Luture 3 part 1 -First Wave to Second Wave Feminism: Historical Context

Limitations of First-Wave Feminism

  • Primary focus: gaining civil / political rights for women, e.g.
    • Right to Vote\text{Right to Vote}
    • Right to Run for Office\text{Right to Run for Office}
    • Legal Citizenship\text{Legal Citizenship}
  • Economic concerns largely sidelined
    • Wage equity, workplace safety, union representation mostly ignored by middle-class suffragists.
  • Leadership demographics
    • Predominantly urban, educated, middle-class white women in England\text{England}, U.S.\text{U.S.}, Canada\text{Canada}.
    • Interests of Women of Color\text{Women of Color}, Indigenous Women\text{Indigenous Women}, and working-class women under-represented.
  • Working-class women’s activism occurred outside suffrage movement
    • Active in trade unions
    • Campaigns for Equal Pay\text{Equal Pay}, safe conditions, job security.
  • Historiographical gap: Sojourner Truth’s “Ain’t I a Woman?” reveals the “hidden histories” excluded from standard first-wave narratives.

Key First-Wave Milestones in Canada

  • 19171917: Wartime Elections Act
    • Suffrage to women nurses & women with close male relatives in military.
  • 19181918: Universal suffrage to all women >> 2121.
  • Motivation: Granted for wartime sacrifice, tying citizenship to warrior status.
  • 19291929: Persons Case – Supreme Court of Canada legally designates women as “persons.”

Between the Waves: Historical Backdrop

  • Major events producing social/economic upheaval:
    • 192919291940s\text{1940s}: Great Depression
    • 1939193919451945: World War II
  • After first-wave victories, feminist activism becomes less visible – metaphorical “wave” subsides but remains present.

World War II and Women’s Labor

  • Governments urge women to leave private sphere & fill male-dominated jobs.
  • Icon: Rosie the Riveter
    • Symbolizes female strength & factory work (e.g., riveting for tanks, armaments).
    • Reality: Many Rosies were Black women / Women of Color already in low-wage service work.
  • Transformations:
    • Access to skilled trades, union membership, higher wages.
    • First experience of independent income or better-paid employment for numerous working-class women.
  • Continued nursing tradition
    • Women again serve as nurses—parallel drawn to modern COVID-19 front-line framing.
  • Government support policies in Canada
    • Introduction of first universal childcare so mothers could work in war industries.

Post-War Backlash ( 19451945 → Early 1960s1960s )

  • Demobilization: Returning soldiers reclaimed jobs; women laid off “en masse.”
    • Example: Windsor, Ontario women receiving pink slips on V-Day.
  • Cultural re-inscription of gender norms
    • “New Angel in the House” ideology saturates magazines & television (e.g., Leave It to Beaver).
    • “Good Wife’s Guide” (Housekeeping Monthly) prescribes:
    • Prepare dinner on time\text{Prepare dinner on time}
    • Look refreshed, touch-up makeup\text{Look refreshed, touch-up makeup}
    • Ensure quiet, orderly children\text{Ensure quiet, orderly children}
  • Psychological / Pharmaceutical intersection
    • Late 1950s1950s spike in female diagnoses: depression, hysteria, psychosomatic illness.
    • Rise of drugs like Valium (“mother’s little helper”).

Betty Friedan & “The Feminine Mystique” ( 19631963 )

  • Friedan—a former WWII journalist—investigates mental-health epidemic among suburban housewives.
  • Key findings / arguments:
    1. Disorders are social, not individual biochemistry.
    2. Women suffer from an “unnamed problem.”
    3. She names it The Feminine Mystique:
    • Cultural myth that female fulfillment derives solely from beauty, perfect home, obedient children, & supportive wifehood.
    1. Resultant Housewife Syndrome:
    • Invisible labor, lack of recognition, enforced domestic confinement → deep unhappiness.
    1. Solution: Entry into meaningful paid employment & public life.
  • Impact
    • Book ignites Second-Wave Feminism by linking private discontent to systemic patriarchy.
    • Spurs consciousness-raising groups—women discuss shared experiences, recognize collective oppression: “The personal is political.”

Conceptual & Contemporary Connections

  • Economic independence ≈ physical security—vital for escaping gendered violence.
  • Wartime mobilizations create precedents for state-funded childcare & valorization of frontline caregiving (echoes in COVID-19 rhetoric).
  • Cycle observed: State need → Women’s public participation → Post-crisis re-domestication.

Next Steps in Course (preview)

  • Detailed exploration of Second-Wave Feminist goals, theories, and movements emerging from this post-war context.