ch 10
The Attention Economy and the Race to the Bottom of the Brainstem
The Attention-Extraction Business Model
Social media companies operate on an advertising-driven revenue model in which services are offered for free because users are the actual product being sold.
User attention is extracted as a scarce commodity and sold to commercial advertisers.
This dynamic creates operating incentives analogous to gambling casinos, where platforms prioritize retaining user attention above all else, even when it causes psychological harm.
Historical precedents demonstrate that industry-wide commercial incentives can be redirected by regulatory interventions, such as Progressive Era food safety regulations and 1960s automotive safety regulations, both of which drove steep reductions in child mortality.
Intentional Design of Psychological Vulnerabilities
In a 2017 interview, Sean Parker, the first president of Facebook, described the core design philosophy of social media platforms during the 2000s as centered on the question: "How do we consume as much of your time and conscious attention as possible?"
The platforms deliberately engineered a social-validation feedback loop to exploit human psychological vulnerabilities.
Features were explicitly designed to deliver dopamine hits whenever a user received a like, comment, or interaction, incentivizing the continuous contribution of content to prompt further validation cycles.
Parker stated that early leaders—including himself, Mark Zuckerberg, and Kevin Systrom (cofounder of Instagram)—consciously understood this mechanism and deployed it regardless, remarking: "God only knows what it's doing to our children's brains."
The Race to the Bottom Dynamics
In 2013, former Google ethicist Tristan Harris produced an internal presentation titled A Call to Minimize Distraction and Respect Users' Attention, warning that products created by three firms—Google, Apple, and Facebook—were systematically dictating human attention allocation and draining it away, causing a collapse in real-world focus.
After departing Google in 2015, Harris founded the Center for Humane Technology.
During 2020 testimony before a U.S. Senate committee hearing on consumer protection, Harris explained that companies face an inescapable collective action problem: if one firm avoids exploiting an available cognitive weakness, it is outcompeted by less scrupulous actors.
Harris defined this market dynamic as a "race to the bottom of the brainstem":
It begins with minor behavioral hooks, such as variable slot-machine "pull to refresh" reward schedules.
It eliminates natural stopping cues through mechanisms like infinite scroll, preventing users from shifting focus.
As competitive pressure intensifies, platforms drill deeper into fundamental psychological needs, linking product usage directly to personal identity, social validation, and addictive engagement.
Three Imperatives Driving Attention Exploitation
Platform Imperative 1: Maximizing Total Users
Ad-driven platforms depend on continuous user base expansion, leading companies to neglect the enforcement of their own age requirements.
Internal platform rules nominally ban children under the age of , but enforcement mechanisms are effectively nonexistent.
During an August 2019 video call with Mark Zuckerberg, when asked why sixth-grade children aged and possessed Instagram accounts despite the official minimum age of , Zuckerberg claimed accounts under were prohibited and stated: "We're working on that."
Testing confirmed that a user could create accounts for a fictional -year-old with zero age verification in August 2019, and the exact same lack of verification remained true when tested again in August 2023.
Platforms experience an existential risk regarding market share: if one platform bans underage users, those users migrate to competitors like TikTok.
Early user acquisition is prioritized because behavioral habits formed during childhood persist into adulthood.
Whistleblower documents released by Frances Haugen revealed that Meta researched and targeted preteens, exploring methods to reach children as young as years of age, mirroring historical marketing strategies employed by tobacco companies.
Platform Imperative 2: Maximizing Time Spent on the App
Artificial intelligence algorithms analyze exact user dwell time on content to curate customized algorithmic feeds, reinforcing patterns by serving increasingly targeted material.
Short-form video feeds such as TikTok and Instagram Reels detect micro-pauses during scrolling, surfacing unconscious interests or impulses without active user intention and exposing minors to inappropriate sexual content.
Designers maximize viewing duration by eliminating friction: autoplay and infinite scroll induce continuous consumption that users find difficult to interrupt.
Platforms employing zero-friction features consistently rank highest among users reporting unwanted screen time.
Modern video games leverage analogous retention hooks: free-to-play economics, validation feedback loops, randomized loot boxes that function as unregulated gambling, and endless multiplayer loops.
Platform Imperative 3: Maximizing Content Production and Engagement
Platforms leverage the heightened sensitivity of adolescents to peer approval and social status.
Snapchat streaks gamify peer communication by tracking daily photo exchanges; the fear of breaking a visible streak pressures adolescents to maintain network maintenance tasks over physical real-world interactions.
Account configurations default to public visibility, ensuring that user-generated posts automatically feed the broader ecosystem and supply content for platform-wide consumption.
