicating authority and the built sublime.
Archeological Rediscovery and the Greco-Roman Revival
Ruin Fervor and the Excavation of Pompeii:
Romanticism closely linked architectural ruins—structures lost or desecrated—with seeds of lingering beauty.
Mid- Century Excavation: Pompeii was buried under volcanic ash in . Its excavation provided architects and scientists with a pristine, well-preserved specimen of an ancient Greco-Roman city frozen in time from over years prior.
Impact on Architectural Practice: Sparked a widespread "ruin fever/fervor." Aristocrats and wealthy patrons financed excavation enterprises to dig up ruins, leading architects to turn directly to the Greco-Roman era for primary inspiration.
Classical Orders and Proportional Systems
The Eighteenth-Century Resurgence of Palladio:
Andrea Palladio was a -century Renaissance architect, yet his texts were heavily republished during the century, highlighting the era's demand for authoritative architectural rules.
Frontispiece Analysis: Features Palladio centered, illuminated by divine light from a small angel, surrounded by Athena and angels of inspiration. Palladio is depicted as the sole figure looking directly at the reader, illustrating the agency, privilege, and self-elevated status of the architect.
Palladian Modular Proportional System:
Palladio abstracted architecture into a strict numeric system based on a fundamental unit called the module (derived from the base of the column).
Proportional Formulas:
Column Base =
Column Shaft = ( times the radius of the base)
Entablature (Architrave, Frieze, Cornice) = ( times the width/height of the base module)
Didactic Implication: Architecture was transformed into a standardized, teachable discipline governed by rigid rules. A designer could produce correct architecture by adhering to proportional formulas without requiring innate artistic talent or inspiration from a muse.
Claude Perrault's Taxonomy of the Five Orders:
Though originating in the century, Claude Perrault ("Claude Perron") deeply shaped -century French architectural theory.
The Five Classical Orders:
Tuscan Order ("Toscania"): Simple capital; the only order that lacks fluting (vertical grooves) on its shaft.
Doric Order: Fluted column; shaft height standard is modules.
Ionic Order: Characterized by spiral scroll capitals (volutes/rouleaux); shaft height standard is modules.
Corinthian Order: Capital decorated with stylized acanthus leaves (considered the most architectural plant).
Composite Order: A hybrid capital combining the Ionic volutes/rouleaux with the Corinthian acanthus leaves.
Proportions were fixed by style, reducing design to an operational manual where science superceded individual creative license.
Representational Politics and Viewing Techniques:
Diagrammatic architectural drawings began organizing multiple visual perspectives onto a single page:
Direct elevation views of the capital.
Worm's-eye views looking up at the underside of the cornice.
Exploded detail views of individual capital components.
Truncated column shafts (cutting out the midsection to maximize visual efficiency).
Required viewers to learn a specific, standardized visual syntax, further framing architecture as an exact science.
Neoclassical Adaptations and Residential Architecture
Reinterpreting Renaissance Authority:
The Genius of Architecture Discovering the Progress of Its Art: An illustration depicting an angel bearing the fire of inspiration and presenting a tray of and century Renaissance mansions, asserting that ultimate architectural perfection resided in Renaissance models.
Pattern Books: Works such as Plinth, Section, Elevations of the Most Beautiful Houses and Hotels in France were printed in French, German, and English for a European-wide audience, operating as the -century equivalent of modern high-end architectural magazines.
Etienne Louis Bouley's Hotel de Brunei:
Demonstrates practical, feasible construction designed for an actual client.
Retains classical symmetry, Ionic columns, and Palladian windows.
Neoclassical Innovation: Rather than featuring a traditional smooth triangular pediment over the entrance, Bouley designed a stacked, stepped pediment profile, exercising creative autonomy over classical rules.
Circular Rotunda Residential Reconfiguration:
Adapts the classical circular rotunda (derived from religious/imperial monuments like the Roman Pantheon) into a domestic residence.
Attempts to pack floor plans within a single, perfect circular perimeter.
Spatial Compromises: Negotiating regular living spaces inside a rigid circle resulted in misshapen room shapes and odd residual corners.
Democratization and Popularization of Architecture:
Publications such as Practical Architecture or A Sure Guide to Architecture reduced design formulas into basic numerical charts.
Enabled laymen, hobbyists, and non-professionals to design structures without hiring professional architects, redistributing creative agency.
