The Presidency

what explains presidential success?


  • the presidency was not supposed to be as much of an executive order-based position

  • lots of legislation and not needing congressional approval


high public expectations

  • presidents have a unique political asset in that they are elected by a national constituency

  • the only office elected by everyone in the US

  • with the advent of tv, the public came to see the president in personal terms

  • through seeing presidents in personal terms can be an asset, it also creates a problem for presidents

  • they are held accountable for most everything government does, and they can never meet high expectations

  • high expectations are fed by:

    • rising expectations that government should solve all problems

    • presidential campaigns promising to solve all problems

    • media depictions through exaggerations of presidential power

  • to meet high expectations, all presidents try to augment their power

  • the primary basis of presidential power lies in the constitution

  • presidents doing more and more to make the executive branch more powerful


presidential campaigns

  • “i alone can fix it” - trump’s 2016 acceptance speech

  • presidents engage in hyperbole


the constitutional basis of presidential power

  • the delegates to the constitutional convention were wary of unchecked executive power

  • the articles of confederation had failed, however, in part because of the lack of a strong national executive

  • the framers had seen the role as a modest role of simply just carrying out laws, not making the laws


legislative powers

  • convene congress

  • recommend necessary and expedient legislation

  • inform congress of the state of the union

  • veto legislation

    • president can veto any bill except constitutional amendments

    • one of the president’s most powerful tools

    • can be used strategically

    • congress may override a veto

    • congress has the last word

    • a veto can be overridden by a 2/3 vote of both chambers of congress

    • overriding a presidential veto is uncommon, not impossible, but doesn’t happen often


executive powers

  • administrative head of the federal bureaucracy

  • appoint top officials, though some are subject to the advice and consent of the senate


foreign policy powers

  • commander in chief

  • make treaties (needs senate approval)

  • recognize countries by the power to receive ambassadors


expansion of presidential powers

  • the power of the modern presidency also stems from claims of inherent powers

    • executive orders (carry the weight of law even though not enacted by congress)

    • executive privilege

  • congress has also delegated power to the executive branch


what are the limits of presidential power?

  • in trump v. united states (2024), the supreme court ruled that a former president “has some immunity for criminal prosecution for official acts during his tenure in office”

    • the word “some” obscures the extent to which presidents have immunity

  • the court rejected trump’s claim of absolute immunity but also the government’s claim that a former president is not “above the law”


trump v. united states (2024)

  • presidents are immune from prosecution for “core” executive functions

    • core functions are those explicitly found in the constitution

  • presidents have “presumptive immunity” for noncore powers

    • noncore functions are not specifically listed in the constitution so ambiguity

    • the court did not clarify what noncore functions include

  • presidents have no immunity from criminal prosecution for nonofficial, private conduct


but why are some presidents more powerful than others?


traditional strategies of presidential power

  • how do we define presidential power?

    • presidential power is traditionally measured by how successful presidents are in getting their programs passed in congress

  • presidents have used 3 strategies to pass their programs through congress

    • bargaining

    • approval ratings

    • going public


bargaining with congress

  • bargaining with party leaders is the traditional way that presidents have attempted to shape public policy

  • in the legislative arena, presidential power is determined in part by the political skills of the president

  • power to persuade

  • book entitled presidential power and the modern presidents

  • lyndon johnson was masterful at personal relationships

  • reagan (republican) also had exceptional personal skills, warm and cordial relationships, befriended democratic speaker of the house thomas/tip o’neil


presidential approval

  • presidents have also tried to use high public approval ratings as capital with congress to pass their programs


going public

  • going public is “a strategy whereby a president promotes legislation by appealing to the american public for support”


what is the key to presidential success in congress?

  • a persuasive personality, high approval ratings, and going public only have modest effects of presidential success

  • the president’s legislative success depends upon whether divided government exists

  • what is a divided government? it is when one or both chambers of congress is controlled by the party not in control of the president

  • biden didn’t have as much legislative success in his second term because of divided government


so what does a president do when faced with divided government?


unilateral powers

  • given the desire to meet high expectations and the difficulty of passing laws, presidents pursue objectives using unilateral powers (article 2 powers)

  • appointing

  • signing statements

  • executive orders


unilateral powers and the administrative presidency

  • since the bureaucracy implements policy, presidents have pursued policy objectives through control of bureaucratic agencies

  • by pursuing policy objectives through the bureaucracy, presidents politicize it despite how it is created to be politically neutral


administrative presidency

  • nixon initially pursued a legislative strategy when he first took office- this changed after reelection

  • in his second term nixon replaced many of his cabinet appointees with loyalists

  • nixon recognized that the day-to-day management of tasks, regulation writing, and budgeting are tasks that involve making policy

  • reagan also used this strategy, appointing staunch conservatives to federal agencies that changed the direction of policy