Legislative and Tech Solutions for Online Protection
Action 1: Establishing a Legal Duty of Care
British filmmaker Beeban Kidron directed the 2013 documentary InRealLife, examining adolescent exploitation by digital technology platforms.
Following her appointment as a life peer in the U.K. House of Lords, Kidron established online child safety standards, creating the Age Appropriate Design Code (AADC), enacted into U.K. law in June 2020.
The AADC legally mandates that technology platforms prioritize the "best interests" of children, defining a child as any user under the age of .
Core provisions of the AADC include:
Mandatory high-privacy default settings: while commercial firms benefit from widespread distribution, child protection requires private defaults, permitting public distribution only if a minor makes an active, informed choice.
Geolocation defaults: precise location tracking must be turned off by default so that location data cannot be harvested from posts or app usage.
Transparency: terms of service, privacy practices, and parental oversight mechanisms must be explained in language or video formats suitable for younger audiences.
Systemic market impact of the AADC:
Global adoption: major technology firms elected to apply several AADC design requirements globally rather than build fractured, jurisdiction-specific platforms.
Subnational legislation: California enacted its own version of the AADC in 2022, prompting other U.S. states to follow.
Federal movement: while federal gridlock persists, bipartisan support has developed around bills like the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA), which integrates AADC design frameworks.
Addressing regulatory and free expression concerns:
Critics express legitimate concerns that online regulations could lead to speech suppression or partisan censorship.
The AADC and KOSA circumvent content regulation by targeting structural platform design—elements within platform control that incentivize or amplify harms—rather than policing user speech.
Design modifications are viewpoint-neutral, such as TikTok restricting direct messaging from strangers to minors or Facebook restricting targeted personal advertising toward underage users.
Action 4: Encouraging Phone-Free Schools
All educational institutions, from elementary schools through high schools, should establish entirely phone-free environments throughout the school day to improve mental health and academic focus.
Federal, state, and local governments can assist schools by underwriting the financial costs of physical phone storage, such as lockable pouches or secure phone lockers.
Departments of education at state and federal levels should fund empirical research evaluating the impacts of phone-free school policies on student well-being and academic outcomes.
Raising the Age of Internet Adulthood and Reforming COPPA
Action 2: Raising the Minimum Age of Internet Adulthood to 16
During the late 1990s, the internet lacked protections for minors, enabling companies to harvest and monetize personal data without parental consent.
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) recommended parental consent laws for data collection from children.
Representative (now Senator) Ed Markey originally drafted legislation defining a child as anyone under the age of .
The proposed -year threshold faced intense lobbying opposition from e-commerce corporations and civil liberties organizations, who argued that data restrictions would hinder teens from accessing information on sensitive topics like abortion and contraception.
A political compromise lowered the protection threshold from down to , a decision made solely for political expediency rather than developmental science.
Senator Markey stated regarding the compromise: "It was too young and I knew it was too young then. It was the best I could do."
Flaws and Consequences of the 1998 COPPA Standard
The Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), enacted in 1998, inadvertently established as the global de facto age of internet adulthood.
COPPA imposed no positive obligation on tech companies to verify user ages; companies were only barred from collecting data if they possessed "actual knowledge" that an individual user was under .
Setting the baseline at functioned as an implicit government endorsement to parents that platforms were safe for middle-school children, similar to the Motion Picture Association's PG-13 rating.
Readiness to view a PG-13 film is fundamentally different from a child's capacity to exercise self-regulation against algorithmic, attention-extracting software.
Internet adulthood refers specifically to the legal capacity to enter into binding terms-of-service contracts, give away personal data, run algorithmic feeds, and upload content—not to basic web browsing or passive video viewing.
The Inefficacy of Solely Relying on Parental Enforcement
Parents are systematically outmatched when attempting to police digital boundaries individually.
Alexis Spence's mother highlighted this systemic mismatch, stating: "I'm fighting AI and I can't beat that. I can't beat a computer that is smarter than me and that is telling her how to outwit me."
Regulating age requirements should not fall entirely on parents, just as the burden of enforcing legal drinking ages rests on liquor retailers rather than parents.
Developmental Justification for a Minimum Age of 16
Adolescents at age exhibit significantly higher maturity and cognitive agency than at age .
Age falls just beyond the peak developmental window for social media vulnerability, which spans ages for girls and ages for boys.
While the adolescent frontal cortex continues developing past , leaving teens partially susceptible to digital addiction, establishing as the statutory standard represents a pragmatic, achievable compromise with broad political viability.
