Untitled

CHAPTER III 

METHODOLOGY 

 

This chapter presents the methods and procedures that will be used to investigate the coagulation potential of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders, individually and in varying combinations, for the treatment of turbid water. It describes the research design, research setting, materials and equipment, experimental variables and treatment conditions, preparation and application procedures, data-gathering procedures, ethical and safety considerations, and statistical treatment of the data. The methodology provides a systematic procedure for preparing the seed-based coagulants, applying the treatments to turbid water samples, and evaluating their coagulation potential in terms of turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics. A commercially available coagulant will also be included as a benchmark for comparison with the natural coagulant treatments. 

 

 

Research Design 

 

The study will employ a quantitative experimental research design using a comparative experimental approach to investigate the coagulation potential of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders, individually and in varying combinations, for the treatment of turbid water. Experimental research involves the application or manipulation of treatments to determine their effects on a measured outcome, while comparative experimental designs involve comparing the outcomes of different treatment conditions (National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, 2012). The study will involve the controlled application of different coagulant treatments to water samples and the measurement of their effects based on turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics. A commercially available coagulant will also be included as a benchmark for comparison. 

 

This design is appropriate because it allows the researchers to determine and compare the coagulation potential of the different natural coagulant treatments under controlled conditions and address the research questions concerning the individual performance of the seed powders, the performance of their varying combinations, and their comparison with the commercially available coagulant. The experimental conditions, including the volume and initial condition of the water samples, total coagulant dosage, mixing procedure, settling conditions, and turbidity measurement procedure, will be standardized to ensure that differences in the results can be attributed primarily to the coagulant treatment applied. 

   

The independent variable in the study is the coagulant treatment or composition, consisting of the individual Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders, their specified combinations and ratios, and the commercially available coagulant. The dependent variables are the turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics following treatment. The experimental treatments will consist of applying the designated coagulant to equal water samples under the same experimental conditions, followed by standardized mixing and settling procedures. The results from the individual natural coagulants, their combinations, and the commercially available coagulant will then be compared to determine differences in their coagulation potential and performance. 

 

Research Setting 

 

The study will be conducted in a designated, well-ventilated outdoor area within the researchers' residence where the preparation of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders and the water treatment experiments can be performed using the materials and equipment required for the study. The experimental activities will involve preparing the seed materials, preparing and standardizing the turbid water samples, measuring the seed powders according to the designated treatment formulations, applying the coagulant treatments to the water samples, mixing the treatments according to a standardized procedure, and allowing the treated samples to settle before observations and measurements are conducted. 

 

The materials and equipment to be used will include beakers, a blender, a digital gram weighing scale, a hammer, an induction cooker, a jar, a mortar and pestle, a stirring rod, a wooden spoon, and a turbidity tester. The setting will be appropriate for the study because the procedures require sufficient space for processing the seeds into powder, preparing and handling the water samples, measuring the treatment materials, and conducting the controlled water treatment experiments. The selected area will provide adequate ventilation to maintain airflow throughout the experimental activities and will be kept away from flammable materials and other potential hazards. The turbid water samples will be prepared or obtained from a consistent source and distributed into equal volumes to minimize differences in the initial condition of the samples. Each designated coagulant treatment will then be applied under standardized conditions, followed by mixing and settling for the predetermined observation period. Final turbidity measurements, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics will subsequently be recorded for data analysis. 

 

Materials and Equipment 

  

The study will use various materials and equipment for preparing the natural coagulant and flocculant, conducting the water treatment experiments, and evaluating changes in water quality before and after treatment. The primary materials will consist of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera) seeds, Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus) seeds and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seeds. These seeds will be processed into powder and used individually and in combination according to the designated treatment formulations. Dirty water samples will serve as the test samples for evaluating the effectiveness of the prepared seed powders in reducing water turbidity. 

 

The materials and equipment will include beakers, a blender, a digital gram weighing scale, a hammer, an induction cooker, a jar, a mortar and pestle, a piece of cloth, a stirring rod, a wooden spoon, and a water turbidity tester. The quantities, capacities, and specifications of these items will be based on the requirements of the experimental procedures. The volume of water, mass of seed powders, and proportions of the treatment formulations will follow the predetermined experimental design to maintain consistency among the treatments. 

