Electoral College
Usually, I've given you a handout, kind of guide dirt taking, you may write on this if you like. We still take your notes digitally. I just really gave this to you to guide them, they're taking on the electrical college a little bit, um, because this is something that is very unfamiliar to a lot of people, kind of the details of it. So I wanted to make sure that you focused in on the things that I really want you to do, right? respect. Um, all right, so, Military College, um, was designed, right, to be the process through which we select our president and vice president, and it was designed very intentionally to be a process that would not focus on popularity, it's why it's not based on the popular vote. So it was trying to remove that aspect of it, to eliminate, hopefully, the, like, I'm gonna vote for George Washington, 'cause I think he's the bestest, he's the coolest. Um, and really try to have a system that would hopefully focus on a more qualified individual, right? I mentioned this back in Module One. But a lot of people will say that, you know, this is an American. Again, we invented it, number one. But number two, it perfectly aligns with our system of government, because we are representative democracy, right? So just like we elect representatives to Congress House and Senate, to pass laws for us, the idea here is that we are electing representatives to choose president and vice president, right? The same principle as that representative system. And so, hopefully, we'll also see, by the time we're done talking about this this morning, that individuals who say, Well, it doesn't matter if you vote for presidents, because it's the electoral college. Hopefully, you will see why that is a really bad statement, and it'll inform statement. because we drive the entire process. All right, so starts with election day. Election day is the first Tuesday. After the first Monday. in November of even number years. Okay, first Tuesday after the first Monday, in November, of even numbered years. Of course, it's every four years, right? First Tuesday after the first Monday, in November, of even numbered years, every four years, right? Now, it seems a little convoluted, but there was a lot of thought and intention in making the selection, bless you. What would have been the problem of just saying, like, November 3rd is election day? Just setting a specific date. Yeah, it changes every year, right? The day of the week, um, rotates, and then it comes, sometimes be on a Sunday, right? And so they couldn't pick a specific date itself. Even November was hyped very intentionally. They picked November because of him, you think about when these decisions were being made, right? And primarily an agrarian economy, at the time, these decisions were being made. And so by picking November, it was after the fall harvest. They needed to make sure dinner didn't interfere with our commerce, right? So it was after the fall harvest, but also before the weather got so bad in winter that it may traveled difficult. Because you're talking at a time, I mean, it's very easy for us to be able to vote, like, Grayson College has a polling place. It was really easy for me, right? I go to work and I can vote. But if not, I can drive 10 minutes, right? And go vote somewhere. But you're talking a time period where people had to travel by horse and wagon, right, in order to be able to go boat. And they have to travel, like, a day or more, in some instances, to get to their county seat. So, if you're trying to do it at a time when there's two foot snow banks, that's gonna make it really difficult. So they kind of thought November would be the sweet spot in that respect. They didn't want to pick a Monday, because, again, you're talking right there next to Sunday, so you could be possibly traveling on a religious day, right? So they're like, No, we'll do Tuesday. So that way, maybe they can start traveling on Monday, right? To get there on Tuesday, in order to be able to vote. And they didn't pick the first Tuesday of November, because it's first Tuesday after the first Monday, right, in November. They didn't pick the first Tuesday in November, because, again, days of the week, and everything, it all adjusts, and what have you, that would mean that sometimes that first Tuesday would be November 1st. What would be the issue if election day were on November 1? Would you let me know? It's a black story. I'm always curious. The labor originally had... All Saints Day. It's a holy day of obligation. So it's another religious reason. So that's why they said first Tuesday after the first Monday, so the earliest movie would be November 2nd, right? So a lot of thought went into picking a day for election day that, to us, now reads very convoluted, right? First Tuesday, you have to the first Monday in November of even numbered years. Now, when we go vote, we are not casting a direct vote for President and Vice President, even though, you know, we'll get our little ballots, and we're, you know, circling, or checking little box, whatever, right? Next to president and vice presidential running mate. We're