Comprehensive Guide to Clinical Audiometric Masking

Principles of Auditory Cross-Hearing and Interaural Attenuation

Cross-hearing occurs when an auditory stimulus presented to a test ear (TE) travels across the head with sufficient intensity to be perceived by the cochlea of the non-test ear (NTE). The risk of cross-hearing is highest when the non-test ear possesses superior hearing sensitivity relative to the test ear.

Mechanics of Signal Crossover

When an air-conduction (AC) tone is presented at a high intensity level through headphones or insert earphones, the acoustic energy vibrates the transducer against the skull, inducing mechanical vibration of the cranial bones. This bone-conduction (BC) stimulation directly excites the fluids of both cochleae. Consequently, if the acoustic stimulus delivered to the TE, minus the energy lost across the head, meets or exceeds the bone-conduction threshold of the NTE, the signal will be detected by the non-test ear.

Interaural Attenuation Definitions and Baseline Values

Interaural Attenuation (IA) is defined as the loss of acoustic energy (expressed in decibels) as a sound signal travels from the test ear to the non-test ear.

  • Cross-Hearing vs. Interaural Attenuation: Cross-hearing refers to the clinical event wherein a test stimulus crosses the skull and is heard by the non-test ear's bone-conduction pathway. Interaural attenuation represents the quantitative loss of sound energy that occurs during this transmission.

The magnitude of interaural attenuation depends directly on the transducer type:

  • Air-Conduction via Supra-Aural Headphones: IA=40 dBIA = 40\,\text{dB}

  • Air-Conduction via Insert Earphones: IA=60 dBIA = 60\,\text{dB}

  • Bone-Conduction (BC Transducer): IA=0 dBIA = 0\,\text{dB}

Because the interaural attenuation for bone conduction is 0 dB0\,\text{dB}, a bone-conduction oscillator vibrates the entire skull, stimulating both cochleae equally regardless of placement location on the mastoid or forehead.

Headphone interaural attenuation showing a 100 dB presentation reduced by 40 dB across the skull, yielding 60 dB at the non-test earInsert earphone interaural attenuation showing a 100 dB presentation reduced by 60 dB across the skull, yielding 40 dB at the non-test earBone conduction interaural attenuation of 0 dB showing equal 30 dB stimulation to both cochleae

Criteria and Clinical Indications for Clinical Masking

Uncontrolled cross-hearing introduces significant clinical errors:

  1. Test responses are recorded from the non-test ear rather than the test ear, generating a false or shadow audiogram.

  2. True auditory thresholds of the test ear cannot be isolated or accurately established.

To eliminate cross-hearing, clinical masking is applied. Masking involves presenting a continuous noise signal to the non-test ear to temporarily raise its threshold, preventing it from detecting any crossover test stimulus delivered to the test ear.

Transducer Selection Advantages

Insert earphones are heavily favored over supra-aural headphones for pure-tone testing because:

  • Insert earphones provide a higher interaural attenuation (60 dB60\,\text{dB} vs. 40 dB40\,\text{dB}), significantly reducing the frequency with which masking is required.

  • Insert earphones eliminate or minimize the Occlusion Effect (OE) encountered during bone-conduction testing when the non-test ear canal is covered.

Noise Types for Clinical Masking

  • Narrowband Noise (NBN): Used during pure-tone audiometry. NBN is centered around the specific test frequency. A narrow band of frequencies surrounding the pure tone provides maximum masking efficacy with minimal sound pressure level.

  • Speech Noise: Used during speech audiometry. Speech noise consists of broad white noise filtered to match the overall power spectrum of speech, centered around mid-frequency energy.

