Atomic Structure, Electron Configurations, and Fundamental Electrostatic Forces

Course Overview and General Rules for Electron Configurations

  • Course Administration:

    • Course Title: Chem 150: Structure & Properties

    • Instructor: Dr. Lili Wang (she/her/hers)

    • Meeting Time: Tuesday & Thursday (TT) 10:00–11:15 am

    • Location: Atwood 215

  • General Rules Governing Ground-State Electron Configurations:

    • Aufbau Principle: Electrons occupy the available atomic orbitals of the lowest possible energy first before occupying higher-energy orbitals.

    • Pauli Exclusion Principle: Each orbital can accommodate a maximum of two electrons, and these electrons must have opposite (anti-parallel) spins.

    • Hund's Rule: Electrons will not pair up in degenerate (equal-energy) orbitals if an empty degenerate orbital is available; electrons occupy orbitals singly with parallel spins first to minimize electrostatic repulsion.

    • Orbital Filling Sequence: Orbitals fill progressively in the diagonal order dictated by principal (nn) and angular momentum (ll) quantum numbers:

    • Sequence: 1s→2s→2p→3s→3p→4s→3d→4p→5s→4d→5p→6s→4f→5d→6p→7s→5f→6d→7p1s \rightarrow 2s \rightarrow 2p \rightarrow 3s \rightarrow 3p \rightarrow 4s \rightarrow 3d \rightarrow 4p \rightarrow 5s \rightarrow 4d \rightarrow 5p \rightarrow 6s \rightarrow 4f \rightarrow 5d \rightarrow 6p \rightarrow 7s \rightarrow 5f \rightarrow 6d \rightarrow 7p.

Aufbau principle diagonal orbital filling diagram

Transition Metals and Configuration Exceptions

  • Definition of Transition Metals:

    • Transition metals encompass elements situated in Group 3B through Group 1B (and Group 2B).

    • Chemically, transition metals have partially filled dd subshells or give rise to cations that have incompletely filled dd subshells.

  • Notable Transition Metal Neutral Atom Anomalies:

    • The standard periodic trend serves as a general guideline; true ground-state electron configurations are definitively determined through empirical experiments.

    • Chromium (Z=24Z = 24):

    • Predicted configuration: [Ar] 4s23d4[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2 3d^4

    • Actual experimentally observed configuration: [Ar] 4s13d5[\text{Ar}]\,4s^1 3d^5

    • Rationale: Enhanced stability is achieved through a symmetric, half-filled 3d53d^5 subshell with single occupancy in each of the five dd orbitals.

Chromium electron configuration showing half-filled 3d subshell
  • Copper (Z=29Z = 29):

    • Predicted configuration: [Ar] 4s23d9[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2 3d^9

    • Actual experimentally observed configuration: [Ar] 4s13d10[\text{Ar}]\,4s^1 3d^{10}

    • Rationale: Greater thermodynamic stability is achieved by fully filling the 3d3d subshell (3d103d^{10}), which outweighs the minimal energy cost required to promote one electron from the 4s4s orbital.

Copper electron configuration showing fully filled 3d subshell
  • Transition Metal Cation Formation Rules:

    • When transition metals are ionized to form cations, electrons are invariably removed from the outer nsns orbital before any electrons are removed from the (n−1)d(n-1)d subshell.

    • Example Comparison — Calcium (Ca\text{Ca}) versus Titanium Ion (Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}):

    • Both species contain exactly 20 electrons.

    • Neutral Calcium (Ca\text{Ca}, Z=20Z = 20): [Ar] 4s2[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2

    • Titanium Ion (Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}, Z=22Z = 22, 20 electrons): [Ar] 3d2[\text{Ar}]\,3d^2

    • Neutral Titanium (Ti\text{Ti}) has the ground-state configuration [Ar] 3d24s2[\text{Ar}]\,3d^2 4s^2. Upon double ionization to Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}, the two 4s4s valence electrons are lost preferentially, leaving the 3d23d^2 configuration intact.

