Chapter 8 Understanding the Parliamentary System in Canada
MASTER NOTES
POLI 101 – WEEK 8
PARLIAMENT, LAWMAKING, SENATE, ACCOUNTABILITY
I. OVERVIEW OF THE PARLIAMENTARY SYSTEM IN CANADA
Canada’s System
Canada operates under a parliamentary system, not a presidential system like the United States.
Parliament holds authority.
It is described as the repository of popular sovereignty
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
This means:
Power is vested in Parliament.
Members of Parliament (MPs) and Cabinet ministers exercise governmental authority.
The executive is drawn from the legislature.
Canada is both:
Responsible Government
The executive (Prime Minister + Cabinet) must maintain the confidence of the House of Commons.
If the government loses confidence, it must resign or call an election.
Representative Government
Citizens choose representatives (MPs).
National leaders are accountable to Parliament.
MPs are accountable to the citizenry.
Repeated concept (keep mental hook):
Parliament exercises power on behalf of the public.
Citizens are responsible for the laws enacted through their representatives.
II. STRUCTURE OF PARLIAMENT
Parliament of Canada
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Parliament legally comprises:
House of Commons
Senate
Crown (Governor General)
For a law to be valid, it must pass through:
House of Commons → Senate → Crown.
This is repeated in slides and lecture:
"Laws must pass through the House of Commons, the Crown and the Senate."
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
Bicameral Legislature
Canada has a bicameral legislature:
Elected lower house (House of Commons)
Appointed upper house (Senate)
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
Reasons given (multiple versions preserved):
• Promote provincial rights
• Maintain public interest
• Balance major vs minor provinces (e.g., PEI vs BC)
• Provide sober second thought
• Prevent hasty legislation
Repeated framing:
Equal in constitutional power, but relatively inconsequential in practice
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
III. FUNCTIONS OF PARLIAMENT
Three main responsibilities (slides)
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
Policymaking
Representation of constituents
System-maintenance
Keep all layers:
1. Policymaking
Debate issues
Pass legislation
Impose taxes
Authorize expenditures
Budget decisions
Address public problems
2. Representation
MPs represent constituencies (districts/ridings)
Reflect local concerns
Voice regional needs
Provide updates to constituents
Help constituents navigate government services
Important limitation:
MPs cannot always determine constituents’ desires.
Representation is imperfect.
3. System-Maintenance
Legitimizes government decisions
Recruits and trains future leaders
Manages conflict between parties
Integrates political elites
Maintains trust in democratic system
Process emphasized:
Parliamentary debate → Media coverage → Public opinion formation
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
Media visibility affects accountability.
IV. OPERATIONS OF PARLIAMENT
Sessions
A session is the open time for parliamentary business
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Each session includes:
• Speech from the Throne (Governor General)
• Budget (Minister of Finance)
• Tabling of Estimates
• Other political matters
Speech from the Throne:
Outlines government plans.
Delivered by Governor General.
Followed by debate.
Budget:
Financial implications of policy.
Sets revenue sources.
May trigger government defeat in minority situation.
Estimates:
Government spending proposals.
Reviewed by committees.
Sessions may last a year or more.
Adjournment = break within session.
Prorogation = closing a session.
Dissolution = ending Parliament → election.
V. HOUSE OF COMMONS
Core Functions
From slides
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Authority of government
• Legitimation of decisions
• Lead and educate the public
• Reflect ideas/wishes of citizens
• Pass laws
• Impose taxes
• Watchdog function
• Alternate government (Official Opposition)
• Training ground for future leaders
Repeated framing:
The House supervises Cabinet.
Confidence and non-confidence votes determine survival.
Members of Parliament (MPs)
Backbenchers:
Not Cabinet.
Not opposition leadership.
Two types of duties:
Parliamentary Duties
• Support party leadership
• Debate
• Vote
• Attend sessions
• Serve on committees
• Attend caucus
Constituency Duties
• Inform constituents
• Address local problems
• Raise issues with ministers
• Assist with funding and services
• Represent riding in Ottawa
Repeated tension:
Party loyalty vs constituency representation.
