Motivation and Management Theories

Management: Motivation - Chapter 16

Motivation

  • Definition: The processes that account for an individual's intensity, direction, and persistence of effort towards achieving a goal.
    • Intensity: How hard someone works on a task.
    • Direction: Whether the effort is aligned with organizational goals.
    • Persistence: How long someone sticks with a task.
  • Key Question: When does someone work hard (intensity), toward things that matter (direction), and stay at it (persistence)?

Early Theories of Motivation

Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
  • Humans have five levels of needs, and one must meet the bottom-level needs before moving up.
    1. Physiological: Food/water; salary to buy food.
    2. Safety: Shelter and security; job security and benefits.
    3. Social: Friends and love; teamwork and workplace friends.
    4. Esteem: Respect and status; promotions and recognition.
    5. Self-Actualization: Becoming your best; learning new skills.
  • When someone's basic needs aren't met, they won't care about promotions or achieving goals.
McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
  • The way you think about your employees changes how you treat them.
  • Two types of managers:
    1. Theory X boss: Thinks employees are lazy and hate work (micromanages).
    2. Theory Y boss: Thinks employees like responsibility and can be trusted (supports and empowers).
  • Your assumptions about people influence how you manage them.
Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory
  • Hygiene factors: Remove dissatisfaction (pay, policies, working conditions).
  • Motivation factors: Create satisfaction (achievement, growth, recognition).
  • You need both; for example, a clean, safe office (hygiene) and a job they love (motivation).
  • Implication: If you take away their job satisfaction, they'll quit.
McClelland's Needs Theory
  • People are motivated by one of these needs:
    • Need for Achievement: Desire to excel; likes to win and hit targets.
    • Need for Power: Desire to influence and lead; desire for control over others
    • Need for Affiliation: Desire for friendships and being liked; desire for positive relationships
  • If you know what motivates someone, you can motivate them better.

Contemporary Motivation Theories

  • More realistic and used today.
Goal-Setting Theory
  • Clear, specific goals = better performance.
  • Goals give people a direction and something to aim for.
  • Best goals are SMART:
    • Specific
    • Measurable
    • Achievable
    • Realistic
    • Time-bound
Reinforcement Theory
  • You get what you reward.
    • Reward good behavior; it will continue.
    • Punish bad behavior; it may stop.
  • Behavior is a function of its consequences.
  • Uses principles of operant conditioning (Skinner) to change behavior through rewards and punishments.
  • Like training a puppy / team.
Equity Theory
  • Employees compare their input-output ratios to others.
  • People compare what they give and what they get at work, then compare that with others.
  • Managers need to treat people fairly.
  • If it's unfair, they might reduce input, ask for more output, or simply leave.
Expectancy Theory (Vroom)
  • Motivation = Expectancy x Instrumentality x Valence
    • Motivation=Expectancy×Instrumentality×ValenceMotivation = Expectancy \times Instrumentality \times Valence
    • Expectancy: Will effort lead to good performance? (Confidence in self)
    • Instrumentality: Will performance lead to an award?
    • Valence: Do I value the reward? (Value of outcome)
  • If any of these factors = 0, motivation is gone.

Current Motivation Issues for Managers

Cross-Cultural Challenges
  • Motivation factors vary across cultures (e.g., individual vs. group based awards).
  • In some places, team success matters more than personal goals (Japan); in others, individual achievement is king (USA).
Motivating Different Groups/People
  • Professionals: Want autonomy, growth, and challenge.
  • Temporary workers: Want job security.
  • Low-skill workers: Want clear rules and simple rewards.
Designing Reward Programs
  • Money: Bonus and raises.
  • Recognition: Employee of the month.
  • Perks: Flexible hours.
  • The reward should fit what the person wants.