Homophrosyne, Infiltration, and Character Analysis

Course Mechanics and Administrative Announcements

  • Reading Assignments and Texts:

    • The primary text for the upcoming section is Plato.

    • Any modern translation is acceptable for study. Eighteeth-century rhyming verse translations must be strictly avoided.

    • The Oxford translation is out of print, making the Penguin paperback translation the primary recommended edition.

    • Plato lecture content begins on Wednesday.

  • Midterm Examination:

    • The midterm exam takes place next week on Monday.

    • Explicit guidance on exam contents and necessary preparation will be distributed to all students via email.

  • Post-Midterm Documents and Resources:

    • Following the return of the midterm exams, several guidance documents will be emailed to students:

      • Paper Writing Guide: Detailed instructions outlining how to compose and structure the required term paper.

      • Grammatical Guide: A curated guide targeting common grammatical errors that frequently affect lower-performing students.

      • Mistakes to Avoid: A clear list of specific paper-writing errors and ineffective techniques based on past course performance.

      • Simplified Summary: A short, two-sentence summary distilling the complex paper instructions into essential directives.

The Concept of Homophrosyne in The Odyssey

  • Definition and Etymology:

    • Homophrosyne (or homoprosyne): The core term of the text's resolution, translating to "same-mindedness," "same thought," or "same feeling."

    • Homo- is Greek for "like" or "same" (contrasted with hetero-, meaning "different" or "other").

    • Phrosyne relates to mind, thought, or feeling.

    • Linguistic note: The term "homosexual" is an inter-linguistic compound combining Greek (homo) and Latin (sexual). A purely Greek linguistic construct is homoeros or homoerotic.

  • Odysseus's Application on Phaeacia:

    • Odysseus achieves homophrosyne on the island of the Phaeacians (Pyakyans), beginning with Princess Nausicaa.

    • Context of the encounter: Odysseus is at maximum physical disadvantage—naked, beaten, washed ashore, and approaching a wealthy young princess.

    • Progression of alignment: After establishing same-mindedness with Nausicaa, he utilizes her assistance to achieve homophrosyne with her parents, King Alcinous and Queen Arete.

  • Characteristics of the Phaeacians:

    • They are non-divine mortals (do not live forever) favored by the gods beyond ordinary humans.

    • They possess magical ships capable of winter navigation.

    • As Hesiod notes, ordinary human beings cannot sail during winter without provoking the wrath of Poseidon, but the Phaeacians are granted special divine privilege to do so.

  • Arrival on Ithaca:

    • The Phaeacians transport Odysseus to Ithaca on their magic ship while he sleeps, suffering from extreme exhaustion from the previous two days.

    • They place him asleep on a pallet or bed on the Ithacan beach, stacking his extensive guest gifts around him, and depart.

Odysseus's Spy Mission and Allies on Ithaca

  • Nature of the Mission:

    • Odysseus's return functions structurally like a covert spy thriller (analogous to James Bond entering hostile territory).

    • The prominent figureheads in Ithaca are his direct enemies who do not wish for his return.

    • Suitors exploit societal expectations: Presuming Odysseus dead, they pressure Penelope to remarry or return to her parents, allowing a new king to claim the throne.

    • Telemachus despairs of his father's return, telling the disguised Athena that his father's bones lie rotting on a beach.

  • Psychological Condition of Ithaca:

    • Faith in Odysseus's survival is psychically impossible for the population; even his wife and son believe he is dead.

    • The long absence of central authority has isolated individuals, preventing open communication across the island.

  • Execution of the Strategy:

    • Odysseus must discreetly identify the few isolated individuals who mourn him and desire his return.

    • He must individually draw loyal allies into mental unity (homophrosyne) with himself.

    • He reveals only enough information to align their intentions with his own, dominating them to act as extensions of his mind.

    • Targeted Loyal Allies:

      • Athena (goddess and tactical guide).

      • Eumaeus (a slave fig/swine herder).

      • Telemachus (his son).

      • Penelope (his wife).

      • Argos (his old hunting dog).

      • Two or three additional unnamed loyal servants.

    • Once this network of mental unity is established, the plan transitions directly to physical violence and execution.

The Image of Metis: Scylla, Charybdis, and Calypso

  • Hanging on the Fig Tree:

    • Odysseus navigates past Scylla and Charybdis a second time, clinging to a fig tree growing out of a sheer cliff face.

    • He remains suspended for 10 to 12 hours without footrests, supporting his weight with his upper body and legs wrapped around the trunk.

    • He hangs positioned between Scylla's striking heads above and Charybdis's whirlpool below.

  • Spatial and Temporal Opposites:

    • Spatial position: Suspended between heaven and the underworld.

    • Temporal position: Suspended in painful anticipation between past memory and future expectation.

    • Distinction between Kronos and Kairos (Torah):

      • Kronos: Extended, empty duration spent waiting without fulfillment.

      • Kairos (Torah): The decisive, opportune hour when action occurs.

  • Resolution and Escape:

    • At the exact hour (Kairos), Charybdis regurgitates the ship's wreckage.

