Honors Final Spring 2026
Response
3/9/26
Letter from Sor Filotea background
In 1690, the bishop of Puebla, Manuel Fernandez de Santa Cruz, published the Letter from Sor Filotea (a pseudonym) as a preface to the Athenagoras Letter
Sor Juana’s critique of that priest's sermon
Its incendiary
Sor Filotea was the pseudonym for the Bishop of Puebla, Manuel Fernandez de Santa Cruz
Her letter from Sor Filotea criticizes Sor Juana for studying and writing on secular subjects rather than sacred ones, and reprimands her for ingratitude
The Parable of the Talents in the Gospel of Matthew
25: 14-30
The letter from Sor Juana opens with praise of Sor Juana’s talents, but its actually a pernicious move to count up all her many talents, because Fernandez de Santa Cruz makes those talents into a liability
See end of paragraph on page 87
The bishop references Jesus’ use of parables at the very bottom of pg 86, and refers to the gospel of Matthew in paragraph 2 on page 88
Slavery reference
Allude to slavery in parable of the talents
End of paragraph 1, page 88
Paragraph 1. P. 89
End of paragraph 1 p. 90
Line 95B- get quote for quizlet
The rhetorical structure of the Response
Follows the structure of a classical argument. The translator made it into sections:
Exordium: beginning, pages 90-96, introduction/opening/hook
Narratio: section 1, pages 90-101, the context/background of the topic
Proposito and Partito: section 2, pages 102-110, claim/stance and the argument
Confirmato and Refutatio: section 3, pages 110-124, gives positive and negative proofs of support
Peroratio: conclusion, page 124 last three paragraphs, summary of discourse and call to action
Exordium
The introduction
Modesty topos- even denies using it at top of pg 91 and top of page 92; see also pg 95
Sor Juana addresses her Response to Sor Filotea
She knows that the Bishop of Puebla wrote the letter that attacked her, though. Responding to Sor Filoetea justifies Sor Juana’s use of a more casual tone
In a few parts of the letter, you can tell shes writing to the bishop though
Pg 93 middle: “your having, like another Ahesuerus…”
Pg 120 top: refers to one “of my ancestors”
Pg 125, penultimate paragraph: apology for how she has been addressing Sor Filotea/the Bishop
Silence and the Response
Sometimes silence is the right choice, like when it allows you to listen to another person share their knowledge
See page 116
Sometimes silence is not the right choice though
“I almost decided….saying nothing” pg 92
Page 91 at the top, page 92 at the bottom (see slides), page 93 top, page 97 middle
Her last few years
They silence her
They ban her from reading and writing
3/11/26
Things to read between the lines for
Earnestness
Something
Something
Section 1 (pgs 97-101)
Narratio: the background of the topic
The first sentence of this section uses the word narration
The narratio outlines the basic context for the discourse and the basics of the argument. Sor Juana uses this section of the argument to recount her own personal narrative.
The teacher who taught Sor Juana and her sister to read (96 top)
Cheese (96 middle)
Haircuts (97 top)
Why enter the convent (97 middle)
Women supporting girls
Kitchen jokes
The intellect and the body
Portrays female intellect incredibly different than other classical authors
3/13/26
Constituent elements of opera:
Staging
Scenery
Lighting
Singers/Actors
Costume
Libretto/Book
Dance/Ballet
Orchestra (instrumental ensemble)
Challenges of language: supertitles in many opera houses
Musical style: normally NOT amplified
Artificial conventions: opera is all or mostly all sung
Finance!
Le nozze di Figaro (1786, Amadeus Mozart)
Act one: Opening duet
Count Almaviva’s Castle near Seville
A partially-furnished room with a large armchair in the center
Figaro and Susanna are both servants employed by the Count Almaviva
In this scene we meet Figaro who is engaged to be married to Susanna
Droit du Seigneur
Nobucco (1842, Giuseppe Verdi)
Act one: opening chorus
Set in the sixth century BCE
The priest and people of Jerusalem lament their defeat at the hands of Nabucco, King of Babylon and their impending lives as slaves
The chorus sing “va pensiero”
Risorgimento
Carmen (1875, Geroge Bizet)
Act one: Seguidilla
Set in Seville in the early part of the nineteenth century
Carmen is a factory girl, fatalistic seductress, cigarette smoker and drug smuggler
Carmen has been arrested by the soldier Don Jose who is supposed to keep watch while her fate is decided
Opera comique
Turandot (1942-1926 Puccini)
Act III “Nessun droma”
Recording session
Set in China
Prince Calaf has fallen in love with the cold hearted Princess Turandot. In order to win her hand.
