Critical Engagement: Introduction to Senate Proceedings and the Impeachment Process

Guidelines and Participant Protocol for FINMA Education Network Social Involvement and Transformation

  • Host and Introduction: Jean Bermudo, from the FINMA Education Network team (Social Involvement and Transformation), introduced the program.

  • Engagement Hashtags:

    • #makinglivesbetterthrougheducation

    • #socialinvolvementandtransformation

  • Zoom Room Guidelines:

    • Naming Convention: Participants must indicate their school followed by their name (e.g., "u I dash Sheehan").

    • Audio/Visual: Microphones should be turned off when not speaking; cameras are encouraged to be turned on.

    • Interaction: Questions or concerns can be voiced using the "raise hand" button or typed in the chat box. Participants can agree with points by using the react buttons or typing "+1" in the chat.

    • Note-taking: Participants are advised to have pen and paper ready.

    • Attendance: Attendance is strictly tracked through an evaluation form provided at the end of the session, not by comments in the chat.

  • Mission Statement: The session aims to be a safe, secure space for mutual learning, rooted in respect, cooperation, and the dignity of each person without discrimination.

  • Livestreaming: The session is streamed live on the Facebook page of Social Development and Transformation for students unable to join Zoom.

  • Opening Rituals: The program began with an opening prayer to the Almighty Father for strength, responsiveness, and peace, followed by the Philippine National Anthem.

Mulat: Empowering Students for Civic Transformation

  • Project Leads:

    • Katz Navarro: Head of Social Involvement and Transformation.

    • Gian Berudo: Extracurricular Manager for Social Involvement and Transformation.

  • Program Definition: "Mulat" is a nonpartisan program designed by FINMA Education to empower students to be active agents of change. It underscores patriotism and a love for the country and its people.

  • Objective: To equip students with the tools to become critical-minded catalysts for transformation to improve the lives of Filipinos.

  • Participating Institutions (Roll Call):

    • Arau University (AU)

    • University of Iloilo

    • Saint Jude College Manila and Saint Jude College Quezon City

    • Southwestern University

    • Rizal College of Laguna

    • Union College of Laguna

    • FINMA Southeastern College (Newly welcomed member)

    • Guests from the Finma Education head office.

Understanding the Senate and Impeachment: Context and Participant Perspectives

  • Webinar Title: "Senates area impeachment at…" (The discussion focused on evolving happenings in the Senate and their impact on ordinary citizens' lives, livelihoods, and lifestyles).

  • Primary Speaker: Katrina "Katz" Navarro.

  • Session Philosophy: These sessions are periodic interruptions to regular academic programming to facilitate a safe space for discussing global and local events.

  • Initial Poll Results (Public Perception and Literacy):

    • Trust in Governance: In response to the statement "I believe that the congress and the senate are acting in my best interest," the majority answered negatively (00 and 1717 responses).

    • Legal Awareness: Participants were polled on their familiarity with current issues like the "legal ICC warrant" and "impeachment."

    • Impeachment Knowledge: Regarding the vote for impeachment for plunder (a non-bailable offense leading to jail and trial), responses were mixed, with some noting they were suspended or seeking expert intervention.

  • Senator Judge Biases (Survey of Preference):

    • Risa Hontiveros: 62%62\%

    • Isko Moreno: 56%56\%

    • Loren Legarda: 10%10\%

    • Robin Padilla: 13%13\%

    • Raffy Tulfo: 31%31\%

    • Bato De La Rosa: 13%13\%

    • Ping Lacson: 21%21\%

    • Cynthia Villar: 9%9\%

    • Mark Villar: 5%5\%

    • Bong Go: 18%18\%

    • Jinggoy Estrada: 27%27\%

    • (Note: The poll measured which senators students felt were acting effectively or fairly as "Senator Judges," with Hontiveros and Hontiveros receiving high marks for perceived performance).

The Mechanics and Grounds of Impeachment

  • The Procedural Split:

    • Congress (House of Representatives): Acts like a prosecutor; they look at arguments and determine if there are sufficient grounds to send the case to the Senate.

    • Senate: Acts as a trial court (Senator Judges) to balance arguments and evidence to decide on acquittal or conviction.

  • Specific Case Study: Vice President Sara Duterte:

    • The discussion explored grounds for her potential impeachment based on recent political developments.

