Comprehensive Study Notes on the Siege and Surrender of Yorktown (1781)
Allied Advance and Strategic Setup at Yorktown
Movement and Encampment:
On , at , the combined French and American armies, totaling troops, began their march toward Yorktown.
The Allied forces established a crescent-shaped encampment enveloping the town:
The French army was positioned on the left.
The American army was positioned on the right.
General George Washington and the Comte de Rochambeau set up their respective headquarters just a few hundred yards apart.
Washington and Rochambeau rode forward together to reconnoiter the enemy positions.
Strategic Assessment of Yorktown:
Washington understood Yorktown's strategic limitations and the tactical disadvantage the British had created for themselves.
Outer Defenses: Situated from Yorktown stood an outer line of trenches and redoubts, their bases bristling with abatis (sharpened logs designed to repel invaders).
Inner Defenses: Black laborers were seen working to complete an inner ring of defenses around the town.
Terrain Barriers: Swamps and marshy creeks rendered a direct tactical assault impractical.
Time Constraints: The Allies could not afford to starve the defenders into submission, as the French fleet was scheduled to return to the Caribbean within weeks.
European Siege Strategy:
A traditional European-style siege was identified as the solution.
Washington left the planning of the siege entirely to the French military leadership.
Rochambeau noted that the Americans were totally ignorant of siege operations, whereas Rochambeau had personally taken part in sieges.
British Withdrawal and Construction of the First Parallel
British Tactical Retreat:
At dawn on September 30, French and American troops advanced cautiously toward the outermost British defenses, expecting heavy resistance.
The Allied troops found the outer positions completely abandoned.
Lord Cornwallis, outnumbered , pulled his men back into the town itself.
Cornwallis made a fatal mistake driven by exhaustion and depression, operating well below his usual effectiveness as a commander.
Allied Construction Operations:
For , Allied soldiers worked continuously to transform the abandoned British positions into their own strongholds.
Troops brought up artillery, heavy equipment, and entrenching tools required to dig their first parallel trench and begin siege operations.
British artillery continuously hurled shot and shells at the working French and American soldiers.
Support Operations and Sarah Osborne:
Women provided vital support by carrying provisions to the digging crews; Sarah Osborne, the wife of a New Jersey corporal, was among those who brought beef, bread, and hot coffee to the men.
Interaction with George Washington:
Washington happened by and asked Sarah Osborne if she was afraid of the British cannonballs.
Sarah Osborne replied: "No, it would not do for the men to fight and starve too."
Completion and Initial Bombardment:
The completed first parallel stretched for more than , measuring wide and nearly deep.
At on October 9, the French opened fire on the British positions.
Allied Artillery Bombardment and Second Parallel Construction
Initiation of American Artillery Fire:
At on October 9 ( after the French began firing), Washington was given the honor of touching off the first American cannon.
Cannons and mortars all along the Allied lines commenced a heavy fire into Yorktown.
Eyewitness Bombardment Accounts:
Bartholomew James reported that the remainder of the night passed in "dreadful slaughter," noting that several parts of the garrison were in flames and "the whole discovered a view awful and tremendous."
Private Johan Conrad Duller likened the artillery strike to witnessing the shock of an earthquake, noting that shots fired by the enemy were counted in that period against Yorktown, Allied lines, and ships in the harbor.
Construction of the Second Parallel:
By the night of October 11, the Allies commenced digging a second parallel trench to tighten the encirclement.
Before the noose could be fully tightened, two strategic British outposts—Redoubt Number 9 and Redoubt Number 10—had to be captured.
Redoubt Number 10 was assigned to American forces drawn from the Marquis de Lafayette's command, led by Alexander Hamilton.
Private Joseph Plum Martin and his company led the front line of the assault.
Assault on Redoubts Number 9 and Number 10
Preparation and Tactical Watchword:
American troops advanced beyond the trenches and lay flat on the ground to await the signal.
Tactical Watchword: "Rochambeau". When pronounced quickly, it sounded like "rush on, boys".