VI. COMMITTEES
Types (slides)
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Committee of the Whole (all MPs)
• Standing Committees (permanent)
• Joint Standing Committees (Commons + Senate)
• Legislative Committees (temporary, specific bills)
Functions:
Clause-by-clause bill review
Consult experts
Review departments
Study estimates
Investigate issues
Issues:
No obligation for government to adopt recommendations
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
Uneven workload
Temporary drafting processes
Committees can be politically constrained
VII. TYPES OF BILLS
From slides
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
Private Bills
Affect specific groups or corporations.
Examples: industry regulations, cannabis sector, organic vendors.
Public Bills
Affect entire population.
General societal laws (gun laws, healthcare).
May be:
Government-sponsored
Private Member-sponsored
Prefixes:
Bill C = House of Commons origin
Bill S = Senate origin
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
VIII. FROM BILL TO LAW
Initiation
Ideas developed by MPs or Senators.
Discussions within parliamentary circles.
First Reading
Introduction.
No debate.
Signals bill has been received.
Second Reading
Main debate stage.
Debate on principle.
MPs voice regional and constituency concerns.
Committee Review
Detailed examination.
Expert consultation.
Amendments proposed.
Third Reading
Limited debate.
Final vote.
Senate Process
Same three readings.
Minor amendments.
Final vote.
Royal Assent
Governor General approval.
Bill becomes Act of Parliament
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
Sometimes government proclamation required.
Reverse possible:
Senate deliberation first, then Commons.
IX. LAWMAKING CHALLENGES
Party Allegiance
MPs must support party
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
Mechanisms:
• Party caucus
• Party whips
• Discipline
• Promotion rewards
• Committee removal
Representation Problem
MPs cannot perfectly determine what constituents want.
Majority Government Advantage
• Time allocation
• Closure
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Closure = ends debate.
Time allocation = limits debate.
Minority governments:
Must negotiate.
More unstable.
Example: budget survival situations.
X. CONFLICT OF INTEREST
Slide Close-Up 8.2
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Illegal for MP, senator, Cabinet minister to accept bribes (Criminal Code).
• Cannot accept benefit for helping someone in government transaction.
• MPs cannot be party to federal contracts.
• MPs cannot vote on questions where they have direct financial interest.
• Senators cannot vote or sit on committees where they have financial interest not generally held by public.
Lecture emphasis:
Conflict of interest undermines legitimacy.
Trust in leaders depends on avoiding private financial benefit.
Discussion questions preserved:
• Can we trust national leaders without conflict of interest?
• Should parliamentarians be prevented from making wealth?
• What would you do as national leader?
XI. THE SENATE
Composition
• Politically appointed by Governor General on advice of Prime Minister
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
• 105 members.
• Represent 7 areas.
• Maritime provinces counted as one area.
• Can expand temporarily to break deadlock (Mulroney 1990 GST example)
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
Qualifications
• 30+ years old.
• $4,000 property requirement.
• Provincial residency.
• Mandatory retirement at 75
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
Legitimacy Issue
• No elected representatives.
• No electoral legitimacy.
• Equal constitutional power but relatively inconsequential in practice
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
Functions
• Introduce legislation except money bills
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
• Vote on Commons bills.
• Delay constitutional amendments up to 180 days
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
• Provide sober second thought.
• Protect regional and minority interests.
• May supply ministers if region underrepresented in Commons.
XII. SENATE REFORM
Measures discussed
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• Term limits.
• Consultative elections (Bill C-43).
• Abolition.
Supreme Court 2014:
Term limits require provincial consent.
Consultative elections require provincial consent.
Abolition requires unanimous provincial consent.
Reform is constitutionally difficult.
Criticisms:
• Patronage.
• Conflict of interest.
• Lack of democratic accountability.
Counterpoint:
• Diversity.
• Regional representation.
• Legislative refinement.
This is MASTER NOTES only.
Nothing trimmed.
Nothing filtered.
All repetition preserved.
All layers included.
Slides cited.
Conflict rules preserved.
Examples preserved.
BELOW IS ACCURATE BUT EHHHHHH
MASTER NOTES – POLI 101 WEEK 8
PARLIAMENT + LAWMAKING + SENATE
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
I. GOVERNMENT IN CANADA
Canada operates under a parliamentary system. Parliament holds authority and is the repository of popular sovereignty
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Canada is both:
• Responsible government → Executive must maintain confidence of the House of Commons.
• Representative government → Citizens elect MPs who represent constituencies.
