Ch 1 Five Principles of Politics
AMERICAN GOVERNMENT: POWER & PURPOSE - Chapter 01
The Complexity of American Government is No Accident
The division of power among institutions was intended to:
Allow competing interests access to power.
Prevent any one group from monopolizing power.
Resulting complexity within the American framework is equated with liberty and political opportunity.
However, this complexity creates challenges for citizen participation:
Questions arise about who the relevant decision maker is and what type of participation works.
rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
How Do We Study Politics?
Empirical: What facts and patterns do we observe?
Example: Observational studies to assess voting behavior.
Analytical: Why?
This requires constructing a theory to explain observed phenomena.
Example: Analyses that predict electoral outcomes based on demographics.
Normative: What "should" be?
Example: Ethical discussions about voter representation.
What is Government?
Definition: Government is the institutions through which a land and its people are ruled.
Simple Example: A neighborhood council that meets occasionally.
Complex Example: The U.S. system of separations of powers across different branches and levels of government:
Branches: Legislative, Executive, Judicial.
Key Positions:
Legislative: Senate, House of Representatives
Executive: President, Vice President, Cabinet
Judicial: Supreme Court, Other Federal Courts.
Hypothetical: Building Government in a Dorm
Scenario: Assume everyone in the room is a citizen of a self-contained dorm room society:
Proposal: Building a communal kitchen.
Key Questions:
How decisions will be made?
How will these decisions be enforced?
Forms of Government: Who Governs?
Autocracy: One single individual rules.
Oligarchy: A small group of people controls most of the governing decisions.
Democracy: A system that permits citizens to play a significant part in government.
Forms of Government: How Much Do They Control?
Constitutional: Specific legal limits on government powers.
Authoritarian: No legal limits on government but can be checked by social institutions.
Totalitarian: No formal or effective limits on government power.
Test Our Understanding
Hypothetical society where a king has total power but is constrained by church decisions:
Type of government? Consider both who governs and how much control they exert.
Politics
Definition: Politics involves conflict and cooperation over leadership, structure, and policies of government, or more fundamentally, over who governs and who has power.
Key Questions in Politics:
Who gets what? When? And how?
Forms of Political Participation:
Voting, Running for office, Joining parties, Speaking to friends and neighbors.
Five Principles of Politics
Rationality Principle: All political behavior has a purpose.
Institution Principle: Institutions structure politics.
Collective Action Principle: All politics is collective action.
Policy Principle: Political outcomes arise from individual preferences, institutional procedures, and collective action.
History Principle: How we got here matters.
The Rationality Principle: All Political Behavior Has a Purpose
Political behavior is instrumental:
Characteristics:
Purposeful, not random or automatic.
Usually done with forethought and calculated.
Common political goals may include:
Pursuing specific policies, winning reelection, gaining power, improving personal circumstances.
Test Our Understanding
Examples of Rationality Principle in Action:
A. Voting for a favored candidate.
B. Legislator blocking a bill affecting constituents.
C. Candidate clarifying environmental positions on television.
D. All of the above (Correct).
The Institution Principle: Institutions Structure Politics
Definition: Institutions are the rules and procedures that provide incentives for political behavior, thereby shaping politics and governance.
Institutions are not permanently fixed, but:
Changes to institutions are hard to achieve.
Institutions in Action: Term Limits
Term Limits: Determine how long an official can serve.
Specific applications include:
U.S. Presidents, Governors in certain states.
Questions to Consider:
What are the positive and negative effects of term limits?
What does political science literature suggest about term limits?
The Institution Principle
Institutions confer authority through several means:
Jurisdiction.
Agenda power.
Veto power.
Decisiveness.
Delegation.
Jurisdiction
Definition: The domain over which an institution or its member has authority.
Examples include:
Congressional committees controlling specific policy areas.
Executive agencies (e.g., limits on states creating their own currency).
Agenda and Veto Power
Agenda Power: Control over what a group will consider for discussion (e.g., Congressional committees exercising gatekeeping).
Veto Power: The ability to block decisions (e.g., the president vetoing a bill).
Decisiveness
Decisiveness Rules: These include rules for decision-making, such as when and in what order votes are taken.
Examples:
Motions in the House (e.g., motion to adjourn, motion on the previous question).
Requirements for ending debate in the Senate (e.g., 60 votes required).
Delegation
Definition: The process of transmitting authority to another official or body.