   

The digital gram weighing scale will be used to measure the required amounts of the seed powders. The mortar and pestle and blender will be used to grind the seeds into fine powder. The induction cooker and wooden spoon will be used to heat and stir the tamarind seeds, while the hammer and piece of cloth will be used to break the softened tamarind seed coats. Beakers and jars will be used as containers for preparing and treating the water samples, while the stirring rod will be used to mix the prepared coagulant with the water.  

   

The water turbidity tester will be used to measure the turbidity of the water samples before and after treatment. These measurements will provide quantitative data for evaluating the effectiveness of the natural coagulant and flocculant in improving water quality.  

  

 

Experimental Variables and Treatment Conditions 

 

The independent variable in the study is the coagulant treatment or composition used for water treatment. The treatment conditions will consist of the individual seed powders, two-seed combinations, and three-seed combinations of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica), expressed in a fixed ratio format (Malunggay:Okra:Tamarind). Across the experiment, a total of 21 distinct treatment conditions are evaluated to determine their comparative coagulation potential. 

 

To determine the baseline coagulation performance of each plant species individually, three single-seed treatments are included at full concentration (1:0:0, 0:1:0, and 0:0:1). Potential synergistic effects between seed pairings are systematically evaluated through nine dual-seed combinations covering all three possible pairings: Malunggay with Okra (1:1:0, 2:1:0, and 1:2:0), Malunggay with Tamarind (1:0:1, 2:0:1, and 1:0:2), and Okra with Tamarind (0:1:1, 0:2:1, and 0:1:2). For each dual pairing, the formulations test equal proportions (1:1) alongside asymmetrical ratios (2:1 and 1:2) to assess whether doubling one seed powder over another improves turbidity reduction. 

 

To investigate multi-component interactions, seven triple-seed combinations are structured across distinct relative proportion profiles. These include an equal balance ratio (1:1:1), single-powder dominance ratios (2:1:1, 1:2:1, and 1:1:2) where one seed powder is doubled relative to the other two, and dual-powder dominance ratios (2:2:1, 2:1:2, and 1:2:2) where two seed powders are present at twice the proportion of the third. 

 

Completing the experimental matrix, a commercially available coagulant serves as the positive benchmark control to evaluate efficacy against industry standards, while an untreated water sample serves as the negative control to determine baseline sedimentation. Thus, there are 21 total experimental conditions (treatments) evaluated in the study. Crucially, the total mass dosage of coagulant applied to each treated water sample is held strictly constant across all formulation treatments, ensuring that observed variations in water clarification performance are directly attributable to the relative composition and ratio of the seed powders rather than total concentration differences.  

 

The dependent variables are the indicators used to evaluate the coagulation potential and performance of the treatments. These include turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics following treatment. Initial and final turbidity measurements will be obtained to determine the reduction in turbidity. The settling behavior of the treated samples will be monitored to determine settling time. Observable changes in water characteristics will be assessed based on water clarity, the presence of visible suspended particles, and changes in the overall visual appearance of the water, using a predetermined observation procedure. 

 

The untreated water sample will undergo the same experimental observations and measurements without receiving a coagulant treatment. The individual seed powders and their combinations will be compared with one another to determine differences in their coagulation potential. The commercially available coagulant will serve as a benchmark for comparing the performance of the natural coagulant treatments under the same experimental conditions. 

 

The following conditions will be kept consistent throughout the experiments: the volume of water used per treatment, the initial condition of the water samples, the total coagulant dosage, the mixing procedure and duration, the type and size of containers used, the settling conditions and observation period, the temperature during experimentation as reasonably maintained, the procedure for measuring turbidity, the preparation and processing method of the seed powders, and the measurement procedure and equipment used for each treatment. 