3/16/26
The Diva
There are opera stereotypes
Diva: terminology used to describe the personality of certain opera singers (usually sopranos)
Puccini
1858-1924
Puccini Operas
Le vili- 1884
Edgar- 1889
Manon lescaut- 1893
La boheme- 1896
Tosca- 1900
Madama Butterfly- 1904
La fanciulla del West- 1910
Loa rondine- 1917
Il trittico- 1918
Turandot- 1926
Characters
Madame Butterfly (Cio-Cio-San)
Soprano
Suzuki
Servant of Butterfly
Mezzo soprano
Benjamin Franklin Pinkerton
Lieutenant US Navy
Tenor
Kate Pinkerton
Wife of Ben
Mezzo soprano
Sharpless
US Consul at Nagasaki
Baritone
Goro
Marriage broker
Tenor
Prince Yamadori
Rich Japanese man
Baritone
The Bonze
Cio-Cio-San’s uncle
Bass
The Imperial Commissioner
Bass
The Official Register
Baritone
Trouble
Cio-Cio-San’s trouble
Baritone
Aunt, Uncle Yakuside, Cousin, relatives, friends, and servants
Terminology
Kami
A word used in prayer that means god or spirit
Izaghi and Izanami
Italianization of Izanagi and Izanami, the mythic gods who created the islands of Japan
Bonzo
Italianization of Bonze, a term for a Buddhist monk Nakodo- a matchmaker or marriage negotiator
Mikado
A japanese emperor
Shosi
Geisha
3/18/26
Starts out with some Japanese style notes, but then turns very Western
Pinkerton has this little Star Spangled Banner theme style thing
But its English gentlemen's club music
And then it becomes the American Naval anthem (from that time)
Pinkerton and Gorro are introduced at the beginning of the opera
Gorro = Epstein
Pinkerton is a womanizer, a nationalist, a stereotype of a sailor, an ass
Says he may love Butterfly, but ya know
Sharpless doesn’t share Pinkerton’s attitude
He comes back at the end of the opera to say ‘I told you so’
Exotic wedding ceremony !
Pinkerton and Butterfly meet
Butterfly is 15 here
She asks Sharpless how old he thinks she is, he says ‘maybe 10’
Quick wedding
Announces that she is no longer Butterfly but Mrs. Benjamin Franklin Pinkerton
Her evil uncle shows up, admonishes her for breaking her religion, and disowns her
Then her and Pinkerton are left alone for 16 minutes and it's a beautiful duet of love
Symbolic of love making
The end of Act I is entirely in Puccini’s Italian style
Thank you Nona for this lovely addition
Act II time
We don’t see Pinkerton at all in Act II, returns in Act III and its been three years
Starts in Bach style
Act III Time
Pinkerton returns to his child bride as an 18 year old woman
There is a trio
Pinkerton has regrets (wow!)
Sharpless in sympathy to the actions taking place
Suzuki of great sadness
Suzuki
She confesses (and Butterfly) confess they don’t know if God is listening to them
She suggests that Pinkerton might not come back
She is Butterfly’s friend, confidant, servant, etc.
One Fine Day Aria
Sharpless has a funny motif
Kinda like a nursery rhyme/childish/simple
Yamadori
The old wealthy boyfriend of Butterflys
She unfortunately does not go with him
Trouble
What a lovely name for a child
Butterflys and Pinkertons kid
His music is very western
Like you hear little bits of Star Spangled Banner when he arrives
He has no agency in this story
Pinkerton does not know he exist
Canon explodes in the harbor and announces that Pinkerton has returned
Butterfly and Suzuki cover the house in flowers and make everything pretty
Butterfly sits up all night long waiting for Pinkerton to get to the house
The humming chorus ends Act II
Act III opens
Listen very carefully to the opening
It has the foreshadowing theme
Dawn music
Extended pieces of dawn music
Warning music is in the background when Kate walks in
Kate knows that they have come to pick up Trouble and take him back to the US
Two white people taking away an Asian child from his mother, yea sure ok
The opera ends with a big loud chord from the orchestra, but the last music played in the opera is an unfinished harmony
3/20/2026
The Trouble with Others way of doing things
Kant
What if everyone did things
Sor Juana
Home being interrupted with how other people do things
Christianity
Wish to impose cultural dominance
Conversion
Madama Butterfly
Home being interrupted with how other people do things
Colonialism
Wish to impose cultural dominance
Conversion
Int. of Maladies
Home being interrupted with how other people do things
Immigration
Conversion
Int. of Maladies
Jhumpa Lahiri’s debut work
Published in 1999
Pulitzer Prize in 2000
She wrote out of a sense of loneliness and isolation
Arts in an Int. of Maladies
Photographs
Translation
Cooking
Seduction
Clothing
Applying makeup
Knitting
Entertaining
Religious art
Ancient art
Art in a museum
Art you travel to see
Losing
Conversation
Making a home
Building a life with someone
Building a life in a new country
Decorating a home
Things to look out for
Loneliness
Art
Loss
A Temporary matter
Temporary things
Electricity (p1)
Candles
Seasons
In between Winter and spring
Beauty (p 13b)
Pregnancy
Love (p 21b)
Life
Their son’s (p 21b)
Shukumar’s father (p 6 m/t, 16m, 17t)
‘Used to’ language speaks to what is temporary
‘Used to’ (p. 1b, 6m, 8b)
‘These days’ (3)
‘Before’ (11b)
‘No longer’ (4b)
Seasons
The baby died in September, the story takes place in March
The time period covers the seasonal shift into and out of winter
Passages that highlight the changing season are on p 2, 4 t/m, 15t
The warmer weather, the melting snow. How does this setting in a seasonal shift fit with the bigger story?
Rituals in their game
Rituals help us mark important transitions, happy and sad.
The rice ceremony
They are losses that no one can be prepared for, losses for which there is no clear ritual to guide us through the grief.
Shoba likes to be prepared for so many situations. She makes the rules for their game.
Memories of gatherings at her grandmother’s inform the idea; why does that matter?
Darkness at 8pm; light candles; tell something you haven’t told before.
The art of throwing a party (8-9)
Temporary too
Marks transition
How do you talk to someone in the wake of a great loss?
