CH10

Chapter 10: Emotional Development

  • Module 10.1 Emerging Emotions

  • Module 10.2 Temperament

  • Module 10.3 Attachment

Module 10.1 Emerging Emotions

Topics:

  • The Function of Emotions

  • Experiencing and Expressing Emotions

  • Recognizing and Using Others' Emotions

  • Regulating Emotions

10.1 The Function of Emotions

Emotions are useful because they help people adapt to their environments:

  • Fear leads to avoiding dangerous situations

  • Happiness strengthens relationships

  • Disgust keeps people away from substances that make them ill (e.g., rancid food)

10.1 Experiencing and Expressing Emotions

Basic emotions are universal and consist of three elements:

  1. Subjective feeling

    • What we "feel" inside

  2. Physiological change

    • Heart rate, blood pressure, etc.

  3. Overt behaviour

    • Observable behaviours like facial expressions

The "Basic Emotions" or Primary emotions are:

  • Happiness

  • Anger

  • Surprise

  • Interest

  • Disgust

  • Sadness

  • Fear

Why are emotions important?
  • They are a way that children let other people know how they feel

  • They are a window into children's likes and dislikes and way to communicate their general views of the world

  • They are linked to children's social success

  • They are linked to children's mental and physical health

  • The purpose of emotions is to help people achieve their social and survival goals (e.g., joy of making new friends, fear and avoiding danger)

  • Emotions help children reach their goals

  • Emotional signals provide feedback that guides other people's behavior

  • Memories of past emotions shape how people respond to new situations

Timeline of Basic Emotions
  • Newborns experience only two general emotions:

    • Pleasure

    • Distress

  • At approx. 2-6 months, social smiles appear:

    • Social smiles emerge at 2 to 3 months of age and seem to express an infant's happiness at interacting with others

    • When infants smile at another person - a sign of happiness - emerges out of pleasure

    • Smiles more at familiar faces than unfamiliar ones

    • Smiles more when mother rather than unfamiliar other reinforces their smile

    • Duchenne smile - a smile reflecting genuine pleasure, shown in crinkles around the eyes as well as an upturned mouth reserved for caregivers

Joy: What makes babies laugh?
  • Auditory stimuli elicit few laughs at any age during infancy

  • Tactile stimuli elicit a substantial amount of laughter in infants 7 to 9 months old

  • Visual and social stimuli elicit more laughter overall and the likelihood of this laughter increases with age

  • Laughing continues to increase in frequency and becomes more social as children mature

Anger
  • At approx. 4 months, anger emerges out of distress

    • When a favourite toy is taken away

    • Set down for a nap

  • Newborns' first negative expressions are not anger, per se, but startle, disgust, and distress

  • Infants reliably display facial expressions of anger

  • Anger is elicited by pain and frustration

Fear
  • Two phases in the emergence of fear

    • From 3 to 6 months of age, infants develop wariness, which they exhibit when they encounter events they do not understand

    • From 6 to 9 months of age, infants begin to show genuine fear

  • At approx. 6-9 months, the reaction known as stranger wariness appears

    • The baby looks away and begins to fuss

    • Typical reaction to unfamiliar people

    • By six months of age, infants are wary of strangers and often become upset when they encounter people they don't know, particularly when strangers rush to greet or hold them.

  • Conditioning and Observation:

    • Children may also acquire fear through conditioning

    • E.g., when an adverse consequence, such as a painful fall, follows climbing up a high ladder

    • E.g., fear the doctor who gives a painful shot during their first office visit

    • Children learn still other fears simply by observing other people's reactions

  • Fear (recall the visual cliff)

    • The apparatus consists of a glass surface placed over a checkerboard base that is close to the glass on one side, the so-called shallow side, and some distance below it on the deep side. The infant is placed on the shallow side and encouraged to crawl across the deep side to reach the mother. At about 6-7 months of age, infants begin to refuse to crawl from the shallow side to the deep side-indicating that they see and fear the drop. Experience walking and perhaps falling contributes to the onset of this fear.