Isoelectronic Species

  • Definition of Isoelectronic:

    • Isoelectronic is an adjective applied to distinct atoms, ions, or molecules that share identical total electron configurations and identical numbers of electrons, despite having different atomic numbers (ZZ).

  • Primary Examples:

    • 10-Electron Series:

    • Neon (Ne\text{Ne}, Z=10Z = 10): 10 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6

    • Fluoride ion (F−\text{F}^-, Z=9Z = 9): 10 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6

    • Sodium ion (Na+\text{Na}^+, Z=11Z = 11): 10 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6

    • 18-Electron Series:

    • Argon (Ar\text{Ar}, Z=18Z = 18): 18 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p63s23p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6 3s^2 3p^6

    • Chloride ion (Cl−\text{Cl}^-, Z=17Z = 17): 18 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p63s23p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6 3s^2 3p^6

    • Calcium ion (Ca2+\text{Ca}^{2+}, Z=20Z = 20): 18 electrons; configuration is 1s22s22p63s23p61s^2 2s^2 2p^6 3s^2 3p^6

Magnetic Properties and Experimental Proof of Electron Configuration

  • Physical Origin of Atomic Magnetism:

    • Electrons possess intrinsic spin angular momentum, behaving as microscopic magnetic dipoles.

    • When electrons are spin-paired in an orbital (↑↓\uparrow\downarrow), their magnetic moments cancel out, resulting in no net magnetic dipole moment for that orbital.

    • When an atom or ion has unpaired electrons, a net magnetic moment exists.

  • Classification of Magnetic Behavior:

    • Paramagnetic:

    • Characterized by the presence of one or more unpaired electrons.

    • Paramagnetic materials are attracted into an external magnetic field.

    • Diamagnetic:

    • Characterized by all electrons being completely spin-paired.

    • Diamagnetic materials have no net magnetic dipole and are weakly repelled by an external magnetic field.

  • Using Magnetic Properties as Empirical Evidence:

    • Theoretical Claim: In positive ions with partially filled or filled 3d3d orbitals, the 4s4s orbital remains completely unfilled until all 3d3d orbitals are filled (electrons are removed from 4s4s first upon ionization).

    • Empirical Evidence: Titanium(II) ion (Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}) is experimentally observed to be paramagnetic.

    • Deductive Reasoning:

    • Neutral Titanium (Ti\text{Ti}): [Ar] 3d24s2[\text{Ar}]\,3d^2 4s^2

    • If the claim is TRUE:

      • Electrons are lost from the 4s4s subshell first.

      • Configuration of Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}: [Ar] 3d2[\text{Ar}]\,3d^2

      • Number of unpaired electrons: 2

      • Magnetic property: Paramagnetic (matches empirical observation).

    • If the claim is FALSE:

      • Electrons are lost from the 3d3d subshell first.

      • Configuration of Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+}: [Ar] 4s2[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2

      • Number of unpaired electrons: 0

      • Magnetic property: Diamagnetic (contradicts empirical observation).

    • The experimental paramagnetism of Ti2+\text{Ti}^{2+} validates that 4s4s electrons are removed before 3d3d electrons.

    • Diagnostic Testing: Cu2+\text{Cu}^{2+} vs. Zn2+\text{Zn}^{2+}:

    • To test this claim further, testing the magnetic behavior of Zn2+\text{Zn}^{2+} (Z=30Z = 30) provides a definitive test:

      • If claim is TRUE: Zn2+\text{Zn}^{2+} loses two 4s4s electrons to become [Ar] 3d10[\text{Ar}]\,3d^{10} (all paired, diamagnetic).

      • If claim is FALSE: Zn2+\text{Zn}^{2+} loses two 3d3d electrons to become [Ar] 3d84s2[\text{Ar}]\,3d^8 4s^2 (contains 2 unpaired electrons in 3d3d, paramagnetic).

      • An experimental finding of diamagnetism for Zn2+\text{Zn}^{2+} uniquely confirms the loss of 4s4s electrons.

The Four Fundamental Forces of Nature

  • Gravitational Force:

    • Always attractive in nature.

    • Acts universally between any two masses over a given distance.

    • Has infinite range but is the weakest force at the atomic/subatomic scale.