not casting a direct vote for those candidates. Instead, we are voting for electors. Okay? Instead, we are voting for electoral. I'm going down the sheet just to guide my own luxury trail, okay? So, we're not voting directly for the candidate. instead, we're voting for electors. So that begs the question, then what's an elector, right? People. People, electors are people. These are individuals who have been selected by each candidate to represent them in the electoral college. So each candidate running for president, in every state where they appear on the ballot, is going to hit electors, pick people who are pledged to support them in the electoral college. So again, each candidate, and every state, where they appear on the ballot, is going to pick electors, these people, who are pledged to support them in the electoral college. Now, how many people do they pick? They pick the number of people that matches that state's electoral count. They pick the number of people that matches that state's electoral camp. So, again, each candidate is picking electors, right, these people, in every single state. We're pledged to support them in the electoral college. And number of people they pick depends on that state's electoral count. So how is the state's electoral count determined? It is equal to that state's total representation in Congress House Plus Senate. It is equal to that state's total representation in Congress, House, plus Senate. Yes. States Electoral County is equal to that state's total representation in Congress, House, plus Senate. That's why I'm going much slower today. Well, that stays total representation of Congress House plus seven. So, looking at Texas, how many seats do we have in the U.S. House of Representatives? Three... One dollar. Oh, my goodness. What's going on here? 38? 38? All right, so we have 38 seats in the U.S. house. How many senators do we have? Two, which would make our electoral cow? 40, right? House plus Senate. We have 38 seats in the house, two senators, that makes Texas's electoral count 40. So, again, what that means, then, using the last presidential election as our example, Donald Trump picked 40 people from Texas, right, who were pledged to support him in the electoral college, and Kamala Harris picked 40 people from Texas, who were pledged to support her in the electoral college. Both candidates picked 30 in Florida, 54 in California, 7 in Oklahoma, 28 in New York, right? All over it, every single state. They are picking the number of people who met, and, you know, that matches that state's electoral camp, that are pledged to support him in the electoral college. Okay? So a lot of people being picked, right? Okay. Thank you. Questions to this point. Makes sense. So are they just, like, random people? It's a great question. They typically, let's be real, it's not really Donald Trump and Kamala Harris or the bag. I think Bob is great, right? It's the parties, really. So the party leaders in each state, because they're the most connected, right, to everyone? They're picking people from within the party, so they might be county chairs. It might be state reps, state senators, things like that. People who are active in respective parties. Yeah. Great question. Any other questions to this point? Okay. In 48 of the 50 states, it is winter, takes all. Okay? 48 of the 50 states is winner takes all, which means it does not matter if a candidate wins the popular vote of a state by one vote or a million votes. Whichever candidate wins the popular vote of a state. All of their electors are picked to go vote in the electoral college. Winner tanks all. So again, I'm gonna keep using Texas as an example. So, in the last presidential election, Donald Trump did not win 100% of the vote in Texas. He won about 56% of the popular vote in Texas. It wasn't the 56% of his 40, right, that he picked, go to the electoral college, winner takes all. He won the popular vote, so all 40 of his electors are picked to go vote in the electoral college, and none for Kamala Harris, even though she got over 40% of the vote, right? And that brings up one of the greatest criticisms of the electoral college. is because people say, Well, that doesn't really seem fair, because if you're talking about getting over 40% of the vote, that's still a significant number of people to stay who don't feel they're being represented in the electoral college, right? Because all of Donald Trump's electors were picked, none for Harris. And that doesn't seem really fair for representative, right, of the will of the people. And that's an absolutely valid argument to make. Which is why two states do it differently. Each state gets to decide how to award their electoral votes. Because I said, it's 48 of the 50, right? Maine and Nebraska. Maine and Nebraska, do it differently. Because they agree that this doesn't seem fair, that winner takes all, seems to be anti Democratic. So I'll show you, I'll use Maine as the example. Understanding the Nebraska is a similar process. But just to give you an idea of how it works. So Maine has four electoral notes. That tells them they have two house