Comprehensive Study Notes on Price Elasticity of Demand

Concepts of Price Elasticity: Case Studies and Real-World Scenarios

  • David's Law Clerkship Interview (Inelastic Demand Scenario):

    • Background: David, a third-year law student in California, applied for judicial clerkships. Clerking for a distinguished judge serves as a critical milestone to kickstart a legal career.
    • Interview Trip: David landed prestigious interviews in Washington, D.C. Upon flying into Reagan International Airport, he was scheduled to be picked up at the airport, driven straight to his hotel, and then transported immediately to his first interview.
    • The Crisis: While on the airplane or landing, he had a sudden sinking realization that he forgot to pack a tie. Facing the most important interview of his life, he had no tie to wear.
    • Purchase Decision: Walking past a kiosk in Reagan International Airport selling ties, David grabbed a tie and bought it immediately. He did not look at the price tag and did not care how expensive it was.
    • Behavioral Analysis: Although David is a practical, common-sense individual who does not waste money on overpriced clothing, he had no other options in his mind in that critical moment. His entire law career depended on this single tie.
    • Demand Characteristics:
    • David required exactly 1 tie1\,\text{tie}.
    • He would not buy extra ties if they were cheap.
    • He would not refrain from buying the tie if it was expensive.
    • Demand was entirely unresponsive to price, making it rigid and inelastic.
    • Outcome: David secured the clerkship. He currently practices intellectual property (IP) law at a law firm in Washington, D.C., where he is very successful.
  • David Window Shopping for Work Attire (Elastic Demand Scenario):

    • Context Shift: In his current job as an intellectual property attorney, David must wear a tie every single day for work.
    • Scenario Setup: While walking through a shopping center window shopping, David enters a store selling high-quality ties. He does not have an urgent emergency need for a tie, but has an ongoing general need for work attire.
    • Elastic Demand Behavior Across Three Price Points:
    • Scenario 1 (300 dollars300\,\text{dollars} per tie): David chooses not to purchase any ties. He has alternative options because he already owns ties and there are other stores throughout town.
    • Scenario 2 (100 dollars100\,\text{dollars} per tie): Because it is a very nice tie, David might purchase 1 tie1\,\text{tie}.
    • Scenario 3 (25 dollars25\,\text{dollars} per tie): The store is going out of business and slashes the price of fancy Italian silk ties to 25 dollars25\,\text{dollars} each. David chooses to stock up and buy a whole bunch of ties.
    • Demand Characteristics: Quantity demanded changes significantly as the price changes. Demand is flexible, stretchy, and elastic.

Determinants of Elasticity and Industry Examples

  • Fundamental Determinant of Elasticity:

    • The presence or absence of alternative options (substitutes) determines whether demand for a good is elastic or inelastic.
  • Life-Saving Pharmaceuticals (Perfectly Inelastic Demand):

    • Context: A unique drug that represents the one and only medicine capable of saving a patient's life.
    • Price Sensitivity: Consumers will buy the medication if they possibly can. A price increase of 20 dollars20\,\text{dollars} does not alter demand because the dosage is required to stay alive.
    • Price Drop Effect: If the price falls, consumers do not buy additional units beyond their required medical dose.
    • Classification: Represents a real-world approximation of perfectly inelastic demand.
  • Movie Theater Admissions (Elastic Demand):

    • Context: Attending the movies for leisure.
    • Price Sensitivity: If movie ticket prices rise, consumers readily switch to alternative entertainment options.
    • Available Substitutes: Staying home to watch Netflix, going to a concert, or going out to a club.
    • Classification: Demand is elastic due to the abundance of substitute options.
  • Gasoline Consumption on Island A vs. Island B (Public Transit Availability):

    • Initial Baseline: On both Island A and Island B, when the price of gasoline is 2 dollars2\,\text{dollars} per gallon, total demand across each island is 10000 gallons10000\,\text{gallons}.
    • Island A (Good Public Transit System):
    • Gas Price Increase: Price rises from 2 dollars2\,\text{dollars} to 3 dollars3\,\text{dollars} per gallon.
    • Demand Change: Gasoline demand drops from 10000 gallons10000\,\text{gallons} to 7000 gallons7000\,\text{gallons} (a drop of 3000 gallons3000\,\text{gallons}).
    • Elasticity: Demand is elastic (stretchy). Island residents have options and readily switch to public transit when gas prices increase.
    • Island B (Bad Public Transit System):
    • Gas Price Increase: Price rises from 2 dollars2\,\text{dollars} to 3 dollars3\,\text{dollars} per gallon.
    • Demand Change: Gasoline demand drops from 10000 gallons10000\,\text{gallons} to 9000 gallons9000\,\text{gallons} (a smaller drop of 1000 gallons1000\,\text{gallons}).
    • Elasticity: Demand is inelastic. Island residents lack transit alternatives and need to commute to work. They make minor adjustments by carpooling and combining trips, but quantity demanded declines very little relative to the price increase.

Graphical Slope and Elasticity Rules of Thumb

  • Graphical Relationships:
    • Steep Demand Curve: Demonstrates inelastic demand.
    • Flat Demand Curve: Illustrates elastic demand.
  • Analytical Distinction: While the exact relationship between slope and elasticity involves additional mathematical variables, steepness versus flatness serves as a reliable economic rule of thumb.

