Seymour Martin Lipset
Economic Development and Democracy
Definition of Democracy
Democracy is characterized by:Political system allowing constitutional opportunities to change governing officials.
Social mechanisms enabling broad population influence over major decisions, primarily through electoral processes.
Hypothesis on Economic Development and Democracy
Common generalization: higher economic development correlates with a higher likelihood of sustaining democracy.
Lipset utilizes indices: wealth, industrialization, urbanization, and education to evaluate this hypothesis.
Findings show that wealthy nations tend to exhibit stronger democratic institutions.
Data and Indices of Economic Development
Wealth Indices
Indicators of wealth include:
Per capita income.
Number of persons per motor vehicle.
Physicians per thousand persons.
Access to radios, telephones, and newspapers per thousand persons.
Findings highlight significant income disparities:
Democratic European countries: average per capita income $695.
Less democratic European countries: average per capita income $308.
Latin America: democratic countries average $171; dictatorial countries average $119.
Industrialization Indices
Measured by the percentage of employed males in agriculture and per capita commercial energy consumption (tons of coal per person per year).
Typical percentages:
Democratic European countries: 21% in agriculture.
Less democratic European countries: 41% in agriculture.
Less dictatorial Latin-American countries: 52% in agriculture.
More dictatorial countries: 67% in agriculture.
Urbanization Indices
Derived from the percentage of populations in communities of 20,000 or more, 100,000 or more, and metropolitan areas.
Better urbanization is observed in democratic countries across both Europe and Latin America.
Education Indices
Education levels are critical markers for democracy's presence.
Findings:
More democratic countries: literacy rate is nearly 100%.
Less democratic countries: average literacy rate is around 85%.
Latin America: less dictatorial average literacy is 74%, while more dictatorial is 46%.
Enrollment statistics depict stark contrasts between nations (i.e., Haiti's 11 primary school students per thousand compared to the US's 18 college students per thousand).
Education's Impact on Democracy
Link between Education and Democratic Values
Education broadens perspectives, cultivates understanding of tolerance, and shapes rational electoral choices.
Public opinion data show correlations between higher education levels and democratic attitudes (e.g., tolerance towards opposition and support for multi-party systems).
The Role of Class and Political Extremism
Economic Development and Class Struggle
Economic conditions influence class perspectives and political ideologies.
Evidence reflects different political consequences based on national income levels, with wealthier nations exhibiting lesser communist influence.
Findings across nations mirror class structures: higher per capita income correlates with moderation in leftist political movements.
Comparative Political Contexts
Country Comparisons
The eight wealthiest countries showed limited success of extremist parties (e.g., Communist parties secure less than 7% of votes).
In contrast, poorer nations observed greater support for communism and anarchism:
Countries with per capita income below $500 reported higher percentages of support for extreme left parties.
National Income and Political Behavior
Dynamics of Economic Conditions
National wealth enhances stability in democratic ideals by reducing perceptions of status inferiority among classes.
A more equitable distribution of wealth facilitates cooperative political behavior, and wealthy nations often advocate for more democratic participation.
Countervailing Power and Voluntary Associations
Voluntary organizations strengthen democracies by preventing singular power dominance, facilitating communication, and promoting political engagement.
Cultural and Historical Contexts
Economic modernization is paralleled by cultural changes, with Protestant values historically aligning with capitalism and democracy in Western societies.
Conclusion
The interwoven nature of wealth, education, industrialization, urbanization, and cultural elements underlines their collective impact on democratic structures.
These relationships invite nuanced exploration of how different contexts shape the practice and persistence of democracy.