districts, and then, of course, there are two senators, right? So looking at Maine, in the last presidential election, Kamala Harris won the popular vote of the state of Maine overall. So she received two electoral votes based on the fact that the Senate seats are statewide seats. So the two electoral votes that are based on those senate seats, she received. because she won the state overall. Then they look at the congressional districts. So they have two congressional districts, A and B. Harris won, this one. So now she has one more, so now she has three electoral notes. Right? Trump won beat. So he received the electoral vote based on that house district. So, this divides up, to be more representative, right, of the way the people are voting, because not everybody, in any state in the nation, 100% votes for any single candidate, right? And so they have divided it up, and again, Nebraska does it similarly. to be more representative of how the people are actually voting. Now, does it have a huge impact overall when you're talking main with four electoral votes in Nebraska with five? No. But imagine that a California with 54 electoral loads, or Texas with 40, did that. You would see drastic changes, right? There would be major shake ups in presidential election politics. Because here's, unfortunately, what happens. Because of winter takes all, some states are kind of considered safe for the respective parties. right? Like, people look at California and say, They're gonna vote for Democrats, so if I'm a Democrat, I don't need to waste capital campaigning in California. I'm gonna carry California. If I'm a Republican, I'm not gonna waste capital going out there, campaigning, because I'm not gonna get it. Right? And there are quite a few states in the nation that are solidly, one way or the other, in recent presidential politics, right? And you have to remember campaigns have finite resources, time and money. You have X amount of time to campaign, an X amount of dollars. So, someone who used to run campaigns, you have to be very strategic about where you invest in those things. And I'm not gonna waste capital in a state where I know how it's gonna turn out. So what ends up happening is that candidates spend most of their time in what people call swing states, right? those purple states that aren't consistently Republican or Democrat? And so they spend all of their time in places like Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, right? Florida. All of those types of places, and kind of ignore the other states. And you may get, you get a cursory stop here or there, but they don't spend a lot of time, right? They're, like, living in Pennsylvania in Ohio. during the last days of a campaign, because that matters, right? They're trying to get every single vote there that they can get. because they can't predict it. And it's winter takes all, right? That feeds into this. Because if you split up, the votes in every single state, every state would be competitive, right? Because you'd need every single vote you could get. And that, honestly, would be better, because, honestly, they should be going out there talking to all of us, because the president and vice president are gonna represent all of us, right? So they need to hear and speak to our interests. The things that are important to us, 'cause that does vary state by state. right? Now, some have also said this is a great example of why we should get rid of the Electoral College entirely. Yeah, reject that before he recess. Um, and we're gonna, you know, continue talking about this. But one of the arguments people say is, like, well, maybe you should just go to a popular mode system. I get the idea behind it. But please understand there is no simple solution here, because if we went to a straight popular vote system, please understand that the majority of the population of this country resides in nine states in this country. So nine states would be the deciders, and that's where candidates would spend all their time ignoring the other 41. So it's not the perfect fix. is my point, right? There's no simple solution. This is much better if you really want to talk about being your representative. It makes sense at the time why they didn't want to do something like this, because, again, historically, hand counting ballots, right, is what they had to do. And it takes a long time. So, okay, we get it in history, but today, these things are counted on a computer, right? And so we can get results much quicker. So this is possible today, where it hasn't been historically. But now, as I said, each state gets to decide, right? Doesn't say in the Constitution, winner takes all. Each state decides, it's just passed by a state law of how the state awards their electoral votes. So if you really want to have an electoral college that is more representative, then that's where you make the change. But I'll tell you this, states aren't gonna make that change unless we put the pressure on them. Because for the people in power, they like the way the system works. Works for them. And people in power want to continue their power. And