Thermal Resistance Analysis in Parallel and Series-Parallel Composite Wall Systems

Fundamentals of Thermal Resistance in Parallel Configurations

  • Heat transfer through composite systems can occur across layers arranged in parallel or in combined series-parallel configurations, directly analogous to electric circuits containing parallel and series resistors.

  • In a pure parallel layer arrangement, multiple materials are placed side by side between two common isothermal boundaries at temperatures T1T_1 and T2T_2.

  • The primary governing equation for heat transfer using the thermal resistance network method is:   Q˙=ΔTRtotal\dot{Q} = \frac{\Delta T}{R_{total}}   where ΔT=Thigh−Tlow\Delta T = T_{high} - T_{low}, replacing the direct application of Fourier's law of conduction (Q˙cond=−kAdTdx\dot{Q}_{cond} = -k A \frac{dT}{dx}).

  • Heat transfer rate Q˙\dot{Q} is expressed in units of watts (W\text{W}) or kilowatts (kW\text{kW}).

  • Thermal resistance RR is expressed in units of degrees Celsius per watt (∘C/W^\circ\text{C/W}) or Kelvin per watt (K/W\text{K/W}).

  • For parallel conduction layers across common temperature limits T1T_1 and T2T_2 (assuming T1>T2T_1 > T_2), the total heat transfer rate is the sum of the heat flow rates through each individual layer:   Q˙total=Q˙1+Q˙2\dot{Q}_{total} = \dot{Q}_1 + \dot{Q}_2

  • Substituting the resistance relation into the summation yields:   T1−T2Rtotal=T1−T2R1+T1−T2R2\frac{T_1 - T_2}{R_{total}} = \frac{T_1 - T_2}{R_1} + \frac{T_1 - T_2}{R_2}

  • Dividing by the temperature difference gives the equivalent resistance equation for parallel layers:   1Rtotal=1R1+1R2\frac{1}{R_{total}} = \frac{1}{R_1} + \frac{1}{R_2}

  • Solving directly for the equivalent parallel resistance yields:   Rtotal=R1∥R2=R1R2R1+R2R_{total} = R_1 \parallel R_2 = \frac{R_1 R_2}{R_1 + R_2}

  • Individual conduction resistances for materials 1 and 2 are determined by:   R1=L1k1A1R_1 = \frac{L_1}{k_1 A_1}R2=L2k2A2R_2 = \frac{L_2}{k_2 A_2}   where LL is the thickness along the direction of heat flow, kk is the thermal conductivity, and AA is the surface area normal to the heat flow.

Area Considerations and Circuit Sketching in Parallel Arrangements

  • Heat transfer direction dictates the orientation of the surface area: the area AA used in thermal resistance calculations must always be perpendicular (normal) to the direction of heat transfer.

  • In series configurations, the cross-sectional area normal to heat transfer typically remains constant across all layers (A1=A2=AtotalA_1 = A_2 = A_{total}).

  • In parallel configurations, the total height is divided among the different materials, meaning each parallel layer has a distinct area determined by its specific height and depth (A=height×widthA = \text{height} \times \text{width}):

    • Layer 1 area: A1=H1×WA_1 = H_1 \times W
    • Layer 2 area: A2=H2×WA_2 = H_2 \times W
    • When heights differ (H1≠H2H_1 \neq H_2), the areas differ (A1≠A2A_1 \neq A_2), even if their thickness LL along the heat path and width WW are identical.
  • Procedural steps for solving thermal resistance problems:

    • Step 1: Sketch the thermal resistance circuit diagram identifying all boundary, interface, and fluid temperatures as nodes.
    • Step 2: Determine the cross-sectional heat transfer area normal to heat flow for every distinct component.
    • Step 3: Write down the general heat transfer equation based on the thermal resistance analogy (Q˙=ΔTRtotal\dot{Q} = \frac{\Delta T}{R_{total}}).
    • Step 4: Express and calculate each individual thermal resistance (Rcond=LkAR_{cond} = \frac{L}{k A}, Rconv=1hAR_{conv} = \frac{1}{h A}).
    • Step 5: Combine parallel branches into equivalent resistances and add series resistances to determine RtotalR_{total}.
    • Step 6: Substitute numerical values and solve for the heat transfer rate or unknown temperatures.