  • Electromagnetic Force:

    • Manifests as both attractive (between opposite charges) and repulsive (between like charges).

    • Governs interactions between electric charges via Coulomb's Law and magnetic fields.

    • The dominant interaction determining atomic structure, chemical bonding, electron configurations, and molecular geometry.

  • Strong Nuclear Force:

    • A short-range, powerful attractive force mediated by gluons/mesons.

    • Binds protons and neutrons together within the atomic nucleus, overcoming the immense electrostatic repulsion between positively charged protons.

  • Weak Nuclear Force:

    • A short-range force mediated by intermediate vector bosons (W+W^+, W−W^-, Z0Z^0).

    • Responsible for flavor transitions that convert one type of quark into another, playing a central role in subatomic particle decay processes (such as beta decay involving neutrinos).

Gravitational Force and Gravitational Potential Energy

  • Gravitational Force Formulation:

    • The gravitational force between two point masses is strictly attractive:

Fgrav=−Gm1m2r2F_{\text{grav}} = -\frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2}

  • GG is the Universal Gravitational Constant: 6.67×10−11 N⋅m2/kg26.67 \times 10^{-11}\,\text{N}\cdot\text{m}^2/\text{kg}^2.

  • m1m_1 and m2m_2 represent the masses of the two interacting bodies.

  • rr is the separation distance between the centers of mass of the two bodies.

    • Gravitational Potential Energy (PEPE):

  • Potential energy is defined as the energy an object possesses by virtue of its position relative to other objects.

  • Fundamental formulation:

PEgrav=−Gm1m2rPE_{\text{grav}} = -\frac{G m_1 m_2}{r}

  • In a uniform gravitational field near Earth's surface:

PE=m⋅g⋅hPE = m \cdot g \cdot h

  • gg represents the acceleration due to gravity, approximately 9.8 m/s29.8\,\text{m/s}^2 on Earth.

  • hh is the elevation height above a reference plane.

    • Behavior as Distance Changes:

  • As two masses approach one another (rr decreases), the gravitational force increases in magnitude inversely with the square of distance (F∝1/r2F \propto 1/r^2).

  • As distance decreases, gravitational potential energy becomes increasingly negative (drops to lower energy states).

Electrostatic Interactions and Coulomb's Law

  • Principles of Charge Interaction:

    • Opposite charges (+−+-) experience an attractive electrostatic force.

    • Like charges (++++ or −−--) experience a repulsive electrostatic force.

Opposite charges attract and like charges repel
  • Coulomb's Law Equation:

    • The electrostatic force between two point charges is quantitatively expressed by Coulomb's Law:

F=kq1q2r2F = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r^2}

  • kk is Coulomb's constant: k=8.988×109 N⋅m2⋅C−2k = 8.988 \times 10^9\,\text{N}\cdot\text{m}^2\cdot\text{C}^{-2}.

  • q1q_1 and q2q_2 are the electrical charges of the two particles (in Coulombs).

  • rr is the distance between the point charges.

    • Sign Conventions for Electrostatic Force:

  • Positive Sign (F>0F > 0): Indicates a repulsive force. For example, two interacting electrons have charges (−1)×(−1)=+1(-1) \times (-1) = +1.

  • Negative Sign (F<0F < 0): Indicates an attractive force. For example, an electron and a proton have charges (−1)×(+1)=−1(-1) \times (+1) = -1.

  • In multi-electron atoms, both attractive forces (between the positive nucleus and negative electrons) and repulsive forces (between individual negative electrons) operate simultaneously.

    • Electrostatic Potential Energy (PEPE):

  • The potential energy stored in an electrostatic field between two charges is:

PE=kq1q2rPE = \frac{k q_1 q_2}{r}

  • Asymptotic Zero: Both electrostatic force and potential energy asymptotically approach zero as the distance becomes infinite (r→∞r \rightarrow \infty).

  • Opposite Charges (Attraction): Both force and potential energy are negative. A negative potential energy indicates a bound, stable state; energy must be added to the system to pull the particles apart to infinite separation (r→∞r \rightarrow \infty, where PE=0PE = 0).