so until it becomes important enough to us, that we actually don't just cry about it on social media, but actually show up on election day and say, We're getting rid of you, if you don't start making changes. They're not gonna do it. Just that's how it is. So, we can make the system better, we just have to, you know, do more than complain on social media about the unfairness of the electoral college. Now... So, we have gone on election day, they cast our ballots. Then what we're doing is we're picking those representatives, right? We're picking the representatives in the various states, indicating who we want to go and vote, right, for president and vice president, these individuals who are pledged to their respective candidates. So now, the electors have to meet, right? When they've been selected, to actually choose president, vice president. He thought the first one was bad. All right, the electors meet the first Monday, after the second Wednesday, in December. The first Monday... after the second Wednesday... in December. Yeah, first Monday after the second Wednesday in December. Now we're screwed. Like, this will be better. First Monday after the second Wednesday in December. So what happens is that the electors who have been picked in the respective states all go to their state capitals to officially cast the vote for President and Vice President. So we don't technically have a president or vice president elected until the electoral college meets in December, right? Why, then, do we feel comfortable in November, being able to say so and so is the winner? Because we have never, ever, ever, ever, never, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever, Have I made my point? Mm hmm. Okay. Had an electoral upset, because the electoral college got there and just went bananas, right? Went differently than we anticipated. Because, as I mentioned, these are individuals who are active within their respective parties, right? And they have hopes, dreams, and aspirations typically beyond serving as an elector. And they're not gonna screw themselves in their party. by going just wild, okay? Now, they do exist as a safety net. We do occasionally have what are called faithless electors. We're an electoral will look differently than they are pledged, but they are few and far between. Only ever a handful, not enough to ever swing an election. And honestly, again, we should hope that that is the case, because if they get there, and then en masse, vote very differently than they are pledged, that means we have messed up somewhere, right? And there is something wrong with a candidate where they feel so compelled as to break from their party ranks and say, We've got to vote differently. Because a mistake was made. That safety net is why the electoral college was created, 'cause imagine this scenario. Imagine that we didn't have the electoral college. right? And we just did a popular road system, and we vote somebody in, right? We have the Legends in November, and we say, Okay, Bob is the winner, great President Bob. Love it. And then, I don't know, somewhere around January. First, we discover that Bob's a serial killer. Oh, crap. That's gonna be a problem. What are you gonna do? If he did it before he was elected, it is not impeachment worthy. Oh. You are stuck with serial killer Bob as your president.. No, the Constitution prohibits data, actually. Officeholders are protected from those types of things while they're currently holding office. Yeah, I'm sorry. Would you be arrested? He could be. Yeah. He could be. But you'd be stuck with him for four years, right? Ow. He's got the military at his disposal, the nuclear luxury. No, legally, we're talking legally things. Legal things here. But, okay, I don't think our bounding fathers were envisioning a serial killer like scenario, but it illustrates the point, right? That's why the electoral college exists. It's an opportunity to have that final check, right? That final say. Because, remember, they were fearful of mobocracy, right? The tyranny of the majority. And so, they wanted to have these representatives who would be that final, like, Yes, this is the person who we should empower in the highest elected office in our government, right? That's the idea behind it. And so, well, we certainly can feel comfortable, because history has told us that we can predict with pretty decent accuracy, right, how the electoral college is gonna end up voting. It still isn't technically a selection for these offices until the electoral college has met, right? They do exist as that last check, that safety net, in case we need it. Okay? No, but he's walking the side roping, and they're gonna fall off, but it's nice when you have to get there in case you do. And that's the whole idea behind having it. Does that make sense? Okay. All right. So, originally, the way that the winners were selected is that, again, the electors would meet in their respective state capitals, and they were told to put two names on a piece of paper. And whoever ended up with the most votes would be president, and whoever came in second would be vice president. It