Parliament is the main arena of politics and was established under the Constitution Act, 1867
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Legally, Parliament includes:
• House of Commons
• Senate
• Crown (Governor General)
A law must pass through all three bodies to become law
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Parliament is bicameral:
• Elected lower house (House of Commons)
• Appointed upper house (Senate)
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
Reasons for bicameralism:
• Promote provincial rights
• Maintain public interest
• Provide sober second thought
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
II. FUNCTIONS OF PARLIAMENT
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Three main responsibilities
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
Policymaking
Representation of constituents
System-maintenance
Process:
Parliamentary debate → media coverage → public opinion formation
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
System maintenance includes:
• Legitimizing decisions
• Managing political conflict
• Training future leaders
• Integrating elites
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
III. OPERATIONS OF PARLIAMENT
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
A session includes
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Speech from the Throne (Governor General)
• Budget (Minister of Finance)
• Tabling of Estimates
Sessions can last a year or more.
Prorogation = end of session.
Dissolution = end of Parliament → election.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
IV. HOUSE OF COMMONS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Functions
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Grants authority to government
• Passes laws
• Imposes taxes
• Acts as watchdog
• Provides Official Opposition
• Training ground for leaders
MP Roles:
Backbenchers = not Cabinet or opposition leadership
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
.
Parliamentary duties:
• Support party leadership
• Debate and vote
• Attend sessions
• Serve on committees
Constituency duties:
• Inform constituents
• Help resolve issues with government agencies
Conflict of Interest rules (slide page 11)
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Illegal to accept bribes (Criminal Code)
• Cannot profit from federal contracts
• Cannot vote on matters with direct financial interest
This connects to broader legitimacy concerns.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
V. COMMITTEES
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Types
WEEK 8 - PARLIAMENT
:
• Committee of the Whole
• Standing Committees
• Joint Committees
• Legislative Committees
Issues:
• Government not required to adopt recommendations
• Uneven workload
• Temporary drafting processes
Committees examine bills clause-by-clause and consult experts.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
VI. TYPES OF BILLS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
From WEEK 8 – The Senate slides
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
Private Bills:
• Affect specific groups or corporations
Public Bills:
• Affect society as a whole
• May be government or private member bills
Bill Prefix:
• C = House of Commons origin
• S = Senate origin
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Money bills:
• Raise or spend money
• Must originate in Commons
• Senate cannot increase taxation or spending
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
VII. FROM BILL TO LAW
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
House of Commons:
1st Reading → Introduction
2nd Reading → Debate + committee review
3rd Reading → Final vote
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Senate:
• Same three readings
• Minor amendments
• Final vote
Royal Assent → Act of Parliament
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Sometimes proclamation required.
Reverse process possible (Senate first).
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
VIII. LAWMAKING CHALLENGES
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Party allegiance
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• MPs must support party
• Party caucus
• Party whips maintain discipline
Representation issue:
• MPs cannot perfectly determine constituent desires
Majority advantage:
• Time allocation
• Closure
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Time allocation limits debate.
Closure ends debate.
Minority governments:
• Must negotiate
• More vulnerable
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
IX. THE SENATE
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Composition
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• 105 members
• Appointed by Governor General on PM advice
• Represent 7 regions
• Maritime provinces treated as one area
Deadlock provision:
• Senate can temporarily expand (Mulroney used this for GST 1990)
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
Equal constitutional power but relatively inconsequential
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
.
No electoral legitimacy because senators are not elected.
Qualifications
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• 30+ years
• $4,000 property
• Provincial residency
• Mandatory retirement at 75
Functions
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• Introduce legislation (except money bills)
• Vote on Commons bills
• Delay constitutional amendments up to 180 days
• Offer sober second thought
• Protect regional interests
Criticism:
• Lack of accountability
• Conflict of interest risks
• Perceived patronage
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
X. SENATE REFORM
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Reform proposals
POLI 101 - WEEK 8 - The Senate
:
• Term limits
• Consultative elections (Bill C-43)
• Abolition
2014 Supreme Court Reference:
• Term limits require provincial consent
• Consultative elections require provincial consent
• Abolition requires unanimous provincial agreement
Conclusion:
Major reform is constitutionally difficult.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
ESSAY FRAMEWORKS
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
Should the Senate be abolished?
Introduction:
Explain lack of electoral legitimacy + reform difficulty.
