Body snatchers
The Role of Bodies in Medical Science
Historical Context
18th Century: Surgeons required extensive knowledge of anatomy for training.
Increased demand led to the establishment of new medical schools.
Legal and Illegal Body Acquisition
Legal access limited to bodies of executed criminals post-Enlightenment laws.
Surgeons often resorted to illegal means (body snatching) to acquire cadavers for study.
Term: Resurrectionists or resurrection men were those who illegally snatched bodies.
Notable Depictions
"Death oversees the work of grave robbers" (Thomas Rowlandson, 1775) illustrates societal views on body snatching.
Legislative Changes
Anatomy Act of 1832
Preceded by the Murder Act of 1751 which restricted burial of executed murderers to prevent misuse of their bodies.
Anatomy Act legalized the use of unclaimed bodies, predominantly from the poor and criminals.
Impact
Greater supply of cadavers for medical students but also cultivated a black market due to high demand.
Surgeons sometimes resorted to murder to supply bodies for profit, notably illustrated by Burke and Hare's notorious activities.
Ethical and Religious Considerations
Dissection and Religion
Many religions held beliefs regarding resurrection, advocating for intact bodies after death.
Originally, dissection was allowed only for criminals as a punishment.
The body snatching phenomenon facilitated legalization of unclaimed bodies, particularly from workhouses.
Literary Representation
The poem "The Body Snatchers" by David Lewis Paget reflected on physicians’ need for fresh cadavers for dissection.
Notorious Figures in Body Snatching
Burke and Hare
Responsible for the deaths of 16 individuals to sell their bodies for medical study.
Sold stolen bodies to Dr. Robert Knox, an established medical educator.
Burke was executed, whereas Hare and Knox fled from justice.
The term "Burking" emerged associated with murder for dissection purposes.
Countermeasures Against Body Snatching
Protection of Corpses
Wealthy individuals hired "watchers" to guard graves until decomposition rendered bodies unusable.
Use of mortsafe (heavy cage over graves) to deter body snatchers.
Even medical students participated in grave robbing, showing the depth of the issue.
Social Class and Burial Practices
Potter's Field
Designation for public burial grounds for the poor and unclaimed bodies.
Viewed as a warning against social immorality, housing the indigent and marginalized.
Segregation in Death
Historical disparities based on race and social class; marginalized groups often buried in separate graveyards.
Contemporary Reflections on Body Trading
Body Parts and Commodification Today
Discussions on modern parallels to body snatching, including the sale of body parts and commodities.
Examples: egg and sperm sales, organ trade, and exploitation in desperate socio-economic scenarios.
Black Market Organ Trade
Exploitation of victims from the Global South by those in the Global North seeking organs.
The Plasma Industry
Blood Plasma Donation
Plasma comprising the liquid part of blood remains vital for many medical treatments.
Industry generates significant revenue, with ethical concerns based on the vulnerability of donors.
Regulatory Responses
Canada prohibits the sale of organs, emphasizing an altruistic model for blood and plasma donation.
Critiques of US practices showing exploitation of impoverished neighborhoods for plasma collections.
Exploitative Practices and Inputs
Financial Dependency
Many donors rely solely on proceeds from plasma donation for basic needs, illustrating socio-economic desperation.
Personal testimonies showing reliance on plasma for survival, raising ethical questions.