sounds super simple. And it worked for our first two presidential election cycles. Because they were uncontested. Nobody ran against George Washington. He was gonna be dumb enough to run against George Washington. right? That's... waste of time. So, when you only had one person running for president, and then, of course, one person running for vice president, It was really easy to orchestrate, 'cause what you have to make sure, 'cause you can't have everybody put both of their names on a piece of paper, 'cause then, you don't have one who wins, right? is an exact top. So they would be like, Okay, here's what we're gonna do. Everybody's gonna put Washington now, right? We all great. Okay, great, sounds good. And then everybody but you, right? Put John Adams. And you put, I don't care, right? Somebody else doubled it. Okay, it doesn't exist in count. Whatever. Put somebody else. And they were able to ensure, without orchestration, that it turned out the way they wanted, right? And again, it's fine. You can do that when you don't have a contested election. But our first contestant presidential election happened in 1796, and it wasn't 1796 that we realized this system might be a little flawed. Because what ended up happening is we had John Adams, a federalist, who was elected president. And because of poor orchestrations, not the person, not the federals candidate who was running for vice president was picked, but the Democratic Republican candidate for President Thomas Jefferson became vice president. So you had a federalist and a Democratic Republican as president and vice president. Imagine, if you will, a Trump Paris presidency. Right? Terrifying. We're entertaining. I don't know, whichever way you want to go with that. Um, it'd be a lot. Cage match. No. Um, so, it would be a problem. Um, so, we're like, ooh, that's not what that's not what we intended. And so the next election was 1,800. Yeah. It didn't work here, either. Again, poor orchestration. And what ended up happening is Thomas Jefferson was running as the Democratic Republican candidate for president again. And Aaron Burr, who was also a Democratic Republican, who was seeking the Office of Vice President on that ticket. They actually tied in the electoral college. And it took 36 rounds of voting to break the tie. So, we were like, Yeah, there's two names on a piece of paper thing is dope, right? We got to fix this. So we passed the 12th amendment. When the 12th Amendment did, is it separated, it separated the voting for president and vice president. That's very nice thing I understand. Changes the volume. So it separated the voting for president and vice president. So now what happens when the electoral college meets is they get together and they say, Okay, we're casting our ballots for president, right? And then put the one name on a piece of paper. They gather those up, and they're like, Hey, now we're casting the ballot for vice president, right? So they've separated the voting for president and vice president to ensure, to the best probabilities, that we don't have kind of those statues. Now, could it still happen that you result in time? Yes, definitely. Could it still happen that you having president and vice president of different parties selected? Yes, technically. But we've minimized that, right? At least through these snap boobs. of the likelihood of that happening. So the 12th Amendment was really instrumental in making sure that we tried to fix some of these things. that we didn't perceive, right, when they first kind of designed all of this. And just as a note, where our votes are secret ballot, electors or not, because there are representatives, right? So just like we know how members of Congress vote on various bills, because it's public. Same as true of a labelers. We know exactly how they vote. Because they are representatives, their votes have to be public. Funny. Makes sense? Okay. All right, onto the back. In order to win, in the electoral college. Okay, your last bullet's on the backside. In order to win in the electoral college, It takes an absolute majority. What a majority means is 50% plus one, right? There are 538 possible electoral votes. There are 538 possible electoral loads. You said five... 5:30? 538, possible electoral votes. Which made you need 270, right, in order to win? That's your 50% plus one. I need 270 electoral votes in order to win. And that's why, on election night, that's the count, right? Getting to 270. Even if we don't have all of the results in from all of the states, once a candidate goes to 270, that's it. They've got the 50% plus one, right? That is all that is easy. They make it more, but 270 is what they need. in order to get. Now, here's my question. I told you that a state's electoral count is able to their total representation of Converse House system, right? How many total house seats are there in the U.S. House of Representatives? 4:35. 