  • Prosecution Argument 1: Misuse of Confidential Funds:

    • Amount/Timeline: $125,000,000\$125,000,000 spent in just 1111 days.

    • Purpose of Confidential Funds: Legally intended for secret operations, safe houses, informant rewards, and purchase of information related to national security.

    • Contention: Critics argue the Office of the Vice President (OVP) does not conduct NBI or PNP-style secret operations that would justify such spending in a short window.

  • Prosecution Argument 2: Unexplained Wealth and SALN Discrepancies:

    • Definition of SALN: Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth. A mandatory sworn document for all public officials filed annually.

    • Data/Growth: VP Duterte's declared net worth jumped from $720,000\$720,000 to $88,500,000\$88,500,000 during her tenure from 2007 to early 2024 (serving as Vice Mayor, Mayor, etc.).

    • Irregularity: Between 2019 and 2024, reports indicated zero cash on hand and zero bank deposits despite the high net worth.

    • Private Business: Prosecution claims SEC records show family businesses either declared financial losses or tiny earnings, making the wealth accumulation difficult to explain via legal dividends.

  • Prosecution Argument 3: Bribery:

    • Witness Testimony: Witnesses like Gloria Jumamil-Mercado and others claimed they received 50,00050,000 per month in envelopes to approve bids or awards for DepEd (112,500,000112,500,000 total in confidential funds involved).

  • Prosecution Argument 4: Grave Threats:

    • Evidence: Videos where the VP allegedly threatened the President, First Lady, and the Speaker of the House.

    • Interpretation: Prosecution views this as betrayal of public trust and a legitimate threat given her family background and ties to the Davao Death Squad.

The Defense Position and Legal Counter-Arguments

  • Political Motivation: The defense argues the impeachment is a "numbers game" intended to derail a 2028 presidential bid, as the VP currently leads national polls.

  • Lack of Due Process: Claims that Congress had already made up its mind before the hearing (aggressive questioning of staff like Zuleika Lopez).

  • Freedom of Expression: A core defense is the basic human right to free speech.

    • Legal Principle: Free speech applies not only to favorable ideas but also to those that offend, shock, or disturb. The defense claims the "threats" were emotional expressions, not physical intent.

  • Evidence/Procurement: Characterized as a "fishing expedition" by the prosecution without concrete proof of a hired hitman or direct bribery.

  • Cultural Context: Styled as a conflict between "Imperial Manila" bullies and regional leaders.

Potential Outcomes of an Impeachment Trial

  • Not Guilty (Acquittal):

    • The VP remains in office until June 2028.

    • Charges are dropped relative to the impeachment, though criminal cases could follow independently.

  • Guilty (Conviction):

    • Immediate removal from the Vice Presidency.

    • Perpetual disqualification from holding any public office (including local positions like Mayor).

    • Succession: The President nominates a new Vice President, or it may trigger a complicated succession process depending on the ruling.

  • Nature of the Process: Impeachment is a political process, not a criminal one. It determines fitness for office, not necessarily immediate imprisonment.

Questions & Discussion

  • Q: How can the SALN be an effective tool for preventing corruption?

    • A: Transparency forces potential crime into the light. While the SALN itself doesn't stop corruption, it provides the documentary basis for prosecutors to file criminal charges when discrepancies arise.

  • Q: Should student participation be mandatory or are they allowed to be apolitical?

    • A: Being apolitical is a choice. In a democracy, staying informed is a responsibility as government happenings affect livelihoods and the economy. Avoiding political awareness with access to information is problematic in a healthy democracy.

  • Q: Should impeachment be based on legal evidence or public opinion?

    • A: As a legal proceeding, the decision must be based on legal evidence and Constitutional principles. However, Senator Judges often feel the pressure of public opinion in a political process.

  • Q: What about the ill-gotten wealth of the Marcos family?

    • A: (Note for future discussion). This is a complex historical and legal topic that the team is willing to address via email or future modules.

Checklist for Watching Impeachment Trials

  • Evidence: Are the arguments from both the defense and prosecution fact-based or repetitive?

  • Objections: Are they legally sound or just delay tactics?

  • Senator Participation: Observe which judges are active, which are sleeping/absent, and who shows obvious bias.

  • Presiding Officer: Is the presiding judge (e.g., Chiz Escudero) being fair in their rulings?

  • Neutrality: Can you identify which senators are staying neutral versus those acting as de facto extensions of the prosecution or defense?