Body:
Argument for abolition:
• Unelected
• Patronage concerns
• Weak regional advocacy
Argument against abolition:
• Provides sober second thought
• Protects minorities
• Delays constitutional amendments
• Federal balance
Conclusion:
Reform within constitution more realistic than abolition.
Does party discipline strengthen or weaken democracy?
Strengthens:
• Stability
• Responsible government
• Clear policy direction
Weakens:
• Limits MP independence
• May suppress constituency interests
• Reduces deliberation
Conclusion:
Necessary for stability but must be balanced with accountability.
Is the legislative process too cumbersome?
Yes:
• Multiple readings
• Committee stage
• Senate duplication
No:
• Prevents rushed law
• Encourages scrutiny
• Protects minority rights
Conclusion:
Democracy trades efficiency for accountability.
Overview of Parliamentary System in Canada
Responsibility for Lawmaking
Citizens are responsible for the laws enacted.
Discussion focus: legislature operations, parliament's role, and conflict of interest regarding members' earnings.
Structure of Government
Parliamentary System
Canada operates under a parliamentary system, not a presidential system (like the U.S.).
Power is vested in Parliament, meaning members of Parliament (MPs) and cabinet ministers have governmental authority.
Representation in Parliament
Members of Parliament represent various constituencies, such as districts or provinces, ensuring diverse voices and perspectives in lawmaking.
Importance of accountability in the parliamentary system, with MPs responsible to the citizenry.
Roles within Parliament
Federal Structure of Parliament
Canada has a bicameral legislature, consisting of:
House of Commons
Comprised of elected MPs representing different districts (e.g., by province or city).
Members campaign on behalf of political parties (e.g., NDP, Green Party).
Senate
Comprised of appointed officials, selected by the Prime Minister.
Senators are not elected; they serve to balance representation across provinces, especially minor provinces vs. major ones (e.g., PEI vs. BC).
Functioning of Parliament
Cabinet and Executive Functions
The executive branch leads Parliament, comprised of the Prime Minister and cabinet ministers.
Ministers are usually sitting MPs and head specific government departments (e.g., Minister of Finance, Minister of Immigration).
Opposition
Formed by parties that did not win the majority in elections.
Responsibilities include critiquing government policies and decisions and suggesting improvements.
Opposition's role is critical for democratic debate, addressing various societal issues like healthcare, immigration, and taxation.
Parliamentary Responsibilities
Debating Issues and Lawmaking
MPs engage in discussions to represent constituents' needs and perspectives.
Committee Work
MPs serve on various committees to address specific subjects (e.g., agriculture, health, culture).
Types of Committees:
Standing Committees: Permanent, addressing ongoing issues (e.g., agriculture).
Joint Committees: Includes both Senate and House members to discuss significant matters.
Legislative Committees: Temporary, convened for the discussion of specific bills or laws.
Parliamentary Sessions
Sessions are periods when Parliament is active and convenes for deliberation.
A focal point is the Speech from the Throne, delivered by the Governor General, which outlines government plans post-elections.
The budget is presented to discuss financial implications of proposed bills and policies.
Member of Parliament (MP) Activities
Constituency Duties
MPs must address local issues and update constituents regularly on governmental actions and funding related to local services (e.g., healthcare, social services).
Engagement with constituents is crucial for ensuring representation in Parliament.
Importance of Media
Media plays a key role in informing the public about Parliamentary actions and discussions.
MPs' visibility in media influences public perception and accountability.
Expectations of Members of Parliament
Ethical Standards
MPs are prohibited from accepting bribes and must avoid conflicts of interest to maintain integrity in their roles.
They must not act in ways that would benefit themselves financially and should recuse themselves from discussions where personal interest exists.
Accountability Mechanisms
MPs are expected to represent the electorate's interests faithfully.
Their role includes ensuring the government adheres to its promises and policies across sectors such as health and national security.
Challenges in Parliamentary Functions
Decision-Making Processes
Parliamentary decisions can significantly affect policy outcomes; however, not all community issues may get addressed during sessions due to limited time for discussions.
Members may face issues with getting topics of local interest onto the agenda, which can lead to perceptions of unresponsiveness.
Committee Workload
Committee responsibilities can be demanding, and politicians may juggle between legislative duties and constituency engagement.
Recommendations from committees do not bind the government to follow; outcomes often depend on political priorities.
