L 6

Accessing the Medical Literature

Learning Outcomes

  • Identify and utilize high-quality medical information resources to inform patient care.

  • Construct a PubMed search using the most important concepts from a research question to retrieve relevant evidence.

  • Identify appropriate usage of AI tools as outlined in the PA (Physician Assistant) program’s policy on the use of AI.

Evidence-Based Practice Process

  • Component Steps:

    • Ask: Formulate a clear clinical question based on a specific patient situation.

    • Acquire: Gather evidence from appropriate medical literature to answer the clinical question.

    • Appraise: Critically assess the evidence for its validity, impact, and applicability.

    • Apply: Implement findings in clinical practice to enhance patient care.

    • Analyze: Evaluate the outcome of the application in clinical practice.

    • Adjust: Modify practices based on continuous evaluation and feedback.

  • Definition of Key Elements:

    • Clinical Experience: Practical knowledge gained through direct patient care and clinical exposure.

    • Patient Values: Considerations of the patient's preferences, beliefs, and cultural contexts in healthcare.

    • Best Scientific Evidence: High-quality research findings derived from rigorous studies.

Levels of Evidence

  • Hierarchy of Evidence:

    • Animal/Lab Studies

    • Case Control Studies

    • Cohort Studies

    • Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs)

    • Systematic Reviews

    • Meta-analysis

AI: An Illusion of Intelligence

  • Nature of Generative AI:

    • It is pretrained on datasets and can generate human-like text based on input prompts.

    • It does not synthesize ideas or form original thoughts.

  • Usage in Education: While AI may assist as a tool for educational purposes, outputs must be critically evaluated for potential bias and inaccuracies.

  • Critical Engagement with AI:

    • Continuously ask questions, revise prompts, and evaluate outputs critically.

Use of AI in the PA Program

  • Permitted Uses:

    • Idea generation

    • Locating research articles

    • Creating outlines

    • Editing for grammar, spelling, and clarity

    • Managing citations

  • Prohibited Uses:

    • Writing SOAP (Subjective, Objective, Assessment, Plan) notes or content

    • Composing personal reflections

    • Summarizing research or interpreting data

    • Paraphrasing content

PA Program Policy: Disclosure

  • Requirements for Disclosing AI Tool Use:

    1. Type of AI tool utilized

    2. Purpose of use

    • Students are encouraged to consult faculty regarding the use of AI tools.

Accessing High-Quality Research & Information

  • Preferred Resources: Utilize the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews and PubMed, among others, to inform patient care effectively.

Accessing Quality Medical Information
  1. Starting Research: Always begin at the library homepage for access to clinical resources.

  2. AI as a Tool: AI can be used to pull open-access sources, but it lacks access to proprietary journals behind paywalls.

  3. Limitations of Google: Starting with Google often leads to encountering paywalls for high-quality articles.

  • Library Resources:

    • Utilize the Get it @ MWU button to search the library's entire collection for full-text articles.

    • You may be:
      A. Directed to the full-text online through a library resource, or
      B. Prompted to initiate the inter-library loan process (ILLiad).

ILLiad Process
  • To use the ILLiad system:

    • Create an account.

    • Request articles by completing a form with a specified 'not needed by' date.

    • Expect email notifications about PDF deliveries within 4 to 10 days.

    • Log into your account to download the requested PDF.

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

  • Utility of Systematic Reviews: They provide high-quality clinical answers to healthcare questions.

  • Characteristics:

    • Includes only systematic reviews to limit bias.

    • Cochrane reviews are recognized as the gold standard for systematic reviews.

    • Expect fewer results due to high-quality standards.

Understanding PubMed

  • Components of PubMed:

    • Medline: Comprising roughly 75% of PubMed, this is a curated list of high-quality medical journals assessed by experts (e.g., NEJM, JAMA).

    • PMC (PubMed Central): Accounts for almost 25% and includes free articles, as government-funded research must be publicly accessible.

    • Bookshelf: The smallest segment functioning similarly to Wikipedia articles.

  • Access to PubMed: Use the PA guide and MWU Library Database, which encompasses various research types, including RCTs and practice guidelines.

Search Limiters on PubMed
  • Options for filtering search results:

    • Date of publication

    • Type of study

    • Age and sex parameters

    • Medline only access

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
  • Importance of MeSH:

    • Preferred terms for PubMed searches, enhancing the precision of search results.

myNCBI Account Benefits
  • A myNCBI account allows users to:

    • Track their PubMed searches

    • Create alerts for new publications

    • Highlight search terms in results.

Search Box Usage
  • Entering Search Terms: When using either the search box or constructing an AI prompt:

    • Evaluate whether the results are relevant, biased, or too broad/narrow.

    • Revision is a crucial part of the search process.

Avoiding Bias in Search Terms

  • Terms to Avoid: Be cautious of language that implies a specific desired outcome, such as “benefits” or “improved” versus “reduced efficacy.”

  • Search Example:

    • Avoid vague prompts; instead of asking AI for trials supporting low-dose aspirin for prevention, gather context for a more detailed query.

Recommendations for Searches in PubMed
  • Search Strategies:

    • Limit searches to 2 or 3 key concepts from your PICO (Patient, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome) question.

    • Simple searches generally yield better results.

    • Check MeSH terms, which you can ask AI to help identify.

  • Example PICO Query: In adults with systolic heart failure (HFrEF) (P), does participation in an exercise-based rehabilitation program (I) compared with usual care or no structured exercise (C) reduce the risk of hospital admission due to heart failure (O)?

Questions to Reflect On During Searches
  1. Have I considered how algorithms may be influencing my search results?

  2. Should I revise my search?

  3. Am I using the preferred medical term (MeSH) for my key search concepts?

  4. Am I utilizing 2 or 3 of the most essential concepts from my PICO question in PubMed?

  5. While searching for literature:

    • Remember key takeaways\n - Medline is the leading medical database available.

    • Creating a myNCBI account assists with alerts and tracking searches.

    • Cochrane systematic reviews are esteemed for their high quality.

    • The search process is iterative: a first search rarely yields optimal results.

    • Access a wide range of research through the library’s website without restricting oneself to only freely available research.