The doctor’s words aren’t directly quoted (p 3)
They echo as Shukumar observes Shoba get back on her feet (p 5)
They echo in the way Shoba speaks to Shukumar about her decision to move out as her words are not directly quotes (p 20)
Shoba’s unfinished home improvements can be seen differently at the end of the story (p 5-6)
I missed the pictures slide
3/23/26
Sexy
Miranda’s mistress clothes (90b)
Trying on a different identity
How is it like a costume?
Trying to make a dream real?
Also tries on a new identity writing the name Mira in the Bengali alphabet (95)
The way she writes it is like drawing more than writing
A different person in a different language
More art in the story
Rohin asks Miranda to draw the room so he can memorize it (102)
Is ‘not forgetting’ a kind of transcending?
How was his attempt to memorize their day together different from his memorization of capitals?
Rohin also asks Miranda to draw his portrait (102)
Does he want her to remember him?
Rohin draws an airplane (107)
Trying to process his dad’s affair
Or to make sense of the international travel he is in the midst of?
Even more art in the story
Photo of Laxmi and her husband on a bench in front of the Taj Mahal (82,90)
A monument to love
A souvenir of their trip
Monuments and souvenirs are to remember
The mapparium
Glowing stained glass
Maps as art, too, in the Economist and the atlas
Transcending distance?
In seeing the globe represented
In hearing someone whisper from far away
How is memory like hearing someone whisper from far away and feeling it under your skin?
The Taj Mahal and the First Church of Christ, Scientist on the Christian Science Plaza in Boston. The story ends with Miranda sitting on a bench in front of the church. The church looks vaguely similar to the Taj Mahal
Story structure
The first paragraph is like a short story in miniature. It sets up a parallel between two stories of infidelity
The last paragraph also sets up a parallel between Miranda and another couple in the story
Still more art
Religious art of the goddess Kali (94)
The god Shiva lays down for her to step on him, helps Kali transcend her rage
How does religious art in the home help transcend in the sense of coping? Or connecting with the divine?
The Hindu goddess Kali is associated with time, death, and destruction. She also embodies feminine energy, creativity, and fertility.
Careful now
Important passages
Page 87
Lonely to move to a new city. Loneliness of riding the T.
Have you felt similarly on the CTA?
Page 83b
Like a film montage. At 91b, she is imagining another moment to put in the film montage. The scene on the last page feels like such a moment.
Pages 86-87
How does Dev seduce Miranda? (especially at page 87t)
Page 91m
Conversation with a stranger in the dressing room
Page 107
Dev forgets their exchange in the Mapparium
Sexy and Madama Butterfly
Infidelity while your wife is on another continent
Reasons for pairing Sexy and This Blessed House
In Sexy, sexy is defined as loving someone you don’t know (105)
In This Blessed House there is a question about loving someone you don’t quite know (143). And the actual questions: ‘what was there not to love?’ (145) could be taken as what you find out when you get to know the person you love.
This Blessed House
Sanjeev wonders if he loves Twinkle (144), and if she loves him (144)
A thin line between love and hate (145. 153)
The look of characters eyes in moments of confrontation in the stories: 20m/b, 105 t/m, 145b
A thin line between love and irritation (137, 139, 145, esp 152)
Page 152: is the 2nd big paragraph describing love?
Art in the story
A honeymoon souvenir (135)
His memory of their wedding in India has the quality of art (104, 144t)
Sanjeev’s CDs of classical music
Twinkle’s clothes, makeup, jewelry, and shows. Twinkle like a work of art.
All the Catholic religious art they find in their home
1st piece: p. 133t
2nd-6th pieces: p. 134
7th piece: 136t
8th piece: 138m (more than 8 though, because there are multiple switchplates)
Twinkle like a goddess
Or the feminine divine
145, 146 her blue mask is hard (like the statue)
Kali and Mary are both depicted in the color blue
Other crying women in the stories we have read?
153b like a bust, like the silver Jesus in the attic
Could Twinkle and Sanjeev’s dynamic be like the iconography of Kali stepping on Shiva, who has submitted to her?
3/27/26
Why read it?
This unit is making good trouble - while B arguably endorses the idea in general, each of these concepts are complex in her account
Important intellectual tradition: existential ethics
Introduces a new framework that can help us determine how to act ethically in a world characterized by crisis, and remain accountable to ourselves and to other people
Biography: Simone de Beauvoir
Born 1908 in Paris, died 1986 in Paris
Grew up in a middle class Catholic family in Paris. Started rebelling in adolescence
Youngest to pass the aggregation exam in philosophy at the Sorbonne ever (8th woman in history)
Lifelong unmarried non-monogamous partnership with Sartre
Dismissed from teaching in 1941 by Nazis: starts Les Temps Modernes journal with Sartre and others in 1945
Ethics and Ambiguity (1947) followed by The Second Sex
Public intellectual: wrote novels, essays, travel diaries, philosophy; active in feminist and decolonial movement
Background: Occupation of Paris in WWII
1940- Nazi occupation of Paris begins (deportations, murders, scarcity, curfews, censorship of the press)
1940- 1st protest of the anti-fascist French Resistance
1941- Sartre imprisoned near Trier, Germany
1944- French Resistance uprising
1944- Liberation of Paris
1945- 1st municipal elections where women had suffrage
Many small factions; resistance much smaller than most people assume
Existentialism
Key ideas:
Existence precedes essence:
Human beings define themselves through their choices and actions; who we are is not defined or predetermined by God, nature, or anyone else/ We create who we are by engaging with/in the world
We are condemned to be free:
As there’s no one or no thing defining who we are, we take on the task and responsibility of freedom, which is often not that fun- this recognition can cause us anxiety and nausea
Camus’ novel The Stranger (1942)
Peak book
10/10
Better than this shit
Sartre’s novel Nausea (1938)
Samuel Beckett’s play Waiting for Gadot (1978)
Beauvoir’s first novel She Came to Stay (1943)
Ethics Review and the Trolley Problem
Deontology (Kant)
Action = good if expresses duty to will a universal maxim (moral law); treat rational humanity as end in itself. Means and ends are subordinate to the principle they necessarily emerge from. Trolley: is killing a person universalizable or treating them as an ends? No. You must abstain from acting.
