Notes on the Second Red Scare and the Rise of McCarthyism

After World War II: The Rise of Anticommunism

  • After World War II, the United States experienced a surge of anticommunism.
  • An estimated 1-3 million federal employees were investigated for communist ties.
  • Individuals accused of having connections to known communists or exhibiting 'moral weakness' were often fired without due process.

Key Figures and Events

  • Alger Hiss:

    • A former State Department official convicted of consorting with a communist spy.
    • His case exemplified the intense fear and suspicion surrounding communism in America during this period.
  • Joseph McCarthy's Rise:

    • In 1950, Senator Joseph McCarthy claimed to have a list of over 200 names of known communists working for the State Department.
    • He led a campaign filled with innuendo, inciting fear among innocent individuals whose lives were disrupted.

McCarthyism and Blacklisting

  • McCarthy initiated a wave of accusations targeting individuals in various sectors:
    • Government, education, and the entertainment industry.
    • Lists of accused individuals labeled as ‘tainted’ resulted in widespread blacklisting.
  • Those placed on these lists faced severe career consequences, including unemployment and social ostracization.

Eisenhower’s Position

  • President Dwight D. Eisenhower expressed concern about McCarthy's unchecked power and the fear he generated.
  • Eisenhower took steps to combat McCarthy's influence but was cautious about direct confrontation.

Downfall of McCarthy

  • McCarthy’s decline began when he accused the U.S. Army of harboring communists.
  • The Army defended itself vigorously, leading to public hearings.
  • The televised hearings revealed McCarthy’s aggressive tactics and lack of substantial evidence, causing public opinion to turn against him.
  • Ultimately, McCarthy's tactics were seen as overreaching, leading to his loss of credibility, but the fear of communism persisted in American society.