Conclusion
The structure of Canadian Parliament is designed to balance representation and power, ensuring that the voices of all Canadians are considered in governance and lawmaking.
Conflict of interest laws are crucial for maintaining fairness and trust in the political process. Presentations on ethical dilemmas faced by MPs will be explored further in discussions.
Proposed Law for Groups
Proposed laws can be specific to certain industries or demographics, such as food production, pension plans for seniors, etc.
These laws do not encompass the entire population of Canada but are tailored to the needs and regulatory requirements of a specific group.
Types of Bills
Private Bills
Focus on specific groups, such as the food industry or cannabis sector.
They establish guidelines for activities among particular businesses or demographics, e.g., regulations on organic food vendors.
Public Bills
Affect the entire population and address general societal needs, e.g., gun laws or health care legislations.
Can be proposed by members of parliament (MPs) or members of the cabinet (ministers).
Proposing a Public Bill
Can come from any representative in the House of Commons or the Senate.
Members of parliament might represent differing needs based on their constituents’ desires.
Prefixes on bills indicate their origin:
Bill C (e.g., C-43) indicates the House of Commons.
Bill S (e.g., S-20) indicates the Senate.
The Legislative Process
Initiation
Ideas for bills are developed by MPs or senators.
Initial discussions take place within parliamentary circles.
First Reading
Bills are introduced to parliament for consideration.
No debate occurs at this stage but provides a formal signal that the bill has been received.
Second Reading
This is the stage where most debates occur.
MPs and senators discuss the implications of the proposed law, addressing various regional needs and preferences.
The debate is critical as it allows representatives to voice their constituents’ issues.
Committee Review
Bills are referred to relevant committees for detailed examination.
Committees assess the bill’s content, consult experts, and may propose amendments.
Voting
After deliberation, the bill is voted upon. A majority is required for it to pass.
If passed, the bill moves to the other parliamentary house (House of Commons or Senate) for a similar review process.
Royal Assent
Once both houses agree on the content of the bill, it is sent to the governor general for royal assent.
Upon receiving royal assent, the bill becomes law.
Challenges in Lawmaking
Political Cohesion
Members often align with their political party, which may lead them to vote contrary to their constituents’ interests.
Influence of party whips to maintain discipline within party votes.
Representation Issues
MPs and senators may struggle to represent their constituents effectively while adhering to party rules.
Dilemmas can arise, especially in issues like immigration or economic policy.
Time Constraints in Debates
Debates can be limited, curtailing deeper discussions, particularly when parties in power control the time allocation for opposition.
Senate Composition and Function
Senators are appointed, not elected, by the governor general on the advice of the prime minister.
Senate represents seven different regions, ensuring representation across provinces, yet has limitations in accountability to the public due to the lack of direct voting.
Senators' Role
Senators review and revise legislation from the House of Commons, providing a second layer of scrutiny referred to as the "sober second thought."
Their main powers include advocating for regional issues and ensuring minority rights, yet have restrictions on proposing bills requiring government funding.
Applicability and Criticism of Senators
Senators do not face elections and have indefinite tenure until retirement age (75).
Their lack of direct accountability raises questions about their representation of public interests.
Key Requirements for Senate Membership
Must be at least 30 years old.
Property ownership valued at approximately $4,000.
Recent Legislative Examples
Bill C-45 (Cannabis Act) exemplifies the legislative process:
Multiple readings and amendments were proposed, culminating in its passage.
Issues of Concern in Recent Legislation
Bill C-51 (Anti-Terrorism Act)
Expanded governmental surveillance powers.
Received significant criticism for potential overreach impacting civil liberties.
Bill C-75 (Criminal Justice Reform)
Aims to modernize the justice system.
Criticized for being too lenient on offenders regarding bail provisions.
Success Stories in the Senate
Diversity and Inclusion
Senator Dillon, as an RCP officer, symbolizes progress in representation.
Advocate for Women’s Rights
Senator Senior promotes gender equity initiatives.
Indigenous Relations
Senator Boniface’s contributions to improve ties between police services and First Nations communities.
Conclusion on Senate’s Role
Ontario’s representation in the Senate reflects aspects of Canadian federalism.
While the Senate's role is essential for legislative review and regional advocacy, issues around representation, accountability, and political pressure remain significant concerns.