Delegation and the Principal-Agent Problem
Principal-Agent Relationship: The dynamic between an authority holder (principal, e.g., citizen) and the delegate (agent, e.g., elected official).
Challenges within this relationship stem from:
Lack of complete control by the principal over the agent.
Examples: Personal instances of hiring or reliance on others for tasks.
Transaction Costs
Definition: The costs associated with determining aspects of the principal-agent relationship and monitoring compliance with agreements.
The Collective Action Principle: All Politics is Collective Action
Overview: Collective action can be challenging due to:
More participants potentially complicating coordination.
Collective Action Dilemmas: Situations where individual incentives do not align with collective interests.
Solutions to overcome these dilemmas include:
Bargaining.
Shared incentives.
Bargaining
Informal Bargaining: Occurs in everyday situations with low stakes.
Examples: Negotiating among friends.
Formal Bargaining: Involves complex issues governed by established rules.
Examples: Labor negotiations.
Collective Dilemmas and Bargaining Failures
Even if mutual gain exists, tensions can arise as rational incentives may compel parties to defect from agreements.
A Collective Dilemma / Prisoner's Dilemma
Definition: A situation in decision analysis where two individuals pursuing self-interest do not achieve the optimal outcome.
A Collective Dilemma Example
The paradigm of two individuals deciding whether to mend a communal fence:
Choices and consequences depicted in a payoff matrix.
Collective Action and Public Goods
Collective Action: The coordination of efforts and pooling of resources by a group to achieve common goals.
Public Goods: Benefits available to anyone once provided and not easily withheld from anyone.
Examples: Public parks, clean air.
Barriers to Collective Action
Free Riding: Benefiting from resources without contributing.
Tragedy of the Commons: Overuse of a shared resource leading to depletion.
Solution: Institutions can mitigate these issues.
The Policy Principle
Definition: Political outcomes stem from a combination of individual preferences, institutional procedures, and collective action.
This principle integrates the first three principles, suggesting:
Individual preferences (rationality principle) shaped through institutional frameworks (institution principle) yield collective outcomes (collective action principle).
The Policy Principle
The intricate political system makes change often difficult:
Status quo tends to prevail due to resistance.
Policy outcomes frequently lack clarity due to the entanglement of personal ambition and decentralized governance.
The History Principle: How We Got Here Matters
Historical context is crucial for understanding current government and politics:
It outlines the choices political actors faced at pivotal moments and the resulting consequences.
Additionally, it contemplates alternative historical paths that could have been taken.
Path Dependency
Definition: Certain options become more or less probable due to previous decisions.
Importance of history in shaping political processes:
Rules and procedures.
Loyalties and alliances.
Historically conditioned viewpoints.
Conclusion: Preparing to Analyze American Politics
An analytical perspective on politics emphasizes both argumentation and evidence.
The Five Principles of Politics can be utilized to construct informed arguments about American politics, requiring solid evidentiary backing.
Analyzing the Evidence: Making Sense of Charts and Graphs
Step 1: Identify the purpose of the graph/chart:
Objectives? One variable or more?
Variables: Represent sets of possible values.
Descriptive Graph
Example: Party Identification in the United States, 2024.
Chart illustrates percentages of party affiliation (Democrat, Independent, Republican).
Graphs and Charts That Show Relationships
Analyzing relationships between two variables:
Importance of understanding how the change in one variable relates to the change in another.
Chart that Shows a Relationship
Example: Policy Priorities by Age Group.
Comparison of percentages indicating top government priorities across various age demographics.
Analyzing the Evidence: Evaluating Arguments
Step 2: Evaluate arguments based on evidence:
Consider the compelling nature of the argument.
Assess concerns about how the evidence is presented.
Assessing Graphs
Example: Median Household Income over Time (Charts A and B).
Importance of appropriate y-axis range to avoid distortion of data interpretation.
Causal Relationships vs. Correlations
Understanding if relationships depict cause and effect or mere correlation:
Correlation can result from a third influential variable.
Causal Relationship or Just Correlation?
Example: Number of letters in winning Scripps Spelling Bee word correlating with fatalities from venomous spiders.
Highlighting the distinction between correlation and causation.
Analyzing the Evidence: Considering the Source
Step 3: Evaluate the data source:
Clarity on what is measured? Are survey questions appropriately crafted?
Is data based on a well-chosen, representative sample?
Voter Registration Rates by Age, 2022
Source: U.S. Census Bureau report referencing voter registration data gathered during November 2022 elections,
Importance of checking methodologies for accuracy and reliability.