Introduction to Scientific Method, Theories, and Pseudoscience

Experimental Design and Peer Review

  • Peer review requires independent experts to examine and attempt to replicate scientific findings.
  • Experiments must manipulate only one changeable characteristic (variable) at a time to avoid confounds.
  • Confounds occur when multiple variables are tested simultaneously, causing confusion in experimental interpretation.
  • Controls are used to ensure variables are accounted for and to highlight differences in experimental groups.
  • Scientific studies must be repeatedly executed; testing a small group (such as 1010 to 1212 subjects in clinical trials) once does not represent an entire population.
  • Biases can skew scientific work; objective evaluation (such as blinded peer review) increases female first-author publishing success beyond the 23.7%23.7\% rate observed when author sex is known.

Scientific Theories, Laws, and Facts

  • Facts and laws describe observable events in the natural world, such as the law of gravity.
  • Theories explain why natural phenomena occur and require extensive testing and consensus across multiple fields.
  • Cell theory (states all organisms are composed of cells) and evolution are primary examples of biological theories.

Pseudoscience and Misleading Claims

  • Pseudoscience utilizes scientific terminology mistakenly or intentionally to spread misinformation, manipulate data, or sell products to consumers.
  • Claims based on improper studies:
    • Trident gum marketed that 44 out of 55 surveyed dentists recommend sugarless gum, despite dentists warning against mastication due to TMJ damage.
  • Claims based on nonexistent research:
    • Airborne claimed for over 2020 years to boost the immune system based on a "rigorous clinical study" that was never conducted, resulting in government intervention and a class-action lawsuit.
  • Claims based on fabricated data:
    • In 19981998, Andrew Wakefield published a fraudulent paper in The Lancet asserting that MMR (measles, mumps, rubella) vaccines caused autism using fabricated data from 1212 children.
    • Wakefield faked data to financially benefit from a patented alternative vaccine and funding from parents of autistic children.
    • Following retraction of the paper and loss of his medical license, Wakefield relocated to Austin.
    • Reduced vaccination rates caused resurgences of previously controlled pathogens, including measles, mumps, rubella, whooping cough, and polio.

Questions & Discussion

  • Why do commercial entities use scientific jargon?
    • Companies aim to appear trustworthy and gain consumer confidence to sell products quickly.
  • How did fraudulent vaccine research clear peer review?
    • Peer reviewers were bribed and paid out, bypassing proper review standards prior to attempts at replication by the wider scientific community.