    • Odysseus releases his hold, drops into the sea beside the floating keel, rolls onto the timber using his hands, and rows away without being seen by Scylla.

    • Drifts for 9 days (a standard epic temporal unit) before reaching Ogygia on the 10th evening.

  • Calypso's Paradise vs. Ithaca:

    • Calypso offers paradise, love, care, and immortality.

    • Odysseus deliberately chooses to reject immortal paradise, preferring the severe hardships of his hard-scrabble kingdom in Ithaca.

Athena's Disguise and the Transformation into a Beggar

  • Return to Ithaca (Book 13):

    • Odysseus wakes on a generic Ithacan beach and encounters Athena disguised as a young shepherd boy / slave.

    • He instantly fabricates an elaborate false persona and lie.

    • Athena smiles, transforms into a tall, beautiful woman skilled in arts, and commends his duplicity, trickery, and talent for fiction.

    • Athena notes that both of them possess supreme craftiness—he among mortals, she among gods.

  • Contrast with Agamemnon:

    • Agamemnon returned home rashly without discreetly testing his household, resulting in his murder by his wife Clytemnestra (Helen's twin sister) and her lover.

    • Odysseus demonstrates tactical intelligence by refraining from rushing home or immediately asking about his family.

  • The Disguise of the Pathetic Old Man:

    • Athena promises that the suitors' blood and brains will spatter the floor (Book 13, lines 390-400).

    • She uses her wand to transform Odysseus (who is approximately 40 years old and in his physical prime) into a pathetic beggar:

      • Shrivels the skin on his supple limbs and makes his joints arthritic.

      • Bleaches and ruins his hair.

      • Dims and clouds his eyes to make him ugly to the suitors, his wife, and his son.

      • Transforms his garments into tattered, salt-stained rags and a dirty tunic.

      • Wraps a massive leather deer skin over his shoulders.

      • Hands him a threadbare tote bag and a walking stick.

    • Directs him to seek out Eumaeus the swineherd first.

Eumaeus the Swineherd and Historical Context of Slavery

  • Encounter with Guard Dogs (Book 14):

    • Odysseus ascends the cliff and is attacked by Eumaeus's savage guard dogs.

    • Odysseus employs a tactical defense by crouching down and making himself small.

    • Eumaeus runs out to restrain the dogs, terrified that they might harm a stranger and bring him disgrace.

  • Eumaeus's Loyalty and Hospitality:

    • Eumaeus mourns his absent master while raising pigs consumed by the suitors.

    • Linguistic note on non-Greeks: Non-Greek speakers were termed "barbarians" (derived from the Greek perception of foreign speech as bar-bar nonsense or baby talk, later linked to barba/beards and barbers).

    • Eumaeus adheres strictly to the proper order of hospitality: provides food, wine, and warmth before interrogating the guest.

    • Eumaeus believes Odysseus is dead (bones lying on a beach heaped with sand or eaten by marine life).

    • Declares Odysseus was the kindest master he will ever have—superior even to his biological parents—and calls him "brother."

  • Historical Context of Ancient Slavery:

    • Origins: Captured in war (e.g., Julius Caesar taking Gallic captives; the end of the Gallic Wars flooded Italy with slaves, eliminating paid free labor) or through piracy (e.g., Caesar's multi-month captivity by Mediterranean pirates, whom he later hunted down and crucified).

    • Etymology: The word "slave" derives from Slav, originating from the medieval and Renaissance Italian slave markets supplied by Slavic populations.

    • Nature of Ancient Slavery: Non-racial. Slaves could earn income, purchase freedom, or be freed as freedmen. Freedmen established businesses with former owners as sponsors, and their children became full Roman citizens (e.g., a Getty Museum bust of a deceased 4-5 year old slave child with the lock of Horus, commissioned by his owner).

    • Contrast with American 18th/19th-Century Slavery:

      • Racialized and governed by hypodescent (assigning the child the legal status of the mother).

      • Sustained by internal breeding; slave owners routinely fathered children with enslaved women (typical ratio: 4 slave children for every 1 legitimate white child, exemplified by Thomas Jefferson fathering sons with Sally Hemings and freeing them to Northern states).

Reconnections, Revelations, and the Plan to Reclaim the Palace

  • Differentiated Communication Strategy:

    • Odysseus adapts his identity and level of disclosure to each person:

      • Athena: Full operational partnership.

      • Eumaeus: Maintained as the old beggar persona; receives false tales of news about Odysseus's survival but no reveal of true identity.

      • Telemachus: Complete reveal of identity.

  • Reunion with Telemachus (Books 15–16):

    • Setting: Winter solstice period (long nights suitable for storytelling and rest).

    • Telemachus returns from his mainland voyage (where he picked up exiles, including a murderer and a prophet) and visits Eumaeus's hut.

    • Epiphany / Theophany: Athena strips away the beggar disguise. Telemachus is terrified, believing he is witnessing the terrifying appearance of a god (theophany / epiphany).

    • Odysseus clarifies: "I am no god… I am your father… after twenty years, I have come home."