Criteria for Masking Pure-Tone Air Conduction

Masking for air conduction is required whenever the presentation level of the test signal in the test ear minus the interaural attenuation is greater than or equal to the bone-conduction threshold of the non-test ear:

ACTE−IA≥BCNTEAC_{TE} - IA \ge BC_{NTE}

Criteria for Masking Pure-Tone Bone Conduction

Masking for bone conduction is required whenever an air-bone gap (ABG) in the test ear exceeds 10 dB10\,\text{dB}:

ABGTE>10 dBABG_{TE} > 10\,\text{dB}

Quantitative Masking Equations and Occlusion Parameters

Effective Masking and Boundary Definitions

  • Effective Masking (EM): The minimum intensity of a masking noise required to just mask a signal at a given presentation level. EM serves as the starting point for clinical masking.

  • Overmasking: A condition wherein the masking noise delivered to the non-test ear is so intense that it crosses the skull back to the test ear, raising the threshold of the test ear signal.

Pure-Tone Air Conduction Masking Level Equations

  • Minimum Masking Level for Air Conduction:

Minimum Masking LevelAC=TE Presentation Level−IA+NTE ABG+Buffer\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{AC} = \text{TE Presentation Level} - IA + \text{NTE ABG} + \text{Buffer}

where the standard safety buffer is approximately 10 dB10\,\text{dB}.

  • For Insert Earphones (IA=60 dBIA = 60\,\text{dB}):

Minimum Masking LevelAC=TE Presentation Level−60 dB+NTE ABG+10 dB\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{AC} = \text{TE Presentation Level} - 60\,\text{dB} + \text{NTE ABG} + 10\,\text{dB}

  • For Supra-Aural Headphones (IA=40 dBIA = 40\,\text{dB}):

Minimum Masking LevelAC=TE Presentation Level−40 dB+NTE ABG+10 dB\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{AC} = \text{TE Presentation Level} - 40\,\text{dB} + \text{NTE ABG} + 10\,\text{dB}

  • Maximum Masking Level for Air Conduction:

Maximum Masking LevelAC=BCTE+IA−5 dB\text{Maximum Masking Level}_{AC} = BC_{TE} + IA - 5\,\text{dB}

  • For Insert Earphones (IA=60 dBIA = 60\,\text{dB}):

Maximum Masking LevelAC=BCTE+60 dB−5 dB\text{Maximum Masking Level}_{AC} = BC_{TE} + 60\,\text{dB} - 5\,\text{dB}

  • For Supra-Aural Headphones (IA=40 dBIA = 40\,\text{dB}):

Maximum Masking LevelAC=BCTE+40 dB−5 dB\text{Maximum Masking Level}_{AC} = BC_{TE} + 40\,\text{dB} - 5\,\text{dB}

Pure-Tone Bone Conduction Masking Level Equations

  • Minimum Masking Level for Bone Conduction:

Minimum Masking LevelBC=Expected BC Threshold+OE+NTE ABG+Buffer\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{BC} = \text{Expected } BC \text{ Threshold} + OE + \text{NTE ABG} + \text{Buffer}

where the standard safety buffer is approximately 10 dB10\,\text{dB}.

  • Occlusion Effect (OE) Values:

The Occlusion Effect is an artificial enhancement of bone-conducted low-frequency sound caused by occluding the external auditory meatus with a transducer (earphone).

Frequency (Hz)

Occlusion Effect (dB)

250 Hz250\,\text{Hz}

20 dB20\,\text{dB}

500 Hz500\,\text{Hz}

15 dB15\,\text{dB}

1000 Hz1000\,\text{Hz}

10 dB10\,\text{dB}

>1000 Hz>1000\,\text{Hz}

0 dB0\,\text{dB}

  • Maximum Masking Level for Bone Conduction:

Maximum Masking LevelBC=BCTE+IA−5 dB\text{Maximum Masking Level}_{BC} = BC_{TE} + IA - 5\,\text{dB}

Speech Audiometry Masking Formulas

Masking principles apply similarly to speech signals, using speech noise centered over speech frequencies across the 250 Hz250\,\text{Hz} to 8000 Hz8000\,\text{Hz} spectrum.

