9B
AQA A-LEVEL HISTORY (7042)
HIS1D Stuart Britain and the Crisis of Monarchy, 1603-1702
________________________________________________________________
SECTION TWO Revolution, 1629-1649
Topic 9 Political Divisions: the Long Parliament, Pym and the outbreak of civil war
Key Question B: How did the political divisions in England result in the outbreak of civil war by 1642?
Growing divisions in the Long Parliament
The divisions among MPs that emerged in the first session of the Long Parliament (November 1640 – August 1641) gradually led to the formation of a ‘royalist party’, without which there could not have been a civil war. These divisions had initially been created by:
disagreements between Pym’s Junto and moderates over how to safeguard against another period of Personal Rule;
the use of a Bill of Attainder to remove Strafford;
radical calls to remove the episcopacy in England (thereby creating a Presbyterian system);
The Ten Propositions in June 1641, which increasingly convinced moderates that it was the actions and beliefs of extremists such as Pym posed more of a threat to the established order than the King himself.
Gradually, a concept of ‘constitutional royalism’ emerged. Its adherents regarded the institution of monarchy (though not necessarily the person of Charles himself) represented the best guarantee for the survival of the Church of England, law, order and the continued political influence of the natural ruling elite (i.e., themselves).
Charles tried to capitalise upon the sympathy he was gaining by making further concessions. He had already signed away the life of his most trusted minister and agreed to legislation eradicating the instruments of Personal Rule. Just before the end of the first session of the Long Parliament, he released one of the leading opponents of Laud, John Williams, from the Tower and appointed him Archbishop of York. He also reassured the House of Lords that he would “die in the maintenance” of the Church of England. However, just as conciliation seemed to be a possibility, events in Scotland and Ireland reignited fears about absolutism and a Catholic conspiracy.
Reaction in Scotland, Aug – Nov 1641: The royalist reaction north of the border was led by James Graham, the Earl of Montrose. Perceiving that some of the more radical Covenanters were opposing Charles for their own personal gain, he had formed the ‘Cumbernauld Bond’, with fellow supporters of the Crown. The King’s decision to ignore Parliament’s wishes and travel to Scotland was partly based on a desire to capitalise on this movement. However, his departure only served to undermine his cause further:
In Charles’s absence, Parliament extended the scope of its activities into new areas. A newly-established Committee for Defence monitored his activities in Scotland, while another committee managed business in England by claiming right over the Great Seal. Parliament now had the power to pass ordinances (these had the same authority as statute laws and essentially allowed MPs to run the country without the King).
Charles’s concessions in Scotland were typically grudging and insincere. For example, in September 1641, he agreed that the Edinburgh Parliament should confirm his choice of all key officials – then proceeded to appoint a new Scottish Chancellor without consultation
Most damaging of all was the revelation of ‘The Incident’, a royalist plot to kidnap the Covenanter leaders. Charles’s reputation in Scotland was effectively destroyed. He was unable to allay suspicions that he had encouraged the conspirators, and when invited to the Scottish Parliament to prove his innocence, he arrived with several hundred soldiers, deepening suspicions further. The leaders of the plot fled, and the King had no option but transfer authority in Scotland to his Covenanter enemies. As a result, Charles returned to England in November without the support he had hoped for, and now found himself in an even weaker position than before.
Opposition in Ireland: The Irish Rebellion, Oct 1641: Despite the failure of the Scottish expedition, Charles was welcomed back to London in November with a huge royalist procession, suggesting that there had been a shift in the public mood while he had been away. However, he was not able to take advantage of this because, within a few days, news arrived of a rising by Catholics in Ireland which had resulted in the slaughter of Protestants.
The brief alliance between the various ethnic groups in Ireland had been broken by Strafford’s return to England in 1639. Charles had made the situation worse by offering the ‘Old English’ Catholics confirmation of the Graces and an end to the policy of plantation in return for their financial assistance in May 1641. This was a promise he could not keep, as by this point the Irish Parliament was taking its orders from Puritan MPs in England. In protest (and in the absence of any form of Crown authority that would have been provided by a Lord Deputy), Irish Catholic leaders organised a rebellion, hoping to reassert their influence over political and religious policy, and guarantee the security of their land. Crucially, the rising was aimed against the hated ‘New English’ Protestants in Ireland, and the English MPs who were thought to be supporting them; thus many who participated felt they were actually acting in support of the King.
The Irish Rebellion of October 1641 itself involved the brutal massacre of around 3,000 Protestants in Ulster. Political perceptions of the event radicalised the situation in England. Stories of atrocities soon began to circulate (the death toll was placed as high as 200,000 by some reports) and Parliament published graphic, completely exaggerated illustrations of murders. Moreover, rumours spread that Henrietta Maria had ordered the rising, bringing large crowds onto the streets of London to protest against ‘the Queen’s Rebellion’.