Consequentialism/utilitarianism (Mach-ish)
Action = good if it begets the best consequences (greatest happiness for the greatest number, maximal utility, unity of Italy). Ends justify the means. Trolley: pull lever because killing 1 is better than killing 5: save 5 humanity points but lose 1 humanity point
Virtue Ethics (Epictetus-ish)
Action = good if it is an expression of one’s virtuous character (and/or aligns with my ruling principle). Action flows from the virtue, so overall, virtuous intentions and actions matter more than effects or aims. Trolley: If virtue is ataraxia? Do nothing.
Existential ethics (Beauvoir)
Action = good if it advances fundamental freedom and acknowledges the real living embodied limitations of circumstances. Means and ends both matter. Trolley: thought experiments are antithetical to ethical decision making, as they assume we live in an ahistorical vacuum. Ethics is not a math problem, an empty formula, or the cultivation of property. These ethical systems are themselves unethical due to their failure to face reality as it really is.
Good faith and Bad faith
Bad Faith:
A kind of faux self-deception or disingenuousness.
Failure to take responsibility for views or actions
Failure to recognize situational limitations
Failure to treat/view other people with respect as rational human beings
Examples:
The requirement from the Loa
Good Faith:
Living and choosing in a way that invokes fairness, sincerity, authenticity, honest about one’s own biases or limitations
Characterized by respect for another person’s dignity and freedom
Examples:
Using the principle of charity: granting your interlocutor the benefit of the doubt, interpreting their views generously, in the way they probably intended, maximizing truth and plausibility
The serious world and play
Children explore freedom to imagine and from ethical responsibility/accountability - freedom with exuberance but without anxiety
Freedom and Transcendence
The foundation of human subjectivity
The ability to make choices and act as an ethical agent and take responsibility for these choices
Ability to create yourself in the way you want to (‘disclose being’)
Facticity and Innocence
Elements of self and life that one doesn’t choose
Example
Nationality, the era and location we were born in, physical constraints of our environments, our historical pasts
The serious world that appears, and meaningfully is in certain ways, unchangeable- 'that's just the way it is’
Ethical goodness, for Beauvoir, consists in taking responsibility for and actualizing freedom for oneself and others, and recognizing the reality of one’s facticity, or the constraints on one’s freedom in the world
Willing one’s facticity
“Their behaviour…a positive fault” quote page 41
Concerns knowing that one is fundamentally free but choosing unfreedom as the motivation for actions. A kind of bad faith that is a result of leaning passively into external unchosen circumstances. Involves clinging to one’s facticity to avoid the agony of freedom and/or to exploit other people
B acknowledges the important distinction between:
Someone being trapped in ignorance in their facticity- a delusion about the limits of their freedom- in which they don’t know any better. This individual is not morally culpable.
Someone knowing they are free, but choosing to be unfree: yielding one’s freedom- aka one’s humanity- for the ease of living as a facticity. This individual's willing facticity is morally culpable.
Example: invocations of willful ignorance. “I was just doing my job”
These are difficult, tragic, and/or cowardly circumstances
There is a lot at stake, and Beauvoir isn’t under any pretenses about this fact.
Discovering subjective freedom via intersubjectivity in adolescence
“With astonishment… that of others” page 41
Aka growing up- child recognizes that they are free because they see freedom in others: at a certain point, they figure out how they want to be and how they don’t want to be.
Example: recognizing ones’ parents’ complacency or hypocrisy, recognizing the injustice of poverty
Being a good person- acknowledging realities of facticity and freedom to choose how to live- is hard, so we often take solace in simple refusal; the freedom of avoidance, saying ‘No!’
Beauvoirian theme song: you’re not the boss of me now and you’re not so big; life is unfair
Takeaways and Questions
Takeaways
Historical context of Beauvoir’s existential ethics: existential ethical crises (war, violence, genocide, hunger, destruction)
Existence precedes essence; we are condemned to be free
Distinction between freedom and facticity and the problem with willing one’s facticity
Good faith and bad faith
Questions
What do you think of the ideas of ‘freedom’ and ‘facticity’?
Can you think of a time in childhood when you were confronted with a feature of the world or someone’s behaviour that made you ask: “Is the way things are the way they should be?” or “Why am I expected to act a certain way?” Did you do something about it?
Can you think of a memorable time in your life when you acted in bad faith, or a time when you acted in good faith (even when it was hard?)
3/30/2026
Subjectivity through intersubjectivity: recognition
“He discovers his subjectivity; he discovers that of others.” (Beauvoir, 41)
→ Recall that a subject is at their core, freedom
Self-consciousness can be attained “only in another self-consciousness” (Hegel ¶169).
