Comprehensive Study Notes: Classical Greek Dramaturgy, Theater Architecture, and Philosophical Theory

Course Context, Production, and Dramatic Competition

  • Transition in Dramatic Study:

    • Analysis shifts from dramaturgy—defined specifically as the structural construction of a play—to elements of theatrical production.
    • Production elements previously introduced include performance masks and specialized footwear.
    • Discussion shifts to the organization of ancient Greek drama as a formal, highly regimented contest, framing the upcoming examination of Euripides' The Bacchae.
  • Class Schedule and Course Logistics:

    • Detailed discussion of Euripides' The Bacchae is scheduled to begin in two class periods.
    • Practical assignments include the ongoing completion of Worksheet 2.
    • Course logistics and inquiries are handled via email or text messaging.

Playwrights as Performers: Sophocles and the Evolution of Acting

  • The Playwright-Actor Tradition:

    • Originating with Thespis, early Greek dramatists acted as their own lead performers and stage directors.
    • Protagonist Definition: Derived from ancient Greek roots literally meaning "first competitor" or "first actor."
    • The dual role of playwright-as-actor persisted unbroken until the career of Sophocles.
    • Sophocles ceased acting in his own productions due to a weakening voice, subsequently limiting his theatrical role to directing.
  • Historical Account of Sophocles by Athenaeus:

    • Source Context: Written by the historian Athenaeus in the 3rd century CE (Common Era), approximately 700 years after Sophocles lived in the 5th century BCE (400s BCE).
    • Historical Distance: A 3rd-century CE account of 5th-century BCE events is analogous to a contemporary historian writing about events from the 1400s.
    • Physical and Musical Training: In his youth, Sophocles was handsome and achieved high proficiency in music and dance under the instruction of Lampras.
    • Post-Battle Celebration: Following the Battle of Salamis, Sophocles danced naked (or clad only in a cloak, according to conflicting historical variants) and anointed with oil around a victory trophy, accompanying himself on the lyre.
    • Performance in Nausicaea: Sophocles performed in his now-lost tragedy Nausicaea, where he demonstrated notable physical skill by playing ball on stage.
  • Evolution of Competitive Awards at the City Dionysia:

    • Originally, first prizes at the City Dionysia festival were restricted exclusively to playwriting.
    • By the middle of the 5th century BCE, official prizes were introduced for acting.
    • Actors were evaluated on physical appearance, athletic ability, vocal performance, and versatility across music, dance, and physical display.
    • Athletic display on stage allied theatrical performance with sport, establishing a precedent that expanded into ancient Roman spectacles.

The Architecture of Ancient Greek Performance Spaces

  • The Theater of Dionysus (Athens):

    • Location: Situated at the southeastern base of the Acropolis in Athens.
    • Physical Evolution:
    • Initial stage buildings (skene) were temporary wooden structures, later rebuilt in permanent stone. Modern archaeological remains show the complete disappearance of the skene.
    • Orchestra: The circular performance space reserved for chorus singing and dancing evolved out of traditional dithyrambic competitions. At its center stood the thymele (altar).
    • Theatron: The "viewing place" seated an audience of 10,000 to 20,000 Athenian citizens (predominantly adult males).
    • Architectural Tribal Organization: The fan-shaped seating of the theatron was divided by radial aisles into 10 distinct wedges or spokes, corresponding to the 10 political tribes of Athens to facilitate tribal competition and seating.
  • Adjoining and Neighboring Structures on the Acropolis:

    • Odeon of Pericles: Constructed directly adjacent to the Theater of Dionysus under the leadership of the democratic statesman Pericles following the Persian War. Dedicated to musical performances (ode meaning song) and civic meetings rather than dramatic plays.
    • Odeon of Herodes Atticus: Constructed around 161 CE on the southern slope of the Acropolis, west of the Theater of Dionysus. Built roughly 600 years after the prime of classical Greek tragedy, its structure reflects Roman architectural design rather than classical Greek theater construction.
  • The Theater at Epidaurus:

    • Location: Situated on the eastern coast of the Peloponnesian Peninsula.
    • Conservation Status: Represents the best-preserved example of classical Greek theater architecture, built on the model of the Theater of Dionysus.
    • Integration of Scenery: The low height of the skene allowed natural landscape features—mountains, sky, and surrounding flora—to serve as the primary backdrop for theatrical performances.
    • Acoustic Engineering: Constructed with precise geometric seating and material proportions that enabled unamplified sound (such as a finger snap in the center of the circular orchestra) to carry clearly to the top tier of the theatron filled with thousands of spectators.

