Surveillance and the Digital Panopticon
National Security Collection (Google, Microsoft, Apple - PRISM)
Course Paper Feedback
- Congratulations on good course paper scores (85-92 average).
- Absences or incomplete prompts lowered some section averages.
- Course rewards critical thinking and connecting course material, not just regurgitating content from online chats.
- Use lectures, slides, and discussions as the base for writing, proofreading, and outlining.
Watchtowers and Surveillance
- Common element across historical watchtowers: a single directional view (binoculars, camera).
- Watchtowers represent the oldest surveillance technology.
- Design Affordance: fewer guards watching more inmates. Goals are to reduce number of guards and maximize number of inmates watched.
- Economic design that saves money.
- Prisoners are constantly aware of guard presence, but can't see the guards (asymmetrical).
- Constant surveillance leads to self-control and internalized observation, even when not watched.
Panopticon and Disciplining Power
- Michel Foucault's idea of panopticon as a form of disciplining power.
- Ideology that surveillance is necessary and good.
- Acceptance of slavery as better than death or subjugation.
- Prisoners internalize being watched as better than being killed outside of prison.
- Society is metaphorically a large prison system with rules, regulations, and hierarchies.
- Observation occurs via social media and government.
- Questioning the impact on liberty, freedom, human rights, and privacy.
- Voluntary contribution to digital platforms creates a digital panopticon.
- Unchallenged acceptance leads to a dominant ideology or "-ism."
- Most people have internalized social media as necessary.
Digital Panopticon Infrastructure
- Computers in phones, watches, etc.
- Internet companies aggregating massive data (browsers, social media, emails, IP addresses).
- Agencies like CIA, FBI, and NSA involved.
- Terms and conditions of online tools lead users to internalize constant observation and voluntary data sharing.
- Documentary "Terms and Conditions May Apply" recommended.
- Trailer Quote: Google potentially a 500 per year service in data value.
- Companies possess approximately 1,500 data points on average American citizen.
- Easy to find specific personal details (voting, psychological problems, etc.).
- Government accessing data from Google/Facebook is easier than direct wiretapping.
- Concerns about automated systems flagging based on search terms.
- Surveillance used to silence protests.
Surveillance Capitalism and Network Effect
- Theoretical foundation for data gathering and selling.
- Capitalism based on surveillance.
- Tactics:
- Cookies: track browser movement
- Device tracking: GPS and calibration technologies reveal device location (next to bed, in pocket).
Data Mining and Algorithms
- Data mining algorithms sort credit cards, smart home devices, and other sources.
- Example: Algorithms decide credit worthiness based on data patterns.
Data Usage and Implications
- Algorithms make decisions on credit card applications, impacting rejection or credit limit.
- Job applications can be influenced by surveillance data.
- Companies want more data to enhance AI capabilities for various purposes.
- Example: professor's data can be used against somebody else.
- predict and contain a threat before it goes to panel
Military Origin of Internet
- Internet's creation traced to a military project (similar to AI).
- DARPA funded ARPANET.
- Launched in the 1950s for long distance communication.
- Strategic orbital weapon system development.
- 1972: First creation of nodes, largely built by university engineering.
- Rapid growth in networks and messaging protocols.
Internet Evolution
- Public enterprises (universities, laboratories) contributing to the Internet.
- Internet composed of 12,000 individual computer networks.
- Started in 1969 as a Pentagon tool.
- Scientists can share knowledge with another scientist at lightning speed.
Internet Infrastructure
- Seattle: International gateway for sea cables to the Pacific Ocean.
- Satellite communication is popular.
Google as Surveillance Capitalism Example
- Google embodies surveillance capitalism, network effect, and military-industrial complex.
- Expands beyond online ads (mobile, robotics, weather).
- Acquisition of Motorola Mobility and use of obsolete satellites.
- Facebook's acquisition of Instagram.
Military-Industrial Complex
- Close alliance between governments, military institutions, and defense contractors to manufacture and acquire weapons.
- Companies like Lockheed Martin and Boeing involved.
- Creating digital hapticon apparatus.
Geopolitical Discourses
- U.S. presents China as a surveillance state.
- U.S. uses information for geopolitical advantage against other countries like Russia.
- Metadata connects all information in a digital tower or PRISM program.
- Example: Metadata leads to deportation. Daughter's boyfriend's mother's visa expired.
CIA Tactics
- CIA targets depressed individuals.
- Accessing information without court orders via Facebook's backdoor using XT score's under 702 authority.
- FISA court orders seen as rubber stamps.
- Metadata is crucial for identifying similarities.
PRISM Project
- Code name for NSA and FBI program to collect private electronic data from major internet services.
- Tools used for microtargeting, suspicion, and surveillence.
- Occurred without user consent.
GCHQ and Hacking
- GCHQ (Government Communications Headquarters) can hack into personal data on smartphones (computer network exploitation or CNE).
- Program code named Smurfs:
- Dreamy Smurf: Turns phone on/off.
- Nosy Smurf: Hot mic tool.
- Tracker Smurf: Geolocation tool.
Legal Framework
- PRISM dependent on FISA.
- Lists of companies recruited and dates.
Privacy Concerns
- Social media and surveillance tools impact privacy.
- Privacy ratings (Electronic Frontier Foundation): Apple has high security, Facebook and Twitter have low security because they are vulnerable to legal requests.
- If a service is free, the user is the product.
- Fundamental individual right to determine what information is shared.
- Privacy pragmatists trade privacy for benefits.
Privacy and Personal Stance
- Consider personal stance on privacy and reasons for that view.
- Privacy is a common right, but why might it be given up?