A spate of revenge killings by Irish Protestants soon followed, and events soon spiralled out of control, leaving Ireland in chaos. To make matters worse for Charles, one of the leading Catholic rebels claimed to possess a royal commission instructing him to seize the property of Irish Protestants. This was later proved to be a forgery, but at the time it seemed only too credible to MPs who had long suspected Charles of being at the centre of a Catholic conspiracy. The normal process of government began to collapse as Parliament debated how best to defend itself and the country.
The Grand Remonstrance, Nov 1641: Charles naturally wanted to suppress the rebellion by raising an army. Many MPs, however, feared that he would use it against Parliament rather than the Irish Catholics. It was agreed that troops from England must be raised, but the question of who would control the army was a matter of fierce debate. Moderates felt that to challenge the King’s right to control the military (a long-established feature of the royal prerogative) was a step too far, but the panic generated by the Irish atrocity stories was enough for Pym to demand that Parliament, not Charles, should select the army commanders. His motion was approved in the Commons by a vote of 151-110.
Pym saw the Irish Rebellion as another opportunity to weaken the King and halt the steady growth of royal support which had been growing since Charles had made concessions to Parliament at the beginning of 1641. He chose this moment to introduce The Grand Remonstrance – a document he had been working on since August listing 204 articles that discredited Charles’s past and present conduct. The majority criticised his economic policies, although there were also clauses accusing Henrietta Maria of controlling Charles and threatening national security by trying to convert him to Catholicism. To further his agenda, Pym proposed to have The Grand Remonstrance published. This was an underhand move – it was dangerous and uncharted territory to make government a matter for public consumption in the 17th century. Nevertheless, it had the potential to win Pym’s Junto the support of the London mob, as he could portray the potentially treasonable action of going against the King as nothing more than the honest duty of every loyal Englishman.
The real significance of The Grand Remonstrance lay in the debates that it created in the Commons. Ultimately, it was passed, but only by 159-148 votes. Charles was slowly acquiring a body of supporters (the constitutional royalists) who perceived him as a more reliable preserver of the stability of the country than the radicals running Parliament. These MPs felt that since 1641, the King had rectified the abuses of Personal Rule and had already agreed to sufficient safeguards that would prevent him acting in an autocratic manner in the future. Now the greatest threat seemed to come from Pym’s Junto, who were demanding ever more radical reform.
The Militia Bill, Dec 1641: As discussions about who should control the Army continued, Sir Arthur Haselrig introduced The Militia Bill. The intention was to remove all the King’s power over the county militias (localised bands of trained soldiers) and give Parliament the general right to appoint army commanders. In the context of the Irish Rebellion, MPs were therefore being forced to take sides over who should lead the force that would be sent to Ireland to defeat the Catholic rebels.
This was a revolutionary step because it represented an attempt to transfer the prerogative power of control over the military from the King to Parliament. Pym’s Junto believed that the growing anger of the London mob would pressure MPs to pass the Bill.
For his part, Charles intelligently positioned himself as the defender of ‘fundamental law’ and the constitution against potential revolutionaries, winning himself more influential supporters. However, he then appointed one of his key supporters, Colonel Thomas Lunsford, as Commander of the Tower of London in an attempt to overawe the radicals and MPs and assert royal power. Lunsford’s strong-arm tactics immediately led to rioting and Charles was forced to back down and have him replaced.
In a last-ditch effort to buy off his leading opponents, Charles offered Pym the Chancellorship of the Exchequer on New Years’ Day, 1642. Pym refused.
Events culminating in the outbreak of Civil War
The Five Members Coup, Jan 1642: For Charles, Pym’s attempts to portray the Irish Rebellion as a royalist plot and use it as an excuse to remove his military power was the last straw. He was also increasingly concerned about attacks on the episcopacy and the increasingly personal vendetta against Henrietta Maria. Accordingly, the King now embarked on a very high-risk strategy.
As Parliament debated The Militia Bill, Charles accused five MPs (Pym, John Hampden, Arthur Haselrig, Denzil Holles and William Strode) and one peer (Edward Montagu, the Earl of Manchester) of treason and demanded their arrest. The Lords initially refused to comply and instead appointed a committee to investigate the legitimacy of the charges. The King, however, was not prepared to wait: he went to the Commons himself with an armed guard, entered the chamber and, to the amazement of MPs, demanded that the Speaker hand over the accused so they could be taken into custody. His action was a complete failure. Forewarned of what was about to happen by Pym’s network of spies, the ‘Five Members’ had escaped Westminster and been smuggled away to a safe house outside London.