Mutual recognition = condition for free subjectivity
Recognizes w joy that one is free, recognizing w anxiety the responsibilities
Freedom of refusal
Hegel- to become a real self-conscious person (free subject), you have to come into contact w other free subjects
You first encounter objects
By doing stuff, we have a life
When we interact w an external thing, we solidify our idea of ourselves
When we encounter another person, we recognize them as both like and unlike us
It is only thru this encounter that i recognize myself as a human subject
The other is their own person and i am myself my own person
If one part of mutual recognition is distorted, it produces a lopsided perception
Willing one’s freedom & the disclosure of being: - & + freedom
Negative freedom (-)
“No!” - Hegel calls this “freedom of the void”
Universal, indeterminate, empty of content (abstract)
Freedom from authority or limitations. ‘I’ as inwardness
“You’re not the boss of me”
Positive freedom (+)
Beauvoir: …willing one’s freedom & disclosing being (pp 84):
“Yes!” - Hegel calls this the “freedom of self-determination”
Using negative freedom to become a person in the world (concrete)
Freedom as universal ‘I’–aka a human subject–and specific ‘I’–aka an individual
Freedom to become oneself through specific choices and actions; intersubjective
“I am xyz, I do xyz to become who I am”
However, you can’t have positive freedom (willing freedom as a particular and determinate project) without negative freedom (fundamental and universal capacity to will freedom).
We exercise both, but only positive freedom is ethical freedom.
Ambiguity
2 ways
1. Being open to more than one interpretation; having multiple meanings or options
2. Uncertain, inexact
Unlike other existentialists, Beauvoir tells us that we must not be paralyzed by these ambiguities and lack of absolutes: we must act amidst them.
Ex. “Do no harm” (deontology) / “Do less harm” (consequentialism)
Does “doing no [harm]” count as an action? What if abstaining causes harm? (bystander effect)
What about unintended harm? (Save drowning baby–oh no, baby Hitler!, keeping on life support)
What if one person’s harm is another person’s help? (Tough love, confrontation)
When does discomfort, frustration, or conflict become harm? (Couples therapy, micromanaging boss)
Does pain = harm? What about violence? (WWE, resetting a broken limb)
Are there exceptions? (Someone hurting your family)
What about instrumental harm–small-scale harm now to avoid large-scale harm? (Violent revolution)
What if minimizing harm for others harms you? (Going broke giving to charity)
WHen confronted w an ambiguity, we also confront w an ANTIMONY
The antinomies of action
Antinomy: A real or apparent contradiction between two conclusions, both of which seem justified:
...each is interested in the liberation of all, but as a separate existence engaged in his own projects. So much so that the terms “useful to Man,” “useful to this man,” do not overlap… From this angle, we again come upon the same antinomy: the only justification of sacrifice is its utility; but the useful is what serves Man. Thus, in order to serve some men we must do a disservice to others. By what principle are we to choose between them? …But what makes the problem so difficult is that it is a matter of choosing between the negation of one freedom or another: every war supposes a discipline, every revolution a dictatorship, every political move a certain amount of lying; action implies all forms of enslaving, from murder to mystification. Is it therefore absurd in every case? Or, in spite of everything, are we able to find, within the very outrage it implies, reasons for wanting one thing rather than another? 121-122
One might be confronted with a choice to use some human beings, deny their transcendence, reduce them to facticity, as a means to pursue the ends of all human beings, or the advancement of transcendence and improvement of facticity for all.
2 conceptions of the future
Present & future = continuous
Is & will be
Present contains future within it
At least quasi-linear
...the future is the definite direction of a particular transcendence and it is so closely bound up with the present that it composes with it a single temporal form (125)
Present vs. future = separate
Is vs. will be
Future breaks from the present
Episodic
Present = transitory, future = permanent
…only by its efficacy with regard to the coming of the future that the present is validly realized: reduced to itself it is nothing, one may dispose of it as he pleases…ultimate meaning of the formula: the end justifies the means: all means are authorized by their very indifference. (126)
On first glance, progress would be the first one
Not really, it’s actually the second one
blatant/overt hostility to the present (realm of the living)
Man as a “negation” / humanity as a “detotalized totality”
“...this dream is not permitted because man is originally a negativity” 127
Pure negativity: ‘pure’ freedom of negation, destruction, absorption, taking in
Creative negativity: ‘constructive’ freedom of negation; the creative metabolization of reality
…it is a matter of pursuing the expansion of his existence and of retrieving this very effort as an absolute. 85
She notes that there is temptation to think that our power to create ourselves and the world can be complete, that domination of space and time is in our grasp. But it isn’t 130-131 All categories that function as definitive universal ends–humanity, history, the universe–these are “detotalized totalities” or ongoing, evolving processes that we participate in creating into the uncertain future.
We are individual and unpredictable expressions of universal freedom: freedom’s self-realization in real time. Hence, we must try and fail to act freely:
Just as the scientist…does not wait for the light of completed knowledge to break upon it… to make a decision, [we] will not wait for a perfect knowledge to prove to him the necessity of a certain choice; he must first choose and thus help fashion history. A choice of this kind is no more arbitrary than a hypothesis; it excludes neither reflection nor even method; but it is also free, and it implies risks that must be assumed as such. 132-33
We, as individual people, are expansions of the universe because we are free?