Architectural Representation and Moral Architecture
Architecture as the Subject of Art:
Piranesi ("Piranozzi"): Etchings of the Pantheon feature dramatic lighting contrast, positioning the architectural structure as the direct protagonist of the artwork rather than a passive background.
Jacques-Louis David (Brutus Painting): Illustrates the Roman consul Brutus () choosing the Republic over his family by executing his conspiring sons. In this work, classical architecture (Tuscan columns, drapery) serves purely as a theatrical stage backdrop to foreground human dramatic action.
Jean-Jacques Lequeu and Narrative Provocation:
Il est libre ("He is Free"): Features a central figure with female anatomy, directly confronting normative -century gender expectations.
Interpretations of "He":
The Bird: Male birds possess ornate display features; animal symbolism where the tail visually suggests male anatomy.
The Building: The female figure extricates herself from a masculine architectural frame (featuring a Diocletian window).
Demonstrates architecture operating as an enigmatic, conceptual narrative device rather than a plan for physical construction.
The Morality of Ornamentation:
-century Enlightenment architects denounced Baroque and Rococo architecture for perceived licentiousness and arbitrary, abusive ornamentation.
Rational Ornamentation: Enlightenment theory permitted decoration only if applied with restraint, symmetry, and clear purpose.
Bouley's Royal Library: Features a stark, sterile, austere facade with a blank cornice line and restrained decorative swags (wreaths with medallions). Uses two Atlas giants holding a celestial sphere with zodiac symbols to explicitly state the building's function.
L'Architecture Parlante and Social Engineering
Nicolas Ledoux and the Royal Saltworks at Arc-et-Senans:
Located at Arc-et-Senans ("Arc De Saint Maisons"), Ledoux utilized simple elementary geometry to lay out a moralized social and industrial community.
Socio-Economic Context of Salt: Salt was a state-controlled, heavily taxed commodity tied to royal authority. The facility required an imposing design to command obedience and respect.
Entrance Facade: Minimalist Tuscan columns, plain cornice, and a roof parapet (a low protective wall along the roofline). Behind the columns, the stone opens into exuberant archivolts styled like natural crystalline salt rock.
Architecture Parlante ("Speaking Architecture"):
Defines architecture whose physical form explicitly communicates its internal function, purpose, and institutional identity.
Examples from Ledoux's Saltworks Complex:
Sculpted reliefs depicting overflowing streams of salty water.
Oikema (House of Passion): A proposed brothel framed in the layout of a palace, designed on the theory that containing base human passions within engineered spatial boundaries would sublimate those desires into productive industrial labor.
Chinese Pavilion: Incorporated orientalist sculptures.
Entrance to Bar/Hunting Facility: Designed literally in the visual shape of a cow.
Moral Philosophy: Architecture must maintain complete functional honesty and transparency, openly declaring its purpose to the public.
Global Modernities and Historiographical Critiques
Ledoux's Theater of Besançon:
Ledoux's design for the Theater of Besançon ("Theater Of Belencon") depicts the interior auditorium framed entirely inside a large human eye emanating light, symbolizing architecture as the literal vanguard of Enlightenment.
Critique of European Chronology:
Establishing the European century as the definitive origin point of modern architecture incorrectly categorizes all non-European global developments prior to this era as "premodern."
During the European Middle Ages (circa years \text{--}), non-Western civilizations maintained thriving urban, scientific, and architectural cultures whose sophistication equaled or exceeded the later European Enlightenment.
Questions & Discussion
Student Question: In Jean-Jacques Lequeu's Il est libre, who does the pronoun "He" refer to if the figure has female anatomy?
Response / Student Points:
The bird depicted in the drawing may be the subject ("he"), as male birds feature longer display plumage, and the bird's tail forms visual associations with male anatomy.
Alternatively, the building itself represents a masculine body (delineated by the Diocletian window) from which the female figure is liberating herself.
Lequeu left no explicit answer; the visual ambiguity is intentionally constructed to provoke debate surrounding gender, space, and architectural identity.
Student Observation: Nicolas Ledoux's drawing framing the Theater of Besançon inside a human eye resembles classical Greek motifs.
Response: Confirmed as an astute observation of neoclassical visual synthesis, where classical Greek iconography is adapted to symbolize Enlightenment enlightenment and modern observational science.