Mathematical Calculation of Price Elasticity of Demand

  • Basic Formula:

    • Price elasticity of demand calculates how much quantity demanded changes relative to a percentage change in price:     Price Elasticity of Demand=% ΔQd% ΔP\text{Price Elasticity of Demand} = \frac{\%\,\Delta Q_d}{\%\,\Delta P}
    • Notation: \\\Delta\\ signifies "change in", \\Q_d\\ signifies quantity demanded, and \\P\\ signifies price.
    • Calculation Objective: Determines the percentage change in quantity demanded when price changes by 1%1\%
  • Step-by-Step Calculation Example: Ice Cream Cones

    • Baseline Data:
    • Initial Point: At 2 dollars2\,\text{dollars} per cone, 100 cones100\,\text{cones} are demanded.
    • New Point: At 3 dollars3\,\text{dollars} per cone, 75 cones75\,\text{cones} are demanded.
    • Calculating Percentage Change in Quantity Demanded (Numerator):
    • Absolute Change in Quantity: 100−75=25 cones100 - 75 = 25\,\text{cones}.
    • Directional Ambiguity Problem:
      • If quantity increases from 7575 to 100 cones100\,\text{cones}, dividing the change by initial quantity gives 2575=0.333...\frac{25}{75} = 0.333... (33.3%33.3\% increase).
      • If quantity falls from 100100 to 75 cones75\,\text{cones}, dividing the change by initial quantity gives 25100=0.25\frac{25}{100} = 0.25 (25.0%25.0\% decrease).
    • Resolution via Midpoint Method: To eliminate dependency on whether price is rising or falling, divide the change by the average of the two quantities.
    • Average Quantity Calculation: 75+1002=87.5\frac{75 + 100}{2} = 87.5
    • Numerator Value: −2587.5=−0.286\frac{-25}{87.5} = -0.286 (quantity demanded drops by 28.6%28.6\%
    • Calculating Percentage Change in Price (Denominator):
    • Absolute Change in Price: 3−2=1 dollar3 - 2 = 1\,\text{dollar}.
    • Directional Ambiguity Problem:
      • If price rises from 22 to 3 dollars3\,\text{dollars}, dividing by initial price gives 12=0.50\frac{1}{2} = 0.50 (50.0%50.0\% increase).
      • If price falls from 33 to 2 dollars2\,\text{dollars}, dividing by initial price gives 13=0.333...\frac{1}{3} = 0.333... (33.3%33.3\% decrease).
    • Resolution via Midpoint Method: Divide the price change by the average of the two prices.
    • Average Price Calculation: 2+32=2.5\frac{2 + 3}{2} = 2.5
    • Denominator Value: 12.5=0.40\frac{1}{2.5} = 0.40 (price changes by 40.0%40.0\%
    • Final Elasticity Calculation:     Elasticity=−0.2860.40=−0.715\text{Elasticity} = \frac{-0.286}{0.40} = -0.715
    • Economic Interpretation: In this region of the demand curve, a 1%1\% change in price results in a 0.715%0.715\% change in quantity demanded. Because quantity demanded changes by less than the percentage change in price (0.286<0.400.286 < 0.40), demand is inelastic.

General Midpoint Formula and Elasticity Spectrum

  • The Midpoint Formula for Price Elasticity of Demand:

    • To calculate elasticity between point (Q1,P1)(Q_1, P_1) and point (Q2,P2)(Q_2, P_2):     ϵ=Q2−Q1Q1+Q22P2−P1P1+P22\epsilon = \frac{\frac{Q_2 - Q_1}{\frac{Q_1 + Q_2}{2}}}{\frac{P_2 - P_1}{\frac{P_1 + P_2}{2}}}
    • Key Components:
    • Symbol: ϵ\epsilon (Epsilon) represents price elasticity of demand.
    • Numerator: Q2−Q1Q1+Q22\frac{Q_2 - Q_1}{\frac{Q_1 + Q_2}{2}} represents the percentage change in quantity demanded.
    • Denominator: P2−P1P1+P22\frac{P_2 - P_1}{\frac{P_1 + P_2}{2}} represents the percentage change in price.
  • Sign of Elasticity:

    • Elasticity (ϵ\epsilon) is always negative due to the Law of Demand.
    • When price increases (P2−P1>0P_2 - P_1 > 0), quantity demanded decreases (Q2−Q1<0Q_2 - Q_1 < 0), resulting in a negative ratio.
  • The Elasticity Spectrum and Boundary Values:

    • Perfectly Inelastic Demand (ϵ=0\epsilon = 0):
    • Price changes result in zero change in quantity demanded.
    • Demand does not stretch at all.
    • Inelastic Demand (−1<ϵ<0-1 < \epsilon < 0):
    • Percentage change in quantity demanded is less than the percentage change in price.
    • Elastic Demand (ϵ<−1\epsilon < -1):
    • Percentage change in quantity demanded is greater than the percentage change in price.
    • Perfectly Elastic Demand (ϵ→−∞\epsilon \rightarrow -\infty):
    • Occurs when quantity demanded changes by an infinite amount relative to an infinitely small change in price (mathematically dividing a non-zero quantity change by a price change approaching zero).