  • Like Charges (Repulsion): Both force and potential energy are positive. Bringing like charges closer together increases the potential energy.

  • Quantum Limitation at r=0r = 0: While classical Coulomb potential energy goes to negative infinity (−∞-\infty) as r→0r \rightarrow 0, the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle prevents an electron from collapsing entirely into the nucleus (r=0r = 0).

    • Quantitative Force Comparison:

  • Calculation evaluating the attractive force on an electron by a Hydrogen (H\text{H}) nucleus versus a Helium (He\text{He}) nucleus:

    • Case 1: Hydrogen nucleus (+1+1 charge) at a distance of 10.0 pm10.0\,\text{pm}.

FH∝(+1)(−1)(10.0)2=−1100=−0.01 relative unitsF_{\text{H}} \propto \frac{(+1)(-1)}{(10.0)^2} = -\frac{1}{100} = -0.01\,\text{relative units}

* Case 2: Helium nucleus (+2+2 charge) at a distance of 20.0 pm20.0\,\text{pm}.

FHe∝(+2)(−1)(20.0)2=−2400=−0.005 relative unitsF_{\text{He}} \propto \frac{(+2)(-1)}{(20.0)^2} = -\frac{2}{400} = -0.005\,\text{relative units}

* Result: The Hydrogen nucleus at 10.0 pm10.0\,\text{pm} exerts double the attractive force on the electron compared to the Helium nucleus at 20.0 pm20.0\,\text{pm}, demonstrating that halving the distance increases the force by a factor of 4, which overpowers a doubling of nuclear charge.

Sloping Surface Analogies for Potential Energy

  • Attractive Interactions (Opposite Charges):

    • When charges have opposite signs (q1q2<0q_1 q_2 < 0), the system's potential energy curve represents a descending sloping surface leading down into a deep well relative to "sea level" (PE=0PE = 0 at r→∞r \rightarrow \infty).

    • Large Distances (r≫0r \gg 0):

    • Potential energy is small and negative.

    • Not much work is required to bring the particle out to sea level (PE=0PE = 0).

    • The slope is gentle; minimal effort is needed to resist falling forward because the attractive force is negative but weak.

    • Short Distances (r→0r \rightarrow 0):

    • Potential energy is large and negative (deep in the potential well).

    • A large amount of work/energy input is required to separate the charges to infinite distance (PE=0PE = 0).

    • The slope is extremely steep; substantial effort is needed to keep from sliding further down into the depths because the attractive force is negative and strong.

Sloping surface analogy for attractive interactions showing negative potential energy well
  • Repulsive Interactions (Like Charges):

    • When charges have identical signs (q1q2>0q_1 q_2 > 0), potential energy is positive, representing a steep hill rising above "sea level" (PE=0PE = 0 at r→∞r \rightarrow \infty).

    • Large Distances:

    • Moving closer from infinity requires very little climbing; potential energy is small and positive.

    • The repulsive force is positive but weak; minimal effort is needed to hold position.

    • Small Distances:

    • Bringing like charges close together requires overcoming strong repulsive barriers; potential energy is large and positive.

    • The repulsive force is strong and pushes outward in the positive direction toward greater distances; considerable effort is required to maintain proximity.

Sloping surface analogy for repulsive interactions showing positive potential energy hill

Orbital Penetration and Electron Shielding

  • Underlying Atomic Principles:

    • The spatial distribution and energy hierarchy of atomic orbitals in multi-electron systems are governed by two physical phenomena: orbital penetration and electron shielding.

  • Orbital Penetration:

    • Definition: Penetration refers to the proximity to which an electron in a given orbital can approach the nucleus.

    • Orbitals with higher radial probability near the nucleus penetrate core electron shells more effectively, experiencing less shielding and greater attraction from the nuclear charge.

    • Comparison within Shell n=2n = 2 (2s2s vs. 2p2p):

    • The 2s2s orbital has a small inner radial probability peak located close to the nucleus, inside the core 1s1s region.

    • The 2p2p orbital has zero probability at the nucleus (node at r=0r = 0) and its radial distribution lies mostly outside the inner region.