Combined Series-Parallel Systems with Convective Boundaries

  • Composite structures frequently combine parallel and series solid layers with fluid convection boundaries at exposed outer faces.

  • For a composite wall where parallel materials 1 and 2 are followed in series by material 3, bounded on the outer side by a moving fluid:

    • Node T1T_1 represents the inner surface temperature.
    • Node T2T_2 represents the interface temperature between the parallel block (layers 1 and 2) and layer 3.
    • Node T3T_3 represents the outer surface temperature of layer 3.
    • Node T∞T_\infty represents the ambient free-stream fluid temperature.
  • If no fluid temperature or convection coefficient is given for a boundary (e.g., the inner surface), convection is absent on that side, making the surface temperature the terminal node.

  • The equivalent thermal circuit for this system comprises:

    • Parallel conduction resistances R1R_1 and R2R_2 between nodes T1T_1 and T2T_2.
    • Series conduction resistance R3R_3 between nodes T2T_2 and T3T_3.
    • Series convection resistance RconvR_{conv} between nodes T3T_3 and T∞T_\infty.
  • Individual resistance formulations:   R1=L1k1A1R_1 = \frac{L_1}{k_1 A_1}R2=L2k2A2R_2 = \frac{L_2}{k_2 A_2}R3=L3k3A3R_3 = \frac{L_3}{k_3 A_3}Rconv=1hAconvR_{conv} = \frac{1}{h A_{conv}}

  • Critical rule for convective area: Convection occurs across the exposed physical surface in contact with the fluid. If material 3 covers the entire exterior face, the convective area is identical to the surface area of material 3 (Aconv=A3A_{conv} = A_3).

  • The total resistance across the entire assembly is:   Rtotal=(R1∥R2)+R3+Rconv=R1R2R1+R2+L3k3A3+1hA3R_{total} = (R_1 \parallel R_2) + R_3 + R_{conv} = \frac{R_1 R_2}{R_1 + R_2} + \frac{L_3}{k_3 A_3} + \frac{1}{h A_3}

  • The total heat transfer rate through the complete network is:   Q˙=T1−T∞Rtotal\dot{Q} = \frac{T_1 - T_\infty}{R_{total}}

  • Sub-network calculations using intermediate temperatures:

    • Heat rate across the parallel section: Q˙=T1−T2R1∥R2\dot{Q} = \frac{T_1 - T_2}{R_1 \parallel R_2}
    • Heat rate between T1T_1 and T3T_3: Q˙=T1−T3(R1∥R2)+R3\dot{Q} = \frac{T_1 - T_3}{(R_1 \parallel R_2) + R_3}

Example 1: Multi-Layer Composite System Analysis

  • System setup and specifications:

    • One-dimensional steady-state heat conduction occurs through a composite wall in the positive xx-direction (left to right).
    • Specified boundary surface temperatures: T1=370 ∘CT_1 = 370\,^\circ\text{C} (inner surface) and T4=66 ∘CT_4 = 66\,^\circ\text{C} (outer surface).
    • Convection is absent since fluid temperatures are not present; the arrows indicate fixed surface temperatures.
    • Cross-sectional area of component C: AC=0.1 m2A_C = 0.1\,\text{m}^2.
    • Area relationship clue: AB=AD=12AC=0.1 m22=0.05 m2A_B = A_D = \frac{1}{2} A_C = \frac{0.1\,\text{m}^2}{2} = 0.05\,\text{m}^2.
    • Component A spans the full height of the composite equal to component C, resulting in: AA=AC=0.1 m2A_A = A_C = 0.1\,\text{m}^2.
    • Thicknesses along the heat path must be converted from centimeters to meters:
    • Component A: LA=2.5 cm=0.025 mL_A = 2.5\,\text{cm} = 0.025\,\text{m}
    • Components B and D: LB=LD=7.5 cm=0.075 mL_B = L_D = 7.5\,\text{cm} = 0.075\,\text{m}
  • Identification of circuit nodes and thermal arrangement:

    • Node T1T_1: Surface temperature before layer A (370 ∘C370\,^\circ\text{C}).
    • Node T2T_2: Interface temperature between layer A and the parallel block (layers B and D).
    • Node T3T_3: Interface temperature between the parallel block (layers B and D) and layer C.
    • Node T4T_4: Outer surface temperature after layer C (66 ∘C66\,^\circ\text{C}).
  • Network resistance components:

    • Conduction resistance of layer A: RA=LAkAAAR_A = \frac{L_A}{k_A A_A}
    • Conduction resistance of layer B: RB=LBkBABR_B = \frac{L_B}{k_B A_B}
    • Conduction resistance of layer D: RD=LDkDADR_D = \frac{L_D}{k_D A_D}
    • Conduction resistance of layer C: RC=LCkCACR_C = \frac{L_C}{k_C A_C}
  • Equivalent resistance calculation:

    • Parallel combination of layers B and D:     RB∥D=RBRDRB+RDR_{B \parallel D} = \frac{R_B R_D}{R_B + R_D}
    • Total equivalent circuit resistance:     Rtotal=RA+RB∥D+RC=RA+RBRDRB+RD+RCR_{total} = R_A + R_{B \parallel D} + R_C = R_A + \frac{R_B R_D}{R_B + R_D} + R_C
  • Total heat transfer rate calculation:   Q˙=T1−T4Rtotal\dot{Q} = \frac{T_1 - T_4}{R_{total}}

  • Procedure to evaluate intermediate interface temperature T3T_3:

    • By conservation of energy, the heat transfer rate through layer C equals the total heat transfer rate (Q˙C=Q˙\dot{Q}_C = \dot{Q}):     Q˙=T3−T4RC\dot{Q} = \frac{T_3 - T_4}{R_C}
    • Rearranging to solve for T3T_3:     T3=T4+Q˙RCT_3 = T_4 + \dot{Q} R_C
    • Alternatively, evaluating from the upstream temperature drop:     Q˙=T1−T3RA+RB∥D  ⟹  T3=T1−Q˙(RA+RB∥D)\dot{Q} = \frac{T_1 - T_3}{R_A + R_{B \parallel D}} \implies T_3 = T_1 - \dot{Q} (R_A + R_{B \parallel D})

Example 2: Periodic Brick Wall Construction Specifications

  • Geometric dimensions of the entire wall:

    • Height: H=3 mH = 3\,\text{m}
    • Width: W=5 mW = 5\,\text{m}
    • Total frontal face area of the wall:     Atotal=H×W=3 m×5 m=15 m2A_{total} = H \times W = 3\,\text{m} \times 5\,\text{m} = 15\,\text{m}^2
  • Construction composition of the wall:

    • Horizontal bricks of rectangular cross-section: height 16 cm16\,\text{cm} (0.16 m0.16\,\text{m}) and depth/thickness along the heat flow path 22 cm22\,\text{cm} (0.22 m0.22\,\text{m}).
    • Horizontal plaster layers separating the bricks: total thickness 3 cm3\,\text{cm}, allocated symmetrically as 1.5 cm1.5\,\text{cm} above and 1.5 cm1.5\,\text{cm} below each brick.
    • Vertical plaster layers on both faces of the bricks: thickness 2 cm2\,\text{cm} (0.02 m0.02\,\text{m}) on each side.
    • Rigid foam insulation on the inner side of the wall: thickness 3 cm3\,\text{cm} (0.03 m0.03\,\text{m}).
  • Thermophysical material properties:

