Sunni vs Shia

Sunni vs. Shia Islam Study Guide

1. Origin of the Split

• The division began after the death of Muhammad in 632 AD.

• Muslims disagreed about who should succeed him as leader of the Muslim community.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

Sunni View

• Believe Muhammad did not name a successor.

• Leadership should be chosen through consensus (shura) among the Prophet’s companions.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• This led to the election of Abu Bakr as the first caliph.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

Shia View

• Believe Muhammad appointed his cousin and son-in-law Ali as his rightful successor.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Leadership should remain within Muhammad’s family (Ahl al-Bayt).

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

2. Shared Beliefs

Despite their differences, both groups share the core beliefs of Islam:

• Belief in one God (Allah)

• Belief in the prophethood of Muhammad

• Follow the Qur'an

• Believe in angels and the Day of Judgment

• Follow the Five Pillars of Islam

  • Shahada (faith)

  • Salat (prayer)

  • Zakat (charity)

  • Sawm (fasting)

  • Hajj (pilgrimage)

    Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

3. Religious Authority

Sunni Islam

• Authority comes from the Quran and Sunnah (teachings and practices of Muhammad).

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Use consensus (Ijma) and analogy (Qiyas) to interpret Islamic law.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Religious authority is decentralized among scholars (ulama).

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• No single infallible religious leader.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

Shia Islam

• Believe in the Imamate — leadership by divinely appointed Imams starting with Ali.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Imams are believed to be infallible and spiritually guided.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Teachings of the Prophet’s family (Ahl al-Bayt) are an important source of authority.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

4. Leadership Structure

Sunni Leadership

• Led historically by a caliph, a political and religious leader but not divinely appointed.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Religious guidance comes from scholars (ulama).

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• An imam usually just leads prayer in a mosque.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

Shia Leadership

• Leadership is through Imams, who are considered divinely chosen.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• The largest Shia group believes in 12 Imams.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• The 12th Imam, Muhammad al-Mahdi, is believed to be in occultation (hidden) and will return one day.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• In his absence, senior clerics like ayatollahs give guidance.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

5. Lifestyle and Practice Differences

• Temporary marriage (Mut’ah) is allowed in Shia Islam but rejected by Sunnis.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• Dress differences may appear:

  • Sunni women commonly wear the hijab

  • Shia women may wear the chador

    Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

6. Modern Political Impact

• The Sunni–Shia divide still affects global politics today.

• Example: rivalry between Iran (mostly Shia) and Saudi Arabia (mostly Sunni).

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

• A major event tied to Shia political power was the Iranian Revolution, which created an Islamic republic led by religious leaders.

  Sects, Groups, Movements and De…

Quick Comparison (Test Review)