Reference Table: Stimuli Causing Fear Across Development

Age

Stimuli Causing Fear

0-1 year

Loss of support; loud noises; unexpected, looming objects; strangers; heights

1-2 years

Separation from parent; injury; strangers; baths (down the drain with the water)

2-3 years

Separation from parent; animals, especially large dogs; insects; darkness

3-6 years

Separation from parent; animals; darkness; strangers; bodily harm; imaginary beings such as monsters and ghosts; nightmares

6-10 years

Snakes; injury; darkness; being alone; burglars; new situations such as starting school

10-12 years

Negative evaluations by peers; school failure; thunderstorms; ridicule and embarrassment; injury; burglars; death

Adolescence

Peer rejection; school failure; breaking up; family issues such as divorce; war and other disasters; the future

Disgust
  • The least understood emotion

  • Infants respond negatively to unpleasant odours

Sadness
  • In infancy occurs less often than anger

  • Young infants become sad when parent-infant communication breaks down

  • In older infants, separation from the mother or other familiar caregiver for some period of time can lead to sadness

  • Sadness is a signal children can use to control their social partners

  • Sadness is an effective emotional signal for eliciting care and comfort from adults

Emergence of Complex, or Secondary Emotions

In addition to the basic emotions, people feel "complex" emotions such as: Pride, Shame, Guilt, Embarrassment, Jealousy, and Empathy.

  • These self-conscious emotions involve feelings of success when standards or expectations are met or feelings of failure when they are not met

  • Develop in the second year of life

  • These social or self-conscious emotions depend on children's abilities to be aware of, talk about, and think about themselves in relation to others

Self-Conscious Emotions Breakdown
  • Timeline & Requirements:

    • Emerge between 18-24 months

    • Dependent on the child's having some sense of self, which occurs at 15-18 months

  • Pride

    • For example, when completing a task by themselves for the first time, like building a tower out of blocks.

    • By 18-24 months of age, children experience pride in accomplishing a difficult task.

    • Pride is experienced with personal achievement in North America and Europe

  • Shame, Guilt, and Embarrassment

    • Elementary school age children start to experience more shame and guilt for example

    • Shame: Perception of deficiency

    • Guilt: For example, when they do something they should not have done

    • Embarrassment: For example, when asked to sit for a photograph - they might cover their eyes

  • Jealousy

    • Can occur as early as 1 year of age

    • Children express jealousy when their parent directs attention away from them toward another child, a newborn infant, or even a doll

    • Younger children show jealousy with expressions of distress, older children with anger and sadness

  • Empathy

    • A shared emotional response that parallels another person's feelings, especially distress

    • Development path of empathy in childhood and adolescence:

      • Young children experience empathy only in presence of distressed other

      • By mid to late childhood respond with empathy to another's general condition

      • Adolescents are able to respond to difficulties experienced by groups of people

Summary Table: Infants' Expression of Emotions
  • Basic

    • Defined: Experienced by people worldwide; include a subjective feeling, a physiological response, and an overt behaviour

    • Emerge: Birth to 9 months

    • Examples: Happiness, anger, fear

  • Complex (self-conscious)

    • Defined: Responses to meeting or failing to meet expectations or standards

    • Emerge: 18 to 24 months

    • Examples: Pride, guilt, embarrassment

10.1 Recognizing and Using Others' Emotions

  • By 4-6 months, infants can identify facial expressions associated with different emotions

  • Can distinguish a happy smiling face from a sad frowning face

  • Like adults, infants are biased toward negative emotions

    • They attend more rapidly to faces depicting negative emotions such as anger and pay attention to them longer than happy faces

  • Young infants can respond to emotions - e.g., become distressed if they see an angry or sad face

Social Referencing:
  • In unfamiliar or ambiguous environment, infants often look at their caregivers for cues to interpret the situation

  • If a 12-month sees a parent respond with fear to a certain toy, the child is less likely to play with the toy

  • If a 12-month sees a parent respond with disgust to a certain toy, but not another, the child is less likely to play with the toy that elicited disgust

  • By 14 months of age a child will remember this information for at least an hour

  • Therefore, infants use social referencing to direct their own behaviour

During elementary school, children understand:
  • Why people feel as they do

    • E.g., an undesirable event can make a person feel sad

  • There are impacts of emotions

    • Someone may do less well on a test if they are feeling sad or angry

  • That people can have mixed feelings. Some situations may lead people to be happy and sad at the same time

Display Rules

Children also learn display rules for their cultural context:

  • Specific standards for appropriate expression of emotion in a particular setting or with a particular person or persons.

