Elliot Book Chapter 12: Risk Management Environment and Culture

Internal and External Environments

  • Identifying internal and external environments and their stakeholders is the first step in the enterprise risk management (ERMERM) process.

  • Stakeholders include any individual or organization directly or indirectly involved with or affected by organization decisions.

  • Senior management uses SWOTSWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) analysis to assess these environments.

  • External Environment factors: Physical (location and climate change), social (cultural norms and NGOsNGOs), legal (regulations and case law), and economic (business cycles and gross national output).

  • Internal Environment factors: Product demand flux, operations processes, technology and information systems, and cognitive perceptions of risk.

Risk Centers and Risk Owners

  • Organizations divide into smaller units called risk centers to manage diverse risks effectively.

  • Risk Center: A discrete unit with a leader and specific objectives where risks are most appropriately managed.

  • Risk Owner: The party responsible for identifying and assessing risks within a specific component of the organization.

  • Ownership should be assigned to the stakeholder who creates the risk or is most affected by its volatility.

  • Significant risks exceeding a risk center's capacity are managed at the corporate level.

  • Relationships with external risk owners (suppliers, partners) require an assessment of shared values, culture, and risk appetite.

Organizational Culture and Risk Attitudes

  • Organizational Culture: The shared beliefs, values, and behaviors that define how an organization operates and communicates.

  • Risk Attitude: An organization's perspective on the qualitative and quantitative value gained versus potential loss.

  • Risk Seeking (Risk Naive): Overemphasizes rewards, underestimates negative impacts, and focuses on a short-term horizon.

  • Risk Avoiding (Risk Obsessed): Preoccupied with negative outcomes and inclined toward risk transfer rather than innovation.

  • Risk Optimizing (Risk Managed): Balances the risk-reward relationship by realistically evaluating consequences against organizational goals.

  • A strong risk-aware culture is necessary to establish new behaviors as shared norms throughout the organization.

Communication with Stakeholders

  • Ongoing, transparent communication builds a cushion of trust and credibility essential during crises.

  • Internal Channels: Formal channels follow official structures, while informal channels allow for rapid information exchange.

  • External Channels: Standard operating procedures (SOPsSOPs) specify guidelines for information release to external parties.

  • Communication Modes:

    • Verbal: Emphasizes active listening and accurate expression.

    • Nonverbal: Includes body language and tone, which convey the majority of a listener’s understanding.

    • Written: Includes reports, memos, and risk stewardship reports to ensure transparency for boards and shareholders.

Ethical and Social Responsibilities

  • Social Responsibility: Considering the consequences of organizational actions on all stakeholders and protecting societal welfare.

  • Code of Ethics: Provides minimum standards of expected behavior and guides ethical decision-making beyond legal requirements.

  • Internal Governance: Institutionalized parameters such as audit committees providing standards for financial control and risk management.

  • External Governance: Rules and standards set by regulators and special-interest organizations.

  • Sustainability: Managing the conflict between short-term profits and long-term goals, such as reducing carbon emissions to address environmental impacts.