Parrish (2020)

Achieving Justice for Girls in the Juvenile Justice System

Introduction

  • Female involvement in the juvenile justice system has increased over the last three decades in the U.S.

  • Male arrests have declined, while female arrests rose significantly.

  • Social workers and researchers call for addressing the unique needs of female youths.

  • The article summarizes key research on girls' experiences and needs in the juvenile justice system.

  • Advocates for services rather than punitive measures for these females who are mainly nonviolent.

Growth in Female Delinquency Cases

  • From 1990 to 1999, female delinquency cases entering detention increased by 50% while male cases rose only by 5% (Sherman, 2005).

  • By 2004, girls constituted 30% of juvenile arrests, a rise from 17% in 1980 (Puzzanchera & Ehrmann, 2018).

  • The 1992 amendment to the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act called for gender-specific treatments.

  • OJJDP provided guidance on gender-responsive reforms in the mid-1990s, leading to female-only programs and system-wide changes (Watson & Edelman, 2012).

  • In 2015, the OJJDP demanded broader reforms for the unique needs of girls in the juvenile justice system.

Unique Needs of Female Youths

  • Research highlights differences between male and female juvenile offenders.

  • Girls experience higher rates of maltreatment, exposure to violence, and trauma compared to boys (Butts & Mears, 2001; Chesney-Lind et al., 2008).

  • Common issues include early sexual activity, substance use, health and mental health challenges, STIs, and academic problems.

  • Girls often live in poverty and have a higher likelihood of teenage pregnancy (Crosby et al., 2004).

Status-Based Offenses

  • Girls are frequently arrested for status-based offenses (truancy, running away, underage drinking).

  • In 2015, girls made up 56% of runaway cases (OJJDP, 2018).

  • Research indicates girls often run away to escape abusive or dysfunctional homes (Bloom et al., 2002).

  • Girls represent 73% of teenage prostitution arrests, with many states still criminalizing child prostitution.

Legislative Changes and Needs for Reform

  • The Juvenile Justice Reform Act of 2018 presents an opportunity for comprehensive reforms addressing the unique needs of girls.

  • Urgent need for well-developed, empirically sound interventions that can improve health and reduce vulnerability for these girls (Leve, Chamberlain, & Kim, 2015).

Gender-Specific Needs and Treatment

  • Despite calls for gender-specific treatment, literature on girls in juvenile justice remains limited.

  • Research indicates that girls often experience trauma at higher rates than boys, which necessitates tailored approaches that consider their specific backgrounds and experiences.

  • Previous studies failed to adequately address the unique trajectories and needs of girls involved in the system.

  • Common challenges faced by both genders are acknowledged, but girls' needs must not be overlooked to prevent further neglect.

Arrest Trends Among Girls

  • Girls’ arrests more commonly relate to minor offenses, while boys are charged with more serious crimes such as robbery and weapon violations (OJJDP, 2017).

  • Boys also dominate aggravated and simple assault arrests, though girls have shown increasing trends in these areas (Puzzanchera & Adams, 2011).

  • Historical context suggests biases in treatment and arrest rates based on gender.

/

Detainment and Recidivism Rates

  • Girls are more likely to be detained for minor status offenses and technical violations compared to boys (Sickmund et al., 2017).

  • A survival analysis indicated that detained girls have a much higher mortality rate compared to the general population (Teplin et al., 2014).

  • Dually involved youths face increased risks of poor outcomes and longer involvement in the juvenile justice system.

Racial Disparities in Outcomes

  • Black girls are roughly three times more likely and American Indian girls 1.4 times more likely to be referred to juvenile courts than white girls (Puzzanchera & Hockenberry, 2015).

  • Dually involved girls are often persons of color, exacerbating vulnerabilities and resultant outcomes in the juvenile justice system.

Trauma and Its Impact

  • Girls experience higher rates of adverse childhood experiences than their male peers, including family violence and sexual abuse (Baglivio et al., 2014).

  • Coping mechanisms may lead to behaviors resulting in judgment or arrest.

  • Many girls in the system suffer from co-occurring mental health issues and substance abuse problems.

Gender-Sensitive Programming

  • Girls Circle program showcases effective practices tailored to the unique needs of girls in juvenile detention through relational-cultural theory (Geis et al., 2015).

  • The complexity of need necessitates mental health and substance abuse interventions alongside community and educational support.

Health Outcomes and Continuity of Care

  • Medically underserved population with high rates of health issues including substance use and pregnancy (American Academy of Pediatrics, 2011).

  • Programs like IMARA and CHOICES-TEEN demonstrate effectiveness in addressing specific risks for girls.

  • Need for strong continuity of care post-release is highlighted to mitigate health risks associated with pregnancy and STIs.

Role of Social Workers

  • Advocating for interdisciplinary integration in health and social services is essential for addressing the needs of these youths.

  • Social workers can help mitigate disparities through community engagement, education reform, and individual assessments.

  • Effective change will require research-informed policies and additional training in gender-sensitive care within the juvenile justice framework.