Charles regarded that parliamentary business was being subverted by a small group of radical Puritans who were determined to reduce his power. While he undoubtedly had grounds for this belief, the Five Members Coup constituted a serious mistake on several levels:
in one move, he had undone the growing impression that he could be trusted, destroying months of work undertaken by his supporters (e.g., Edward Hyde) to try and restore his reputation;
the use of force could be portrayed as further proof of the danger Charles posed if he had control of an army;
the outlandish rumours that Charles was at the centre of a Catholic plot were now given a degree of credibility;
the House of Lords now came under increasing pressure to bow to the Commons’ demand to exclude the bishops (see below);
demonstrations by the London mob – now even more firmly behind the parliamentary cause – forced the King and his family to abandon London, allowing the Five Members to return in triumph a week later.
The Bishops’ Exclusion Act, Feb 1642: Back in December 1640, 15,000 Londoners had signed The Root and Branch Petition, demanding the end of the episcopal system of church government. The petition was driven by Puritan MPs who feared that bishops would prevent the King’s ‘evil councillors’ from being found guilty and would refuse to pass any reforming legislation to overturn the worst aspects of Personal Rule. Eliminating bishops would also be an effective way of removing the King’s influence over the Church, as it would give local people more control over the religion in their parishes.
When The Petition was debated by the Long Parliament in February 1641, moderates expressed concern that dismantling the structure of the Church might undermine the whole order of society. All the Commons could agree upon, therefore, was that the secular powers of the bishops should be curtailed. After the revelation of the Army Plot to free Strafford, Parliament issued The Protestation Oath – a promise that the Protestant religion must be defended against ‘Popish innovations’. A Bishops’ Exclusion Bill was subsequently drawn up in June 1641, stating that bishops should no longer sit and vote in parliament. Unsurprisingly, it was defeated in the Lords.
However, by early 1642, Pym could put Presbyterianism back on the agenda. Using the slogan ‘No Bishops, No Popish Lords’, popular support against the episcopacy was mobilised once again. When some of the bishops demanded that laws made under duress should be invalidated, Pym proclaimed that parliamentary business was being corrupted and the Commons swiftly voted to impeach the bishops. This time, the Lords concurred, possibly influenced by large-scale demonstrations outside Parliament. The Bishops’ Exclusion Act thus passed into law in February, with all but two bishops sent to the Tower.
The Militia Ordinance, Mar 1642: The issue of who should control the army was decided by The Militia Ordinance. In denying the King his military powers, MPs were legislating without the monarch for the first time in English history. Local officials (appointed by MPs) were then commanded to raise £400,000 – for the purposes of Parliament, not the Crown.
The Commissions of Array, June 1642: Resorting to a medieval method of raising an army in an emergency, Charles instructed leading men in every county and city whom he believed would support the royal cause. These commissioners were empowered to persuade local militias to declare for Charles, were expected to collect money on behalf of the Crown and send their own armed men to join the King’s army.
These developments placed men throughout England in an impossible dilemma – whether to fight for their monarch or for the institution that claimed to represent the people. The majority on both sides still wished to avoid war. Across the country, members of the gentry attempted to prevent a conflict by constructing neutrality pacts. However, as both sides tried to get hold of local munition stores in the event of war, sporadic fighting began to break out.
The Nineteen Propositions, Jun 1642: A final bid to reach a settlement was made by some members of the Royalist camp, who invited Parliament to state its terms. Pym’s response was to publish The Nineteen Propositions. Its terms would effectively make Parliament the sovereign power in England through its control of appointments to the Privy Council, House of Lords, and offices of state (including the army), as well as over religious and foreign policy. They even extended to selecting the teachers and future spouses of the King’s children. Many were dismayed at the extreme position Parliament had decided to adopt.
The Royalists countered with The Answer to the Nineteen Propositions. Carefully playing to public opinion, it argued that the King was the only force in the country capable of preventing anarchy, and that Parliament’s demands must be rejected on the grounds that they would result in a ‘chaos of confusion’ that would make ‘popular rebellion’ inevitable.
The calls to arms, July-August 1642: There could be no hope of compromise after The Nineteen Propositions. On 12 July, Parliament passed a resolution stating that Charles had started a war and declared those who had assisted him guilty of treason. An army under the command of the Earl of Essex was raised. On 22 August, the King raised his royal standard on Castle Hill in Nottingham, calling all his loyal subjects to support him against Parliament. The Civil War in England had begun, and its people now had to choose a side.