BLAW Ch 11 Contract Performance, Breach, and Remedies

Chapter 11 – Contract Performance, Breach, and Remedies

1. Voluntary Consent

  • Definition: The knowing and voluntary agreement to the terms of a contract.

    • If voluntary consent is lacking, the contract will be voidable.

2. Mistakes in Contracts

  • Types of Mistakes:

    • Only a mistake of fact (not a mistake of value or quality) makes a contract voidable.

2.1 Unilateral Mistake of Fact
  • Definition: A mistake occurs when one party to a contract is mistaken about a material fact.

    • Normally enforceable against the mistaken party.

  • Exceptions:

    1. The other party knew or should have known about the mistake of fact.

    2. The error was due to a substantial mathematical mistake, made inadvertently and without gross (extreme) negligence.

2.2 Bilateral (Mutual) Mistake of Fact
  • Definition: Both parties are mistaken about the same material fact.

  • Options for Rescind: Either party can rescind the contract.

    • Mutual misunderstanding may allow the contract to be rescinded or reformed.

  • Future Market Value Mistake:

    • If a mistake concerns the future market value or quality of the object of the contract, the mistake is considered a mistake of value; the contract is typically enforceable.

    • Not knowing the actual value does not make the contract unenforceable; it implies one side made a bad deal.

3. Misrepresentation

  • Fraudulent Misrepresentation (Fraud): Misrepresentation that is consciously false and intended to mislead another party.

    • Typically involves:

    1. A misrepresentation of a material fact must occur.

    2. There must be an intent to deceive.

    3. The innocent party must justifiably rely on the misrepresentation.

    4. To collect damages, a party must demonstrate harm as a result of the misrepresentation.

  • Types of Misrepresentation:

    • Misrepresentation by words or actions: Specific actions taken to conceal a material fact related to the contract.

  • Injury Requirement:

    • Most courts do not require proof of injury to rescind a contract.

    • However, proof of harm is universally required to recover damages caused by fraud.

4. Undue Influence

  • Definition: When one party can greatly influence another, thus overcoming that party’s free will.

    • Example: Influence of a guardian on a minor.

  • Presumption of Undue Influence:

    • Clear and convincing evidence must prove the person did not act of their free will.

5. Duress

  • Definition: Use of threats to force a party to enter into a contract.

    • Functions as both a defense against contract enforcement and a ground for rescission of a contract.

  • Requirements:

    • Proof of a threat to do something that the threatening party has no right to do.

    • Example of Insufficient Duress: Giving a bad review or threatening court action (both permissible);

    • Example of Sufficient Duress: Threatening to get someone prosecuted (not permissible).

6. Third Party Rights

  • General Principle: After validating an enforceable contract, attention can shift to the rights and duties of the parties involved.

6.1 Privity of Contract
  • Definition: The relationship existing between the promisor and promisee of a contract.

7. Statute of Frauds

  • Definition: Identifies types of contracts that must be in writing.

8. Assignment and Delegation

8.1 Assignments
  • Definition: The transfer of all or part of one’s rights under a contract to another.

    • Roles:

    • Assignor: Party assigning the rights to a third party.

    • Assignee: Party receiving the rights.

  • General Rule: All rights can be assigned with exceptions:

    1. Assignment is prohibited by statute.

    2. Contract is for personal services.

    3. Assignment significantly alters the risk or duties of the obligor.

    4. The contract prohibits assignment.

8.2 Delegations
  • Definition: Transfer of duties to a third party through delegation, not assignment.

    • Roles:

    • Delegator: Party making the delegation of obligation.

    • Delegate: Party to whom the duty has been delegated who may fail to perform.

  • Delegation Prohibitions:

    • Special trust has been placed in the obligor (attorneys, accountants, physicians).

    • Performance depends on the personal skill or talents of the obligor.

    • Performance by a third party will vary materially from what is expected by the obligee.

    • Contract expressly prohibits delegation.

  • Enforceability Consideration: The delegate does not possess the right to assign rights or be held responsible as compared to the assignee.

9. Third Party Beneficiary vs. Incidental Beneficiary

9.1 Third Party Beneficiary
  • Definition: The original parties can agree that performance is to benefit a third person (intended beneficiary).

    • Enforceability: Intended beneficiaries can enforce the contract.

9.2 Incidental Beneficiary
  • Definition: A third person who benefits from the contract unintentionally.

    • Legal Rights: Incidental beneficiaries cannot sue to enforce the contract.

10. Performance of Contracts

  • Definition: The most common way to discharge or terminate contractual duties is through performance.

10.1 Conditions of Performance
  • Condition: Qualification based on a future event that triggers legal obligations. If not satisfied, obligations are discharged.

    • Types:

    • Conditions Precedent: Must happen before one party’s promise is required (e.g., passing a physical exam in a life insurance contract).

    • Conditions Subsequent: Legal obligation fulfilled only when a subsequent condition is met.

    • Concurrent Conditions: Conditions apply to both sides simultaneously.

11. Discharge of Contracts

11.1 Discharge by Performance
  • General Statement: Contract concludes when both parties fulfill their respective duties by performing.

  • Types of Performance:

    • Complete Performance: The party performs exactly as agreed; no question of contract performance.

    • Substantial Performance: A good faith effort that meets most terms of the contract.

