Chapter 13 (notes)

Compromise of 1850

  • California's request to join the United States initiated vigorous debates between the Northern and Southern states, similar to the debates that arose with Missouri's admission in 1820.
    • Northerners contended that slavery should not expand westward, asserting it was economically impractical there.
    • Referenced the Wilmot Proviso—a legislative proposal aimed at banning slavery in territories acquired from Mexico.
    • Southerners felt threatened, believing Northerners were attempting to economically suppress their region.
  • Henry Clay, known as "the great compromiser," spearheaded a significant compromise which temporarily eased tensions and delayed the onset of civil strife.

Key Figures: Stephen A. Douglas

  • Stephen A. Douglas emerged as the chief architect of the Compromise of 1850, playing a prominent role in U.S. politics during this period.

Provisions of the Compromise of 1850

  1. California Admission: California was admitted to the Union as a free state under its existing borders.
  2. Popular Sovereignty: The territories acquired from Mexico would decide their own status regarding slavery through popular sovereignty, allowing the residents to vote.
  3. Abolition of Slave Trade in DC: The sale of slaves was prohibited in Washington, D.C., though slavery itself was still legal.
  4. Texas-New Mexico Boundary: The boundary between Texas and New Mexico was delineated, with Texas relinquishing some territorial claims in exchange for federal assumption of its debts.
  5. Fugitive Slave Law: A law was enacted that permitted bounty hunters to pursue runaway slaves into the Northern states and imposed penalties on Northerners who assisted these slaves in evading capture. This law incited significant unrest in the North.

Underground Railroad

  • Motivated by the moral imperatives reminiscent of the Second Great Awakening, Northerners took action against slavery despite the Fugitive Slave Law.
    • Abolitionists played an active but secretive role in assisting runaway slaves in reaching freedom.
  • The Underground Railroad comprised a network of safe houses that provided shelter and support to runaway slaves on their journey north.
    • The goal was to help these individuals reach Canada, which offered greater safety, or alternatively, to states like Massachusetts or Maine in New England.

Senator Stephen A. Douglas

  • Known as a Democratic Senator from Illinois, often referred to as the "new Henry Clay" for his compromise efforts.
    • Douglas played a critical role in crafting the Compromise of 1850 and later authored the Kansas-Nebraska Act in 1854, which reiterated the principle of popular sovereignty regarding slavery.
  • Engaged in significant debates against Abraham Lincoln, famously running against him in the 1860 presidential election.

Bleeding Kansas

  • The shortcomings of the Compromise of 1850 led to increased Southern frustration, with many of its intended benefits failing to materialize.
  • The Kansas-Nebraska Act allowed new territories to decide on slavery, prompting an influx of settlers from both the North and South into Kansas.
    • This resulted in violent confrontations, deemed "Bleeding Kansas," where pro-slavery and anti-slavery factions clashed.
    • Notably, Southern settlers received support from pro-slave raiders in Missouri.
  • John Brown, a fervent abolitionist, engaged in violent reprisals against pro-slavery settlers, infamously leading attacks that resulted in bloodshed, further heightening the conflict in Kansas.

Political Repercussions and the Rise of Lincoln

  • The crisis heightened tensions, reviving a retired politician from Illinois: Abraham Lincoln, who later became a prominent figure in the Republican Party formed from the remnants of previous political factions.
    • The Republican Party was predominantly supported in the North and focused on abolitionist principles.

Franklin Pierce and James Buchanan

Franklin Pierce (14th President, 1853-1857)

  • Known primarily for endorsing the Kansas-Nebraska Act, Pierce's presidency has been rated among the least effective in American history.
    • Over time, he became a critic of Lincoln during the Civil War but died before expressing his views.

James Buchanan (15th President, 1857-1861)

  • Became extremely unpopular, particularly in the Northern United States, due to his support of the Supreme Court decision in the Dred Scott case, which further polarized the nation.
  • Both presidents failed to adequately tackle issues surrounding sectional differences and the expansion of slavery.

The Dred Scott Case

  • Dred Scott, an enslaved person, was brought to Illinois by his owner and subsequently sued for his freedom after being denied the opportunity to purchase it.
    • Initially declared free by a jury, the verdict was challenged, ultimately reaching the Supreme Court.
    • Led by Chief Justice Roger Taney, the ruling concluded that African Americans could not be citizens and that Congress lacked authority to restrict slavery, effectively nullifying prior compromises on the issue.

Lincoln-Douglas Senate Race

  • In 1858, Lincoln faced Douglas in a heated Senate race, prominently debating issues such as popular sovereignty and the implications of the Dred Scott decision.
    • Although Lincoln lost this contest, the debates heightened his national profile and outlined his views against slavery.

John Brown and the Election of 1860

John Brown's Raid

  • John Brown, previously involved in "Bleeding Kansas," attempted to instigate a slave uprising on October 16, 1859, by seizing the Federal Armory at Harper's Ferry, Virginia.
    • Despite being armed, the uprising failed as no slaves joined, and U.S. troops subdued Brown's group, leading to his capture.
    • Brown was subsequently executed for treason, becoming a martyr for the abolitionist cause.

Election of 1860

  • Sectional tensions reached a climax during the election; the Democratic Party split between Northern Democrats who supported Douglas and Southern Democrats who favored John Breckinridge.
    • The internal divisions almost assured Lincoln's electoral success, as he secured votes from all free states in the North and West.