435 plus 100 senators. That's 53. Five. So are there 538? Electoral votes. Where's the extra three? D.C. Yep. Washington, DC. Absolutely. Because, remember, representation of Congress is based on statehood, right? And D.C. is not a state. It's a district. It was designed that way, right? So that no state would have kind of the pull or the power of having the nation's capital in it. So it was set aside on district land. But there are people who live there, right? And so what we have done is in the electoral college, we have awarded to them the minimum number of electoral ones that each state could possibly have, 'cause every state gets at least one same house in two, seven seats. So that's where the extra three come in, while it's five. Okay. So 277 in order to win. Now, if you do not have a presidential candidate who gets that 270, right, who gets that majority, you have an 1800 situation, right, where you have Jefferson and Burr with a tie. Nobody got a majority. in the electoral college. That election from president gets thrown into the House of Representatives. Okay. So there is no presidential candidate who wins a majority in the electoral college. The election is thrown into the House of Representatives. And what happens is that the house will vote as state delegations and choose from the top three presidential candidates. Okay, the House will vote as state delegations. and will choose from the top three presidential candidates. And what I mean is by state delegation, is they don't vote individually as house members, so all 38 representatives from Texas would have to get together and cast Texas as one vote, right? They vote as a state delegation. And so that would mean that you would have to get at least 26 states, right? You have to get 26 states to vote for you in order to win. So that's also what I meant when I said it took 36 rounds of voting to break that tie. There's 36 routes of voting in the House of Representatives. And then you had one dude from Delaware, who, I guess, was just, like, fine, I don't care anymore. Let it be done. Right, he was tired. No, he have real reasons, but, yeah, so he changes the vote, and that's what ended up giving it to Jefferson. So again, one vote does make a difference, right? Now, if no VP candidate gets a majority in the electoral college, they also have to get the 270, right? No, VP candidate gets a majority in the electoral college. That election goes into the Senate. That election will go into the Senate. And what will happen is that, in the Senate, they will choose from the top two VP candidates. And there they do vote as individual senators. They don't vote by state. So you have to give 51 of them in order to be able to win. See, I have to get 51 of them. They notice individual centers. Questions. Did you learn at least one new thing about the electoral college? Yes. Good. Good. I was calling when if I can learn my own things. Um, hopefully the other thing that you see in this, as well, the electoral college certainly does have flaws, admittedly so. Particularly with winner takes all, right? It does have some goals. But it exists as that safety net, number one. We'll talk about negative seven, where I let's say it can be very important. But the other thing is that, hopefully, you see why it is absolutely essential that we do go and vote in presidential elections, because we are the ones who are picking those electors, right? You're gonna ultimately decide President Vice President. So we don't show up, then the candidate, we don't like, their electors might get picked, right? So we absolutely have to show up to say which set of those pledged delegates we want to go vote for President, Vice President. Makes sense. Any questions at all on the electoral college? Good? No. No good? Um... You have your test that is due win? Absolutely. Yes, so do you not take an exam, too, or you just three and four? Make sure that you take it by end of day to day. Also, your Barbary assignment opened, right? That's due next week, so don't lose sight of that. Whenever you get that writing assignment still out there, right, to be working on? I did ask you to read the packet that's the other part of the Module 5 notes. So I lecture the electoral college, and I've given you tied notes, right? For the other part. Did anyone have any questions on anything in the packet that was unclear? Now I did a great job, actually. Gold star for me. So, if you haven't read them, do make sure you read them, because this will be information that progress on your next exam right after this one. Moving towards the next test. And these are considered part of your notes, and so you absolutely can use them when you're taking the test. Okay, so just like PowerPoint and things like that. Okay? Shall we feel good about where we are? Okay. So we've got just a few minutes, so keep it to a dull door. Um, if you want to work out some stuff with this class, with another class... Yeah, I know, so I need to check the profile. Did everyone sign the attendance sheet? My writing might be a little... You didn't sign the tendency, make sure you'd find it, and sign it now, please. Langer, you know what we're doing now today? Oh, I know. Where are these? Oh, it's been nice. Oh, that's in my binder, isn't it? Are we not in her classroom? No, it's library. I can't. I've played him a week.