Queer Time
Queer Time
Screening Details
Time: 6:30 PM
Location: 188 Dwinelle
Responses - Analysis + Reflection
Instructions for responding to the readings:
Quote Contextualization:
Do not leave a quote from the reading in isolation.
Explain what the author means, specifying their argument.
State concretely what their claims are.
Critical Reflection on Argument:
Analyze how their argument applies to the chosen scene.
Express agreement or disagreement with the author.
Description of Scene:
Focus on showing rather than telling.
For instance:
Instead of stating, "The scene between Lil Nemo and the cat was very melancholic," elaborate:
“The scene between Lil Nemo and the stray cat illustrates Gopinath’s argument in several ways. For example, the idea of the closet is expressed by the positioning of Nemo in the foreground behind a one-way mirror, with the stray cat in the background, oblivious to Nemo’s presence. This composition highlights that the ‘hidden domain’ of the closet is emphasized in the foreground rather than lingering in the rear, implying that…"
Queer Spatial Frameworks/Arrangement
Key components of queer spatial frameworks include:
The Closet (Inside – Outside): Understanding the dynamics between what is hidden and revealed.
Public vs. Private: Tension and distinctions between public displays of identity and private experiences.
Center and Periphery: The positioning of queer identities within societal structures.
Allegory (Visible – Above / Hidden Meaning - Underneath): Layers of meaning in queer narratives.
Homonationalist Optic:
Views the WEST as authentically queer and the EAST as compromised, reinforcing a binary perception.
The GLOBAL NORTH is seen as QUEER/LIBERAL/FREE while the GLOBAL SOUTH is viewed as FIXED, UNCHANGING, HOSTILE, and HOMOPHOBIC.
Gopinath argues, “A queer diasporic formation works in contradistinction to the globalization of ‘gay’ identity that replicates a colonial narrative of development and progress, which judges all ‘other’ sexual cultures, communities, and practices against a model of Euro-American sexual identity.”
Queerness in Content vs. Structure
Queerness Questions the Dominant Order:
It illuminates alternative arrangements and structures within narratives.
Impact on Cinema:
As noted by Thomas Waugh, “gay narratives tend toward open-endedness, displacement, and deferral instead of classical closure.”
For Gopinath, the concept of Queer Diaspora transcends merely identifying “queer people in the diaspora”; it constitutes an interrogation of the prevailing narratives that legitimize diasporic lives only when they replicate patriarchal genealogies.
Queer Diaspora serves as a framework that salvages forms of existence rendered illegible or worthless by dominant cultural forces.
Analyzing Temporal Arrangements
Temporal Sense in Scenes:
How sequences evoke a sense of time.
For example, how does the scene in the laundrette at night characterize time?
Mise-en-scene:
Temporal Margins:
The laundrette serves late-night patrons who are out of step with society’s dominant timeframes, including working-class, unhoused individuals, and those without nuclear families.
This space accommodates multiple temporal experiences, all disjointed from the societal timeline.
Character Example:
Omar’s father: Described as a temporal deviant, appearing ghost-like and anachronistic in fashion.
His melancholic presence embodies being stuck in the past, haunting progress-oriented diasporas.
Chrononormativity (by Elizabeth Freeman)
Definition: Norms as temporal schemes derived from repetition and iteration.
Bodies in society experience synchronization not just with each other but also with larger temporal frameworks.
These frameworks represent strategies for living such as marriage, wealth accumulation, reproduction, and death rituals, thus framing belonging as a natural experience.
Exploring Space and Time
Question of Inhabiting Temporal Frameworks:
At Dwinelle, although we collectively occupy the same physical space, do we share identical temporal frameworks?
Edelman’s Argument on Temporality
Main Argument:
Lee Edelman posits that ordinary perceptions of temporality, such as linear narratives and ideas of progress, limit political possibilities.
He states, “Queer” embodies anything that exists outside or remains unrealized under conventional temporal regimes.
“Reproductive Futurism”: Logic that binds one to political discourse defined by reproductive outcomes, preserving the hegemony of heteronormativity.
This framing renders queer resistance inconceivable, thus masking alternate forms of existence from mainstream political discussion, particularly in cinematic contexts.
Characteristics of Classical Cinema
Narrative Structures:
Typically characterized by one or two protagonists.
Follows a three-act structure, inherently incorporating heterosexuality into its narrative frameworks.
Heterosexual romance acts as the primary motivation within this aesthetic structure.
Frameworks for Legibility
Inextricable Link:
Personal histories gain visibility only within a state-sponsored timeline, which aligns with a nation’s economic interests.
“Three Act Structure” is an aesthetic reflection of social systems.
Hetero-synchrony
Definition:
“Heterosynchrony” describes the enjoyment of harmonizing disparate elements against all odds to produce pleasurable narratives marked by progress and closure.
Film Analyses
Lingua Franca
Directed by Isabel Sandoval (Philippines, 2019)
Film Distributed by BFI London Film Festival
Goodbye, Dragon Inn
Jean Ma's Analysis of Tsai's Films
Rich Reflection:
“The negativities of absence and inaction generate temporal and spatial displacements that diffuse queerness throughout the texture, structure, and rhythms of Tsai’s films.”
“This discourse offers a hermeneutic key to understanding the subtle body politics in his films, focusing on the body’s unbinding from fixed identity coordinates, revealing new forms of fragmented and incomplete corporeality.”
Social Identities as Temporal Constructs
Key milestones in forming social identities:
Birth
Schooling
Marriage to one person
Children
Death
Wealth accumulation
Cruising as Queer Practice
Cruising Definition:
“Cruising for sex” involves searching for a sexual partner, typically anonymous and casual, characterized by solitude and a desire for connection.
Jean Ma describes cruising as “indirection,” an unstructured journey foreseen without a predetermined endpoint.
In Goodbye, Dragon Inn, this theme of desire is exemplified through moments that do not culminate in romantic fulfillment, showcasing a circuitous navigation of suppressed expressions and missed connections.
Slowness in Cinema
Key Concept:
Characterized by “significant attenuation of narrative into expanded temporalities that alter our typical relationship with cinematic time.”
The Principles of Classical Narrative
Structural Elements:
Main characters articulated through psychological motivations working against obstacles towards a defined goal.
This entails primary narratives intertwined with secondary narratives and consists of a clear beginning, middle, and end, typically culminating in a resolution.
Classical Hollywood cinema subjects its characters to defined traits and active pursuits grounded in causal agency with little randomness in event occurrences.
Fuhe, Grand Theater (Taipei)
Highlighted as a Highly Self-Reflexive Space:
The awareness of film viewing intertwines with reflexivity associated with queerness.
Jean Ma articulates, “Although the narrative is contained within the mise-en-scene of the movie theater, the spatio-temporal unit is fractured by the presence of intersecting worlds.”
Homosexuality and Temporality
Associated Themes:
Out of Sync: Homosexual desire operates outside a heteronormative reproductive imperative, often described as ghostly due to perceived untimeliness.
Jean Ma refers to the oppressive timelines regulating sexual and gender identities, which maintain sync with capitalist rhythms and collective national narratives.
The Closet Framework
Critique of Western-Centric Narratives:
The closet serves as an “Anglo-American centric identity-politics framework” that focuses on the coming-out narrative—often viewed as foundational in gay filmmaking.
It identifies how present discussions of gay and lesbian movements in non-Western contexts frequently impose these Western norms as universal standards, often overlooking critical cultural differences.
Forms of Queer Time
Key Terms:
Anachronism
Asynchrony
Slowness
Inattention
Excision
Ellipsis
Each represents varying manifestations of queer time that defy conventional temporal expectations.