  • Tactical Assessment and Plan:

    • Suitor Count: Exactly 107 suitors occupy the palace.

    • Infiltration Plan: Odysseus will enter his own palace disguised as a beggar, escorted by Eumaeus.

    • Telemachus's Mandate: Must maintain absolute emotional composure when suitors abuse, pelt, or physically drag Odysseus out. Must not intervene.

    • Odysseus's Objective: Test Penelope's true intentions, observe suitor behavior, feed his own outrage to heighten the satisfaction of revenge, and identify targets (he secretly warns one decent suitor to leave, but the suitor ignores it and dies).

The Death of Argos and Interactions inside the Palace

  • Recognition by Argos (Book 17):

    • Location: Outside the palace gates, lying directly upon a large pile of mule and cow dung stored for field fertilizer.

    • History: Argos was trained by Odysseus as a puppy 20 years prior. Now old, neglected, and covered in fleas and flies.

    • The Moment: Senses Odysseus, wags his tail, drops his ears, but lacks the strength to move toward him. Dies immediately after seeing Odysseus.

    • Significance: Represents the first voluntary recognition of Odysseus on Ithaca, occurring without prompting or disclosure.

  • Three Sources of Knowledge:

    1. Direct Sensory Observation: Personal presence in the situation.

    2. Kleos: Reputation and stories passed down across distance and time.

    3. Divine Prophecy: Direct knowledge provided by the gods. The suitors are unified by their inability to receive or respect divine prophecy.

  • Confrontation with Antinous (Book 17):

    • Antinous's Name Meaning: Anti-nous ("anti-mind" or "against mind").

    • Odysseus begs at the banquet tables, telling Antinous he looks like royalty and recounting a story of his own past wealth.

    • Antinous refuses to give food. Odysseus points out that Antinous will not even give a crumb of someone else's food.

    • Antinous hurls a heavy wooden stool at Odysseus; it strikes his back and bounces off without effect. He later throws another stool and a joint of meat (Odysseus dodges; the meat knocks a wine boy unconscious).

The Contest with Arnaeus (Irus) and Preparations for the Holy Feast

  • The Fight with Irus (Book 18):

    • Arnaeus / Irus (Eros): Ithaca's resident beggar—young, fat, weak, greedy, and abusive.

    • Suitors organize a "bum fight" between Irus and the disguised Odysseus for entertainment (analogous to modern video trends where wealthy students pay homeless individuals to fight).

    • Girding Up: Odysseus prepares for combat by "girding up" his tunic (pulling up the hem and sleeves with a cord belt to knee/miniskirt length for free movement, a standard ancient practice seen also in Japanese samurai films).

    • Revealed Form: Girding up reveals massive thighs, broad shoulders, a giant chest, and muscular arms.

    • Antinous's Threat to Irus: If Irus loses, he will be shipped to King Echetus (Achaetus) on the mainland—a lord of cruelty—to have his nose, ears, and genitals mutilated and fed raw to dogs.

    • The Outcome: Irus strikes Odysseus's shoulder. Odysseus delivers a single punch to Irus's neck below the ear, fracturing his neck/jaw. Irus vomits blood, flails in convulsions, and collapses.

    • Odysseus drags Irus by his foot across the gateway and props his paralyzed body against the courtyard wall. Irus remains paralyzed outside for two days until he dies.

  • The Sacred Festival (Book 20):

    • Context: A major religious holiday—the feast of Apollo Noumenios (Apollo of the New Moon / Lord of Archery).

    • Timing: Winter solstice period, dark of the moon right before the new crescent light.

    • Sacrifice: A hecatomb (100 cattle driven through town for slaughter and a town-wide feast). The gods consume the blood, life force, and smoke, while the populace eats the meat.

Penelope and the Beggar: The Shroud and the Brooch

  • Penelope's Audience (Book 19):

    • Penelope summons the beggar to her private suite after learning of his mistreatment by the suitors.

    • Odysseus presents himself as a "man of sorrow" and requests that she not ask for his lineage to avoid stirring painful memories.

    • Penelope reveals her trick of the shroud:

      • Promised to choose a suitor once she completed a burial shroud for Laertes (Odysseus's father).

      • Wove the shroud by day and unwove it by torchlight at night for 3 years.

      • Discovered in the 4th year due to betrayal by maidservants.

      • Now out of schemes, facing intense pressure from her parents to remarry, while Telemachus demands an end to the consumption of his estate.

  • The Token of Identity:

    • The beggar claims to have hosted Odysseus in the past.

    • Describes Odysseus's exact attire: A double-folded purple wool cloak fastened with a double-pinned gold brooch.

    • Brooch Engraving: A dog holding down a struggling dappled fawn in its front paws.

    • Symbolic Significance: The brooch depicts animal predation, symbolizing Odysseus's identity as a hunter and predator.

  • The Prophecy to Penelope:

    • Odysseus ignores Eumaeus's advice against telling tales of return.

    • Predicts directly to Penelope: Odysseus is safe, nearby, and will return "this very lunar month, between the waning and the waxing moon."