Ethical Theory Test 1 Notes
Key Concepts and Distinctions
Socrates and Polus:
Oratory vs. philosophy
Socrates argues that oratory is morally worthless because it aims to please audiences through persuasion without requiring knowledge of justice, whereas philosophy (dialectic) seeks truth and moral improvement.
Craft (techne) vs. knack
“I say that it isn’t a craft, but a knack, because it has no account of the nature of whatever things it applies by which it applies them, so that it’s unable to state the cause of each thing” (464d)
This distinction highlights the difference between genuine knowledge and mere skill, emphasizing that a true craft involves understanding and the ability to articulate the underlying principles.
Flattery (apply to pastry baking and oratory; know the analogy)
“Pastry baking has put on the mask of medicine, and pretends to know the foods that are best for the body” (464d)
Socrates provides that if a doctor and pastry baker were to provide knowledge of food to a group of children, they would choose the baker because the baker's offerings appear more appealing and delicious, illustrating how superficial qualities can often overshadow what’s ‘good’. This is flattery
Oratory is a part of flattery
Care of body, care of soul (know the two parts of each practice)
Care of body: medicine, gymnastics
Care of soul: justice, legislation
Doing what one wants vs. what one sees fit (Socrates’ distinction)
Agents perform intermediate actions (means) for the sake of a good end. They want the good end, but merely think it best to perform the specific action to get there.
If an agent performs the action they think best but fails to realize the good end (e.g., a tyrant who exiles someone thinking it benefits them, when it actually harms them), they do what they think best but do not do what they want.
Consequently, Socrates concludes that tyrants and orators have the least power of any citizens because they frequently fail to achieve their real desires (their true good), even if they successfully execute their immediate intentions.
We want all and only what would seem best to us if our desires were perfectly coherent; thus, acting on flawed judgment means acting against one’s own true interests.
Who is happy vs. miserable and why; the good/admirable person, the wicked/unjust person
Happy:
Miserable: tyrants, those with ‘great power’ are miserable if they are unjust because they lack discipline. They suffer more than those who suffer injustice.
Callicles’ speech:
Source of conventional justice
“I believe that nature itself reveals that it’s a just thing for the better man and the more capable man to have a greater share than the worse man and the less capable man” (483d)
What is just by nature
that the superior rule the inferior and have a greater share than they
Compare Callicles’ view with Socrates (why is it more contemptible to suffer an injustice than to commit one?)
In Callicles' view, natural justice favors the strong and asserts that it is right for them to dominate the weak, reflecting a belief that might makes right. Conversely, Socrates contends that it is more contemptible to suffer an injustice because it implies a lack of moral integrity and self-control, leading to the corruption of one's soul. Socrates argues that committing injustice harms the perpetrator more profoundly than the victim, as it distorts one's character and leads to a life devoid of virtue.
Socrates questions Callicles:
Distinction between stronger and superior/better
Callicles determines/agrees that stronger, better, and superior all mean the same thing.
Callicles’ new definition of superior/better
“By better, I mean the worthier.” (489d). Callicles also means the more intelligent (about the affairs of the city). Brave, and ambitious.
Callicles’ rejection of self-control
Rejects self-control, says that “wantonness, lack of discipline, and freedom (if available in goof supply) are excellence and happiness” and self-control/contracts of men go against nature.
Point of the “leaking jar” analogy
Socrates’ rejoinder: the uncontrolled self is like a “leaking jar”; can never be filled, you must constantly work to refill it and never be satisfied
Like scratching an itch that never goes away (scratching feels good but it doesn’t get rid of the itch)
He insists: “pleasure” and “good” are one and the same; a life spent in relentless pursuit of pleasure (no matter what sort!) is better than the self-controlled life.
Socrates’ defense of self-control
(paraphrased) A man who has filled up his jars doesn’t pour any more into them and can relax over them.
Socrates’ closing remarks
Role of good, skilled orator
A good, skilled orator should always support what’s just
Priority of being good over seeming good, of living justly over avoiding suffering
Key Arguments
Socrates’ argument (against Polus) that tyrants have the least power of all
Claim: Tyrants have the least power of all.
Premises: (S) They do just about nothing they want to, but do what they see fit —> They don’t exile or kill their enemies because they want to, but because it’s beneficial to them in the long run (it’s for the sake of what’s good that those who do all things do them) —> Tyrants putting enemies to death may think it’s better for them when it’s actually worse (doing what they see fit) but this isn’t great power as it’s not ‘good’ —> a man who does in his city what he ‘sees fit’ doesn’t have great power and isn’t doing what he wants either
Objection/rebuttal: Some may argue that tyrants possess more power due to their ability to instill control over others. However, this perspective overlooks the idea that true power is not merely the ability to coerce or dominate, but rather the capacity to act in alignment with one's genuine desires and moral principles.