 

 

Development, Fabrication, or Assembly Procedure 

 

Phase 1: Collection and Preparation of Raw Materials 

Collecting and Drying Pods. The Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seeds will be collected from their respective plant materials and prepared for processing. Where the seeds are enclosed within pods, the pods will first undergo drying to reduce their moisture content and facilitate the separation of the seeds from the surrounding plant material. Drying can make the pod walls more brittle, which may facilitate the removal of the pericarp and other surrounding materials. Basilio-Cortes et al. (2023) reported that drying temperature can influence the concentration of bioactive compounds, with increases observed under certain temperature conditions, while temperatures of 90 °C or higher may result in decreases in some bioactive compounds. Thus, excessive drying temperatures will be avoided during preparation. Drying may be performed through air drying or controlled oven drying, depending on the available equipment and the selected standardized procedure. 

 

The drying characteristics of the seed materials may differ because of their physical composition. Tamarind seeds, in particular, have a hard brown seed coat surrounding the kernel, with the seed coat and kernel constituting substantial portions of the seed structure (Phrabu et al., 2014). Consequently, Tamarind seeds may require additional processing before they can be ground effectively. Temperature and air velocity are among the factors that influence the drying rate of seeds and other plant materials. Deepa (2023) reported that increases in drying temperature and air velocity can accelerate the drying process. These considerations will be taken into account when preparing the seed materials while maintaining a consistent drying procedure for the experimental samples. 

 

Phase 2: Processing and Standardization of Seed Materials 

Separation and Cleaning of Seeds. After drying, the seeds will be separated from their respective pods and surrounding materials. The pericarp or pod wall will be removed to obtain the seeds for subsequent processing. Malunggay and Okra pods can be more readily separated after drying because the pod material becomes more brittle. Tamarind requires additional care because its pod contains sticky pulp surrounding the seeds. The remaining pulp and other plant materials will be removed from the Tamarind seeds as thoroughly as possible before further processing. The separated seeds will then be cleaned to remove visible dirt and residual plant material. 

 

Processing Seeds into Fine Powder. The dried Malunggay and Okra seeds will initially be broken down and ground using a mortar and pestle. Tamarind seeds will require an additional preparation step because of their hard seed coat. The seeds will be subjected to controlled heating using an induction cooker while being continuously stirred with a wooden spoon to promote even heating. The heating procedure will be conducted only until the seed coat becomes sufficiently workable for mechanical breaking. After heating, the Tamarind seed coats will be carefully broken using a hammer to expose the kernels. Appropriate precautions will be observed during this step to prevent injury and contamination of the seed material. 

 

The prepared seeds and Tamarind kernels will then be ground using a mortar and pestle before being further processed using a blender, when necessary, to obtain a finer powder. The grinding process will be performed consistently for all three seed materials. The resulting powders will be passed through a strainer or sieve to remove larger particles and promote a relatively uniform particle size. The final Malunggay, Okra, and Tamarind seed powders will be stored separately in clean, dry, and labeled containers until the preparation of the treatment formulations. Maintaining the powders separately will prevent cross-contamination and allow the individual seed treatments to be compared with the combined formulations. 

 

Phase 3: Preparation of the Coagulant Treatment Formulations 

The required amounts of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders will be measured using a digital gram weighing scale according to the designated treatment ratios expressed in the fixed order of Malunggay:Okra:Tamarind. The natural-coagulant treatments will consist of three individual seed-powder treatments, nine two-seed combinations, and seven three-seed combinations, resulting in 19 natural-coagulant treatment conditions. 

 

For each combination treatment, the total amount of coagulant applied to the water sample will be standardized, while the individual amounts of the seed powders will be calculated according to the assigned ratio. The measured powders for each combination will be placed in a clean container and thoroughly mixed to obtain a uniform formulation before application. Each prepared formulation will be properly labeled according to its treatment ratio and stored appropriately until it is applied to the corresponding water sample. 

 

The individual Malunggay, Okra, and Tamarind seed powders will be maintained separately and measured according to their designated individual treatments. A commercially available coagulant will also be prepared according to the designated procedure and included as a benchmark treatment, while an untreated water sample will be prepared as the control condition. 

 

Phase 4: Preparation and Characterization of Water Samples 

Obtaining and Preparing Turbid Water. Water samples will be collected or prepared from a single consistent source to minimize variation in their initial characteristics. The water will be thoroughly mixed before distribution to ensure a relatively uniform suspension of particles. Equal volumes of water will then be measured and transferred into the designated containers for each treatment condition, including the natural-coagulant treatments, commercially available coagulant treatment, and untreated control. 

