Polymorphism in Crystalline Substances

Fundamentals of Polymorphism

  • Definition: Polymorphism is the ability of a single chemical substance to crystallize in more than one distinct crystal structure while maintaining identical chemical composition.

  • Variable Properties: Different polymorphs exhibit unique melting points, solubilities, densities, and stabilities due to variations in molecular packing, orientation, or conformation.

Classification of Polymorphism

  • Packing Polymorphism: Molecules possess identical conformations but differ in their arrangement and orientation within the crystal lattice.

  • Conformational Polymorphism: Molecules adopt different shapes (e.g., torsion angles, ring puckering), leading to distinct crystal forms.

  • Synthon Polymorphism: Features different dominant supramolecular interaction motifs.

  • Tautomeric Polymorphism: Different structural isomers (tautomers) are fixed in the solid state, interconverting via proton movement and double bond shifts.

Case Study: Packing Polymorphism in Glycine

  • General Formula: C2H5NO2C_2H_5NO_2 (amino acid zwitterion).

  • α\alpha-Glycine: Space group P21/nP2_1/n (CSD refcode: GLYCIN29); head-to-tail layer arrangement; metastable.

  • β\beta-Glycine: Space group P21P2_1 (CSD refcode: GLYCIN31); open packing, low density; metastable.

  • γ\gamma-Glycine: Space group P31P3_1 or P32P3_2 (CSD refcode: GLYCIN33); helical chains along the c-axis; thermodynamically most stable form.

Case Study: Conformational Polymorphism in Carbamazepine

  • Application: Drug used for epilepsy and nerve pain; features a flexible ring system and amide group.

  • Form I: Triclinic (P-1P\text{-}1), CBMZPN11; metastable.

  • Form II: Trigonal (R-3R\text{-}3), CBMZPN03; rare.

  • Form III: Monoclinic (P21/nP2_1/n), CBMZPN02; stable hydrogen-bonded dimer; used in pharmaceuticals.

  • Form IV: Monoclinic (C2/cC2/c), CBMZPN12; metastable.

  • Form V: Orthorhombic (PbcaPbca), CBMZPN16; very rare.

Advanced Polymorphic Concepts

  • Synthon Polymorphism Example: 2 : 1 co-crystal of 4-hydroxybenzoic acid and 2,3,5,6-tetramethylpyrazine (ODOBIT and ODOBIT01).

  • Tautomeric Polymorphism Example: 2-Thiobarbituric Acid in Keto form (THBARB01) and Enol form (PABNAJ).

  • Concomitant Polymorphism: Simultaneous crystallization of multiple forms from a single experiment (e.g., mixtures of α\alpha, β\beta, and γ\gamma glycine in polar solvents).

  • Disappearing Polymorphs: A stable form (lower Gibbs free energy ΔG\Delta G) emerges and dominates the nucleation landscape, acting as a seed that prevents the formation of earlier metastable forms.

  • Ritonavir Incident (1998): The unexpected appearance of stable Form II (less soluble) during manufacturing replaced Form I, leading to the drug's temporary market withdrawal.