    • EPA and office of civil rights


traditional path to changing public policy

  • president —> congress —> public policy

  • administrative presidency cuts out needing congress


appointments: trump and the administrative presidency

  • trump has focused on appointing fiercely loyal individuals to head federal agencies

  • probably one of the most effective ways of changing agency


signing statements

  • presidents have also used signing statements to control what the bureaucracy does


trump’s changing laws through presidential signing statements

  • HR 3664. russian sanctions. limited the president’s ability to lift sanctions against russia

  • trump’s signing statement. claimed that several provisions were unconstitutional because they intruded into his constitutional powers to conduct foreign affairs


biden’s changing laws through presidential signing statements

  • “national defense authorization act for fiscal year 2022”

  • presidents can sign bills into a law

  • the use of signing statements might be unconstitutional


executive orders

  • presidential directives often directed toward federal agencies that create or modify federal law without the (direct) approval of congress

  • presidents’ have expanded their use so they have become a “quasi-legislative” power

    • trump has used them for redefining immigration, environmental, and economic rules and standards


examples of executive orders

  • truman’s desegregation of the armed forces

  • FDR’s internment of the japanese during WW2

  • trump’s immigration ban on predominately muslim countries (1st term)

  • biden’s canceling of student loans

  • trump’s recent attempts to exercise greater control over the executive branch (more later)


executive orders have become increasingly more common for presidents to utilize


an unprecedented expansion of presidential power under trump

  • executive orders shutting down (defunding) federal agencies

    • USAid

  • mass firings of federal employees

  • congress must approve funding cuts

  • civil service protections for federal employees


the emergency powers presidency

  • president trump has expanded presidential power by using emergency powers

    • under the national emergencies act, a president can declare an emergency to address a crisis, unlocking potentially 150 different laws

      • what constitutes an emergency?

  • supreme court recently struck down trump’s emergency tariffs but he is now imposing them under a different law that allows the president to impose tariffs for 150 days to redress severe trade imbalances


a constitutional crises in the making?

  • much of what the trump admin has done test legal boundaries and many actions face legal challenges

    • the supreme court has endorsed some of what the trump admin has done representing an expansion of presidential power

    • the trump admin has not only defied the supreme court, but has disregarded court orders


how should you think about this?

  • it’s tempting to think about this in terms of whether you like or dislike the president

  • but that’s short term thinking

    • do you want a more powerful president and what that means when your party is out of office?


1. High Public Expectations and the Presidency
  • National Constituency: Presidents are the only officials elected by the entire U.S., creating a personal connection with the public via television and media.

  • The Expectation Gap: High public expectations—fueled by campaign promises, media exaggeration, and demands for government problem-solving—exceed actual constitutional authority.

  • Power Augmentation: To bridge this gap, presidents continually attempt to expand executive power.

2. Constitutional Basis of Executive Power
  • Framers' Intent: Wary of unchecked authority after the Articles of Confederation failed, the framers intended a modest role focused on executing, not making, laws.

  • Constitutional Powers:

    • Legislative: Convening Congress, recommending legislation, informing via State of the Union, and vetoing legislation (Congress can override with a 2/3 vote in both chambers).

    • Executive: Serving as administrative head of the bureaucracy and appointing top officials (subject to Senate advice and consent).

    • Foreign Policy: Acting as Commander in Chief, making treaties (requires Senate approval), and recognizing foreign nations via ambassadors.

3. Expansion and Judicial Limits of Power
  • Inherent and Delegated Powers: Power has grown through inherent claims (executive orders, executive privilege) and delegation by Congress.

  • Supreme Court Ruling (Trump v. United States, 2024):

    • Core Executive Functions: Absolute criminal immunity for explicit constitutional duties.

    • Noncore Official Acts: Presumptive immunity for noncore official actions.

    • Unofficial Conduct: No immunity for private, nonofficial actions.

4. Determinants of Presidential Success in Congress
  • Traditional Strategies:

    • Bargaining & Persuasion: Using political skills and personal relationships (e.g., LBJ, Reagan).

    • Public Approval: Leveraging high approval ratings as political capital with Congress.

    • Going Public: Promoting policy by appealing directly to the public for support.

  • Key Explanatory Factor: Personal skill and approval have only modest effects; legislative success depends primarily on whether divided government exists (when the opposing party controls one or both chambers of Congress).

5. Unilateral Powers and the Administrative Presidency
  • Shift to Unilateral Action: Faced with divided government, presidents bypass Congress using Article II unilateral powers to enact policy.

  • Strategies of the Administrative Presidency:

    • Loyalist Appointments: Placing staunch loyalists in federal agency leadership to control day-to-day regulation, budgeting, and enforcement (e.g., Nixon, Reagan, Trump).

    • Signing Statements: Issuing statements upon signing bills to challenge provisions or direct agency implementation.

    • Executive Orders: Directives to federal agencies that create or modify policy without congressional approval, functioning as a quasi-legislative tool.