HTBMR - Thinking Scientifically & Research methods

Thinking Scientifically

  • Introduction to Research Methods and Scientific Thinking

What is Science?

  • True science incorporates rigorous scientific methods to validate and verify information.

  • Features of true science include:

    • Systematic Empiricism: Approach based on structured observations and evidence.

    • Publicly Verifiable Knowledge: Knowledge that can be independently confirmed by others.

    • Replication: Ability for studies to be replicated and results verified by different researchers.

    • Peer Review: The process where research is evaluated by other experts in the field before publication.

    • Empirically Solvable Problems: Issues that can be answered through observation and experimentation.

  • Differentiates science from nonscience.

Defining Social Science

  • Social science is described as the "scientific study of social, cultural, psychological, economic, and political forces that guide individuals in their actions" (Hunt & Colander, 2014).

  • Importance of the accumulation of knowledge concerning human behavior and societal structures.

  • Acknowledgment that the understanding of human behavior has not always been framed through scientific approaches.

Types of Sciences

  • Natural Science: Includes areas such as:

    • Physics

    • Chemistry

    • Biology

  • Social Science: Areas include:

    • Sociology

    • Psychology

    • Anthropology

  • Humanities: Encompasses fields like:

    • Literature

    • Music

    • Philosophy

  • Overview of how different branches contribute to scientific knowledge.

Steps of the Scientific Method

  1. Observation: Noticing a behavior or phenomenon.

  2. Question: Formulating a question or stating a problem based on observations.

  3. Hypothesis Formation: Creating tentative explanations for the observations.

  4. Hypothesis Testing: Conducting systematic, planned observations to gather data.

  5. Conclusion: Using gathered observations to support, refute, or refine the original hypothesis.

Research Basics

  • Research Defined: The pursuit of knowledge to uncover information that is not already known, addressing gaps in current understanding.

    • Quote: "Advancing the frontiers of knowledge" (Walliman, Ch. 1, pg. 7).

  • Research Methods: Tools and techniques used to collect, interpret, and analyze information to derive valid conclusions.

    • Definition of valid: Accurately measuring the intended construct and ensuring that conclusions reflect reality.

Types of Research

  • Quantitative Research:

    • Generates numerical data;

    • Data analyzed through statistical methods for summary and interpretation.

  • Qualitative Research:

    • Focuses on observations;

    • Data summarized in narrative formats.

  • Mixed Methods:

    • Combination of quantitative and qualitative approaches in a single study.

Characteristics of Quantitative Research

  • Numeric Patterns: Investigation focused on quantitative data.

  • Deductive Process: Research aims to test predetermined hypotheses.

  • Standardized Instruments: Utilization of consistent measurement tools.

  • Larger Samples: Often employs large, random selections of participants.

  • Laboratory Focus: Researchers frequently conduct experiments in controlled settings.

Quantitative Research Strategies

  • Descriptive Strategy: Describes characteristics or behaviors within a group using averages or percentages.

    • Example: On average, local college students study 12.5 hours/week and sleep 7.2 hours/night.

  • Correlational Strategy: Examines relationships between two variables without implying causation.

    • Example: Observed correlation between wake-up times and GPA among college students; the reason remains unexplained.

  • Experimental Strategy: Aims to establish cause-and-effect relationships through manipulation and control of variables.

    • Example: Increasing exercise levels leads to a decrease in cholesterol levels.

Elements of an Experiment

  • Independent Variable (IV): The variable that is manipulated in the experiment.

  • Dependent Variable (DV): The outcome variable that is measured, which changes due to the IV's manipulation.

  • Extraneous Variables: Factors not being tested that may affect the DV.

  • Confounding Variable: An extraneous variable that varies along with the IV and could falsely influence the results.

Controlling Extraneous Variables

  • Methods for controlling extraneous variables include:

    • Holding a Variable Constant: Keeping certain variables the same across all conditions.

    • Matching Variables: Ensuring that variables are equivalent across treatment conditions.

    • Random Assignment: Randomly allocating subjects to different treatment groups.

What is Qualitative Research?

  • Defined as a method that uses words as data, which are collected and analyzed in various ways (Braun & Clarke, 2013, p. 3).

  • Focuses on studying phenomena in their natural environments to interpret the meanings people assign to them (Denizen & Lincoln, 2013, p. 3).

Characteristics of Qualitative Research

  • Emphasis on understanding from participants' perspectives.

  • The researcher acts as the main instrument of data collection.

  • The research process is typically inductive, where data collection leads to the development of concepts or theories rather than confirming pre-existing hypotheses.

  • Outputs from studies tend to be richly descriptive.

  • Sample selection is generally small, targeted, and nonrandom.

  • A significant amount of research occurs in natural or field settings, rather than controlled environments.

Qualitative Research Strategies

  • Ethnography: Scientific and descriptive examination of cultural groups and practices.

  • Interviews: Systematic dialogues ranging from structured to casual formats.

  • Observations: Directly witnessing and documenting phenomena.

  • Documents & Artifacts: Analyzing relevant materials connected to the research subject.

Interviews

  • Defined as structured conversations with informants varying in formality.

    • Types include:

    • Structured Interviews: Highly formal with predefined questions.

    • Open-ended Interviews: Allow for expansive responses.

    • Casual Conversations: Informal discussions aimed at gathering insights.

Focus Group

  • Semi-structured group discussions led by a moderator focusing on specific topics.

  • Typically involves 6-12 participants with a critical emphasis on selection criteria.

Participant Observation

  • Conducted in the natural environment of the research subject.

  • Allows for first-hand accounts of behaviors rather than mediated perceptions.

  • Researcher may take on roles as either an observer or active participant.

  • Building rapport with subjects is essential, as is respecting their customs and practices.

Case Studies

  • In-depth explorations of distinct subjects or systems (

    • Examples: A person, program, group, institution, or policy).

  • Aim to understand complex issues thoroughly.

  • Include historical analyses when relevant.

  • Focus can be narrow, involving extensive interviews for personal narratives.

  • Comparative Case Studies: Analysis contrasting multiple subjects or cases.

Mixed Methods Research

  • Integration of quantitative and qualitative methodologies in analysis.

  • Types include:

    • Convergent: Simultaneous collection of both data types.

    • Explanatory Sequential: Quantitative data collected first, followed by qualitative data to explain findings comprehensively.

    • Exploratory Sequential: Qualitative data collected initially, informing subsequent quantitative surveys.