    • Consequence: The 2s2s electron penetrates closer to the nucleus than a 2p2p electron, experiencing a higher effective nuclear charge and lower potential energy, placing 2s2s lower in energy than 2p2p.

Radial probability distribution of 2s and 2p orbitals demonstrating penetration
  • Comparison within Shell n=3n = 3 (3s3s vs. 3p3p vs. 3d3d):

    • Penetration capability follows the strict order: 3s>3p>3d3s > 3p > 3d.

    • The 3s3s orbital possesses two inner radial nodes and a peak very close to the nucleus.

    • The 3p3p orbital has one inner node and penetrates less than 3s3s.

    • The 3d3d orbital possesses no radial nodes and has its radial probability concentrated farther out, penetrating least.

    • Consequence: In multi-electron systems, subshell energies within the same principal shell split into the order: E3s<E3p<E3dE_{3s} < E_{3p} < E_{3d}.

Radial probability distribution showing penetration order 3s greater than 3p greater than 3d
  • Electron Shielding (Screening):

    • Definition: Shielding is the partial obstruction or reduction of the full nuclear positive charge felt by an outer electron, caused by repulsive forces from intervening inner (core) electrons.

    • Valence Shell Electrons: Electrons occupying the outermost, highest-energy principal shell of an atom.

    • Inner-Shell (Core) Electrons: Electrons occupying inner, filled electron shells between the nucleus and the valence shell.

    • Core electrons shield outer valence electrons with high efficiency, whereas valence electrons in the same shell shield one another relatively weakly.

Effective Nuclear Charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) and Period Trends

  • Conceptual Framework:

    • Effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) is the net positive nuclear charge experienced by a specific electron in a multi-electron atom after accounting for electron-electron shielding.

    • An electron in an atom is simultaneously attracted to the positively charged nucleus and repelled by all other electrons. This multi-body interaction is approximated as an effective, reduced attraction to the nucleus.

  • Mathematical Equation:

Zeff=Z−σZ_{\text{eff}} = Z - \sigma

  • ZZ represents the actual nuclear charge (atomic number, total number of protons in the nucleus).

  • σ\sigma represents the shielding (screening) constant, reflecting the degree of screening by other electrons (dominated by inner core electrons).

    • Periodic Trend Across a Period:

  • Across a period from left to right, ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} increases steadily.

  • Rationale: Each successive element adds one proton to the nucleus (ZZ increases by 1) and adds one electron to the outermost valence shell. Because core electrons remain constant and valence electrons do not effectively shield each other, the screening constant σ\sigma increases much more slowly than ZZ, causing ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} to rise across the period.

  • Empirical Values for Period 2 Elements:

    • Lithium (Li\text{Li}): Z=3Z = 3, Zeff=1.28Z_{\text{eff}} = 1.28

    • Beryllium (Be\text{Be}): Z=4Z = 4, Zeff=1.91Z_{\text{eff}} = 1.91

    • Boron (B\text{B}): Z=5Z = 5, Zeff=2.42Z_{\text{eff}} = 2.42

    • Carbon (C\text{C}): Z=6Z = 6, Zeff=3.14Z_{\text{eff}} = 3.14

    • Nitrogen (N\text{N}): Z=7Z = 7, Zeff=3.83Z_{\text{eff}} = 3.83

    • Oxygen (O\text{O}): Z=8Z = 8, Zeff=4.45Z_{\text{eff}} = 4.45

    • Fluorine (F\text{F}): Z=9Z = 9, Zeff=5.10Z_{\text{eff}} = 5.10

    • Helium Case Study Demonstrating Electron Shielding:

  • Neutral Helium (He\text{He}, Z=2Z = 2) possesses two electrons in the 1s1s orbital.

  • Removal of the first electron (He→He++e−\text{He} \rightarrow \text{He}^+ + e^-) requires 3.94×10−18 J3.94 \times 10^{-18}\,\text{J}.

  • Removal of the second electron (He+→He2++e−\text{He}^+ \rightarrow \text{He}^{2+} + e^-) requires 8.72×10−18 J8.72 \times 10^{-18}\,\text{J}.