  • Speech Recognition Threshold (SRT) Minimum Masking Level:

Minimum Masking LevelSRT=TE SRT−IA+Largest Significant NTE ABG+Buffer\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{SRT} = \text{TE SRT} - IA + \text{Largest Significant NTE ABG} + \text{Buffer}

  • Word Recognition Score (WRS) Effective Masking Level:

Effective Masking LevelWRS=PL−IA+Largest Significant NTE ABG+Buffer\text{Effective Masking Level}_{WRS} = PL - IA + \text{Largest Significant NTE ABG} + \text{Buffer}

where PLPL is the Presentation Level in the test ear.

  • Maximum Speech Masking Level:

Maximum Speech Masking Level=Best TE BC+IA−5 dB\text{Maximum Speech Masking Level} = \text{Best TE } BC + IA - 5\,\text{dB}

Largest Significant NTE ABG and Best TE BC refer to values measured within the octave range of 250 Hz250\,\text{Hz} to 8000 Hz8000\,\text{Hz}.

The Plateau Method for Threshold Determination

The Plateau Method is the standard clinical technique for determining true masked threshold levels in pure-tone audiometry.

Masking plateau diagram illustrating undermasking, minimum effective masking, the threshold plateau, maximum useable masking, and overmasking

Plateau Mechanics and Regions

  1. Undermasking: When masking noise presented to the non-test ear is insufficient, any increase in masking noise causes a corresponding linear increase in the perceived test ear threshold because the non-test ear is still hearing the test tone.

  2. Minimum Effective Masking: The lowest masking noise level that effectively eliminates the non-test ear's contribution.

  3. The Plateau: A range of masking noise intensities across which the test ear threshold remains constant. An increase of masking noise in the non-test ear across a total range of 15 dB15\,\text{dB} to 20 dB20\,\text{dB} (applied in 5 dB5\,\text{dB} or 10 dB10\,\text{dB} increments) without a shift in test ear response confirms the true threshold.

  4. Maximum Useable Masking: The upper bound of masking noise before overmasking occurs.

  5. Overmasking: Occurs when the masking noise level exceeds the maximum limit, crossing the skull to elevate the test ear's true threshold. Clinically, overmasking causes a continuous back-and-forth increase in both presentation level and masking level without ever establishing a plateau.

Procedural Steps for the Plateau Method

  1. Present the test ear pure tone at the unmasked threshold level while delivering the calculated minimum masking level to the non-test ear continuously.

  2. If the tone is unheard, raise the pure-tone intensity in the test ear in 5 dB5\,\text{dB} steps until the patient responds.

  3. Once the patient responds to the tone in the presence of masking noise, increase the masking noise level in the non-test ear by 5 dB5\,\text{dB}.

  4. Re-test the tone at the same level in the test ear.

  5. Repeat steps 3 and 4 until the masking noise is increased by a total of 15 dB15\,\text{dB} to 20 dB20\,\text{dB} (e.g., three consecutive 5 dB5\,\text{dB} steps) while the patient continues to perceive the pure tone at the exact same intensity level in the test ear.

  6. Record the final test tone intensity as the true masked threshold.

  7. Record the final masking intensity level (the level at the end of the plateau, not the initial minimum masking level) in the masking documentation table on the audiogram.

Worked Examples and Clinical Case Studies

Case Study 1: Headphones Pure-Tone Evaluation

  • Test Parameters: Supra-Aural Headphones (IA=40 dBIA = 40\,\text{dB}), Test Frequency = 1000 Hz1000\,\text{Hz}.

  • Audiometric Findings:

    • Right Ear (TE / AD): Unmasked Air Conduction (ACTEAC_{TE}) = 60 dB HL60\,\text{dB\,HL}, Unmasked Bone Conduction (BCTEBC_{TE}) = 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL}.

    • Left Ear (NTE / AS): Unmasked Air Conduction (ACNTEAC_{NTE}) = 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL}, Unmasked Bone Conduction (BCNTEBC_{NTE}) = 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL}, Air-Bone Gap (NTE ABG\text{NTE ABG}) = 0 dB0\,\text{dB}.