 

Initial Turbidity Measurement. The initial turbidity of the water samples will be measured using a turbidity tester before any coagulant is applied. The recorded values will serve as the baseline measurements for comparison with the final turbidity measurements obtained after treatment. The initial turbidity of the samples will be kept as consistent as reasonably possible across the experimental conditions. 

 

Application and Mixing of Coagulant Treatments. The designated amount of each prepared coagulant treatment will be measured and added to its corresponding water sample. The treated samples will undergo the same standardized mixing procedure for the same duration to ensure consistent distribution of the coagulant throughout the water. The mixing conditions will be kept constant across all treatment conditions so that differences in the observed results can be primarily attributed to the coagulant treatment or composition. 

 

Settling and Observation of Treated Water. Following the standardized mixing procedure, the treated water samples will be allowed to settle under the same environmental conditions. The settling behavior of each sample will be monitored using a predetermined observation procedure, and the settling time will be recorded according to the operational endpoint established for the study. During the settling period, the samples will also be observed for changes in water characteristics, including water clarity, the presence of visible suspended particles, and overall visual appearance. 

 

Final Turbidity Measurement. After the designated settling period or upon reaching the predetermined observation endpoint, the final turbidity of each treated water sample will be measured using the same turbidity tester and measurement procedure used for the initial readings. The initial and final turbidity values will be recorded to determine the turbidity reduction associated with each treatment. The settling time and observable changes in water characteristics will likewise be documented and compared across the experimental conditions. 

 

 

Experimental Procedure 

 

The experimental procedure will begin with the preparation of the natural coagulant materials. The Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Tamarind (Tamarindus indica), and Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus) seeds will be prepared and dried using the standardized procedure described in the preparation of seed powders. The seeds will be separated from their respective pods and surrounding materials, cleaned, and processed into fine powders. Malunggay and Okra seeds will be ground using a mortar and pestle and further processed using a blender when necessary. Tamarind seeds will undergo the additional preparation required to break their hard seed coats before being ground into powder. The resulting powders will be passed through a strainer or sieve to promote uniform particle size and will be stored separately in clean, dry, and labeled containers until use. 

 

The turbid water samples will then be prepared from a single consistent source to minimize differences in their initial characteristics. The water will be thoroughly mixed to promote a relatively uniform distribution of suspended particles and will then be divided into equal volumes for all experimental conditions. Before the application of any coagulant, the initial turbidity of the water samples will be measured using a turbidity tester. The initial turbidity measurements will serve as the baseline values for determining the turbidity reduction following treatment. 

 

The natural-coagulant formulations will be prepared according to the designated treatment ratios expressed in the fixed order of Malunggay:Okra. The 19 natural-coagulant treatments will consist of three individual seed-powder treatments, nine two-seed combinations, and seven three-seed combinations. For each treatment, the required amounts of the seed powders will be measured using a digital gram weighing scale. The total amount of coagulant applied to each treated water sample will be standardized, while the amount contributed by each seed powder will be determined according to its assigned ratio. For combination treatments, the measured powders will be thoroughly mixed in a clean container to produce a uniform formulation before application. The commercially available coagulant will likewise be prepared according to its designated procedure, while the untreated water sample will receive no coagulant and will serve as the control condition. 

 

Each prepared coagulant treatment will then be added to its corresponding water sample. All treated samples will undergo the same standardized mixing procedure, including the same mixing rate and mixing duration, to ensure consistent distribution of the coagulant throughout the water. These mixing conditions will remain constant across all treatment conditions so that differences in the results can be primarily attributed to the composition and ratio of the coagulant treatment. 

 

After mixing, the treated water samples will be allowed to settle under the same environmental conditions. The settling behavior of each sample will be monitored using the predetermined observation procedure, and the settling time will be recorded according to the operational endpoint established for the study. During the settling period, observations will be made regarding changes in water characteristics, including water clarity, the presence of visible suspended particles, and overall visual appearance. These observations will be recorded using the predetermined procedure to ensure consistency among treatments. 