  • Rationale: In neutral Helium, each electron experiences mutual electrostatic repulsion and partial shielding from the other electron, lowering the net attractive force. Once the first electron is removed, the remaining electron experiences the unshielded, full nuclear charge (Zeff=+2Z_{\text{eff}} = +2), shrinking the orbital and requiring substantially more energy (8.72×10−18 J8.72 \times 10^{-18}\,\text{J}) to ionize.

Helium ionization diagram showing first and second ionization energies

Degeneracy: One-Electron versus Multi-Electron Atoms

  • Degeneracy in One-Electron Systems (Hydrogen):

    • In a one-electron atom or ion (such as Hydrogen, H\text{H}), there are no other electrons to cause repulsion or shielding.

    • The energy of an orbital depends solely on the principal quantum number (nn).

    • All subshells within a given principal energy level are completely degenerate (possess identical energies):

    • E2s=E2pE_{2s} = E_{2p}

    • E3s=E3p=E3dE_{3s} = E_{3p} = E_{3d}

    • E4s=E4p=E4d=E4fE_{4s} = E_{4p} = E_{4d} = E_{4f}

  • Non-Degeneracy in Multi-Electron Systems:

    • In atoms containing two or more electrons, electron-electron repulsions cause orbital penetration and shielding to dictate subshell energies.

    • Subshells within the same principal quantum shell split and become non-degenerate:

    • Energy hierarchy: Ens<Enp<End<EnfE_{ns} < E_{np} < E_{nd} < E_{nf}.

    • As nn increases, the spacing between successive principal energy shells contracts significantly, causing higher subshells of lower nn levels to overlap in energy with lower subshells of higher nn levels (e.g., 4s4s lies lower in energy than 3d3d during filling).

Energy levels in hydrogen versus multi-electron atoms showing degeneracy splitting

Energetics of Orbital Pairing, Promotion, and Transition Metal Filling

  • Worksheet Problems and Comprehensive Solutions:

    • Problem 1 (Pairing Energy Cost): Why does it cost energy to pair up two electrons in an orbital (such as a 4s4s orbital)?

    • Solution: Electrons carry identical negative charges (−1-1). By Coulomb's Law (F=kq1q2/r2F = k q_1 q_2 / r^2), placing two electrons into the exact same spatial region (an orbital) generates strong mutual electrostatic repulsion. This repulsive interaction creates a positive energy penalty, known as pairing energy (PP).

    • Problem 2 (Promotion Energy Cost): Why does it cost energy to promote an electron to a higher energy level (i.e., why are energy levels farther from the nucleus at higher energy)?

    • Solution: The positively charged nucleus attracts the negatively charged electron with a force directed inward. Moving an electron farther away (e.g., from n=2n = 2 to n=4n = 4) requires performing work against this attractive electrostatic force. By Coulomb's potential energy formula (PE=kq1q2/rPE = k q_1 q_2 / r), as distance rr increases, the potential energy becomes less negative (closer to zero), representing a higher potential energy state.

    • Problem 3 (Chromium Configuration Rationale): Knowing the true configuration of Chromium is [Ar] 4s13d5[\text{Ar}]\,4s^1 3d^5 rather than [Ar] 4s23d4[\text{Ar}]\,4s^2 3d^4, what does this reveal regarding the energy cost of pairing electrons in 4s4s versus promoting an electron to 3d3d?

    • Solution: Because energy levels draw closer together at higher principal quantum numbers, the energy difference between the 4s4s and 3d3d orbitals is remarkably small. The pairing energy penalty required to force two electrons into the same 4s4s orbital (4s24s^2) exceeds the small promotion energy needed to move an electron from 4s4s into 3d3d. Furthermore, establishing a half-filled 3d53d^5 subshell maximizes exchange energy (stabilizing parallel spins) and spherical symmetry. Thus, the system minimizes its total overall energy by adopting the [Ar] 4s13d5[\text{Ar}]\,4s^1 3d^5 ground state.

General orbital energy ordering in multi-electron systems demonstrating close spacing of 4s and 3d levels