Step 1: Check Need for Masking
  • Air Conduction Check:

ACTE−IA=60 dB−40 dB=20 dBAC_{TE} - IA = 60\,\text{dB} - 40\,\text{dB} = 20\,\text{dB}

Since 20 dB≥BCNTE(10 dB)20\,\text{dB} \ge BC_{NTE} (10\,\text{dB}), Air Conduction masking is required for the Right Ear.

  • Bone Conduction Check:

ABGTE=ACTE−BCTE=60 dB−10 dB=50 dBABG_{TE} = AC_{TE} - BC_{TE} = 60\,\text{dB} - 10\,\text{dB} = 50\,\text{dB}

Since 50 dB>10 dB50\,\text{dB} > 10\,\text{dB}, Bone Conduction masking is required for the Right Ear.

Step 2: Calculate Air Conduction Masking Levels (Right Ear)
  • Minimum Masking Level:

Minimum Masking LevelAC=60 dB−40 dB+0 dB+10 dB=30 dB HL\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{AC} = 60\,\text{dB} - 40\,\text{dB} + 0\,\text{dB} + 10\,\text{dB} = 30\,\text{dB\,HL}

Masking noise starting level in Left Ear = 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

  • Maximum Masking Level:

Maximum Masking LevelAC=BCTE+IA−5 dB=10 dB+40 dB−5 dB=45 dB HL\text{Maximum Masking Level}_{AC} = BC_{TE} + IA - 5\,\text{dB} = 10\,\text{dB} + 40\,\text{dB} - 5\,\text{dB} = 45\,\text{dB\,HL}

Plateau range available with headphones = 30 dB30\,\text{dB} to 45 dB45\,\text{dB} (a 15 dB15\,\text{dB} range before risk of overmasking).

Step 3: Calculate Bone Conduction Masking Level (Right Ear at 1000 Hz)
  • Minimum Masking Level:

Expected BC Threshold=10 dB\text{Expected } BC \text{ Threshold} = 10\,\text{dB}

OE at 1000 Hz=10 dBOE \text{ at } 1000\,\text{Hz} = 10\,\text{dB}

NTE ABG=0 dB\text{NTE ABG} = 0\,\text{dB}

Buffer=10 dB\text{Buffer} = 10\,\text{dB}

Minimum Masking LevelBC=10 dB+10 dB+0 dB+10 dB=30 dB HL\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{BC} = 10\,\text{dB} + 10\,\text{dB} + 0\,\text{dB} + 10\,\text{dB} = 30\,\text{dB\,HL}

Case Study 2: Speech Audiometry Evaluation

  • Test Parameters: Supra-Aural Headphones (IA=40 dBIA = 40\,\text{dB}).

  • Audiometric Findings:

    • Right Ear (TE / AD): Speech Recognition Threshold (SRTSRT) = 55 dB HL55\,\text{dB\,HL}, Word Recognition Presentation Level (PLPL) = 85 dB HL85\,\text{dB\,HL}.

    • Left Ear (NTE / AS): BCNTE=10 dB HLBC_{NTE} = 10\,\text{dB\,HL}, Largest Significant NTE ABG=0 dB\text{NTE ABG} = 0\,\text{dB}.

Step 1: SRT Masking Determination
  • Check Crossover:

SRTTE−IA=55 dB−40 dB=15 dBSRT_{TE} - IA = 55\,\text{dB} - 40\,\text{dB} = 15\,\text{dB}

Since 15 dB≥BCNTE(10 dB)15\,\text{dB} \ge BC_{NTE} (10\,\text{dB}), SRT masking is required for the Right Ear.