Protections under the Age Appropriate Design Code should still cover adolescents aged and because they remain legal minors.
Technical Approaches to Internet Age Verification
Action 3: Implementing Privacy-Preserving Age Verification
Age verification does not require universal presentation of government identity documents.
In 2023, Louisiana passed a law requiring sites containing over one-third () adult content to verify that visitors are at least using the state's digital wallet app to present a Louisiana driver's license.
In response to the Louisiana mandate, Pornhub completely restricted access to users with Louisiana IP addresses, as users are unwilling to link official identification to sensitive browsing habits.
Requiring government identification across regular internet platforms presents acute cybersecurity threats, as corporate databases are vulnerable to hacking, theft, and public leaks.
Third-Party and Cryptographic Verification Systems
Specialized age-verification firms operate under industry trade associations to provide zero-knowledge authentication, returning a binary confirmation (qualified or unqualified) without passing identity details to the destination platform.
Alternative age-assurance architectures include:
Vouching networks: users vouch for the ages of peers, losing their own verification credentials if they make false attestations.
Blockchain tokens: a user verifies age once through an authorized entity and receives an anonymous digital token that proves age eligibility without storing identifying personal records.
Biometric estimates: systems such as Clear utilize biometric verification; originally developed for airport security, Clear is deployed in sports stadiums to confirm that customers meet legal drinking ages.
Device-Level Age Gate Architecture
Operating system developers (Apple, Google, and Microsoft) control the underlying software across virtually all consumer smartphones, tablets, and personal computers.
Parents already submit accurate child birthdates when creating family accounts (e.g., Apple iOS family setups).
Platform manufacturers could introduce an operating-system-level standard, termed "age check," enabled by default whenever an account is established for a minor under the age of .
Whenever an individual navigates to an age-gated site or attempts to register an account, the destination site pings the hardware/OS directly to answer two binary questions:
Is the "age check" protocol enabled?
Does the device user satisfy the site's legal minimum age threshold (e.g., for social networks, for adult content)?
Parents retain administrative discretion to manually toggle age check off if desired, but default-on status ensures universal baseline protection.
Adult users experience zero friction or privacy loss; their devices confirm adult status without requiring personal identity submission.
Device-level gates would protect children in situations like that of Alexis Spence (who joined platforms at age ), eliminate the requirement for parents to manually track and block endless individual URLs, and facilitate the selective age-gating of platform features (e.g., disabling video uploads or stranger messaging for minors).
Reforming Real-World Neglect Laws and Restoring Childhood Independence
State-Sanctioned Overprotection and Criminalization of Childhood
Governmental policies have suppressed independent childhood by criminalizing normal, age-appropriate autonomous play.
The case of Debra Harrell (South Carolina, summer 2014):
Harrell, a single mother working shifts at McDonald's, brought her nine-year-old daughter, Regina, to work while school was out.
After the family's home laptop was stolen, Harrell permitted Regina to play at an active public sprinkler park frequented by friends and other parents.
On the third day, an adult at the park asked Regina where her mother was, learned Harrell was working, and dialed 911.
Police arrested Harrell, jailed her, and charged her with felony child abandonment (carrying a potential prison sentence of up to ).
Child protective authorities removed nine-year-old Regina from her mother's care for .
Incidents like Harrell's induce pervasive fear in parents, causing over-supervision and dismantling unsupervised play models common prior to the 1990s.
Legal Disconnect From Child Development
Existing state neglect statutes rely on vague standards, requiring parents to maintain "proper supervision" without defining reasonable boundaries.
An analysis in Social Policy Report demonstrated that U.S. supervisory neglect statutes have no grounding in developmental biology or empirical child capabilities.
Anthropological and historical evidence indicates children acquire substantial executive capability and communal accountability around ages , traditionally managing younger siblings and livestock.
In contrast, modern laws have treated preteens as incapable; Connecticut law previously barred leaving any child under age unsupervised in public, leading to an arrest of a mother who left her -year-old in a vehicle for minutes during a retail errand.
This legal standard directly contradicts institutional norms, such as the American Red Cross training and certifying babysitters beginning at age .
The Social Policy Report noted: "Parents who fail to provide their children opportunities for physical and cognitive stimulation through independent activities are potentially 'neglecting' their children in those dimensions."
Excessive legal mandates that force continuous parental surveillance constitute state-mandated developmental neglect.
Reasonable Childhood Independence Legislation
The advocacy organization Let Grow launched an initiative to enact "Reasonable Childhood Independence" statutes to shield parents from prosecution for allowing normal outdoor activities.