 

Following the designated settling period or upon reaching the predetermined observation endpoint, the final turbidity of each treated water sample will be measured using the same turbidity tester and measurement procedure used for the initial readings. The initial and final turbidity values, settling time, and observations of water characteristics will be recorded for every experimental condition. The turbidity measurements will subsequently be used to determine the percentage reduction in turbidity for each treatment. The results obtained from the 19 natural-coagulant treatments will then be compared with the commercially available coagulant and the untreated control to determine differences in their coagulation potential and performance. 

 

 

Testing and Performance Evaluation  

Write your content here… If the study involves automation, describe the system performance indicators, such as response time, accuracy, reliability, detection rate, completion rate, efficiency, or other measures appropriate to the research questions. 

 

The coagulation potential and performance of the different coagulant treatments will be evaluated based on three dependent variables: turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics. These indicators will be measured using standardized procedures and will be applied consistently to the individual seed powders, their varying combinations, the commercially available coagulant, and the untreated control. The evaluation will allow the researchers to determine and compare the effects of the different coagulant compositions on the treatment of turbid water. 

 

Turbidity Reduction. Turbidity reduction will be determined by measuring the turbidity of each water sample before and after treatment using a turbidity tester. The initial turbidity measurement will be obtained before the application of the coagulant, while the final turbidity measurement will be obtained after the designated settling period or upon reaching the predetermined observation endpoint. Turbidity measurements will be recorded in Nephelometric Turbidity Units (NTU). The percentage reduction in turbidity will be calculated by comparing the initial and final turbidity values using the following formula: 

 

 

A higher percentage of turbidity reduction will indicate a greater decrease in suspended particles and, consequently, greater coagulation potential under the conditions of the study. 

 

Settling Time. Settling time will be used to evaluate how quickly the suspended particles in the treated water settle following the standardized mixing procedure. The timer will begin immediately after the mixing procedure is completed. The treated sample will then be observed at predetermined intervals until it reaches the operational settling endpoint established for the study. This endpoint will be defined consistently for all treatment conditions based on the observable settling of suspended particles. The elapsed time from the beginning of the settling period until the predetermined endpoint is reached will be recorded in minutes. Shorter settling times will indicate faster particle settling under the standardized experimental conditions. The untreated control will undergo the same observation procedure to provide a baseline for comparison. 

 

Observable Changes in Water Characteristics. Observable changes in water characteristics will be assessed based on the visible condition of the treated water before and after treatment. The observations will focus on water clarity, visible suspended particles, and overall visual appearance. A predetermined 1–3 observation scale will be used consistently across all treatment conditions to minimize subjectivity in recording the results. For water clarity, a score of 1 will indicate that the water remains highly cloudy or turbid, 2 will indicate a noticeable improvement in clarity but with remaining cloudiness, and 3 will indicate a substantially clearer appearance. For visible suspended particles, a score of 1 will indicate a large amount of visible suspended material, 2 will indicate a moderate amount, and 3 will indicate little to no visible suspended material. For overall visual appearance, a score of 1 will indicate little observable improvement from the initial condition, 2 will indicate a noticeable improvement, and 3 will indicate a substantial observable improvement in the appearance of the treated water. The observations will be made at the same designated observation point for all treatments and will be recorded using the established scoring criteria. 

 

The results for the three dependent variables will be recorded for every experimental condition and, where applicable, across repeated trials. The results of the 19 natural-coagulant treatments will be compared with those of the commercially available coagulant and the untreated control. The turbidity reduction percentages, settling times, and observable-change scores will be used to determine differences in the coagulation potential and performance of the treatments. These measurements will provide the quantitative and standardized basis for addressing the research questions concerning the individual seed powders, their varying combinations, and their comparison with the commercially available coagulant. 

 

 

 

 

Ethical and Safety Considerations   

 

The study will involve the preparation and experimental testing of Malunggay (Moringa oleifera), Okra (Abelmoschus esculentus), and Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) seed powders as natural coagulants for the treatment of turbid water. The researchers will handle plant materials, prepared water samples, laboratory equipment, and a commercially available coagulant throughout the experimental procedures. Proper safety practices will be observed during the preparation of the seed powders, preparation and treatment of water samples, operation of equipment, and disposal of used materials. 