Socrates’ argument that it is worse to do an injustice than to suffer one
Claim: It’s worse to do an injustice than suffer one.
Polus begins by stating (1) Suffering wrong is “worse” (less ‘good,’ less ‘beneficial,’ more ‘harmful’). (2) Doing wrong is “more contemptible” (more shameful, less ‘admirable’)
Premises: Two general principles (G1) x is more admirable than y if and only if either x is more pleasant than y or x is ‘better’ (more ‘beneficial’) than y. (G2) x is more contemptible than y if and only if x is more unpleasant than y or x is ‘worse’ (more ‘harmful’) than y. —> So, doing wrong is either more unpleasant or more harmful than suffering wrong. —> A’s doing wrong is not more unpleasant for A (it doesn’t “distress” A more) than A’s suffering wrong —> So, A’s doing wrong is not more unpleasant than A’s suffering wrong. —> So, A’s doing wrong must be more harmful than A’s suffering wrong. —> No one would choose the more harmful over the less harmful. —> Therefore, no one would choose doing wrong over suffering wrong. (e)
Objection/rebuttal: only by (human) law is it more contemptible to do wrong than to suffer it. ADD MORE
Socrates’ argument that it is worst of all to do an injustice and have it go unpunished
Premises: A man going unpunished for his wrongdoing is the most unjust of all and more miserable than the tyrant who isn’t caught —> it corrupts and disorders the soul of the wrongdoer, making them morally worse regardless of external gains —> justice is an internal ordering of the soul, and wrongdoing is a disease that harms the perpetrator more than the victim.
Objection: unpunished wrongdoing allows the perpetrator to live a happy, powerful, and prosperous life.
Rebuttal: genuine strength is found in self-control and justice, proving that those who commit injustice harm their own souls and are therefore pitiable, not enviable or superior.
Socrates’ critique of equating better with stronger
Premises: (C) determines that better = stronger —> (S) the many (the masses) are stronger than the one (the individual) because they can impose laws and enforce their will —> (C) shifts his definition of "stronger" to mean the "wiser" or more intelligent to avoid the absurd conclusion that the mob is superior to the virtuous individual
Objection: What’s admirable by nature is a man who allows his appetite to expand and doesn’t control them.
Rebuttal: This perspective fails to recognize that true strength lies in self-discipline and the ability to govern one's desires, leading to a more profound understanding of virtue.
Socrates’ critique of equating good with pleasure (i.e. critique of Callicles hedonism)
(S) pleasure isn’t equated to good because when a thirsty man stops drinking water, he’s no longer feeling pleasure because he’s not actively quenching his thirst —> he stops having pleasure and pain at the same time but doesn’t stop having good and bad at the same time —> so, good does not equal pleasant
Objection to Socrates’ argument: one could argue that pleasure can still be considered good, as it contributes to overall well-being and happiness. For instance, a pleasurable experience can enhance one's quality of life, leading to positive emotional states and fulfillment. Therefore, even if pleasure is temporary or situational, it still plays a significant role in determining what is good.
Rebuttal to objection: However, Socrates might argue that while pleasure can contribute to a sense of well-being, it should not be the sole criterion for determining the good. He emphasizes that true good transcends transient pleasures, as it encompasses virtues and moral actions that ultimately lead to a more profound fulfillment. Thus, if one solely chases after pleasure, they risk neglecting deeper values that constitute a good and meaningful life.
Be able to connect Socrates’ arguments about self-control to broader argument concerning justice, happiness and the health of the soul
Arguments on self-control:
Socrates posits that self-control is essential for achieving true happiness, as it allows individuals to resist immediate gratifications in favor of long-term well-being.
He argues that an ungoverned pursuit of pleasure can lead to chaos and discord within the soul, which in turn affects one's ability to act justly.
By practicing self-control, individuals can align their desires with rational thought, ultimately contributing to a harmonious state of being that supports both personal fulfillment and social justice.
Objections to self control:
Some argue that excessive self-control may lead to repression of natural desires and emotions, potentially resulting in mental health issues or a lack of authenticity in personal expression.
Rebuttal to objection:
However, it can be argued that self-control does not require the complete suppression of desires, but rather involves the regulation of impulses in a way that promotes well-being and authentic self-expression within a societal context. This balance allows individuals to experience their emotions while still making choices that align with their values and ethical principles.