    • Thermal conductivity of plaster: kP=0.22 W/m⋅∘Ck_P = 0.22\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C}
    • Thermal conductivity of brick: kB=0.72 W/m⋅∘Ck_B = 0.72\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C}
    • Thermal conductivity of rigid foam: kF=0.026 W/m⋅∘Ck_F = 0.026\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C}
  • Environmental and boundary conditions:

    • Indoor ambient temperature: T∞,1=20 ∘CT_{\infty,1} = 20\,^\circ\text{C}
    • Outdoor ambient temperature: T∞,2=−10 ∘CT_{\infty,2} = -10\,^\circ\text{C}
    • Inner surface convection heat transfer coefficient: h1=10 W/m2⋅∘Ch_1 = 10\,\text{W/m}^2\cdot^\circ\text{C}
    • Outer surface convection heat transfer coefficient: h2=25 W/m2⋅∘Ch_2 = 25\,\text{W/m}^2\cdot^\circ\text{C}
    • Thermal radiation is neglected, and heat transfer is assumed to be one-dimensional.

Periodic Unit Cell Thermal Resistance Model and Heat Rate Scaling

  • Representative unit cell selection:

    • The wall geometry exhibits a repeating vertical pattern every 25 cm25\,\text{cm} (0.25 m0.25\,\text{m}) along the height.
    • Height breakdown of the unit cell: 16 cm16\,\text{cm} (brick height) +1.5 cm+ 1.5\,\text{cm} (top plaster) +1.5 cm+ 1.5\,\text{cm} (bottom plaster) +2 cm+2 cm+ 2\,\text{cm} + 2\,\text{cm} and other layers, summing to a 25 cm25\,\text{cm} repeating interval (Hunit=0.25 mH_{unit} = 0.25\,\text{m}).
    • Unit cell width is taken as a unit depth into the page: Wunit=1 mW_{unit} = 1\,\text{m}.
    • Unit cell frontal surface area:     Aunit=Hunit×Wunit=0.25 m×1 m=0.25 m2A_{unit} = H_{unit} \times W_{unit} = 0.25\,\text{m} \times 1\,\text{m} = 0.25\,\text{m}^2
  • Nodal decomposition across the unit cell (seven temperature nodes):

    • Node T∞,1T_{\infty,1}: Indoor ambient air (20 ∘C20\,^\circ\text{C}).
    • Node T1T_1: Inside surface of the rigid foam insulation.
    • Node T2T_2: Interface between the rigid foam and inner plaster layer (P1P_1).
    • Node T3T_3: Interface between inner plaster layer (P1P_1) and the parallel brick/plaster middle section.
    • Node T4T_4: Interface between the parallel brick/plaster middle section and outer plaster layer (P4P_4).
    • Node T5T_5: Outside surface of outer plaster layer (P4P_4).
    • Node T∞,2T_{\infty,2}: Outdoor ambient air (−10 ∘C-10\,^\circ\text{C}).
  • Evaluation of individual thermal resistances for the unit cell (Aunit=0.25 m2A_{unit} = 0.25\,\text{m}^2):

