Body snatchers

The Role of Bodies in Medical Science

  • Historical Context

    • 18th Century: Surgeons required extensive knowledge of anatomy for training.

    • Increased demand led to the establishment of new medical schools.

  • Legal and Illegal Body Acquisition

    • Legal access limited to bodies of executed criminals post-Enlightenment laws.

    • Surgeons often resorted to illegal means (body snatching) to acquire cadavers for study.

    • Term: Resurrectionists or resurrection men were those who illegally snatched bodies.

  • Notable Depictions

    • "Death oversees the work of grave robbers" (Thomas Rowlandson, 1775) illustrates societal views on body snatching.

Legislative Changes

  • Anatomy Act of 1832

    • Preceded by the Murder Act of 1751 which restricted burial of executed murderers to prevent misuse of their bodies.

    • Anatomy Act legalized the use of unclaimed bodies, predominantly from the poor and criminals.

  • Impact

    • Greater supply of cadavers for medical students but also cultivated a black market due to high demand.

    • Surgeons sometimes resorted to murder to supply bodies for profit, notably illustrated by Burke and Hare's notorious activities.

Ethical and Religious Considerations

  • Dissection and Religion

    • Many religions held beliefs regarding resurrection, advocating for intact bodies after death.

    • Originally, dissection was allowed only for criminals as a punishment.

    • The body snatching phenomenon facilitated legalization of unclaimed bodies, particularly from workhouses.

  • Literary Representation

    • The poem "The Body Snatchers" by David Lewis Paget reflected on physicians’ need for fresh cadavers for dissection.

Notorious Figures in Body Snatching

  • Burke and Hare

    • Responsible for the deaths of 16 individuals to sell their bodies for medical study.

    • Sold stolen bodies to Dr. Robert Knox, an established medical educator.

    • Burke was executed, whereas Hare and Knox fled from justice.

    • The term "Burking" emerged associated with murder for dissection purposes.

Countermeasures Against Body Snatching

  • Protection of Corpses

    • Wealthy individuals hired "watchers" to guard graves until decomposition rendered bodies unusable.

    • Use of mortsafe (heavy cage over graves) to deter body snatchers.

    • Even medical students participated in grave robbing, showing the depth of the issue.

Social Class and Burial Practices

  • Potter's Field

    • Designation for public burial grounds for the poor and unclaimed bodies.

    • Viewed as a warning against social immorality, housing the indigent and marginalized.

  • Segregation in Death

    • Historical disparities based on race and social class; marginalized groups often buried in separate graveyards.

Contemporary Reflections on Body Trading

  • Body Parts and Commodification Today

    • Discussions on modern parallels to body snatching, including the sale of body parts and commodities.

    • Examples: egg and sperm sales, organ trade, and exploitation in desperate socio-economic scenarios.

  • Black Market Organ Trade

    • Exploitation of victims from the Global South by those in the Global North seeking organs.

The Plasma Industry

  • Blood Plasma Donation

    • Plasma comprising the liquid part of blood remains vital for many medical treatments.

    • Industry generates significant revenue, with ethical concerns based on the vulnerability of donors.

  • Regulatory Responses

    • Canada prohibits the sale of organs, emphasizing an altruistic model for blood and plasma donation.

    • Critiques of US practices showing exploitation of impoverished neighborhoods for plasma collections.

Exploitative Practices and Inputs

  • Financial Dependency

    • Many donors rely solely on proceeds from plasma donation for basic needs, illustrating socio-economic desperation.

    • Personal testimonies showing reliance on plasma for survival, raising ethical questions.