Crawford Breakdown
Chapter 1:
Places of worship doesn’t define was religion is, it’s just a part of the phenomenon
There are multiple definitions of religion, both metaphorical and theoretical
H.L Mencken:
“The cosmos is a gigantic flywheel making 10,00 revolutions a minute”
Our universe is going beyond and faster than we can comprehend. It goes beyond our understanding of life
“Man is a stick fly taking a dizzy ride on it”
We are simply experiencing the universe at our current lifespans
Because of how our universe is incomprehensible, we are just a small part of something grand
“Religion is the the theory that the wheel was designed and set spinning to give man the ride”
Religion is the closet thing we have to understanding the universe in our current lifespans
We use it rationalization for our existence
Martin Buber
“Religion masks the face of god”
We’re committing blasphemy against god by creating religion
It is the closest thing we have to understanding and rationalizing god as a concept
J.M. Yinger
“System of beliefs and practices by means of which a group of people struggle with the ultimate of human life”
Straight up escapism in our suffering
Similar mindset to Nietzsche
E.B. Tylor
“A belief in spiritual beings”
A need for greater understanding and warmth in belief
Chapter 2:
“Can religion be defined?”
Multiple philosopher’s answers
Alfred North Whitehead
“Religion is what the individual does with his solitariness… institutions, churches, rituals, bibles, codes of behaviour, are the trappings of religion, its passing forms“
If you’re alone, you go to religion
Churches, rituals and rules are just parts of religion and can change overtime
Peter Connolly
“Any beliefs which involve the acceptance of a sacred, trans-empirical realm and any behaviour designed to affect a person’s relationship in that realm”
If your beliefs involve a spiritual world, your actions are connected via the standard of the world you believe in
Arnold Toynbee
“It is the presence in the world of something spiritually greater than a man himself… man’s goal is to seek communication with the presence behind the phenomena”
There is something in the world that is greater than us, it is in our nature to seek and communicate with whatever that is
Matthew Arnold
“It is an emotion or morality touched by emotion”
Religion and the need to worship a higher up is simple an emotion. It is catered to our own desires
Herbert Spencer
“Ancestor worship is the root of every religion”
Borderline Indigenous philosophy
Says that worshiping ancestors is the starting point of all religions
Sigmund Freud
“Religion is an illusion”
It sucks, god doesn’t exist, form of escapism
Bronislaw Malinowski
“Religion is not born out of speculation or reflection, still less out of illusion or misapprehension, but rather out of the real tragedies of human life, out of the conflict between human plans and realities”
We’re using religion as a coping mechanism for suffering and realities
Karl Marx
“It is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the feeling of a heartless world, the soul in a place without a soul; it is the opium of the people”
People in the society who are oppressed (i.e., minorities and women) seek religion to feel less miserable and needed in the world
Capitalism is soul crushing, religion is the opium of the people
Richard Dawkins
Religion is a virus
Colonialism, rampant hatred, violence, etc. (literally Max’s philosophy)
Chapter 3:
Emile Durkheim
“A religion is a unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, that is to say, things set apart forbidden, beliefs, and practices which unite into one single community called a church, all of those who adhere to them”
People have these shared beliefs they think are important. It is human nature to connect
Community is amplified by a church
Most Religions
“It is a way of life“
Emphasizes freedom of choice
Ninian Smart
“A religion is a seven-dimensional organism, ritual, doctrinal, mythical or narrative, experimental or emotional, ethical or legal, organizational or social, material or artistic”
Religion is complex, no right answer, highly subjective in all 7 aspects
Rituals, beliefs, stories, personal experiences, right & wrong, groups of people, and art
Aloysius Pierris
“Religion is a revolutionary urge, a psycho-social impulse to generate a new humanity”
Humans suck, we need to be better, we use religion as self discovery and personal revolution
Rudolf Otto
“Religion is a sense of the numinous, the “wholly other”, the mysterium tremendum et fascinans”
Different and special feeling that’s not experienced in everyday life
The definitions reflect the perspective of anthropologists, sociologists, philosophers, psychologists, biologists, theologians, historians, scriptures and show that there is no universally accepted definition.
John Hick’s Take and Understanding of Despair:
”Religion is one thing to an anthropologist, another to a sociologist, another to the psychologist (and again to another profession). It is one thing to the Marxist, mystics, Buddhist, Jew and Christian. This results in great variety and no universally accepted definition”