Distributive Justice and the Entitlement Theory
The Entitlement Theory of Justice in Holdings
The minimal state is the most extensive state that can be justified; any state more extensive violates individual rights.
Distributive justice is not a matter of central distribution, as no central agency or group controls all resources to dispense shares.
Holdings are legitimately generated through voluntary exchanges, actions, and gifts among individuals.
Justice in holdings is defined inductively by three major topics:
Principle of justice in acquisition: Governs the original appropriation of unheld things.
Principle of justice in transfer: Governs the legitimate voluntary transfer of holdings from one person to another (and passing holdings into an unheld state).
Principle of rectification of injustice: Governs the rectification of past violations of the principles of acquisition and transfer.
A distribution is fully just if everyone is entitled to the holdings they possess under the distribution.
The entitlement theory is historical: transitions governed by the principle of justice in transfer are justice-preserving, parallel to how valid logical deductions from true premises are truth-preserving.
Historical Principles Versus End-Result Principles
Historical principles: The justice of a distribution depends upon how it came about and the past actions that generated differential entitlements.
End-result (or end-state / current time-slice) principles: The justice of a distribution is evaluated entirely by structural matrices of who holds what at a given time (e.g., utilitarianism, welfare economics).
End-state principles treat structurally identical distributions as equally just, disregarding earning, desert, production, and historical entitlements.
Patterning and the Entitlement Slogan
Patterned principles: Dictate that distribution must vary along a natural dimension, weighted sum, or lexicographic ordering of natural dimensions (e.g., moral merit, needs, marginal product, or ).
Entitlement theory is unpatterned: no single natural dimension or small set of dimensions dictates the distribution generated by voluntary exchanges, gifts, and bequests.
F. A. Hayek notes that capitalist societies distribute heavily by perceived benefit to others; however, this is only a prominent strand, not an overarching systemic pattern.
Traditional distributive formulas treat production and distribution as separate questions; under the entitlement view, things come into the world already attached to individuals who have entitlements over them.
Entitlement simplification: "From each as they choose, to each as they are chosen."
Liberty and the Instability of Patterns
Distributional patterns cannot be maintained without continuous interference with people's lives.
The Wilt Chamberlain Example:
Assume an initial favored distribution .
Over a season, spectators voluntarily pay an extra special fee of per ticket directly to Wilt Chamberlain to watch him play.
Chamberlain receives , yielding a new distribution .
Because the movement from to arose via voluntary transfers by individuals entitled to their shares under , is just.
Maintaining any patterned distribution requires either stopping people from making voluntary transfers or constantly confiscating resources transferred between consenting individuals.
Rights as Constraints and Sen's Argument
Amartya K. Sen demonstrates that modeling individual rights as relative rankings within a social choice ordering leads to non-linear and intransitive social orderings.
Rights are properly understood not as inputs to be ranked within a social ordering, but as external side constraints on the social choice mechanism.
Legitimate social choice can only operate within the boundaries and constraints fixed by individuals exercising their rights.
Redistribution, Forced Labor, and Self-Ownership
Patterned distributive theories represent theories of "recipient justice," completely ignoring the rights of givers, transferrers, and producers.
Taxation of earnings from labor is on a par with forced labor: seizing the earnings of hours of labor is equivalent to forcing an individual to work hours for another's purpose.
Enforcing end-state patterns establishes partial ownership by others over a person and their labor, undermining classical liberal self-ownership.
Locke's Theory of Acquisition and the Lockean Proviso
John Locke's principle that property originates from mixing labor with unowned things faces boundary issues (e.g., whether spilling owned tomato juice into the ocean constitutes appropriation of the sea or loss of the juice).
The Lockean Proviso: Requires that appropriation leave "enough and as good left in common for others."
Weak Lockean condition: Appropriation is permissible if the position of others is not worsened through the loss of liberty to use what they previously could freely use (or if adequate compensation counterbalances the loss).
The shadow of the Lockean proviso limits property rights in extreme emergency circumstances (e.g., sole ownership of the only water hole in a desert, or refusing castaways access to an isolated island).
In normal market operations, competitive mechanisms ensure that private acquisition does not run afoul of the proviso.