Philosophical Foundations: Plato’s Critique of Theater and Imitative Art

  • Etymology and Philosophical Lineage:

    • Theory and Theatron: Both share ancient Greek roots. Theatron denotes "a place for seeing," while theory denotes "a way of seeing."
    • Philosophical Succession: Socrates taught Plato; Plato taught Aristotle.
    • Oral vs. Written Traditions: Socrates wrote no texts; his teachings survived entirely through the written Socratic Dialogues composed by his student, Plato.
    • Intellectual Institutions:
    • Plato established his school, the Academy, in an Athenian garden.
    • Aristotle established his school, the Lyceum, in an Athenian garden.
  • Plato’s Republic (c. 380 BCE):

    • Theoretical Context: Composed over half a century after Sophocles' major works, proposing a theoretical, perfectly constructed city-state (polis) as an alternative to Athenian direct democracy and historical tyrannies.
    • Rejection of Theater: Plato argued that theater and imitative arts must be entirely banished from an ideal society.
  • Ontological Objections to Art:

    • Ontology: The branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of being and existence ("that which is").
    • Theory of Forms / Numenal Realm: Plato asserted that physical reality is merely an imperfect copy of absolute, perfect ideas existing in an objective, transcendental realm called the numenal realm.
    • Imitation as Falsehood: Physical objects (e.g., a physical chair) are first-order copies of perfect numenal forms. Dramatic art, acting, and stage props are imitations of physical objects—making them second-order copies ("copies of copies").
    • Art is deemed ontologically inferior, deceptive, and a subversion of truth (turning reality upside down).
    • Exception for Music: Plato permitted non-imitative music within his ideal republic because it does not represent physical objects, existing instead as pure, direct auditory experience.
  • The Allegory of the Cave:

    • An extended metaphor in Plato's Republic illustrating human ignorance and the deceptiveness of imitative art.
    • Scenario: Prisoners are chained inside an underground cave, fixed in place so they can only look straight ahead at a wall.
    • Mechanism: Behind the prisoners, puppeteers walk along a raised roadway carrying cutouts of objects (e.g., cats, tables, chairs). A fire burning behind the roadway casts the shadows of these cutouts onto the wall in front of the prisoners.
    • Conclusion: The prisoners accept the shadows—which are copies of cutouts, which are copies of physical objects, which are copies of numenal forms—as primary reality. Drama operates identically by presenting shadows of copies to delude the audience.
  • Artistic Depictions:

    • Raphael’s The School of Athens (1509–1511 CE): Fresco located in the Vatican Palace outside the Sistine Chapel depicting an idealized gathering of ancient thinkers, centered on Plato (pointing upward to the numenal realm) and Aristotle.

Aristotelian Dramatic Theory: The Definition and Function of Tragedy

  • Aristotle's Poetics:

    • Unlike Plato, Aristotle viewed theater positively and analyzed its mechanics systematically in his treatise, Poetics (frequently translated as On Poetry and Style).
    • Primary focus of the surviving first half of the text is tragic poetry.
    • Serves as a primary historical source for the structure of 5th-century BCE Greek drama and references numerous lost plays.
    • Rembrandt's Aristotle with a Bust of Homer illustrates the lineage connecting Homeric epic poetry to Aristotelian dramatic analysis.
  • Verbatim Definition of Tragedy:

    • Derived from tragedia (literally translated as "goat song").
    • Exact Definition: "Tragedy is the imitation of a serious action, which is complete and of a certain length by means of language made pleasing. It relies on its various elements, not on narrative, but on acting. Through pity and fear, it achieves purgation [catharsis] of such emotions."
  • The Concept of Catharsis and Purgation:

    • Medical Context: Purgation is derived from ancient medical terminology denoting the physical evacuation of harmful fluids, humors, or toxins from the body (e.g., via bloodletting or emetics).
    • Therapeutic Function: Tragedy operates as a psychological and physiological release. It safely draws out and purges excess emotional buildup—specifically pity (distress felt for another's suffering) and fear (anxiety over similar suffering occurring to oneself).
    • Modern Equivalent: Modern usage defines catharsis as a powerful, uninhibited emotional release, such as crying, brought on by art or experience.

Questions and Student Discussion

  • Reading of Historical Account (Athenaeus):

    • Prompt: Volunteer reading of the fragment regarding Sophocles.
    • Reader: Kenna.
    • Content: Sophocles' youthful beauty, musical training under Lampras, naked post-Salamis victory dance with a lyre, and physical agility playing ball in Nausicaea.
  • Interpretation of Sophocles' Physical Display:

    • Question: What does Athenaeus's account reveal about Sophocles as a performer?
    • Student Response (Eve): Sophocles' physical attractiveness was vital for performers despite the use of masks. Performance required well-rounded athletic skills, including dancing, singing, and physical coordination.
  • Reading of Aristotle's Definition of Tragedy:

    • Prompt: Volunteer reading of the foundational definition from Poetics.
    • Reader: Levi.
    • Text: "Tragedy is the imitation of a serious action… through pity and fear, it achieves the catharsis of such emotions."
  • Defining Purgation and Catharsis:

    • Question: What is the precise definition of the term purgation?
    • Student Response (Elizabeth): Purgation means to get rid of or expel excess material.
    • Elaboration: In ancient terms, it mirrors a bodily purge of excess toxic fluids; in dramatic theory, it represents the complete emotional release (catharsis) of pity and fear.