Architectural History: The 18th Century, Neoclassicism, and L'Architecture Parlante

Eighteenth Century as the Starting Point of Modern Architecture

  • Historical Context of the Eighteenth Century:

    • Marked by rapid industrialization in full development.

    • Rise of secular power that rivaled the divine authority of God.

    • Awakening of class consciousness, with the bourgeois class in its formative stages.

    • Acceleration of global trade networks as Western empires opened port cities and colonies in non-Western societies.

    • Surge in literacy driven by the popularization of print culture.

    • Triumph of science as a new, literal religion.

  • Etienne Louis Bouley's Cenotaph for Newton:

    • Designed as a tomb/graveyard for Sir Isaac Newton, reflecting the supreme privilege and elevated status of science in the 18th18\text{th} century, as well as human hubris.

    • Architectural Section Drawings: A section drawing imagines a three-dimensional building cut in half (like using a wedding cake knife) to view the internal spatial structure.

    • Night vs. Day Views:

      • Left section: Night view.

      • Right section: Day view.

    • Expression of Hubris: Bouley used architecture to invert nature—creating a sun inside the thicket of night and creating night during broad daylight. This constructed a man-made microcosm against the laws of physics to demonstrate that science triumphs over nature.

    • Relation to Classical Architecture:

      • Bouley retained classical architectural language despite defying traditional religion.

      • Comparison with Mausoleum of Augustus: Bouley's cenotaph was imagined 1010 times larger than the Mausoleum of Augustus, yet shared design affinities including strict symmetry to convey authority and stability.

      • Diocletian Window: Originally an architectural device invented by Palladio; Bouley reinvented it by utilizing it as an entrance rather than a window.

      • Cypress Trees: Implemented in the design due to their traditional association with death.

    • Drama of Light, Shadow, and Scale:

      • Features extreme lighting contrast across a massive sphere interacting with a vast, ambiguous background landscape.

      • Human figures are drawn infinitesimally small to emphasize scale.

      • Entourage: In architectural terminology, entourage refers to everything in a drawing not intrinsic to the building itself (e.g., trees, human figures) used to communicate scale to the viewer.

  • The Theory of the Sublime and Romanticism:

    • Antrim Burke (Edmund Burke) and the Sublime:

      • Burke posited that human beings derive pleasure and emotional thrill from imminent danger (e.g., the terror experienced on a roller coaster).

      • When observing natural calamities, humans experience terror regarding impending danger, yet are simultaneously moved by the awe-inspiring spectacle.

    • Sublime Aesthetics in Romanticism:

      • Casper David Friedrich: Sought divinity within a godless landscape. Solitary figures in snow-clad landscapes force observers into awareness of their own solitude, weakness, and triviality. This humility makes the vastness of nature moving and beautiful.

      • Transference of Energy: Friedrich drew visual parallels between natural forms (conic fir trees) and architectural forms (conic pseudo-Gothic cathedral spires), transferring divine energy from nature directly into built form.

      • Turner's Walk at the Cathedral: Architecture assumes full agency in communicating authority and the built sublime.

Archeological Rediscovery and the Greco-Roman Revival

  • Ruin Fervor and the Excavation of Pompeii:

    • Romanticism closely linked architectural ruins—structures lost or desecrated—with seeds of lingering beauty.

    • Mid-18th18\text{th} Century Excavation: Pompeii was buried under volcanic ash in 7 CE7\text{ CE}. Its excavation provided architects and scientists with a pristine, well-preserved specimen of an ancient Greco-Roman city frozen in time from over 17001700 years prior.

    • Impact on Architectural Practice: Sparked a widespread "ruin fever/fervor." Aristocrats and wealthy patrons financed excavation enterprises to dig up ruins, leading architects to turn directly to the Greco-Roman era for primary inspiration.

Classical Orders and Proportional Systems

  • The Eighteenth-Century Resurgence of Palladio:

    • Andrea Palladio was a 16th16\text{th}-century Renaissance architect, yet his texts were heavily republished during the 18th18\text{th} century, highlighting the era's demand for authoritative architectural rules.