  • Preschool children will restrain their anger when provoked by peers

  • School age children are more willing to express anger and sadness with parents than with peers

  • As children develop, they learn their culture's rules for expressing emotions, for example, many children living in North America might cry in private or with parents but would avoid crying in public, particularly with their peers.

Experiences that contribute to a child's understanding of emotions:
  • Parents and children often talk about past emotions and why people felt the way they did

    • Especially for fear and anger

  • Also, children overhear parents talk about emotions and how they are elicited by different situations (Bandura)

How is an understanding of emotions related to social interaction:
  • Children are more likely to help others because they are more likely to recognize an emotion that is related to a certain need

  • Better ability to play with others because they can see the impact of their behaviours on others

  • Related to empathy

10.1 Regulating Emotions

  • What is emotional regulation? How do we regulate our emotions?

    • E.g. Control our emotions when we are angry at someone, so we do not say something that we may regret later?

  • We routinely regulate/suppress/control our emotions:

    • Control joy, so we do not appear gloating

    • Control fear, out of embarrassment

    • Control anger, so we do not want to see that something has "gotten to us"

    • We use attention to divert to something else

    • We use executive functioning to find solutions and reappraise the event

  • Regulation of emotions begins in infancy and develops throughout childhood and adolescence

Regulation of emotions begins in infancy:
  • Infants of 4-6 months of age will look away when they encounter something frightening or confusing

  • Infants will also move closer to a parent for protection and comfort to help control their fear

  • By age 24 months, toddlers display sadness rather than fear or anger, as this is the most likely way to get adult support

Older children and adolescents develop a number of new ways to regulate emotions:
  • Children regulate their emotions by relying less on others and more on themselves.

    • E.g., not running to parents when scared of a loud noise

  • Children rely on mental strategies

    • E.g. Hide disappointment in not receiving a certain gift by telling themself that they did not really want it or need it

  • Children adjust their thoughts to regulate their emotions in specific situations

    • E.g., Dentist visit. Think of positive benefits

Not all children learn to regulate their emotions well:

Those that do not:

  • Tend to have difficulties with peer interactions

    • Specifically, difficulty in controlling anger, worry, or sadness can lead to difficulty in resolving conflicts with peers

    • Anger can lead to arguing which prevents finding a mutually agreed upon solution

  • Have difficulty adjusting to school

Module 10.2 Temperament

Topics:

  • What Is Temperament?

  • Hereditary and Environmental Contributions to Temperament

  • Stability of Temperament

  • Temperament and Other Aspects of Development

10.2 What Is Temperament?

  • Temperament: Behavioural styles that are fairly stable across situations and are biologically based

  • Often referred to as the infant's "personality"

  • E.g. All babies cry, but:

    • Some are easily consolable and others are not

    • Some "recover" quickly and others do not

    • Differences are due to temperament

  • The hereditary contribution to temperament is shown by the fact that twins are typically similar in their level of activity.

Thomas and Chess Patterns

Thomas and Chess identified 3 patterns: easy, difficult, and slow-to-warm-up. These are somewhat predictive of personality later on (revisited in stability of temperament).

