Cultural Identity, Reverse Culture Shock, and Global Citizenship Discussions

Personal Experience with Cultural Identity

  • The speaker shares their background of being of Eastern descent and born in Texas.

    • Observations of differences: The speaker felt they did not resemble those around them or behave similarly.

    • Language barriers: Initially did not know English and was in the process of learning.

    • Challenges of integration: Learning to fit into the new culture, including adapting speech patterns.

Revisiting Cultural Roots

  • A few years later, the speaker visited family in the Middle East.

    • Experience of cultural displacement: The speaker felt caught between two cultures, identifying as someone "in the middle."

    • Encountering difficulty with rapid local jokes and language was challenging.

    • Return to original culture made re-adaptation difficult, causing feelings of exclusion from both cultures.

Reverse Culture Shock

  • The speaker acknowledges awareness of the concept of reverse culture shock.

    • Definition: Reverse culture shock occurs when someone returns to their home culture after being immersed in another, often resulting in feelings of alienation.

    • Adaptation Process: Initially, one adapts to a new culture, but returning home brings about a second shock due to the changes experienced abroad.

    • Related question: Many attendees affirm having similar experiences with this concept.

Dialogues on Indigenous Peoples

  • A participant brings up the Canadian context regarding Indigenous Peoples.

    • Suggests a perception of an American influence on Canada's approach to addressing Indigenous issues.

    • Critique on the superficial nature of apologies made to Indigenous communities: "It was kinda just like, oh, like, I'm sorry, and then, like, that's it."

    • Urges for a more substantial dialogue and action regarding Indigenous cultural recognition.

University Policies on Cultural Holidays

  • Discussion about McMaster University's unique approach: It has canceled classes on certain statutory holidays.

    • Contrasts this with other institutions, such as UT Scarborough, where no such cancellation exists.

    • Definitions of statutory holidays: Students note that holidays like Christmas are recognized widely, while holidays linked to other religions, such as Eid or Ramadan, are often overlooked.

    • Example of student involvement: Member of the MSA (Muslim Student Association) raised awareness regarding needed days off for religious observance but faced resistance.

Exclusion in Education

  • Expresses feelings of exclusion based on the prioritization of Christian holidays over other religious observances.

    • Discussion regarding Canadian school systems: Observations of imbalances in recognition of holidays across various religious communities.

Global Citizenship and Elitism

  • Reflections on concepts discussed in a cosmopolitan article regarding global citizenship.

    • Assertion that global citizenship often appears to be an exclusive construct characteristic of the elite.

    • Criteria for elitism: Access to education and fluency in globally recognized languages.

    • Situational awareness in accordance with being in university: Noted that participants in the conversation had resources inaccessible to non-educated individuals.

Education as a Source of Privilege

  • Reflection on the exclusivity in understanding global concepts:

    • Recognizes that without higher education, many individuals lack the vocabulary or concepts to engage in complex discussions about globalization or neoliberalism.

    • Participant references that certain concepts may not translate into other languages or cultures, indicating educational privilege in understanding these terms.

    • Results in a growing awareness of the inherent exclusion generated through systemic educational practices.

Closing Thoughts

  • Openness for further discussion from the reading or personal insights.

  • Encouragement of continued active participation from all attendees in expressing their thoughts.

  • Notable focus on reciprocal learning from diverse experiences and viewpoints among attendees.