Study Notes: United States Civil War - Causes, Course, and Effects 1840-77

The Success and Failure of the ‘Great Experiment’ (Pre-1861)

  • General Prosperity and Growth
        * By 1860, the USA had expanded from the original 13 states to 33, reaching from the Atlantic to the Pacific.
        * The population grew from 17 million in 1840 to 31 million in 1860; white Americans enjoyed the world's highest standard of living.
        * Gross national product increased seven-fold between 1800 and 1850.

  • Technological and Social Transitions
        * Transport: Railway track increased from 3,000 miles in 1840 to 30,000 miles in 1860.
        * Urbanisation: One in five Americans lived in towns by 1860, up from one in ten in 1820.
        * The American Dream: Alexis de Tocqueville noted the lack of a feudal hierarchy, offering social mobility, though wealth inequality remained high (top 5% owned 53% of wealth).
        * The Cult of Domesticity: Women were designated as home-makers, lacking voting and property rights in many states, though they often spearheaded reform movements like temperance.

  • The Failure of the Experiment
        * Native Americans lost massive amounts of land during western expansion.
        * Slavery remained the Great Anomaly, contradicting the Declaration of Independence's claim that "all men are created equal."

The Peculiar Institution: Slavery and the Cotton Economy

  • The Rise of King Cotton
        * Cotton production rose from 9,000 bales in 1790 to 2 million annually by the 1830s after the invention of Eli Whitney's cotton gin (1793).
        * By 1815–1860, cotton accounted for over 50% of all US exports.
        * Slavery became entrenched as a system of social control and economic necessity, particularly through the "gang labour" system on plantations.

  • Demographics of Slavery in 1860
        * 4 million slaves resided in the 15 Southern states; one in four white Southern families were slave owners.
        * 55% of slaves worked in cotton; 50% of slaves lived on plantations with 20 or more slaves.
        * Slave Codes defined slaves as property and restricted movement and weapons.

  • The Great Debate: Paternalism vs. Ruthless Exploitation
        * Benign View (Phillips, Fogel, Engerman): Argued slaves were well-fed and housed compared to industrial workers; noted rare floggings due to the master's vested interest in their "property."
        * Harsh View (Stampp): Stressed that owners held absolute power, ensuring constant insecurity; a quarter of slave marriages were broken by forced sale; education for slaves was illegal.

The Origins of the Civil War: Sectionalism and States' Rights

  • Economic Sectionalism
        * North: Industrializing, urbanized, and ethnically diverse (one in six foreign-born); held a majority of the nation's railway track and manufactured output.
        * South: Agrarian, rural, and less ethnically diverse; felt exploited by Northern tariffs and credit systems.

  • The Doctrine of States' Rights
        * Rooted in the Tenth Amendment, which limited federal power to specific constitutional lists.
        * The Nullification Crisis (1828–1833): John C. Calhoun argued that states could nullify unconstitutional federal laws (specifically the "Tariff of Abominations"). President Jackson threatened force, asserting the Union was perpetual, leading to a compromise tariff.

  • Profitability of Slavery
        * Debate persists whether slavery was a burden to the South's growth (Hinton Rowan Helper) or a highly efficient, profitable business model (Fogel & Engerman).

The Abolitionist Debate and Western Expansion

  • The Rise of Militant Abolitionism
        * William Lloyd Garrison launched The Liberator in 1831, demanding immediate abolition without compensation.
        * The American Anti-Slavery Society (AAS) grew to 250,000 members by 1838.
        * Southern response: Developed an intellectual defense of slavery as a "positive good" and banned anti-slavery literature.

  • Western Expansion and the Missouri Compromise (1820)
        * Maine joined as a free state, Missouri as a slave state.
        * Land north of latitude 36∘30′36^\circ 30' in the Louisiana Purchase was to remain free.

  • Texas and the Mexican War (1846–1848)
        * President Polk provoked war to gain California and New Mexico.
        * The Wilmot Proviso (1846) attempted to ban slavery in all territory gained from Mexico, outraging Southerners.
        * Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo (1848): US paid $15 million for California, New Mexico, Nevada, Utah, and Arizona.