 

During the preparation of the seed powders, the researchers will wear appropriate personal protective equipment, including gloves and, when necessary, protective eyewear and a face mask, particularly during grinding and sieving to minimize exposure to fine particles. The seeds will be cleaned before processing, and the prepared powders will be stored in clean, dry, and labeled containers to prevent contamination and accidental mixing between treatments. The Tamarind seeds will undergo controlled heating using an induction cooker to facilitate the removal of their hard seed coats. This procedure will be performed under supervision and with appropriate precautions to prevent burns and other heat-related accidents. When the seed coats are mechanically broken, the researchers will handle the hammer and other equipment carefully and use appropriate protective measures. The blender, mortar and pestle, weighing scale, and other equipment will be operated according to proper handling procedures and kept clean between treatments to minimize cross-contamination. 

The turbid water samples will be handled as potentially contaminated materials. The water will be obtained or prepared from a consistent source and will not be used for drinking, washing, or any other personal use. Researchers will avoid direct contact with the water and will wear gloves during sample preparation, treatment, and disposal. Containers used for the experiment will be properly labeled and cleaned after use. The water samples will be kept away from food, drinking water, and personal items throughout the experiment. After testing, the treated and untreated water samples will be disposed of properly in accordance with the safety procedures of the designated research area. The seed residues and other solid materials generated during the experiment will likewise be collected and disposed of appropriately. 

 

During the treatment procedure, all water samples will be handled using the same standardized conditions. The researchers will ensure that the containers are placed on a stable surface during mixing and settling to prevent spills or breakage. The predetermined mixing procedure and observation intervals will be followed consistently for all treatments. Turbidity measurements will be performed using the same turbidity tester and measurement procedure throughout the experiment. Observations of settling time and changes in water characteristics will be recorded objectively using the predetermined criteria rather than being altered to favor any particular treatment. 

 

The researchers will maintain accurate and honest records of all experimental observations and measurements. No data will be altered, omitted, or selectively reported to obtain a desired result. All treatment conditions, including the individual seed powders, their specified combinations and ratios, the commercially available coagulant, and the untreated control, will be subjected to the same established procedures. The results will be reported based on the actual measurements and observations obtained during the experiment, including results that may not support the researchers' initial expectations. 

 

All experimental procedures will be conducted with appropriate supervision and in a suitable laboratory or designated research area. The researchers will prioritize personal safety, proper equipment handling, prevention of cross-contamination, responsible handling of turbid water, and proper disposal of experimental materials throughout the study. 

 

 

Data Analysis/Statistical Treatment  

 

The data collected from the experimental trials will be organized according to the assigned treatment condition and replicate. The treatment conditions will consist of the 19 natural-coagulant formulations, one commercially available coagulant, and one untreated control condition. The recorded results for turbidity reduction, settling time, and observable changes in water characteristics will be tabulated and organized for comparison among the treatment conditions. 

 

Descriptive statistics, particularly the mean and standard deviation, will be used to summarize the results obtained from the repeated trials for each treatment condition. The mean will represent the average result of the trials, while the standard deviation will indicate the degree of variation among the measurements. The descriptive results will be presented in tables to facilitate comparison of the performance of the individual seed powders, two-seed combinations, three-seed combinations, commercially available coagulant, and untreated control. 

 

For the quantitative dependent variables, particularly turbidity reduction and settling time, a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) will be used to determine whether statistically significant differences exist among the treatment conditions. The treatment condition will serve as the grouping factor. The level of significance will be set at α = 0.05. If the ANOVA indicates a statistically significant difference among the treatment means, Tukey’s Honestly Significant Difference (HSD) post-hoc test will be used to determine which specific treatment groups differ significantly from one another. 

 

The results for observable changes in water characteristics will be summarized and compared using the predetermined observation scores established in the testing and performance evaluation procedure. These results will be used as supporting evidence in interpreting the overall performance of the treatments alongside the quantitative measurements. 

 

The statistical analysis will be used to determine and compare the relative performance of the natural-coagulant treatments and the commercially available coagulant under the same standardized experimental conditions. The findings will be interpreted based on the descriptive and inferential statistical results to determine whether significant differences exist among the treatment conditions and to address the research questions of the study.