Idk
The festival 1: liberation of Paris
The reason we have festivals is to mark an end
Interesting relationship to temporality…
The festival 2: the spectacular present
…holding their present between their hands:
Existence attempts in the festival to confirm itself positively as existence. That is why, as Bataille has shown, it is characterized by destruction… But the tension of existence realized as a pure negativity can not maintain itself for long; it must be immediately engaged in a new undertaking, it must dash off towards the future. (136)
A way to stop time moving forward
An acknowledgement of the simultaneousness of past, present, and future
The people at your birthday party are a sample of your freedom
The morning after:
The moment of detachment, the pure affirmation of the subjective present are only abstractions; the joy becomes exhausted, drunkenness subsides into fatigue, and one finds himself with his hands empty because one can never possess the present: that is what gives festivals their pathetic and deceptive character. (136-7)
Not-so-peppy pep talk
It’s the goals we failed to achieve but made along the way
Question while we walk
We must act
The tasks we have set up for ourselves and which, through exceeding the limits of our lives, are ours, must find their meaning in themselves and not in a mythical Historical end. But then, if we reject the idea of a future-myth in order to retain only that of a living and finite future, one which delimits transitory forms, we have not removed the antinomy of action; the present sacrifices and failures no longer seem compensated for in any point of time… thus are we not ending by condemning action as criminal and absurd though at the same time condemning man to action?” (138-9, 3.4)
Thus we can set up point number one: In the good of an individual or a group of individuals requires that it be taken as an absolute end of our action; but we are not authorized to decide upon this end a priori. The fact is that no behavior is ever authorized to begin with, and one of the concrete consequences of existentialist ethics is the rejection of all the previous justifications which might be drawn from the civilization, the age, and the culture; it is the rejection of every principle of authority. To put it positively, the precept will be to treat the other (to the extent that he is the only one concerned, which is the moment that we are considering at the present) as a freedom so that his end may be freedom; in using this conducting wire one will have to incur the risk, in each case, of inventing an original solution. (153-154 Ch 3.5 - not assigned)
But an action which wants to serve man ought to be careful not to forget him on the way; if it chooses to fulfil itself blindly, it will lose its meaning or will take on an unforeseen meaning; for the goal is not fixed once and for all; it is defined all along the road which leads to it. (165 end Ch.3.5)
Beauvoir, Kant and subjectivism
Covert Kantian?
Deontology: Human beings are free, rational, self-legislating agents; humanity and human beings must be treated as ends in themselves.
Argument against: There is neither a “moral law” nor a homogenous “humanity” for Beauvoir, as the only unifying element amongst all human beings is freedom, which doesn’t have any determinate content.
Subtle subjectivist?
Subjectivism: the idea that actions can’t be judged as right or wrong by any standard outside of oneself.
Argument against: The is a standard for a good action: it involve the advancement of individual and collective freedom, the ability to self-create and justify one's’ actions, and develop an understanding of one’s circumstances. But, of course, none of these have stable definitions.
Or might you say it’s…ambiguous?
Takeaways and questions
It is not enough to exercise negative freedom, though it is a prerequisite for exercising positive freedom: rather, we must realize our subjectivity in the world with other subjects–this constitutes the domain of ethical freedom.
In ethical decision-making, we are confronted by ambiguity and uncertainty, but we have a responsibility to act in spite of it.
In willing positive freedom, we disclose the future in the present; the future is not a static beyond–we make it here and now.
What do you think “making good trouble” means in the context of Beauvoir’s text?
Do you think that–by Beauvoir's lights–freedom can function like an ethical principle, or do you think that she sees freedom as fundamentally different for every person?
Have you ever been to a celebration, party, or festival where you experienced time differently? Did you feel like time stopped? Did you feel out of time or removed from time? Did it speed up time, or did it feel like an eternity?
4/1/2026
The Harlem Renaissance
Not limited to Harlem
1918-1937 (and beyond)
Double-consciousness
How a black person sees themself as the world sees them, and how they view themselves
As a member of an oppressed group and as a person
Black Codes
Curfews, vagrancy laws, labor contracts, women's rights restrictions, land restrictions
Perpetuated slavery after it was made ‘illegal’
The Great Migration
One of the largest movements of people in US History
2 waves:
WWI - WWII
After
Black people escaped the south
St. Louis isn’t much better guys
WWI
Segregated regiments got treated better in Europe & they wanted that kind of treatment in America
The white people got scared (white anxiety)
Red Summer
Race riots because white people were mad
Black people were moving into cities
Black veterans wanted their jobs back
Murder is fundamentally uncool but they did it anyway
Harlem
Originally settled by the Dutch in 1658
Black pop. grew over 40% from 1910 - 1930 (50,000 to more than 200,00)
Red lining :)
Langston Hughes
Born in Missouri B)
Grew up in Kansas and Ohio
Stayed w his father in Mexico after high school
Came to study engineering at Columbia in 1921 but dropped out
racism
Travelled all over Europe
Enrolled and graduated from HBCU Lincoln University
Got a BA
Moved to Harlem where lots of people were gay
Gay icon (people headcannon bc he’s lowkey Nick Carraway)
Championed black pride, racial consciousness, workers
Gladys Bentley
Black Drag balls
Hughes rejects pressure to be ‘respectable
Shuffle Along (and other performances)
A form of entertainment made for white people made by black people)
We Love Josephine Baker
The Savoy was Not Segregated
Swing dancing
Jitterbug
Variations of the Charleston
Harlem becomes ‘fashionable’ to white people
Tension between black cultural expression and white consumption and exoticization
Hughes is skeptical; black culture is being consumed by white audiences, but not respected. Says black artists should create authentically, not to please white audiences.
4/8/26
Freedom vs Funding
Artists had to
Perform ‘authenticity’
Satisfy white expectations
Maintain artistic integrity
Langston Hughs
1901-1967
Rejects white standards
Embraces Black folk culture
Celebrates everyday people
Nella Larsen
1891-1964
Parents from Denmark
They moved to a mostly white neighborhood in America
Privilege: not just whiteness but
Sexuality
Gender
Class
What physical and social privileges
Chapter one: Establishes Irene as narrator and tells us her limitations. Does Irene know herself?