    • Inner convection resistance:     Rconv,1=1h1Aunit=1(10 W/m2⋅∘C)(0.25 m2)R_{conv,1} = \frac{1}{h_1 A_{unit}} = \frac{1}{(10\,\text{W/m}^2\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.25\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Rigid foam conduction resistance:     RF=LFkFAunit=0.03 m(0.026 W/m⋅∘C)(0.25 m2)R_F = \frac{L_F}{k_F A_{unit}} = \frac{0.03\,\text{m}}{(0.026\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.25\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Inner plaster layer (P1P_1) conduction resistance:     RP1=LP1kPAunit=0.02 m(0.22 W/m⋅∘C)(0.25 m2)R_{P1} = \frac{L_{P1}}{k_P A_{unit}} = \frac{0.02\,\text{m}}{(0.22\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.25\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Parallel middle section resistances (thickness L=22 cm=0.22 mL = 22\,\text{cm} = 0.22\,\text{m}):
    • Top plaster strip (P2P_2): height is 1.5 cm=0.015 m1.5\,\text{cm} = 0.015\,\text{m}, giving area AP2=0.015 m×1 m=0.015 m2A_{P2} = 0.015\,\text{m} \times 1\,\text{m} = 0.015\,\text{m}^2:       RP2=LP2kPAP2=0.22 m(0.22 W/m⋅∘C)(0.015 m2)R_{P2} = \frac{L_{P2}}{k_P A_{P2}} = \frac{0.22\,\text{m}}{(0.22\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.015\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Brick (BB): height is 16 cm=0.16 m16\,\text{cm} = 0.16\,\text{m}, giving area AB=0.16 m×1 m=0.16 m2A_B = 0.16\,\text{m} \times 1\,\text{m} = 0.16\,\text{m}^2:       RB=LBkBAB=0.22 m(0.72 W/m⋅∘C)(0.16 m2)R_B = \frac{L_B}{k_B A_B} = \frac{0.22\,\text{m}}{(0.72\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.16\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Bottom plaster strip (P3P_3): height is 1.5 cm=0.015 m1.5\,\text{cm} = 0.015\,\text{m}, giving area AP3=0.015 m×1 m=0.015 m2A_{P3} = 0.015\,\text{m} \times 1\,\text{m} = 0.015\,\text{m}^2:       RP3=LP3kPAP3=0.22 m(0.22 W/m⋅∘C)(0.015 m2)R_{P3} = \frac{L_{P3}}{k_P A_{P3}} = \frac{0.22\,\text{m}}{(0.22\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.015\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Equivalent resistance of the parallel middle section:       1Rmid=1RP2+1RB+1RP3\frac{1}{R_{mid}} = \frac{1}{R_{P2}} + \frac{1}{R_B} + \frac{1}{R_{P3}}
    • Outer plaster layer (P4P_4) conduction resistance:     RP4=LP4kPAunit=0.02 m(0.22 W/m⋅∘C)(0.25 m2)R_{P4} = \frac{L_{P4}}{k_P A_{unit}} = \frac{0.02\,\text{m}}{(0.22\,\text{W/m}\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.25\,\text{m}^2)}
    • Outer convection resistance:     Rconv,2=1h2Aunit=1(25 W/m2⋅∘C)(0.25 m2)R_{conv,2} = \frac{1}{h_2 A_{unit}} = \frac{1}{(25\,\text{W/m}^2\cdot^\circ\text{C})(0.25\,\text{m}^2)}
  • Total equivalent resistance of the representative unit cell:   Rtotal,unit=Rconv,1+RF+RP1+Rmid+RP4+Rconv,2R_{total, unit} = R_{conv,1} + R_F + R_{P1} + R_{mid} + R_{P4} + R_{conv,2}

  • Heat transfer rate through the unit cell:   Q˙unit=T∞,1−T∞,2Rtotal,unit=20 ∘C−(−10 ∘C)Rtotal,unit\dot{Q}_{unit} = \frac{T_{\infty,1} - T_{\infty,2}}{R_{total, unit}} = \frac{20\,^\circ\text{C} - (-10\,^\circ\text{C})}{R_{total, unit}}

  • Scaling the heat transfer rate to the entire wall:

    • Ratio of total wall area to unit cell area:     N=AtotalAunit=15 m20.25 m2=60N = \frac{A_{total}}{A_{unit}} = \frac{15\,\text{m}^2}{0.25\,\text{m}^2} = 60
    • Total steady-state rate of heat transfer through the complete 3 m×5 m3\,\text{m} \times 5\,\text{m} wall:     Q˙total=Q˙unit×(AtotalAunit)=60×Q˙unit\dot{Q}_{total} = \dot{Q}_{unit} \times \left(\frac{A_{total}}{A_{unit}}\right) = 60 \times \dot{Q}_{unit}