  • The Compromise of 1850
        * Provisions included: California admitted as a free state; Fugitive Slave Act strengthened; Slave trade abolished in DC.
        * Historian David Potter called it an "armistice" rather than a solution.

The Coming of War (1854–1861)

  • Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854)
        * Introduced by Stephen Douglas, it repealed the Missouri Compromise and replaced it with "popular sovereignty."
        * Led to the collapse of the Whig Party and the rise of the Republican Party.

  • "Bleeding Kansas" and "Bleeding Sumner"
        * Civil war in Kansas territory between pro-slavery and free-state settlers.
        * John Brown murdered five pro-slavery settlers at Pottawatomie Creek.
        * Congressman Preston Brooks caned Senator Charles Sumner on the Senate floor.

  • The Dred Scott Decision (1857)
        * Supreme Court ruled that blacks were not citizens and Congress had no right to ban slavery in territories.

  • The 1860 Election and Secession
        * Abraham Lincoln won with 40% of the vote but carried no Southern states.
        * South Carolina seceded in December 1860, followed by six more lower South states by February 1861.
        * First shots fired at Fort Sumter on April 12, 1861; subsequently, Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina, and Tennessee joined the Confederacy.

Union versus Confederacy: Conducting the War

  • Comparative Strengths
        * Union: 22 million people, 90% of industrial output, superior navy.
        * Confederacy: 750,000 square miles of territory, defending "interior lines," psychological advantage of defending home soil.

  • Evolution of Warfare
        * The rifle-musket (accurate at 600 yards) gave defenders an immense advantage, leading to trench warfare by 1864.
        * The Civil War is often called the "first modern war" due to use of railways, telegraphs, and ironclads.

  • War Finance
        * Union: Raised money through Internal Revenue Act (1862) and "greenback" paper money.
        * Confederacy: Suffered 5,000% inflation by 1865 due to overprinting of currency.

  • Military Leadership
        * Robert E. Lee: Exploited aggressive "offensive-defensive" strategies; won brilliant tactical victories at Chancellorsville but suffered heavy losses at Gettysburg.
        * Ulysses S. Grant: Implemented a strategy of "simultaneous movement," utilizing the North's manpower advantage through a war of attrition.

The Road to Union Victory (1863–1865)

  • The Turning Points
        * Antietam (Sept 1862): Bloodiest single-day battle; gave Lincoln the political capital to issue the Emancipation Proclamation.
        * Gettysburg (July 1863): Stopped Lee's invasion of the North.
        * Vicksburg (July 1863): Grant captured the Mississippi River, cutting the Confederacy in two.

  • The End of the War
        * Sherman's March (1864): Marched through Georgia and South Carolina, inflicting $100 million in damage.
        * Appomattox (April 10, 1865): Lee surrendered to Grant, effectively ending the war.
        * Casualties: Approx. 620,000 deaths (more than all other US wars combined).

Reconstruction (1865–1877)

  • Emancipation and Amendments
        * Thirteenth Amendment (1865): Ended slavery.
        * Fourteenth Amendment (1868): Guaranteed citizenship and equal protection.
        * Fifteenth Amendment (1870): Banned racial discrimination in voting.

  • Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction
        * Andrew Johnson: Favored leniency and white supremacy; was impeached by radical Republicans but survived by one vote.
        * Military Reconstruction Act (1867): Divided the South into five military districts.

  • Redemption and Failure
        * The Ku Klux Klan: Used terrorism to restore white Democrat rule.
        * Sharecropping: Replaced slavery as an exploitative economic relationship, leaving many blacks in permanent debt.
        * Compromise of 1877: Republicans agreed to withdraw federal troopsfrom the South in exchange for Hayes's presidency, ending Reconstruction.

  • The Jim Crow South (Post-1877)
        * Supreme Court decisions like Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) established the "separate but equal" doctrine.
        * Disfranchisement through poll taxes and literacy tests reduced registered black voters in Louisiana from 130,000 in 1896 to 5,000 in 1900.