  • "Easy" babies

    • Usually happy and cheerful

    • Adjust well to new situations

    • Easily adhere to routines of sleeping, eating and toileting

    • The most common type of baby

  • "Difficult" babies

    • Usually unhappy and not cheerful

    • Do not adjust well to new situations

    • Do not easily adhere to routines of sleeping, eating and toileting. Instead, they have irregular patterns

    • They are a less common group

  • "Slow to Warm up" babies

    • Often unhappy

    • Are not upset by new situations

    • Do not easily adhere to routines of sleeping, eating and toileting. Instead, they have irregular patterns

    • They are a less common group, as well

Mary K. Rothbart's Three Dimensions of Temperament

Moving away from classifying infants into categories, Mary Rothbart identified three underlying dimensions of temperament. Rothbart views temperament as the individual personality differences in infants and young children that are present prior to the development of higher cognitive and social aspects of personality (Rothbart and Hwang). In research with 3-12 month old children, three broad factors emerged (Garstein and Rothbart):

  1. Surgency/Extraversion

    • This factor reflects the degree to which a child is generally happy, active, and enjoys vocalizing and seeking stimulation (Kail).

    • Increased smiling and laughter is observed in babies high in surgency/extraversion. (Rothbart and Hwang).

    • Includes positive anticipation, impulsivity, increased levels of activity and desire for sensation seeking (Rothbart, Merril).

    • Higher levels of surgency/extraversion in 10-11 year olds are more likely to develop externalizing problems like acting out; however, they are less likely to develop internalizing problems like shyness and low self-esteem (Ormel et al, 2005 in Rothbart, 2007).

  2. Negative affect

    • This factor reflects the degree to which a child is shy and not easily calmed (Kail).

    • Includes fear, frustration, sadness and discomfort (Rothbart, Merril) and anger (Rothbart and Hwang).

    • Anger and frustration is seen as early as 2 to 3 months.

    • Anger and frustration, together predict externalizing and internalizing difficulties. Anger, alone, is later related to externalizing problems, while fear is associated with internalizing difficulties (Rothbart, 2007).

    • Fear as evidenced by behavioural inhibition is seen as early as 7-10 months and later predicts children's fearfulness and lower levels of aggression (Rothbart, 2007).

  3. Effortful Control

    • This factor reflects the degree to which a child can focus attention, and is not easily distracted (Kail).

    • Includes focusing and shifting of attention, inhibitory control of responses, perceptual sensitivity, and low threshold for pleasure (Rothbart, Merril).

    • When high in effortful control, six to seven year olds tend to be more empathetic and lower in aggressiveness (Rothbart Merril).

    • Higher levels of effortful control at age seven also predict lower externalizing problems at age 11 (Valiente et al, 2003 in Merril).

    • Children high on negative affect show decreased internalizing and externalizing problems when they are also high on effortful control (Rothbart, 2007).

    • Rothbart suggests that effortful control is dependent on the development of executive attention skills in the early years. In turn, executive attention skills allow greater self-control over reactive tendencies.

    • Effortful control shows stability from infancy into the school years and also predicts conscientiousness (Kochanska, Murray and Harlan, 2000 in Rothbart, 2007).

Parent-Child Interaction and Temperament
  • Children's development proceeds best when there is a good fit between the temperament and the environment in which they develop and grow.

  • Parents should adjust their parenting to adjust to the temperament and needs of the child.

  • For example: Quiet and shy babies: Parents can present active stimulation.

10.2 Hereditary and Environmental Contributions to Temperament

  • Heredity: Twin studies and genetic research show heredity influence: identical twins more alike in most aspects of temperament than non-identical twins. If one identical twin is more active, the other one will usually be too.

  • Environment: Environmental influences contribute to positive emotional development. Environment that promotes laughing, happiness, expressing pleasure.

    • When parents are more responsive (soothing/nurturing), infants are less emotional.

    • Conversely, infants are more likely to develop intense, difficult temperaments when primary caregiver is abrupt.

  • Cultural Influences: Japanese and Chinese children are less likely to become upset in stressful situations:

    • Babies of European ancestry in Canada cry when they receive an injection for inoculation at 4 months.

    • However, crying is not a universal response; half of the Japanese and Chinese babies cried.

    • When Japanese and Chinese babies are upset, they are soothed more readily by their parents, which may reduce the tendency to respond emotionally.

    • Might also be genetic influences, but experience may be involved.

10.2 Stability of Temperament

  • Temperament is modestly stable through infancy, childhood, and adolescence.

    • Fearful preschoolers tend to be inhibited as older child and adolescent.

    • Shy, inhibited children are more likely to be introverted adults.