Step 2: WRS Minimum Masking Level Calculation
  • Calculation:

Effective Masking LevelWRS=PL−IA+Largest Significant NTE ABG+Buffer\text{Effective Masking Level}_{WRS} = PL - IA + \text{Largest Significant NTE ABG} + \text{Buffer}

Effective Masking LevelWRS=85 dB−40 dB+0 dB+10 dB=35 dB HL\text{Effective Masking Level}_{WRS} = 85\,\text{dB} - 40\,\text{dB} + 0\,\text{dB} + 10\,\text{dB} = 35\,\text{dB\,HL}

Case Study 3: Detailed Plateau Method Walkthrough (Bone Conduction)

  • Test Parameters: Insert Earphones (IA=60 dBIA = 60\,\text{dB}), Frequency = 500 Hz500\,\text{Hz}.

  • Audiometric Findings:

    • Left Ear (TE / AS): Unmasked Air Conduction = 40 dB HL40\,\text{dB\,HL}, Unmasked Bone Conduction = 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL} (ABG=30 dB HLABG = 30\,\text{dB\,HL}).

    • Right Ear (NTE / AD): Expected Bone Conduction = 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL}, NTE ABG=5 dB\text{NTE ABG} = 5\,\text{dB}.

Step 1: Verify Masking Requirement

ABGTE=40 dB−10 dB=30 dBABG_{TE} = 40\,\text{dB} - 10\,\text{dB} = 30\,\text{dB}

Since 30 dB>10 dB30\,\text{dB} > 10\,\text{dB}, Left Ear Bone Conduction masking is required.

Step 2: Minimum Masking Level Calculation

Expected BC Threshold=10 dB\text{Expected } BC \text{ Threshold} = 10\,\text{dB}

OE at 500 Hz=15 dBOE \text{ at } 500\,\text{Hz} = 15\,\text{dB}

NTE ABG=5 dB\text{NTE ABG} = 5\,\text{dB}

Buffer=10 dB\text{Buffer} = 10\,\text{dB}

Minimum Masking LevelBC=10 dB+15 dB+5 dB+10 dB=40 dB HL\text{Minimum Masking Level}_{BC} = 10\,\text{dB} + 15\,\text{dB} + 5\,\text{dB} + 10\,\text{dB} = 40\,\text{dB\,HL}

Step 3: Plateau Procedure Execution
  1. Initial Trial: Present BC tone at 10 dB HL10\,\text{dB\,HL} to Left Ear with continuous masking noise at 40 dB HL40\,\text{dB\,HL} in Right Ear.

    • Patient does not hear tone.

  2. Tone Threshold Search: Keep masking noise at 40 dB HL40\,\text{dB\,HL}. Increase Left Ear BC tone in 5 dB5\,\text{dB} steps until patient responds.

    • Patient responds when Left Ear BC reaches 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

  3. Plateau Step 1: Increase masking noise by 5 dB5\,\text{dB} (to 45 dB HL45\,\text{dB\,HL}). Present Left Ear BC tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

    • Patient confirms hearing tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

  4. Plateau Step 2: Increase masking noise by 5 dB5\,\text{dB} (to 50 dB HL50\,\text{dB\,HL}). Present Left Ear BC tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

    • Patient confirms hearing tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

  5. Plateau Step 3: Increase masking noise by 5 dB5\,\text{dB} (to 55 dB HL55\,\text{dB\,HL}). Present Left Ear BC tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

    • Patient confirms hearing tone at 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL}.

Step 4: Final Documentation and Overmasking Check
  • True Masked Threshold: 30 dB HL30\,\text{dB\,HL} for Left Ear Bone Conduction.

  • Audiogram Notation: Change unmasked BC symbol (>) to masked BC symbol (]). Record the end-of-plateau masking level (55 dB55\,\text{dB}) in the masking table under AS BC.

  • Overmasking Verification:

Maximum Masking Level=BCTE+IA−5 dB=30 dB+60 dB−5 dB=85 dB HL\text{Maximum Masking Level} = BC_{TE} + IA - 5\,\text{dB} = 30\,\text{dB} + 60\,\text{dB} - 5\,\text{dB} = 85\,\text{dB\,HL}

Since final plateau level (55 dB HL55\,\text{dB\,HL}) < Maximum Masking Level (85 dB HL85\,\text{dB\,HL}), the measurement is verified accurate with zero overmasking danger.