    • Frontispiece Analysis: Features Palladio centered, illuminated by divine light from a small angel, surrounded by Athena and angels of inspiration. Palladio is depicted as the sole figure looking directly at the reader, illustrating the agency, privilege, and self-elevated status of the architect.

  • Palladian Modular Proportional System:

    • Palladio abstracted architecture into a strict numeric system based on a fundamental unit called the module (derived from the base of the column).

    • Proportional Formulas:

      • Column Base = Module 1\text{Module } 1

      • Column Shaft = Module 10\text{Module } 10 (1010 times the radius of the base)

      • Entablature (Architrave, Frieze, Cornice) = Module 2\text{Module } 2 (22 times the width/height of the base module)

    • Didactic Implication: Architecture was transformed into a standardized, teachable discipline governed by rigid rules. A designer could produce correct architecture by adhering to proportional formulas without requiring innate artistic talent or inspiration from a muse.

  • Claude Perrault's Taxonomy of the Five Orders:

    • Though originating in the 17th17\text{th} century, Claude Perrault ("Claude Perron") deeply shaped 18th18\text{th}-century French architectural theory.

    • The Five Classical Orders:

      1. Tuscan Order ("Toscania"): Simple capital; the only order that lacks fluting (vertical grooves) on its shaft.

      2. Doric Order: Fluted column; shaft height standard is 2424 modules.

      3. Ionic Order: Characterized by spiral scroll capitals (volutes/rouleaux); shaft height standard is 2626 modules.

      4. Corinthian Order: Capital decorated with stylized acanthus leaves (considered the most architectural plant).

      5. Composite Order: A hybrid capital combining the Ionic volutes/rouleaux with the Corinthian acanthus leaves.

    • Proportions were fixed by style, reducing design to an operational manual where science superceded individual creative license.

  • Representational Politics and Viewing Techniques:

    • Diagrammatic architectural drawings began organizing multiple visual perspectives onto a single page:

      • Direct elevation views of the capital.

      • Worm's-eye views looking up at the underside of the cornice.

      • Exploded detail views of individual capital components.

      • Truncated column shafts (cutting out the midsection to maximize visual efficiency).

    • Required viewers to learn a specific, standardized visual syntax, further framing architecture as an exact science.

Neoclassical Adaptations and Residential Architecture

  • Reinterpreting Renaissance Authority:

    • The Genius of Architecture Discovering the Progress of Its Art: An illustration depicting an angel bearing the fire of inspiration and presenting a tray of 15th15\text{th} and 16th16\text{th} century Renaissance mansions, asserting that ultimate architectural perfection resided in Renaissance models.

    • Pattern Books: Works such as Plinth, Section, Elevations of the Most Beautiful Houses and Hotels in France were printed in French, German, and English for a European-wide audience, operating as the 18th18\text{th}-century equivalent of modern high-end architectural magazines.

  • Etienne Louis Bouley's Hotel de Brunei:

    • Demonstrates practical, feasible construction designed for an actual client.

    • Retains classical symmetry, Ionic columns, and Palladian windows.

    • Neoclassical Innovation: Rather than featuring a traditional smooth triangular pediment over the entrance, Bouley designed a stacked, stepped pediment profile, exercising creative autonomy over classical rules.

  • Circular Rotunda Residential Reconfiguration:

    • Adapts the classical circular rotunda (derived from religious/imperial monuments like the Roman Pantheon) into a domestic residence.

    • Attempts to pack 55 floor plans within a single, perfect circular perimeter.

    • Spatial Compromises: Negotiating regular living spaces inside a rigid circle resulted in misshapen room shapes and odd residual corners.

  • Democratization and Popularization of Architecture:

    • Publications such as Practical Architecture or A Sure Guide to Architecture reduced design formulas into basic numerical charts.

    • Enabled laymen, hobbyists, and non-professionals to design structures without hiring professional architects, redistributing creative agency.

Architectural Representation and Moral Architecture

  • Architecture as the Subject of Art:

    • Piranesi ("Piranozzi"): Etchings of the Pantheon feature dramatic lighting contrast, positioning the architectural structure as the direct protagonist of the artwork rather than a passive background.