Statutory reform clarifies legal neglect: neglect occurs only when a parent blatantly, willfully, or recklessly disregards an obvious, objective danger that no reasonable person would permit.
Momentary loss of direct line-of-sight supervision is explicitly excluded from definitions of neglect.
Legislative momentum:
Utah became the first U.S. state to pass a Reasonable Childhood Independence law in 2018.
Subsequent states adopting similar protections include Texas, Oklahoma, Colorado, Illinois, Virginia, Connecticut (which reformed its criminal endangerment statute in 2023), and Montana.
These legislative reforms consistently secure unanimous or near-unanimous bipartisan passage because voters across the political spectrum oppose unnecessary state disruption of family decisions.
Urban Design, School Policies, and Youth Development Programs
Action 2: Expanding Play and Recess in Educational Curricula
American schools have systematically compressed recess and unstructured free play to maximize classroom seat-time for standardized testing and academic preparation.
Depriving children of physical play induces anxiety, impairs focus, and degrades overall academic performance.
Governors and state departments of education should issue mandates requiring substantial daily recess and active play periods before and after school, especially across elementary and middle school grades.
Action 3: Designing Child-Centric Public Infrastructure
Automobile-dominated urban designs isolate children by making independent pedestrian travel hazardous.
Municipalities must install sidewalks, marked crosswalks, traffic-calming devices, and pedestrian signals to allow safe transit.
Urban zoning reforms should encourage mixed-use development, co-locating residential housing, small commercial storefronts, and recreational green spaces.
Children are more likely to visit a playground if they can walk or ride a bicycle to it compared to when they rely on motor transport by parents.
Municipalities should disperse playgrounds throughout neighborhoods, including adventure playground spaces.
European urban planning models demonstrate successful community interventions:
School Streets: closing streets immediately outside schools to motor vehicle traffic for one hour before morning arrival and one hour after afternoon dismissal. This eliminates traffic congestion, cuts local vehicle emissions, avoids accidents, and provides outdoor space for student play and parent socialization.
Play Streets: programs allowing neighborhood residents to secure simple permits to close local residential blocks to through traffic for scheduled periods, reviving spontaneous outdoor neighborhood play.
Action 4: Vocational Education, Apprenticeships, and Antifragility Programs
American secondary education has prioritized college preparation to the exclusion of Career and Technical Education (CTE).
CTE courses provide hands-on training in shop, automotive repair, agricultural management, and commercial trades.
Scholar Richard Reeves documented that specialized CTE high schools yield substantial, measurable gains in graduation rates and future earnings for male students, though identical outcomes were not observed for female cohorts.
Standardized academic curricula fail to engage millions of adolescent boys, resulting in substantial educational disengagement and lost potential.
Apprenticeship models address high labor turnover: state-subsidized entry-level wages lower the training cost barrier for companies, incentivizing businesses to train young workers directly out of high school.
Civilian service and wilderness development initiatives:
Public funding should expand service years and gap-year programs such as AmeriCorps for adolescents outside standard four-year college paths.
Wilderness experience programs foster psychological antifragility by immersing youth in demanding, natural environments.
While wilderness courses are generally administered by private commercial or nonprofit operators, the State of Connecticut has continuously operated a tuition-free wilderness program for statewide adolescents since 1974.
Summary of Policy and Institutional Reforms
Resolving the Dual Misalignment of Government Policy
State and local governments have overprotected children in the physical real world through overly broad, subjective parental neglect laws.
The federal government has underprotected children in the digital virtual world by leaving the obsolete 1998 COPPA framework unrevised.
Federal and National Online Priorities
Establish a legal duty of care for internet platforms based on the U.K. Age Appropriate Design Code, forcing platforms to build private-by-default, viewpoint-neutral architectures.
Amend statutory standards to raise the national age of internet adulthood from to .
Technology Sector Responsibilities
Implement reliable third-party verification options and integrate native, default-on "age check" settings within mobile and desktop operating systems to lift the verification burden from parents.
Eliminate predatory attention-extraction loops, autoplay, and infinite scroll mechanisms targeting young audiences.
State and Local Physical Priorities
Enact Reasonable Childhood Independence statutes to eliminate penalties against parents who grant children age-appropriate unsupervised freedom.
Mandate daily unstructured recess and free play across public elementary and middle schools.
Revise municipal zoning and transit infrastructure to support walkable mixed-use districts, car-free School Streets, Play Streets, and distributed neighborhood playgrounds.
Fund CTE vocational education, subsidized apprenticeships, public service corps, and tuition-free wilderness resilience initiatives.