  • However, these are tendencies and not "guarantees".

  • In many ways temperament resembles personality and somewhat predicts aspects of personality (however, especially infant and young children's "personality" is referred to as "temperament").

  • Research also reveals many instances where temperament is not related to adult personality.

  • Temperament can change depending on their experiences as the children develop.

10.2 Temperament and Other Aspects of Development

Various aspects of temperament are related to factors such as: school success, peer interactions, compliance with parents, depression, and helping others in distress.

  • Two-thirds of preschoolers with difficult temperaments had developed behavioural problems by the time they entered school.

  • Fewer than one-fifth with easy temperaments had developed behavioural problems by the time they entered school.

  • Specifically, angering easily and little control are related to later behavioural problems.

  • Parenting styles that provide warmth, support and respect of autonomy help children with difficult temperaments.

  • Persistent children are more likely to succeed in school, whereas active and distractable children are less likely to succeed.

  • Children who are frequently angry or fearful are more prone to depression.

  • 3 and 4-year olds who have greater effortful control have higher scores on working memory and also are less likely to be diagnosed with ADHD once in school.

  • Shy, inhibited children more often have difficulty in interacting with peers.

  • Children who are uninhibited and lack self-regulation are prone to alcohol, drug and gambling issues as adults.

Resisting Control
  • Resisting control = children who are difficult to manage, are unresponsive, more impulsive.

  • Children who resist control tend to be more aggressive (a behavioural problem) when they are older.

  • Resistant temperament leads to behavioural problems when parents do not exert much control over their children.

  • When parents exert control - prohibit, warn, scold - resistant temperament is not linked to behavioural problems. This shows the importance of environmental influence.

Life Stressors
  • Children with 'positive' temperaments are less affected by life stressors and consequently are less likely to smoke, drink, or use drugs.

  • Life stressors include: a family member has a serious illness or accident, a parent losing a job, parental-child conflict.

Odds Ratio of Self-Control Outcomes

Odds ratio of self-control in the 30th vs 70th percentile in childhood (ages 3-11 years) predicting adolescent and adulthood outcomes:

  • Adolescence Outcomes (Relative Likelihood):

    • Smoked (~1.7)

    • Dropped out of school (~1.6)

    • Teenage parent (~1.1)

  • Adulthood Outcomes (Relative Likelihood):

    • Health-related problems (~1.5)

    • Substance abuse (~1.4)

    • Criminal conviction (~1.6)

Module 10.3 Attachment

Topics:

  • The Growth of Attachment

  • The Quality of Attachment

10.3 The Growth of Attachment

  • Attachment: A theory proposed by John Bowlby. An enduring social-emotional relationship between infant and parent.

  • This person is often the mother, but can be another person such as the father or grandmother or grandfather.

  • The key is a strong emotional relationship with a responsive, caring person.

  • When an infant has formed an attachment with a caregiver, that person becomes a secure, stable emotional base for the infant.

John Bowlby's Four Stages of Attachment:
  1. Preattachment (birth to 6-8 weeks)

    • After birth, infants recognize their mother's smell and sound which helps set the stage to form an attachment relationship.

    • Caregivers returning a smile when the baby smiles is part of the interactions that are the first step in attachment formation.

  2. Attachment in the Making (6-8 weeks to 6-8 months)

    • Babies start to behave differently in the presence of adult caregivers.

    • Babies smile and laugh more often with the primary caregiver.

    • Babies begin to identify the primary caregiver as the person they can depend on when they are anxious or distressed.

  3. True Attachment (6-8 months to 18 months)

    • Most infants have identified/singled out the attachment figure as a special person.

    • The attachment figure is now the infant's stable socio-emotional base.

    • For example, a 7-month old will explore a new environment, but periodically look toward their caregiver (attachment figure), as if seeking assurance that all is well.

    • At this stage, trust is established.

    • The infant has a mental representation of the primary caregiver(s) - in terms of an understanding that they will meet the infant's needs.

    • Sometimes an infant will cry when separated from their attachment figure - it is because they lose their secure base.