    • Requirements for Substantial Performance:

      1. Performed in good faith (intentional noncompliance is a breach).

      2. Variance from the promised performance is minor and can be remedied by compensation.

      3. Creates substantially the same benefits as promised.

    • Effects of Substantial Duty Performance:

      • Other party’s duty remains absolute if performance is substantial.

      • If not substantial, constitutes a material breach, and the nonbreaching party is excused from further performance.

    • Measure of Damages for Substantial Performance:

      • Cost to bring the object of the contract into compliance, if reasonable. If not, the difference in value between actual performance and promised performance.


  • Time for performance

    • If a contract does not state a time for performance, a reasonable time is implied based on the contract's substance.

  • Anticipatory repudiation: 

    • Breach of contract

    • Before either party to a contract has a duty to perform, one of the parties may refuse to carry out that party’s contractual obligations

11.3 Discharge by Agreement
  • General Principle: Contracts can be discharged by mutual agreement.

  • Types of Discharge by Agreement:

    • Mutual Recission: New agreement formed to rescind the original contract, satisfying all legal requirements.

    • Novation: Substituting a third party for one of the original parties.

      • Requirements for Novation:

      1. Existence of a previous valid obligation.

      2. Agreement by all parties to a new contract.

      3. Extinguishment of the old obligation.

      4. Creation of a new valid contract.

    • Settlement Agreement: A contract reached to settle existing disputes.

    • Accord and Satisfaction: Parties agree to an alternative performance from the original obligation.

      • Definitions:

      • Liquidated Debt: A definite amount due.

      • Unliquidated Debt: An uncertain amount due.

    • Release: Forfeiture of the right to pursue legal claims against another party.

11.4 Discharge by Operation of Law
  • Conditions for Discharge:

    • Material alteration of the contract.

    • Statutes of limitations restricting the lawsuit period for claims.

    • Bankruptcy.

    • Impossibility of performance:

    • Objective Impossibility: Literally cannot be done.

    • Subjective Impossibility: Personal inability to perform.

    • Types of Performance Impossibility:

      • Death or incapacity of a party essential to performance.

      • Destruction of the specific subject matter of the contract.

      • Changes in law rendering performance illegal.

    • Temporary Impossibility: Resolved once conditions permit performance.

    • Commercial Impracticability: May excuse duty to perform.

    • Frustration of Purpose: Court relieves duty when the contract’s purpose is frustrated.

12. Breach of Contract

12.1 Definition
  • Definition of Breach: Nonperformance of a contractual duty; effect depends on whether it is a material or minor breach.

12.2 Types of Breaches
  • Material Breach:

    • Nonbreaching party is excused from duties and can sue for damages.

  • Minor Breach:

    • Nonbreaching party's duty to perform may be suspended until the breach is remedied (but is not entirely excused).

    • Resumption of performance must follow curing of the minor breach.

13. Damages (Compensatory, Liquidated, etc.)

13.1 Types of Damages
  • Categories of Damages:

    1. Compensatory: Cover direct losses and costs.

    2. Consequential: Cover indirect and foreseeable losses.

    3. Punitive: Punish and deter wrongdoing (generally not awarded in breach of contract).

    4. Nominal: Small monetary award for wrongdoing without actual damage.

13.2 Compensatory Damages
  • Purpose: Compensate nonbreaching party for loss of bargain; represents the difference between the promised performance value and the actual performance value, reduced by any avoided loss.

  • Incidental damages: caused directly by a breach of contract

  • Examples of Measurement:

    • Sale of Goods: Difference between contract price and market price.

    • Sale of Land: Unique nature leads to specific performance remedy.

    • Construction Contracts: Measure of damages varies depending on which party breaches.

13.3 Additional Damage Types
  • Consequential Damages: Result from the breach given special circumstances beyond the contract.

  • Punitive Damages: Rare in contract lawsuits.

  • Nominal Damages: Generally a minimal award to acknowledge wrongdoing without monetary loss.

  • Mitigation of Damages: Requirement to minimize damages caused by the breach.

13.4 Liquidated Damages vs. Penalties
  • Liquidated Damages: Stipulated amount believed to reasonably estimate breaching damages.

  • Penalties: Amount specified for default, considered punitive rather than compensatory.

  • Enforceability Considerations:

    • Was it apparent at contract formation that damages would be hard to estimate?

    • Was the estimated damage a reasonable measure and not excessive?

14. Waiver of Breach

  • Definition: An intentional relinquishment of a legal right.

  • Scope of Waiver: Extends only to the specific matter waived, not the entire contract.

15. Contract Provisions Limiting Remedies

  • Contracts may include provisions limiting damages recovery for certain breaches or capping damages to a specified maximum amount.

16. Remedies

16.1 Types of Remedies
  • Recission and Restitution:

    • Recission: Action to undo or terminate a contract; returns parties to positions before transaction.

    • Restitution: Equitable remedy restoring parties to original state before loss or as if the breach hadn't occurred.

  • Specific Performance:

    • Court orders parties to perform as promised; typically granted when legal remedies are insufficient.

  • Types of Contracts:

    • Sale of Land

    • Personal Services Contracts (generally not enforced).

  • Reformation:

    • Equitable remedy for imperfectly expressed agreements (due to fraud or mutual mistake, etc.).

    • Applies to incorrect written statements or oral agreements, and covenants not to compete.