1
Chapter 1: Introduction to Child and Adult Relationships
In this chapter, we explore different models that interpret what children are like and how these views shape the understanding of adult characteristics as well. The three primary models discussed are the Puritan, Romantic, and Freudian models, each offering distinct ideas about innocence, sinfulness, and child development.
1. Puritan Model
Original Sin: In this framework, children are viewed as born with original sin, implying a need for moral guidance from adults to overcome their inherent flaws.
Adult Characteristics: Adults are seen as morally mature, having potentially overcome their flaws through time and guidance.
Role of Adults: Children require wise adults for discipline and moral instruction. This dynamic is exemplified in literature through characters like Marmee from "Little Women," who models virtue and patience, illustrating the importance of adult guidance in moral development.
Moral Instruction in Literature: Texts can reflect the Puritan model even without characters, instead imparting moral lessons directly to child readers through themes and messages.
2. Romantic Model
Childhood Innocence: Contrasting the Puritan perspective, the Romantic model regards children as inherently innocent and close to God, highlighting their purity and imagination.
Loss of Innocence: Innocence is fragile and can be lost, as seen in characters like Meg in "Little Women," who realize adult realities, represented through events like receiving misleading love letters.
3. Freudian Model
Complex Emotions: Freud posits that children may exhibit traits such as greed and anger, contrasting the Romantic ideal where children are innocent.
Adult Repression: In Freud's view, adults often repress their emotions and behaviors, which can negatively impact their interactions with children. This perspective implies that children's self-centeredness may simply be a reflection of their adult influences and societal norms.
Application in Literature
Little Women
Marmee serves as a moral guide, helping her children develop virtues like patience through her actions, such as suggesting acts of kindness. Her character exemplifies the moral maturity expected within the Puritan framework.
Jo’s struggles with her temper and Amy’s unchecked flaws highlight the journey toward moral maturity, reinforcing the idea that growth occurs with age and guidance.
The Princess and the Goblin
This text incorporates both Puritan and Romantic elements. It includes moral instruction while depicting characters like Irene, who embodies Romantic innocence through her untainted moral compass, contrasting with societal expectations.
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
While predating Freudian theory, the novel showcases elements reflective of both Romantic ideals and Freudian insights, where Alice transitions from a well-behaved girl to a more assertive individual, navigating societal expectations and confronting her emotions in Wonderland.
Summary of Key Themes
The chapter intertwines the characteristics of children and how literary texts reveal these through adult interactions and societal norms. The Puritan model emphasizes moral guidance, the Romantic model celebrates innocence, and the Freudian model explores the complexities of emotional development. Each text reflects these influences, teaching lessons about character, growth, and morality, particularly in the context of childhood.