  4. Reciprocal Relationships (18 months +)

    • The infant's growing cognitive and language skills, plus their experience with the attachment figure, make infants better able to act as true partners in the attachment relationship.

    • For example, they take initiative in the interactions with parents (e.g., Ask to read a story).

    • They begin to understand their caregivers' feelings and goals and use this knowledge to guide their own behaviours.

    • They cope with separation because they anticipate that the caregiver will return.

The Role of Fathers
  • Attachment usually forms between infants and mothers because mothers are usually the primary caregiver in NA.

  • However, infants soon become attached to fathers as well.

  • Fathers care is just as high quality.

  • Fathers typically spend more time playing with babies and infants, but the type of play is different:

    • Fathers often engage in more physical play; while mothers spend more time with toys, games, reading.

    • Infants more often choose to play with fathers over their mothers.

  • When infants are distressed, infants prefer their mothers.

10.3 The Quality of Attachment

Results of the Ainsworth test show one of four different types of attachment: Secure Attachment or one of three Insecure Attachment Styles (Avoidant, Ambivalent, Disorganized). Infants with a resistant attachment are upset or angry with Mom when they're reunited with her following a separation.

  • Secure Attachment

    • The baby may or may not cry when the parent leaves, but when the parent returns the baby wants to be with them.

    • If the baby cries when the parent leaves, the baby stops crying on their return.

    • 60-65% of children have this type.

  • Insecure Avoidant

    • Not upset when parent leaves, ignores parent on return.

    • Internal monologue: "Left again"; "I can look after myself".

    • 20% of children have this type.

  • Insecure Ambivalent (Anxious / Resistant) Attachment

    • Baby is upset when parent leaves, and is upset or angry when the parent returns.

    • Hard to console.

    • 10-15% of children have this type.

    • Often due to inconsistent parenting.

  • Disorganized (disoriented) Attachment

    • The baby appears confused when parent leaves, still confused on return.

    • Seems to not understand what is going on.

    • 5-10% of children have this type.

Ainsworth's Strange Situation task
  • Determines the type of attachment.

  • Involves a series of situations; each takes a few minutes.

  • The mother and infant enter an unfamiliar room with toys.

  • The mother leaves the room.

  • The experimenter observes the baby to record the responses.

Figure 10-1 Steps in the "Strange Situation"
  1. Experimenter shows the experimental room to mother and infant, then leaves the room.

  2. Infant is allowed to explore the playroom for 3 minutes; mother watches but does not participate.

  3. A stranger enters the room and remains silent for 1 minute, then talks to the baby for a minute, and then approaches the baby.

  4. Mother leaves unobtrusively. The stranger does not play with the baby but attempts to comfort it if necessary.

  5. After 3 minutes, the mother returns, greets, and consoles the baby.

  6. When the baby has returned to play, the mother leaves again, this time saying "bye-bye" as she leaves.

  7. Stranger attempts to calm and play with the baby.

  8. After 3 minutes, the mother returns and the stranger leaves.

Consequences of Attachment

Quality of attachment during infancy predicts parent-child relations during childhood, adolescence and young adulthood:

  • Infants with secure attachment, as adolescents report depending on parents for care and support.

  • Infants with insecure attachment, as adolescents report being angry with parents and deny being close to them.

  • Attachment is the first social relationship and provides the basis for later social relationships.

  • Infants who experience trust and compassion of an early secure relationship are more likely to develop into preschool children who interact confidently and successfully with peers.

Secure Attachment Consequences:
  • Children with higher quality friends and fewer conflicts among friends.

  • More stable and higher quality romantic relationships in adolescence.

  • Promotes trust and confidence in other people.

  • Secure attachment leads to positive social relationships, due to the establishment of trust.

  • Predictable, responsive parenting is necessary for secure attachment.

  • A secure attachment is more likely to develop when predictable, responsive parenting is present.

  • Develops trust and ability to trust and depend on other people.

  • Needed for satisfying adult relationships.

  • A key ingredient in creating a secure mother-infant attachment is for the mother to respond appropriately and predictably to her infant's needs.