    • Jacques-Louis David (Brutus Painting): Illustrates the Roman consul Brutus (500 BCE500\text{ BCE}) choosing the Republic over his family by executing his conspiring sons. In this work, classical architecture (Tuscan columns, drapery) serves purely as a theatrical stage backdrop to foreground human dramatic action.

  • Jean-Jacques Lequeu and Narrative Provocation:

    • Il est libre ("He is Free"): Features a central figure with female anatomy, directly confronting normative 19th19\text{th}-century gender expectations.

    • Interpretations of "He":

      • The Bird: Male birds possess ornate display features; animal symbolism where the tail visually suggests male anatomy.

      • The Building: The female figure extricates herself from a masculine architectural frame (featuring a Diocletian window).

    • Demonstrates architecture operating as an enigmatic, conceptual narrative device rather than a plan for physical construction.

  • The Morality of Ornamentation:

    • 18th18\text{th}-century Enlightenment architects denounced Baroque and Rococo architecture for perceived licentiousness and arbitrary, abusive ornamentation.

    • Rational Ornamentation: Enlightenment theory permitted decoration only if applied with restraint, symmetry, and clear purpose.

    • Bouley's Royal Library: Features a stark, sterile, austere facade with a blank cornice line and restrained decorative swags (wreaths with medallions). Uses two Atlas giants holding a celestial sphere with zodiac symbols to explicitly state the building's function.

L'Architecture Parlante and Social Engineering

  • Nicolas Ledoux and the Royal Saltworks at Arc-et-Senans:

    • Located at Arc-et-Senans ("Arc De Saint Maisons"), Ledoux utilized simple elementary geometry to lay out a moralized social and industrial community.

    • Socio-Economic Context of Salt: Salt was a state-controlled, heavily taxed commodity tied to royal authority. The facility required an imposing design to command obedience and respect.

    • Entrance Facade: Minimalist Tuscan columns, plain cornice, and a roof parapet (a low protective wall along the roofline). Behind the columns, the stone opens into exuberant archivolts styled like natural crystalline salt rock.

  • Architecture Parlante ("Speaking Architecture"):

    • Defines architecture whose physical form explicitly communicates its internal function, purpose, and institutional identity.

    • Examples from Ledoux's Saltworks Complex:

      • Sculpted reliefs depicting overflowing streams of salty water.

      • Oikema (House of Passion): A proposed brothel framed in the layout of a palace, designed on the theory that containing base human passions within engineered spatial boundaries would sublimate those desires into productive industrial labor.

      • Chinese Pavilion: Incorporated orientalist sculptures.

      • Entrance to Bar/Hunting Facility: Designed literally in the visual shape of a cow.

    • Moral Philosophy: Architecture must maintain complete functional honesty and transparency, openly declaring its purpose to the public.

Global Modernities and Historiographical Critiques

  • Ledoux's Theater of Besançon:

    • Ledoux's design for the Theater of Besançon ("Theater Of Belencon") depicts the interior auditorium framed entirely inside a large human eye emanating light, symbolizing architecture as the literal vanguard of Enlightenment.

  • Critique of European Chronology:

    • Establishing the European 18th18\text{th} century as the definitive origin point of modern architecture incorrectly categorizes all non-European global developments prior to this era as "premodern."

    • During the European Middle Ages (circa years 10001000\text{--}11001100), non-Western civilizations maintained thriving urban, scientific, and architectural cultures whose sophistication equaled or exceeded the later European Enlightenment.

Questions & Discussion

  • Student Question: In Jean-Jacques Lequeu's Il est libre, who does the pronoun "He" refer to if the figure has female anatomy?

    • Response / Student Points:

      • The bird depicted in the drawing may be the subject ("he"), as male birds feature longer display plumage, and the bird's tail forms visual associations with male anatomy.

      • Alternatively, the building itself represents a masculine body (delineated by the Diocletian window) from which the female figure is liberating herself.

      • Lequeu left no explicit answer; the visual ambiguity is intentionally constructed to provoke debate surrounding gender, space, and architectural identity.

  • Student Observation: Nicolas Ledoux's drawing framing the Theater of Besançon inside a human eye resembles classical Greek motifs.

    • Response: Confirmed as an astute observation of neoclassical visual synthesis, where classical Greek iconography is adapted to symbolize Enlightenment enlightenment and modern observational science.