American Imperialism and Anti-Imperialism

Anti-Imperialism in the United States

  • There was significant anti-imperialism in the U.S.
    • Mark Twain: A notable anti-imperialist.
    • American Anti-Imperialist League (formed in 1898): Opposed the U.S. taking over the Philippines.
  • The Philippines takeover was a key moment because it challenged the belief in American values.
    • Violated the republican principle of self-government.
    • Contradicted the idea of consent of the governed.
    • Went against the beliefs of Washington (staying out of world affairs) and Lincoln (government by the people).
  • The anti-imperialist league did not win public opinion due to the popularity of the Spanish-American War.
  • Poems like "The Black Man's Burden" and "The Real White Man's Burden" mocked the idea of the "white man's burden".
    • They criticized the notion of helping overseas people by imposing industrialization, taxes, and job insecurity on them.
    • Highlighted the racial issues within America being spread overseas.

Other Examples of American Imperialism

  • Gunboat Diplomacy: Matthew Perry and Japan (1853)
    • Japan was isolationist at the time, trading only with the Dutch near Nagasaki.
    • Matthew Perry arrived in Japan on behalf of President Franklin Pierce, demanding trade relations with a treaty backed by a gunboat.
    • This forced Japan to open up, leading to its modernization, industrialization, and transformation into an imperial power.
  • Tensions with Japan
    • Incident where Japanese Americans were barred from public schools in California.
    • Gentleman's Agreement: Japan agreed to limit Japanese immigration to America, while America allowed Japanese residents access to certain public services.
  • The U.S. and Japan had a "bound destiny" in the Pacific, growing in power but eventually colliding.

Boundary Dispute in Venezuela

  • The U.S. got involved in a boundary dispute between British Guiana and Venezuela.
  • President Cleveland warned the British not to take Venezuelan territory, citing the Monroe Doctrine.
  • England initially denied the America right to intervene but eventually, they agreed to arbitration, settling the issue.
  • The event helped the U.S. by enhancing its reputation as a Western Hemisphere power without going to war.
  • Latin American countries saw the U.S. as a protector.
  • This was the last time America and Britain were close to war.

Imperialism in Hawaii

  • American missionaries initially went to Hawaii with good intentions.
  • Later, their descendants saw economic opportunities in sugar and pineapples.
  • White planters, led by Sanford Dole, revolted against Queen Liliuokalani in 1893.
  • With unofficial support from American troops led by American minister John Stephens, the government was overthrown.
  • The new government sought annexation by the U.S.
  • President Grover Cleveland opposed the annexation, removed troops, and restored the legitimate government, earning respect from the Hawaiian people.
  • During the Spanish-American War, under the McKinley administration, Hawaii was annexed as a refueling station for ships on their way to Asia.

Imperialism in China

  • China was never fully taken over but was divided into spheres of influence by European powers.
  • Secretary of State John Hay called for an open door policy.
    • This policy aimed to prevent any one nation from taking over China, advocating for all to have controlled areas without direct rule.
  • The U.S. got involved in the Boxer Rebellion in China.
    • An international force, including the U.S., suppressed the uprising to maintain the Chinese government.

Treaty of Portsmouth (1905)

  • The U.S. negotiated the Treaty of Portsmouth, ending the Russo-Japanese War.
  • This demonstrated Japan's rise and Russia's decline.
  • President Theodore Roosevelt acted as a moderator, earning him the Nobel Peace Prize.

American Territories

  • The U.S. took over Guam, Hawaii, Samoa, Midway, and Puerto Rico.
  • Residents of these territories became American citizens.
    • Puerto Ricans have been American citizens since 1913 but lack full representation in Congress and cannot vote for president.
  • America became deeply involved in world affairs as an imperialist power.