9/1: Week 2 Personal Reading Notes

Prolong:

Diamond says new guinea people might be more Intelligent bc of survival of the fittest/natural selection

  • New Guinea ppl had constant war and other harsher environments than Europeans which made those more intelligent more likely to survive

  • Says this to debunk the thought that inherited intelligence leads to faster development.


Diamond seems very quick to point out what other historians are missing as if he is the all knowing when comes to the answer of yalis question

  • he says an author wanting to answer this question would need to be an expert in many fields, which he believes he is

  • However he does says this book is not the ‘answer’, it provides a large part of the answer: “At best, this book identifies several

constellations of environmental factors that I believe provide a large of the answer to Yali's question.”


Diamond says everyone conquest of another people seem to be lopsided meaning their must be a reason why, not just by chance


Mainly believes ppls environments factors lead to the differences between the ppl, not inheritable things


Diamond is trying to identify the ultimate causes that lead to the difference in speed of development between Europe and the rest of the world.


Problems of women:

Reflect the broader global historical trend of modernization, where traditional domestic roles were re-evaluated as political and national issues, and women’s liberation became a central component of a country’s attempt to assert itself in a Western-dominated world order.


Advice to merchants:

A writing detailing advice to merchants in Europe (maybe italy) to china trying the travel specific routes and how to navigate safely and try trade efficient in the places along the routes. Showed one place using paper money as a form of trade while others didn’t.


Big picture: vast differences in culture, economic structure, political order, and safety between the cities/towns and general areas.

  • CONNECTION: This diversity in a small area (europe to china) shows less unity in the area, and as pointed out in later chaps of diamonds book (mentioned in class on Monday 8/31) more diversity = more competition = higher overall development. And this was present in Europe which potentially made them develop faster overall