Rooftop: POV
Man fallen on sidewalk
Beauty
Irene described Clare before she recognizes her in stereotypically white beauty standard ways
Master Study Guide: Identity, Ethics, and the Harlem Renaissance
Double-Consciousness (W.E.B. Du Bois): The internal conflict of seeing oneself through one's own eyes while simultaneously being aware of how a prejudiced world perceives you; "two-ness" (American vs. Negro).
The Great Migration: One of the largest movements in US history (6 million people); Black Americans moved from the rural South to the North/Midwest (1910s–70s) to escape racial violence and "Black Codes."
The Red Summer (1919): A period of intense racial violence and riots sparked by white anxiety over Black veterans returning from WWI demanding equal rights and the influx of Black workers into northern cities.
Black Codes: Laws passed in the South after the Civil War (curfews, vagrancy laws, labor contracts) designed to perpetuate slavery-like conditions after it was made illegal.
Freedom vs. Facticity (Beauvoir): Facticity is the "given" (your race, body, past, place of birth), while Freedom is the capacity to choose how you act upon those facts. The ethical goal is to use freedom to "disclose being."
The "Serious World" (Beauvoir): A world where values are treated as fixed, external, and unchangeable. The "serious man" ignores his freedom and acts as if he is a thing or a cog in a machine (Bad Faith).
The Sonnet as Double-Consciousness: A literary technique where Black poets (like McKay) used a strict, high-European poetic form (14 lines, iambic pentameter) to express themes of Black resistance and racial violence.
Claude McKay's "If We Must Die" (1919): A defiant Shakespearean sonnet written during the Red Summer; it argues that if death is inevitable, one should die "nobly" and "fighting back" to force the enemy to show respect.
Claude McKay's "America" (1921): A poem expressing a "love-hate" relationship with the US; describes America as a "tiger" that feeds him "bitterness," yet the poet finds strength in her "vigor" and "bigness."
Countee Cullen's "Heritage" (1925): An exploration of the psychological distance between the African diaspora and Africa; uses trochaic tetrameter to mimic a drumbeat.
"What is Africa to me?": The central refrain in Cullen's "Heritage," highlighting the struggle of being "three centuries removed" from his ancestral home while feeling a primal, rhythmic connection to it.
Double-Consciousness in "Heritage": Cullen describes playing a "double part" where he worships a white "Jesus of the twice-turned cheek" but secretly wishes for a Black God who knows his "kindred woe."
Langston Hughes's Philosophy: A rejection of "respectability politics"; he believed Black artists should create authentically for themselves and celebrate "everyday folk culture" rather than trying to please white audiences.
"The Negro Speaks of Rivers" (Hughes): A poem that connects the Black soul to the ancient "deep" history of humanity (the Nile, Congo, and Euphrates), asserting that Black history is older than slavery.
"The Weary Blues" (Hughes): A poem that uses syncopation and onomatopoeia (Thump, thump, thump) to mimic the rhythm of a blues performance on Lenox Avenue; captures the "melancholy tone" of Black resilience.
The Savoy Ballroom: A famous Harlem venue that was notable for NOT being segregated; a space for authentic cultural expression like the Jitterbug and the Charleston.
Nella Larsen's "Passing": A 1929 novel exploring light-skinned Black characters who "pass" as white; it examines the performance of identity and the "masks" required by a patriarchal, racist society.
Irene Redfield vs. Clare Kendry: Irene is the "stable" narrator who judges Clare for passing, yet Irene herself passes for convenience (at the Drayton) or social propriety. Clare is the "risk-taker" who passes for status/safety.
The "Drayton Rooftop" Incident: The opening scene of Passing where Irene describes Clare using white beauty standards before recognizing her, establishing the theme of white beauty ideals as a "frame" for the novel.
Intersectional Privilege in "Passing": The idea that the characters are restricted not just by race, but by gender, class, and heteronormative expectations (Irene passing as a "happily married" woman).
The Ambiguity of the Ending (Larsen): Whether Clare fell or was pushed; the lack of closure suggests that "passing" is a performance that can only end in tragedy or further ambiguity.
Sor Juana: "The Response": A 1691 letter defending a woman’s right to study; uses "silence" as a rhetorical tool and argues that "no one is obliged to undertake impossible things" (like repaying God for his gifts).
Sor Juana: "Conversion": Could be viewed as a form of "passing"—making another's way of doing things your own in order to survive or transcend within a dominant culture (Spanish Catholicism).
Puccini's "Madama Butterfly": An opera exploring orientalism and colonial dominance; features "syncopation" and "unfinished harmonies" to mirror the cultural friction between Butterfly (Japan) and Pinkerton (USA).
Jhumpa Lahiri: "Interpreter of Maladies": A collection exploring the "blur" between cultures; focuses on translation, the distance between spouses, and the "loneliness" of the immigrant experience.
Mr. Kapasi & Mrs. Das: Characters in Lahiri's title story who share a "lack of self-knowledge." Mr. Kapasi's role as a "translator" for a doctor mirrors the difficulty of truly communicating across cultural or personal divides.
Beauvoir: Negative vs. Positive Freedom: Negative freedom is the refusal of oppression (saying "No!"); Positive freedom is the constructive "disclosure of being" where you act to create a future with others.
Subjectivity through Intersubjectivity: Beauvoir’s idea (based on Hegel) that we only truly discover our own freedom and self-consciousness when we recognize the freedom and subjectivity of other people.