Disorganized / Insecure Attachment Consequences:
  • In the school years: Anxiety, Anger, Aggression.

Internal Working Model

Infants develop an internal working model:

  • A set of expectations about caregivers' availability and responsiveness generally, and in times of stress as well.

  • Infant needs a consistent internal working model for secure attachment.

  • Infants need to know if parents can be trusted and relied upon for comfort:

    • Some parents can be trusted and relied upon for comfort.

    • Some parents cannot be trusted and relied upon for comfort.

    • Some parents inconsistently can be trusted and relied upon for comfort.

    • E.g., some parents take a long time to respond to a crying baby and then show annoyance. These babies will see social relationships as inconsistent, frustrating.

Links Between Caregiving and Attachment

Secure attachment development depends on close contact between parents and children.

  • Four features of caregiver's behavior associated with quality of attachment:

    1. Sensitive and responsive

    2. Behavior guided by baby's cues

    3. Accepting of baby and minimal frustration

    4. Physically and psychologically available

  • Insecure-Avoidant Associations: Intrusive or irritable/rejecting parenting associated with insecure-avoidant attachment (i.e., fail to respond to cues, minimal body contact, often irritable).

  • Insecure-Ambivalent (Anxious) Associations: Unaffectionate and inconsistent (kind word and cold glance) parenting associated with insecure-ambivalent (anxious) attachment. Children don't know what to expect from parents.

  • Insecure-Disorganized Associations: Neglectful or abusive parenting associated with insecure-disorganized attachment. Also depressed caregiver, displays little eye contact and averts gaze.

Adult Attachment Classifications

Adults can also be classified whether they came from secure or insecure attachments in their early childhoods:

  • Secure (Autonomous) Adults

    • Describe childhood experiences objectively and value, and have a clear understanding of the parent-child relationship.

    • Stems from secure attachment.

  • Dismissive Adults

    • Sometimes deny the value of childhood experiences and attachment.

    • Often have difficulty recalling childhood experiences precisely.

    • Sometimes idealize their parents.

    • Stems from insecure-avoidant attachment.

  • Preoccupied Adults

    • Describe childhood events emotionally and often experience anger or confusion regarding parental relationships.

    • Can recall many conflicts, but cannot organize them into one coherent pattern.

    • Stems from insecure-ambivalent (anxious) attachment.

Attachment Dynamics and Stability
  • Earned Secure: Had insecure attachments to parents, but developed secure attachments with romantic partners, spouses, and/or offspring.

  • Does this mean attachment change is impossible?

    • If parenting behaviors or family circumstances change, then attachment classification can also change.

    • In one study, 42% of insecure at 1 year changed to secure by age 5.

    • More likely to change from insecure to secure instead of secure to insecure.

    • For example, increase in family SES leads to less strain on parents and increased attachment.

    • But secure can change to insecure should trauma (like death in the family) or family conflict ensue.

  • Temperament and quality of attachment: Irritable newborns more likely to develop insecure attachment. However, not all studies show a link.

  • Longitudinal Associations: Evidence of associations between infant attachment classification and later (adult/peer) attachment in both short- and long-term longitudinal studies:

    • Attachment at age 1 year predicted 90% of peer attachment at age 6 years; 72% at age 20.

    • Adults perceived negatively as infants showed insecure patterns of attachments as adults.

    • Parents' attachment to their own parents may influence responsiveness to their children (i.e., intergenerational transmission of attachment).

    • Parents who are rigid and expect the child to adapt to them are more likely to have children with insecure attachment.

    • Children in early child care and institutions can form attachments to caregivers.

    • Even brief parental training programs and education can assist parents to respond to infants more effectively and responsively.

Child Care / Daycare Realities

In Canadian and American studies:

  • Having a child in daycare does not affect quality of parent-child attachment.

  • Time spent, age when starting does not seem to impact except when poor quality child care is added to the effects of parental insensitivity and lack of responsiveness.

  • A child forming attachment to a daycare caregiver is not deleterious to the parental-child attachment.

  • Good quality child care can actually compensate for poor care and poor infant-caregiver relationship at home - better social competence.