Execution of the Assault on Redoubt Number 10:
Upon the signal, Joseph Plum Martin and his fellow soldiers rushed forward, followed directly by Rhode Island troops, including free Black men and former slaves.
British defenders opened fire into the attackers the moment they reached the abatis.
Joseph Plum Martin forced a passage through a section where a cannon shot had cut away part of the abatis.
While passing through, a soldier at Martin's side was struck in the head by a ball, falling under Martin's feet and crying out bitterly.
American forces captured the redoubt quickly and secured it shortly thereafter.
French Coordination at Redoubt Number 9:
Lafayette sent a dispatch to the French officer commanding the column assigned to capture Redoubt Number 9, announcing that American troops were already inside Redoubt Number 10 and asking: "Where are you?"
The French officer replied: "Tell the Marquis, I am not in mine, but will be in five minutes."
Aftermath and Conditions Inside the Redoubts:
Georg Daniel Floor recorded that no mercy was shown that night, with complaints and groans heard everywhere.
Soldiers called out begging to be killed for the love of God.
The redoubt was so densely covered with dead and wounded bodies that soldiers were forced to walk on top of them.
Continuous Bombardment and the British Surrender Signal
Allied Bombardment from Captured Redoubts:
The Allies rolled their heavy artillery directly into captured Redoubts Number 9 and 10 and opened fire on Yorktown.
Defenders experienced continuous bombardment for days with no moments of rest and no place to hide.
Cornwallis' Strategic Position:
Cornwallis realized his cause was hopeless, but could not bear what Banastre Tarleton described as "the mortification of a surrender."
Signal for Negotiations:
At approximately on , a British drummer appeared on a parapet beating his drum to signal a desire to negotiate.
Because the thunder of the artillery drowned out the drumming, a British officer climbed up beside the soldier and waved a white handkerchief.
Ebenezer Denny noted that the drummer might have beaten until doomsday had he not been sighted by front-line troops, but added that when firing ceased, he had never heard a drum equal to it, calling it "the most delightful music to us all."
The Battle of Yorktown concluded in a complete victory for the Patriot forces and their French allies.
Surrender Negotiations, Terms, and Official Protocol
Surrender Terms:
Negotiations continued for .
Cornwallis requested that British and German soldiers be allowed to sail back to Europe as free men.
Washington refused Cornwallis' request, recalling the disrespectful treatment Patriot General Benjamin Lincoln and his men received following the fall of Charleston.
Washington dictated that surrendering forces remain in the United States as prisoners of war until a formal peace was established. Cornwallis accepted.
March-Out of Surrendering Troops:
British and German troops marched out of Yorktown with their flags cased, their ranks severely reduced by wounds and disease.
British soldiers were explicitly ordered to avoid looking at the victorious Americans, having been told that only the French were worthy military opponents.
The Sword Ceremony and Hierarchy of Surrender:
Washington and Rochambeau waited on horseback to receive the surrender.
Lord Cornwallis did not appear, claiming illness, though his absence was attributed to severe humiliation over surrendering his army to rebels.
Cornwallis' second-in-command, General Charles O'Hara, substituted for Cornwallis and attempted to surrender Cornwallis' sword directly to Rochambeau.
Rochambeau refused to accept the sword, stating: "We are subordinate to the Americans. General Washington will give you orders."
Washington also refused to accept the sword directly from O'Hara, referring O'Hara to Washington's second-in-command, General Benjamin Lincoln.
General Benjamin Lincoln formally accepted the surrender sword from O'Hara and handed it back to him as custom dictated, completing the formal process.
Post-Battle Reflections and Documentary Context
Commentary by Major Johan Ewald:
Major Johan Ewald reflected on the discipline and spirit of the Allied troops: "With what soldiers in the world could one do what was done by these men? One can perceive what an enthusiasm which these poor fellows call liberty can do. Who would have thought a hundred years ago that out of this multitude of rebel would arise a people who could defy kings?"
Historical Documentary Context:
Ken Burns directed The American Revolution alongside co-directors Sarah Botstein and David Schmidt to examine the historical impact and founding of the United States.