Part 2
I. Existential Ethics: Simone de Beauvoir
Focuses on the struggle between our limitations and our capacity to choose.
The Ethics of Ambiguity: Beauvoir’s framework for acting ethically in a world of crisis (written post-WWII). It argues that because there is no fixed "essence" to humans, we must constantly create our own values.
Existence Precedes Essence: The core existentialist belief that humans exist first, and then define who they are through their actions. There is no pre-determined "blueprint" for a person.
Facticity: The "givens" of your life that you did not choose (e.g., your place of birth, your body, your past, the fact that you will die).
Freedom: The capacity to move beyond facticity. To be free is to "disclose being"—to make the world meaningful through your choices.
The "Serious World": A world where values are treated as ready-made and unchangeable. The "Serious Man" hides his freedom behind a cause or a job (e.g., "I'm just doing my job") to avoid the anxiety of choice.
Bad Faith (Mauvaise Foi): A lie told to oneself. It is the act of pretending you are a "thing" with no choice, rather than a free subject.
Negative Freedom: The "freedom of avoidance"—the ability to say "No" to oppression or a situation you dislike. It is a prerequisite for positive freedom.
Positive Freedom: The constructive act of "disclosing the future" by making choices that create a world where others can also be free.
Intersubjectivity: The idea that my freedom depends on the freedom of others. I only truly discover my own subjectivity when I recognize others as free subjects, not objects.
The Festival: A Beauvoirian concept (citing the Liberation of Paris) where time feels "out of time." It represents a moment where people experience the "spectacular present" and their shared freedom.
II. Baroque Intellect: Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz
Focuses on the right to knowledge and the "masks" of the colonial era.
The Response (1691): Sor Juana’s letter defending her right to study. It uses the "Narratio" style to tell her life story, including her childhood hunger for learning (cutting her hair, avoiding cheese).
Rhetoric of Silence: Sor Juana’s strategy of using silence to "say a great deal." She argues that sometimes silence is the only way to listen or to avoid "impossible" explanations.
"No one is obliged to undertake impossible things": Her defense against the Bishop’s accusation that she wasn't "repaying" God. She argues no human can repay the infinite gift of God/life.
Syncretism: The blending of different beliefs (Aztec and Spanish Catholic). In the Loa to the Divine Narcissus, she uses the Aztec "God of Seeds" to explain the Catholic "Eucharist."
Tocotin: An Aztec song/dance. Its inclusion in her plays shows how she blurred the lines between indigenous culture and Spanish form.
III. Colonial Friction: Giacomo Puccini
Focuses on cultural dominance and "unfinished" identities.
Orientalism: The depiction of the "East" (Japan) by the "West" (Italy/USA) as exotic, feminine, and weak.
Cio-Cio San (Butterfly): A character who "converts" to Christianity and Americanism for Pinkerton. Her tragic flaw is her total commitment to a "mask" that Pinkerton views as a temporary toy.
Unfinished Harmony: The musical structure of Madama Butterfly. The opera often avoids resolving chords, mirroring the "unfinished" or "unresolved" status of Butterfly’s life and marriage.
Syncopation in Butterfly: The rhythmic "displacement" in the music that represents the cultural friction and tension between the Japanese and American characters.
IV. Translation & Displacement: Jhumpa Lahiri
Focuses on the "maladies" of the immigrant experience and marriage.
Interpreter of Maladies: The title refers to Mr. Kapasi’s job translating symptoms for a doctor, but also his (and Mrs. Das’s) inability to "translate" their own emotional pain to others.
The Mapparium: A setting in the story "Sexy" that represents "transcending distance"—hearing a whisper from across the globe, yet remaining emotionally distant from the person standing next to you.
"Sexy": Defined in the story as "loving someone you don't know." It represents the danger of loving a "fantasy" (the "Other") rather than a real person.
The Third and Final Continent: A story about the narrator’s transition through three eras/continents. It explores how encountering "the other" (Mrs. Croft) can change one's relationship with their own culture.
V. The Harlem Renaissance & Nella Larsen
Focuses on Double-Consciousness and the performance of identity.
Double-Consciousness: W.E.B. Du Bois’s term for the "two-ness" of being Black and American. Seeing oneself through the eyes of a world that views you with "contempt and pity."
Redlining: Systemic housing discrimination that restricted Black populations to specific neighborhoods (like Harlem or the South Side of Chicago).
The Sonnet as Resistance: Claude McKay’s use of the Shakespearean sonnet (a European form) to describe racial violence, effectively using the "master's tools" to dismantle the "master's house."
"If We Must Die" (McKay): A call for "noble" death and defiance. It turns the "hunted" into the "fighter."
"Heritage" (Cullen): Explores the mental "track" of Africa in the mind of a "civilized" Christian Black man. It uses Trochaic Tetrameter (DA-dum, DA-dum) to mimic a heartbeat or drum.
"The Weary Blues" (Hughes): Uses Syncopation and blues rhythms to celebrate the resilience and "melancholy tone" of Black folk culture.
Passing (Nella Larsen): The 1929 novel exploring the "performance" of race. It asks: "When is it ethical to pass?" and "Who is actually passing?"
Irene’s Narrative Limitation: Irene is a "3rd person limited" narrator who is often biased or in "Bad Faith" about her own feelings for Clare or the stability of her marriage.
The Drayton Rooftop: The "inciting incident" where Irene and Clare meet while both are "passing" for convenience/safety. It establishes "White Beauty Ideals" as a frame for the novel.